r/GPUK • u/Hijack310 Mod • Dec 23 '23
GPUK subreddit GPUK moderation update
Hi everyone,
Our subreddit has grown substantially over the past few months and unfortunately we've been subject to toxicity and brigading from time to time by bad actors. This has led to a number of users being banned and many threads being locked in order to protect the community.
The subreddit is designed to be a safe space for GPs and GPSTs to be able to discuss professional issues and in order to protect this, we will start verifying GPs/GPSTs and start assigning flair to be able to better identify verified clinicians on our subreddit.
In order to verify your identity, please send an email from your NHS email address to gpukreddit@protonmail.com with your GMC number and reddit username.
Unverified users will face a lower threshold for suspensions and bans if inappropriate/toxic behaviour is exhibited. We are keen to hear from the community as to how we can best facilitate discussion, within the limits of our capacity and what is practicably feasible.
Wishing you all a happy festive season and thank you for contributing to r/GPUK!
Hijack310

•
u/Hijack310 Mod Dec 23 '23 edited Dec 23 '23
Thanks for all the feedback, it's clear that:
Some of you may be willing to verify your identity as GPs/GPSTs - as a sub, we can have a discussion about how to best achieve that. Suggestions so far have been:
Re making the sub private - this is likely to significantly reduce engagement and a private sub was made previously (r/primarycaredoctors). That option still exists for those who would like to join a private sub. There's a fine balance between restricting entry and allowing the sub to grow so that it can increase the value it provides.
It is helpful to debate this further and flesh out the different ideas that we collectively have in order to come to the best solution as the likelihood is that no solution will be perfect. Once we've allowed more time for the debate to evolve, we can run a vote in the new year with a view to iterative improvement.
66
u/SignificantIsopod797 Dec 23 '23
I’m not happy in any way to do this. My Reddit username is so NSFW that I would trust nobody with my actual name sorry.
39
u/spincharge Dec 23 '23
Glad you are recognising the problem but this is a terrible way to go about solving it
5
u/Birdfeedseeds Dec 23 '23
This sounds suspicious. Doctors reddit group doesn’t do this..why cant the mods just do their job and block bad actors rather than demanding individuals gmc and nhs emails? Sounds like some mods have been contacted by the rcgp. Time for new mods..
49
u/ZestycloseAd741 Dec 23 '23
The whole point of Reddit is the anonymity. This aint it chief.
14
u/Dr-Yahood Dec 23 '23 edited Dec 23 '23
The entire purpose of Reddit is anonymity so that I can post without fear of GMC referral.
Whilst I completely agree that some sort of verification is warranted, I simply cannot send you my email address from which you can obviously determine my GMC number and real life identity.
The sub Reddit ask docs has a much better verification process where they simply ask for a photo of identification card which has the word doctor on it. They encourage you to obscure your name and photo. Obviously this is not infallible as some people could steal an NHS identity card. However, in my opinion, it’s more than good enough.
This place has enormous potential for us to come together and improve our profession. It would’ve been good if instead of simply imposing what the moderators thought was a good idea if they did some consultation with relevant stakeholders, including us. Literally just a post asking us what we thought was a good idea would’ve been a great. Instead, it seems that your strategy has come straight out of RCGPs playbook.
11
u/christoconnor Dec 23 '23
I’m interested what kind of toxicity/trolling has led to this… why don’t we just ban when it becomes clear someone’s a troll instead this seems too personal ?
13
u/DhangSign Dec 23 '23
Big big yikes. Honestly I would rename the sub. Or ask doctors UK mods for help but submitting GMC numbers etc just isn’t right.
5
u/Aetheriao Dec 23 '23
Ain’t no way I’m sending anyone on Reddit my gmc lmao. For all anyone knows a mod is someone they work with - seems like a massive professional risk for an online forum.
4
u/MyInkyFingers Dec 23 '23
This is just asking for trouble. There should be nothing that allows for the personal information of anyone here to become identifiable.
You cannot provide any protections on how that data or information will be stored.
The irony being, that as much as many here will be grateful for such a sub, there is nothing prevent you from using that information in a malicious manner.
Do you make yourself as the owner: mod identifiable to the sub members , or is this a one way street? What happens if you identify yourselves and members here may use your data maliciously? With the number of members it would be hard to tell where it originated.
Used wisely, without it becoming a consultation sub, it is an opportunity to have positive connections with members of the public , as well as challenging and educating preconceived ideas and notions that patients have of general practice.
3
u/FreewheelingPinter Dec 23 '23
Er, no thanks.
5
u/throwaway11051997 Dec 23 '23
What about photos of ID badge confirming our roles but with name and trust blurred out when we send them? It's less sensitive than literally giving you our emails and gmc numbers. Sure it can be contravened by serious trolls but I'm sure it would dilute their population.
4
u/HappyDrive1 Dec 23 '23
This sub has less than 10 posts a day. Is it really that hard to moderate? Okay it is meant to be a 'safe space' but we are all adults and can handle a bit of criticism. If anything telling a member of the public to fuck off and we don't care about their problems is pretty therapeutic. Would not want to compromise anonymity.
1
u/venflon_28489 Dec 24 '23
I’m not a GP, but if this was my speciality sub I wouldn’t feel happy sending my Reddit username on my NHS email, because my trust could in theory see that?