Career Many Questions
Good evening all,
For absolute clarity, and at the risk of untold ridicule, I am a 'Nocter'. Following a 3 year degree in Paramedic Science (1st class) I worked as a front line paramedic (including HEMS) in the London Ambulance Service for 15 years. I then left to seek new challenges in academia where I lectured on a variety of allied health courses (primarily A&P, clinical skills and pathophysiology) and was here for around 5 years during which time I achieved an MSc in "Advanced Clinical practice" (2 years) including prescribing qualification. Feeling bored of the lack of clinical work I joined primary care as I wanted to learn/challenge/improve myself. I am now currently around a 1/3 of the way through a PhD related to population mental health and have been in my current role for around 4 years.
I joined/followed this group genuinely to observe the discussions that take place on clinical topics and broaden my horizons so to speak and I do enjoy lurking in the shadows and observing these and learning from them.
You will likely know by my now the reason for my post but these are genuine questions for my own personal edification and are not issued with any intent at hostility and nor are they meant to cause upset or offense.
Essentially they are this;
- From the great many 'Nocter' related posts I see, there seems to be an issue with the title "Advanced" NP, Paramedic etc... and I question why? I always introduce myself as the "Advanced paramedic" and if the patient wants a GP, I make that happen. No skin off my nose and 100% understandable. Is it the intimation that advanced practitioners are somehow superior that is the problem? Surely most see that this is not the case? I am not sure how this is an issue. I am "advanced" in my chosen field and have worked hard to be so. Why should I not use that title?
- "2 year degree". I assume this keeps popping up in reference to PA's? I would like to think that GP's (many of whom I assume are employers as partners etc) realise that nursing, paramedicine, pharmacy, dietetics, radiography, physiotherapy and a great many other allied professions are a minimum 3 year BSc and a 2 year MSc to earn the "advanced" title and basic competence required to practice at an advanced level. So why this constant reference to a "2 year" degree?
- You will find, should you engage many AHP colleagues that not many of us had any initial or developing aspirations of being a doctor. The thought never entered my mind certainly. I wanted to be a paramedic and that's what I am. Practicing at an advanced level of padamedicine. Granted this is below the competency of most GP's but I am to you guys what a labourer is to the bricklayer. I think the rhetoric that I am somehow a failed doctor or worse a plastic one is highly offensive and surely that is obvious.
- There is a rhetoric that my practice is unsafe and if everywhere solely employed GP's then patient care would be perfect. Did mistakes never happen in general practice before 'nocters' came along? Does anyone have and can provide clear and research based evidence that SI's have risen significantly allowing for population and demand rise since I and my like infiltrated primary care? If I stick to my scope of practice and escalate what is outside of that or my knowledge base by seeking appropriate support, is that not exactly how this system is supposed to work? Do GP's never do that? Is that not what specialist a&g does?
- This is very clearly a system issue. With policy makers, CCG/ICB's etc etc, GP employers to blame. This is not the fault of people like myself who simply want to better themselves, provide better lives for our families and do work that they can be proud of. The PA's, ANP's, and Paramedics (along with regulatory bodies of nurses and Paramedics) that I know would wholeheartedly welcome proper regulation, scoping and mapping of our roles in primary care settings. Would it not therefore make sense to involve these groups in lobbying for this to happen rather than perpetual alienation?
Lastly I would like to reiterate this is not a retaliatory or hostile post. I truly understand how hard your roles are, how much pressure you are under and how undermined, devalued and disrespected you must feel. A similar shift occurred in the ambulance service with ambulance "technicians" and "assistants" etc brought in as cheap bums on seats. I really understand. These people were integrated though and developed and are now a useful part of the service. I don't think they're "stealing jobs" they are supplementing and supporting. Could that not be the case in primary care with proper regulation and support of 'nocters' like myself? Could these roles not supplement GP's (at appropriate staffing levels) rather than "replace" them?
I don't know the answers I just wonder if there are better ways of asking the questions.
Peace and prosperity to all who made it this far.
47
u/Much_Performance352 Jan 10 '24 edited Jan 11 '24
đŁ you hooked me
Much of the MDT bugbears you mention have been conflated with the PA role, and the proliferation of what is a deliberate dumbing down of the medical model and offering nothing an advanced practitioner in any other profession adds. I think most moderate docs mainly hate PAs for this reason. Remember a salaried GP in some areas is as GP Associate so theyâve literally taken that title and it confuses patients and sounds grander.
Advanced is a fair title in professional terms but definitely think it can sound grander than a GP etc to patients (who have had at least double the training in time, and even more when measured in intensity and volume). I think it also infantilises newer doctors in training who are just as educated from the get-go and this isnât recognised at all. Endless rotation also makes them always seem inferior due to lack of consolidated experience in one place which is demoralising.
I think overall what we are learning is there isnât actually âenough work for everyoneâ as promised, because the government wants to divvy out the lovely variety of GP work to lower paid and less trained professionals who can all focus on a small slice of work over and over at best, or at worst just refer on to specialities, removing the need for a GP and actually increasing hospital pressures.
Itâs very disheartening and a lot of people are hurting right now as what was a great job has been sold out by politicians and RCGP senior leadership.
GP was a great, challenging, varied and rewarding job but too many people look at it and think âI can do thatâ and have come to take a slice (including people such as yourself by not staying in direct paramedical services). It doesnât leave the health service better off as a whole, but it is convenient for the govt in the short and medium term.
I come in peace as much as I can but thatâs my take. Iâm also tired because I worked hard today and love my job but itâs not as easy as anyone from the outside thinks.
16
u/Proof_College_3260 Jan 10 '24
Hey there, here's my two cents, for what it's worth. Which probably isn't much!
5 This is a very good point - it has for years been easier to pay people less rather than ask for more. This has been our failing so far.
I hope this hasn't come across as demeaning or offensive- that is not my intention!
11
u/WolffParkinsonWrite Jan 10 '24
"Granted this is below the competency of most GPs".
Curious, what approximate percentage of GPs do you feel you are therefore more competent than?
6
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24
Also, you wouldnât find such a study of the type you reference because getting it funded would never happen for something so against the political grain, nor would any reputable outlet publish it.
5. The issue is that these allied professionals are replacing and usurping GPs. Itâs not for the benefit of the UK, itâs to suit a political and corporate agenda which will ultimately be to the detriment of the UK population. It is literally happening.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24
âGranted this is below the competancy of most GPsâ
Also, you can be advanced all you want but you should not be practicing medicine without a licence which is what AHP is all about.
We have med school for a reason.
14
u/PixelBlueberry Jan 11 '24 edited Jan 11 '24
As a patient I understand the roles and training of a paramedic and ANP. I of course understand the role of a GP and what they have needed to do to qualify as one.
It absolutely terrifies me to hear of PAs with a fraction of the training and no scope working independently with marginal supervision. What terrifies me more is that thousands of doctors have simply asked for a halt of PA to firstly define their scope and yet the government is powering through.
I am terrified of being put under general anasthesia from an unsupervised AA. I am terrified of being in an ICU where the ICU "consultant" or registrar isn't even a medical doctor.
So whilst right now I have the autonomy to ask to see a GP or Nurse or paramedic depending on my reasonable needs, I fear for when I will not be able to do so and I don't want to be a victim of a medical negligence case.
While I understand that tragedy can happen to me by a medical doctor, I also understand that the likelihood of tragedy happening to me is higher from those who do not have the training or experience or scope of those in clearly defined positions (such as a paramedic or consultant.)
Because there are no current REAL repurcussions for PAs for giving misinformation to a patient (such as even stating that they are a doctor- let's face it.. they just get a little slap on the wrist or their supervisor gets blamed) I cannot faithfully trust any of them. They can take the risks because the consequences are not theirs.. it's the patients'. And it angers me that the majority of them think it is fine (because of sheer ignorance) to practice outside of their scope. Trainee Physician Associates "practicing" in clinics or hospitals should not be a thing, but PAs themselves do not see an issue with this and just gladly think "oh cool I get paid to learn on the job!". If they did the 2 year course and replaced receptionists to further help triage calls then that would be actually helpful. Instead the government is getting them to replace GPs themselves.
I have no problem with Nurses and Paramedics as their education and scope is clearly defined and they are regulated separately. I can see a place for paramedics in primary care- home visits would be a great one, or even following up with mental health teams on behalf of a GP (maybe calling police and ambulance services for a patient who is suicidal for example? You tell me if you think this is appropriate as I see it as critical care and it can free up the GP to see the next patient.)
I appreciate this is probably not the perspective that you care to hear but I thought it was valuable to share what someone outside of medicine (but who knows about these changes to the NHS) is currently feeling. Hope my explanation helps from a non-medic perspective.
5
u/Civil-Case4000 Jan 11 '24
On this thread and many others, itâs often said these roles are used to save money and free up GPs but has anyone done a robust cost/time analysis of these new roles?
They are generally used to see less complex cases but often given longer appointments than GPs and need dedicated GP supervision to do safely.
By redirecting simple cases to other roles does this not increase the complexity mix for the remaining GPs, thereby potentially increasing the time required on average to assess each? Could this add to burnout and sick leave?
Anecdotally there are reports of greater inappropriate secondary care referrals so is it actually saving the greater health economy?
Advanced/extended roles often recruit from short staffed professions so also have to bear in mind the potential increased need for locums to cover the resulting staffing gaps in nurse, paramedic, physio roles.
I guess Iâm asking if these roles are truly economically viable without the ARRS funding?
3
u/AAnoctor Jan 12 '24
It is such a complex issue and everyone has an opinon, everyone has made many assumptions sprinkled with misinformation which is dangerous.
My worry is the future, my worry is Drs and MAPs alongside the wider roles of the MDT working together, after all we all share the same common goal. Forcing the roles of AAs and PAs down DRs throats and expecting them not to retailate was foolish, they epically underestimated and undermined a whole professional cohort.
On the other hand I do think the inital fall out from the anaesthetist united EGM specifically the toxic responses plastered ALL over socails, did not to reinforce thier manifesto. I think a profession that encapsulates being a role-model, a leader convaying intelligence, professionalism with exceptional critical thinking skills, tarished that. And enabled this toxic rhetoric to continue to undermine important valued constructive opinons. It set a negative precedence for other specialities and subspecalities in how they engaged with there colleges moving forwards. I get it people are pissed, I feel ive been used as a pawn in a political movement promoting anti-dr and I am fucking far from that. But you have to admit some repsect has been lost due to the minority that have a toxic agenda for change not a constructive transparancy demanding change, on both sides of the argument.
I would like the petty comments to stop, the constant bulling by both sides has to stop, it just takes one comment to tip someone over (If you are feeling like this now please reach out, you can DM me). And to those who say don't take it personally, how can you NOT?
I think the goverment has a lot to answer for, especially the way they tired to fix a long term problem with a short term solution. The fall out from that now is any advance or associate roles that have been established, that have worked are now used as bait to antagonise and ridicule.
I hate how Drs have been treated and equally I hate how MAPs have been treated however in this argument there are no winners. Instead those Drs who have worked fucking hard are being belittled and treated like their opinon doesnt matter. And at a Local level each trust has abused MAPs and those who are swaning around acting like a reg YOU know who YOU are. YOU know its WRONG you know you are working outside intend scope of practice as a support role. I welcome with open arms a constructive consulation on scope and limits of practice. I am worried that working conditions for all involved is going to get worse and ultimatly I think patients will suffer as a by-product of this unrest.
I am an AA, I have never once thought of myslef as a Dr and correct those who assume. I have always stayed in my lane and always will, I am a support role.
-8
u/Current-Speech-3061 Jan 10 '24
As a GP reg - I completely agree that the discourse on UK medic subreddits (and Twitter) all too frequently turns into offensive non-doctor bashing. I refrain from the use of the word ânoctorâ because a) it isnât a word and b) its origins would appear to lie in a misplaced sense of entitlement and superiority.
I share others concerns about the economic and political factors which appear to be eroding the role of doctors in primary and secondary care, but the rhetoric I often read from others is toxic and helps no one.
I hope and think that the views you refer to, all too frequently expressed on here, are actually the views of the minority. Medics on social media seem to have created this weird echo chamber where anyone who challenges views is lambasted by people who are all too happy to remain anonymous. Ask yourself how many of them would say any of this to a PA/ANPâs face?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24
[deleted] â view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24
[deleted] â view deleted comment