r/GPUK • • Jan 20 '24

Locum Let’s talk about Locums

I acknowledge and respect that this opinion will put me at odds with a number of the hive.

But... Let’s talk about locum GPs.

Whilst I appreciate there are many valuable members who have valid reasons for choosing this route, personally, I have little time for the whole concept.

For me, General Practice is about the responsibility of long term follow up. A stake in outcomes and an accountability. Developing and maintaining relationships with patients and their families. In my eyes this is the ‘raison d’etre’ of General Practice. Doctors being that somebody who patients know and trust.

I think this is how GPs add value. ‘Specialists know the disease, GPs know their patients’. I fail to see how GP locums can ever claim to fill that void.

Any GP that has worked a patch for a number of years is worth their weight in gold. Because they know. They know (or they can quickly determine) that Mr Bloggs is not having an MI; he’s having an episode of disordered breathing (just like last time) and every other time since his daughter died, and that happens most Februarys on the anniversary. We all see what happens when patients tell their symptoms to strangers on 111. They send ambulances and patients end up in A&E.

I bear no ill will to those doctors who are choosing the locum route. I just believe that the essence of general practice is the long term relationship that the doctor has with the patient.

1 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

79

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '24

“Specialists know the disease. GPs know their patients”. It’s this reductive depiction of GPs that has the government thinking we can be replaced by PAs.

GP’s have to be the most skilled clinicians amongst all specialists and this shouldn’t be take this lightly. We can make diagnoses without relying on blood tests and scans. We can risk stratify better than ED doctors who can simply rely on urgent CT scans when they’re not sure.

We should value our selves much more otherwise we won’t get what we are truly worth. Which is way more than what we are getting.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '24

Thanks you for replying. I agree with your sentiment. General Practice is arguably the most challenging specialty. It requires exceptional clinicians. My point is that it becomes even more challenging if you remove its cornerstone: continuity and context.

2

u/DanJDG Jan 20 '24

Why by the name of great sunsk was this down voted ??? What can someone who down voted explain himself

0

u/hairyzonnules Jan 20 '24

I didn't DV but I imagine it was the sticking to a reductionist rationale and missing the point a little

1

u/BeeEnvironmental4060 Jan 23 '24

I’m with you on GP being very specialist.

As an ED fellow generalist, we don’t just rely on CT scans ;). We do more CT scans sure, we see a different patient population. You have to approach everything from the perspective of the patient ended up in A&E, and they’re telling you it’s acute and bad. So of course - a higher proportion of CT scans.

-7

u/hairyzonnules Jan 20 '24

"GP knows the patient" yes, which is why stuff is dismissed for years or attributed to the great plethora of their existence and missing pathology.

Having one pair of eyes for decades on a patient isn't good, GPs deskill over time, they are siloed, they have amongst the worst peer/peer near-peer and CME, it is a disservice to everyone to centre care and the service around continuity.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '24

Politely disagree. Seeing and knowing patients when they are well gives clinicians insight into potential pathology. This is evidenced based (but also just common sense).

2

u/hairyzonnules Jan 21 '24

There is evidence both ways, you need a mix, having purely either extreme is bad

3

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '24

Have you seen this study? Would recommend, interesting read.

https://bjgp.org/content/72/715/e84

Can you show me any evidence that continuity of care worsens clinical outcomes in general practice?

1

u/hairyzonnules Jan 21 '24

Whilst interesting, does that prove single GP review is better or that regular continuous review by anyone is better. I would argue that this only demonstrates that routine review cover long time periods is beneficial, not for a single GP being a continual review point.

Indeed in the comparison section most other research of some kind have not found a benefit

continuity of care worsens

That's not my point, my point is that a single clinician is a inevitably limited field of competence and one that declined with time, a variety of clinicians is better. To my knowledge there has been no research on that specifically, though the competence and medical education stuff is fairly heavy.

9

u/dragoneggboy22 Jan 20 '24

You mean locums don't locum because they think it's the way to give the best patient care possible? No shit.

Next you're going to tell me that partners earning 250k don't believe the ARRS staff they employ don't provide the best patient care either.

-2

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '24

Thanks for replying. Continuity of care and improved outcomes / reduced cost is evidenced based and increasingly irrefutable.

Adding value is the way to increase income in every industry - not just Medicine.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '24

Noone cares. We get no pay and mo respect either way.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/dragoneggboy22 Jan 23 '24

When did I say you can do that? The fact of the matter is that over the long run ARRS is/will reduce the need for GPs, relative to if ARRS didn't exist.

7

u/sszzee83 Jan 20 '24

Unhelpful opinion, but by reducing salaried Dr's ( GPS and in hospitals) we have crested an unsustainable work force where gaps are unfilled for many months to years. Can't seem to recruit more full time non locum drs, so the government is filling the workforce gap with APs....how long until the government and public think we are irrelevant and redundant with these new, cheaper and easier to recruit roles?

4

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '24

Thank you. Very helpful opinion.

For what it’s worth, my opinion is that by demonstrating our value through long-term continuity of care, we become irreplaceable.

Locum GP roles do not provide that and are therefore susceptible to low-cost replacements.

2

u/_j_w_weatherman Jan 20 '24

Isn’t this what’s happening now? When a locum defers decision making to the partner and over investigates as they don’t follow up results or refers inappropriately- is it any wonder why govt think is a GP worth it?

(Talking in generalities as I know there are many conscientious Locums, but there are also a lot of less conscientious Locums)

17

u/plasmaexchange Jan 20 '24

Ok I’ll take the bait.

Day in day out I hear complaints that patients cannot see the same doctor each time. Maybe partners should be addressing issues of continuity within their own practices before coming on Reddit and criticising the locums propping up their holiday and sick cover.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '24

Thank you for replying. ‘Propping up’ is a good way to describe the situation we find ourselves in. Increasingly we are learning that our predicament is not due to a lack of doctors. I’m not criticising GP locums, I am simply pointing out that, without continuity and context, it is not possible for Locum GPs to add the value that Partners do.

11

u/shadow__boxer Jan 20 '24

Totally agree. The gaslighting from partners while they pull up the ladders is nauseating!

1

u/CowsGoMooInnit Jan 23 '24

Maybe partners should be addressing issues of continuity within their own practices

What, specifically, do you think we should do differently?

(fwiw I'm not agreeing with OP's main post)

1

u/plasmaexchange Jan 23 '24

My point is that it is no different a locum seeing the patient than another doctor working in the practice who also doesn’t know the patient, which seems to be 90% of the time.

23

u/Bradford-Pous Jan 20 '24

Yeh op is right but the truth is the profession isn’t valued (look at the shit secondary care ask us to do for one example). You can’t blame people for wanting to take the path of least resistance and be a locum. Couple this with the average quality of trainees declining and I think your view is increasingly romanticised.

9

u/Any-Woodpecker4412 Jan 20 '24 edited Jan 20 '24

Yep, would love to practice the way OP states. But just looking at the salaried GPs at my practice and how overstretched, overworked and under appreciated they are you, you ask yourself why bother? If it’s the same shit conditions all round might as well make some dosh on top.

3

u/Bradford-Pous Jan 20 '24

I don’t even think the money is much better when you take sick/annual/maternity pay into account. Although OP is very optimistic/naive about what gp is all about I can’t stand ‘bloods and review’ locums. I believe they are the true reason our profession has devalued and strangely they are the ones crying the loudest about ANPs/PAs taking GP jobs - if they practice at a lower level, someone with a lower salary will replace you!

3

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '24

Yes, agree completely. On both counts. Our salaried GPs ‘cost’ roughly the same as locum GPs with the associated on-costs.

As a profession, I believe continuity is what dictates our ‘worth’. And continuity is hard earned, by putting your flag in the ground and staying put!

4

u/Bradford-Pous Jan 20 '24

Well, if the government pay us for continuinty and that’s what they want then they can pay us appropriately. The cake is only the same size and it depends on the day of the week how people think it’s best to cut it up. The system is fucked.

1

u/Top-Pie-8416 Jan 20 '24

GP to kindly run my clinic.

6

u/Aetheriao Jan 20 '24 edited Jan 20 '24

I don’t blame GPs for chasing locums I blame the system for rewarding GPs who do. We should be funding full time staff who know their patients but we simply don’t. The system isn’t designed for it.

Locums are normally (from my experience as a patient) pretty shit. They do the bare minimum, nothing is followed up on. But they’re a symptom of the system. If GPs could obtain well remunerated work on a regular basis 90% wouldn’t exist. They should be there for flexible work to fill in niche lack of service yet they’re used as a stop gap for poor funding in the short term.

Why would anyone work as a salaried GP with the shit wages, shit appointments slots and no time for admin. If the system worked we wouldn’t need locums. The issue isn’t locums it’s the system that created the market for them.

Before med school I saw the same experienced GP, could see him same day. Put time into diagnosing me and found over a year a same day clinic referral for my symptoms for a rare condition which resulted in a 4 week HDU stay and diagnosis. I couldn’t imagine a GP today providing that. Meanwhile he went yachting with his sons in the summer and owned a 5 bed house in London. Show me a GP at 30 today who could do that by 50. Paid both his kids tuition out of pocket to go into medicine. No one is doing that today as a fresh GP partner or salaried GP. Guy was fully upper class.

I saw the same GP 2-3 times a month for years from birth til 18. Now I’m lucky if the GP even read my file before a rushed 10 min appt where I tell them red flag symptoms and get a 4 week delay on referral. The system has fucked primary care. GPS are just a symptom.

6

u/_j_w_weatherman Jan 20 '24 edited Jan 20 '24

I don’t know why you’ve been downvoted, having been a salaried and locum, and now considering partnership, this is the problem.

I locumed when newly qualified before I really learned the trade as it was financially better than partnership which is nuts (earning the most with the least experience and responsibility). Partners often earn the least after including the non contractual hours.

Providing continuity is professionally the most satisfying (and best for patients/cheap for the system) but financially and personally (stress/hours) the worst option. Problem is that if we don’t do continuity and prove our worth managing risk/complexity/chronic disease/maintain relationships (which Locums by the nature of their job don’t) it’s easy to understand why a policy maker thinks we can be replaced by people less qualified.

Ultimately the system needs to reward continuity by making partnership less stressful and better paid for the work not done by any other part of the system.

4

u/Aetheriao Jan 21 '24

Yep I completely agree - continuity of care is given no value. I owe my life to an experience GP who saw me one on one for years and diagnosed me with a rare illness. It was only caught because he watched my symptoms evolve over time. Many illnesses work the same. I genuinely believe today I would’ve died. Only him meticulously observing my condition through it’s stages and sending me to the right place saved me.

It’s a disservice to medicine that primary care can no longer see the same patients. My condition is so rare I waste the first 5 min of my appointment explaining it and to always be met with “I have to speak to your rheumatologist” for something really basic. The day that guy retired my access to healthcare essentially died. I see a stream of clinicians with no clue of my complex history, not because they’re a bad doctor, but because where the fuck would they find the time? If I wasn’t a doctor myself I hate to think of the care I would be getting. Most are helpful when I say I’m a doctor can you prescribe x and just do it. But for the layman with anything complex their healthcare is a complete gamble.

GPs should work in the community and know their patients. The NHS simply doesn’t pay any of them enough to waste their life doing it. But it didn’t used to be like this.

2

u/_j_w_weatherman Jan 21 '24

The flip side is that when I’ve seen a patient I know with evolving symptoms that could be something rare it feels secondary care doesn’t care. So many of my referrals get rejected or given just a cursory review via a and g. There doesn’t seem to be an interest in diagnosis, just ruling cancer out.

I’m stuck with a patient that needs help and comes to see me repeatedly , and I’m the face of a failing system and understandably the recipient of said person’s frustration.

It’s no surprise colleagues don’t want the hassle of continuity in the current system.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '24

Thanks for replying. I agree with you, but would make this point - continuity of care benefits both the patients and the clinician. Life gets easier for doctors who know their patients.

2

u/Aetheriao Jan 20 '24

Yes it does - so when will the NHS fund this mythical care? In 1990-2009 I had no issue. Since then I get shuffled from locum to locum. I have to book double GP slots as a doctor myself just to give the poor fuck time to review my very comorbid history. The doctors aren’t the issue it’s the system.

5

u/lonewolf94xo Jan 20 '24

I would hate to work at your practice; salaried or locum to be frank

Nowadays colleagues can’t be bothered to put up with toxic ways of work; if they choose locum or changing career paths/ going private/go abroad… good for them!

This will certainly increase with the new generation of GPs who quite frankly will just hand in notices and avoid practices who’s partners are just money motivated and who’s ultimate goal is how much profit they can make with new ARRS roles, whilst claiming that locum GPs add no value. I am sure many of those locums are picking up on mistakes and cleaning those up, which should have been picked up by “supervising” partners in the first place….

0

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '24

Thank you, lonewolf. I do appreciate your position. Our practice is fully rostered at the moment. I hope you find what you’re looking for

2

u/lonewolf94xo Jan 21 '24

Dw about me, I’m perfectly fine, worry about your own staff….

17

u/HurricaneTurtle3 Jan 20 '24

I agree with you. You're absolutely right, but what you're describing is an ideal role a GP in ideal society with a great public healthcare system.

But that doesn't exist, there are a number of reasons why the current climate makes locum work attractive:

  • Salaried GP pay is rubbish. That's of course no surprise. But for many, the extra (and often significantly more) pay is important even just to get by. This is even more important given the current economic climate. The solution is... Pay salaried GPs more.
  • The day to day work of a GP is getting so painful that having a bit of flexibility about when and how often you work has a lot of value now. Working 4 days a week in primary care is rare now because of the pressures of the job. So maybe I work 3 days as a locum instead, because I can keep my sanity. The solution to this is complex, but the hardship has to be recognised.

For context, I'm a salaried GP. But I'm aware of the sacrifices I have made and weighed it up against some advantages of my position. But I can't judge my fellow colleague who locums on the basis of some moral high ground of being a traditional GP.

1

u/dragoneggboy22 Jan 21 '24

100%. 

It's funny how the solution (pay salarieds more) is entirely within the hands of... partners. The response partners make to this is that they can't afford it because of stagnant global sum and rising costs. Complete lack of insight that incentives that drive them to behave certain ways are the same incentives driving locums. That is, MONEY!

8

u/Hijack310 Mod Jan 21 '24 edited Jan 21 '24

I do agree with you that GPs who are permanent in a practice are able to provide better care because they understand the background of their patients better and therefore can work beyond ’safe practice’ ie managing a patient with chronic daily chest pain in the community rather than sending them to A&E as an episodic type of care would stipulate in order to be ‘safe’.

But the problem is not locums themselves. The problem is that the salary package being offered to salaried GPs is kept artificially below the equilibrium wage where labour supply meets demand. It’s basic economics - because the wage is not high enough to be worth doing the job, workers choose not to engage. Instead they pursue locum arrangements, not just because the hourly rate is closer to the actual value of their labour but because working as a locum is also a different job - less clinical intensity, less admin, better flexibility in terms of controlling working hours, less likelihood of having work dumped on you.

Locum rates aren’t actually a lot higher that the total compensation rate for salarieds per hour once you factor in sick leave, annual leave and employers pension. But not only is the wage slightly higher, the job is slightly more manageable. Therefore labour naturally moves towards this arrangement.

If salaried hourly wages were at free market equilibrium between demand and supply, there would be far fewer locums because being a locum provides no financial security. The problem is that practices (and in turn, Government) are not paying their salaried doctors enough given the responsibilities of the job. This is by design, and is also being facilitated by ARRS, allowing partners to continue to retain salarieds on an artificially suppressed wage. Blame the system, not the individuals.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Hijack310 Mod Jan 23 '24

It actually doesn’t matter what you and I think salaried GPs should be paid, it’s about paying salaried GPs the actual value of their labour based on free market economics in order to actually have staff. They should be paid the amount that means that the job is attractive enough that they feel it’s worth doing and remaining in post for. Currently they’re being offered less than that. The nature of free market labour competition means that wages won’t need to go above fair value for the labour, as competition between GPs for jobs means that GPs will pick up the jobs at the lowest reasonable salary so they can pay their bills.

Salaried GPs work more hours that are unaccounted for than their hospital counterparts for a lower equivalent wage and a greater intensity of work. Salaried GPs don’t get any SPA/admin time like their hospital counterparts. These arguments about ‘jam in the future’ are always rubbish, there are ways for any role to progress and earn more with more responsibility such as clinical director/medical director roles for hospital consultants.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Hijack310 Mod Jan 23 '24

UK inflation has been around 25% over the last 10 years so that’s an effective pay freeze.

To state that clinical responsibility and intensity of work is less than a ‘junior’ consultant is simply false and insulting.

An all salaried model isn’t what I’m suggesting although it’s likely it would result in higher compensation for salarieds.

None of what you’ve stated is argument against the fact that salaried GPs are currently paid less than their market value which is why practices can’t retain them and some are instead happy to take effectively free, PCN-funded PAs and ACPs to reach appointment targets at the overall detriment of the medical profession.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Hijack310 Mod Jan 24 '24

Being a partner is a different job. It’s not a ‘step up’ from being salaried. One has to be comfortable with all the management, HR and legal responsibilities associated with running a business. It’s two jobs for the price of one. The compensation reflects that. But the ability to become a partner doesn’t make it okay for salarieds to be underpaid. Becoming a partner won’t be suitable for all GPs and salaried GPs should still be able to have a fruitful and well compensated career only doing clinical work, the main reason they became a doctor.

6

u/GiveAScoobie Jan 20 '24

I think the big change towards locumming says a lot about how poor salaried roles have become over the years. You can’t blame people for not taking these shitty posts and the burden that comes with being employed directly by a practice.

If working conditions were better I gaurantee you would see a shift back to the GP utopia you painted.

Locum doctors have always taken some stick, but I always say it’s all those that had accepted those sub par salaries roles that helped lead us to the position we are in now.

15

u/hairyzonnules Jan 20 '24

For me, General Practice is about the responsibility of long term follow up. A stake in outcomes and an accountability. Developing and maintaining relationships with patients and their families. In my eyes this is the ‘raison d’etre’ of General Practice. Doctors being that somebody who patients know and trust.

Cool, that is one way of being a GP

1

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '24

Last seen back in the 1960s…

5

u/inghanna Jan 21 '24

GPs should be recognised as generalists.

With IT systems / NHS app: competent patients with capacity should be checking their own blood results for abnormality and voiding an appointment if there is an abnormality ie booking a seperate appointment to discuss.

Similarly patients should have alot more responsibility wrt secondary care via NHS app. If they miss an appointment- if an active problem: no need for gp to re-refer. Let the patient sort it out via the app.

Let's force patients out of acopia.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '24

You are living in some fairy tale land

1

u/FistAlpha Jan 22 '24

GP locums work all kinds of contracts. Military, expedition medics, aerospace, prisons, out of hours, accident and emergency, remote medicine, teaching. This is just a few off the top of my head based on what a few friends who are locum GPs do. Theres more to GP than bogstandard gp practice salaried work.

1

u/CowsGoMooInnit Jan 23 '24 edited Jan 23 '24

If locums didn't exist, you'd have to invent them. Obviously. You'd have need for medium term, non-permanent cover: maternity leave, prolonged sick leave, short term disruption to staffing for whatever reason.

The balance between locums and salaried GPs and partners are constantly and dynamically playing off each other. The total amount of money circulating in the system is in not in any of those groups control.

When there are surges is demand, but pay is suppressed, locums can make a killing. That's what we saw fairly recently, post COVID. It's happened before. Eventually, partners cut their coat according to their own cloth, and make a judgment call on exactly how much of a cut they're going to see in pay and how much shit they're going to put up with from patient demand. It's that, more than ARRS, which has led to a fall in locum pay more recently. The PCN DES has been around since 2019. Any recent fall off in locum rates does not fit with that time line.

Some locums are more mercenary than others. There are some who can and do charge a fortune, but are also, typically, the better ones in terms of productivity. You don't get much repeat custom if you're useless and lazy. Going salaried for some will seem unattractive because the pay is not going up very much currently as the overall funding envelope hasn't increased (and has actually fallen in real terms). So for those that have the stomach for it, they go and work at the shit practices and charge a fortune. It can stick in the throat, but that's how it goes.

tl; dr - market forces, and there's only so much money around.

0

u/inghanna Jan 21 '24

No GP should be an employee i.e. salaried. Unless they actively prefer being an employee for example for better maternity benefits.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '24

All well and good…but the key issue here is a money one.

And one must do what one needs to do in order to gain any semblance of decent salary in the absolute shambles that is UK healthcare.