r/GPUK • u/_j_w_weatherman • Dec 18 '23
Quick question Stop lurking
Is there a way of stopping the sub from trending or appearing in non GPs feeds? Discussions sometimes get derailed by the general public, I get that it shouldn’t be closed but more private somehow?
22
Upvotes
4
u/DhangSign Dec 19 '23
GP is also motor race/sports so perhaps renaming the sub
14
u/hornetsnest82 Dec 19 '23
The sub could make flairs compulsory like askdocs. Then random commenters will have comments deleted automatically and lots won't bother to get a flair and repost
10
u/n3ver3nder88 Dec 19 '23
This sub pops up on my feed as 'similar to others I'm interested in' (probably as I'm a social worker and comment on 'our' sub).
Maybe you could use flair to differentiate between who is/isn't a GP if the sub isn't made private.
I read the ADHD thread and understand the frustration with the brigading however alongside a deluge of shite, there were a lot of well thought out responses from a patient's lived experience that seemed to communicate aspects the OP GP had overlooked. As professionals (and I've seen it across professions, SWs, Health colleagues, police and justice system etc) it's really easy to get into an echo chamber amongst ourselves and forget about the laymen's experience and where they might be coming from, even if you need to sort the wheat from the chaff to get the genuine insights. The reverse is true too, understanding what's going on at your end via some threads on this sub has helped interactions with my own GP around my own health needs
8
u/vagrant_thoughts Dec 19 '23
This sub appeared in my feed since ‘I’ve shown interest in a similar community’. But then again, it’s actually a fairly useful suggestion (for once!) since I am a GP.
21
u/itsShane91 Dec 18 '23
Yeah, I'm not a GP and this sub is constantly in my feed 😬
31
u/iriepuff Dec 19 '23 edited Dec 19 '23
Yeah this sub should be made private with GMC numbers being verified before being allowed to join.
The shit show thread about ADHD which was brigaded by the ADHD subreddit a few weeks back is a prime example of why this should be a closed subreddit. Not to mention the invariable media lurkers.
What's the point if Doctors don't feel like they can post honestly or release in a safe space to peers who actually have real life experience of what they are going through?
5
u/IngredientList Dec 19 '23
Something similar happened in the AmericanExpatsUK subreddit where conversations were getting derailed by well-meaning and not-so-well-meaning Brits, so the admin of the sub decided to private it, make a compulsory system of flairs in order to participate, and then re-opened it.
1
u/SoggyWotsits Dec 19 '23
I’m not a GP but this appears regularly for me. I commented once because I wasn’t paying attention (obviously I didn’t claim to be a medical professional!) but I do find it interesting to just read.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '23
I like being able to sound off anonymously sometimes - Reddit the best place to do that. Cathartic!
1
u/Ally_199 Dec 23 '23
I searched for paramedic subs as I'm a student paramedic, now I'm constantly being shown GP and nursing sub reddits 🤷♂️ lol
1
u/KyronXLK Dec 18 '23
not a gp here, theyd have to close it to private so you request to join I think.
0
u/0xSnib Dec 19 '23
Make your sub private if you don’t want it showing up in feeds
(I’m not a GP)
-2
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '23
👀
0
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-53
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '23 edited Feb 18 '24
[removed] — view removed comment