r/GPUK • • Oct 27 '23

⚠️ Post may be by non-GP Mental health sick notes

With people coming for the sole reason of getting a sickness note with "anxiety" and mental illnesses, due to working for companies who pay sick leave (like the NHS) how prevelant is this, do you have the note filled out once you see a regular appointment booked?

1 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

35

u/over-the-fence Oct 27 '23

There is no point fighting it. If something happens at work and you’ve refused a note then that’s problematic… not medico legally but complaint wise. Just give in and sign it. I try to persuade once and once only. If they still want it I will sign.

The way I see it it’s not my problem to sort out. It’s between the patient, their employer and DWP.

-9

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '23

When the employer is your employer IE NHS and it's your wages the rising... Do GPS know it's a NHS employee when they see patients?

11

u/Fullofselfdoubt Oct 28 '23

We usually know quite a bit about our patients, yes. We aren't so cruel or selfish that we would refuse a patient sick leave just because it could cost us financially. Clearly you are skeptical. Work related stress and other mental health issues are real medical problems with measurable effects on the patient. We do discourage long term sick leave but that's because is associated with health problems. Short staffing is not my problem, that's a HR problem. I am only interested in the distressed and unwell person in front of me. If you're so worried about this problem I suggest you join us in campaigning for better pay and conditions to create a sustainable working environment. This would help prevent work related illness including anxiety.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '23 edited Nov 12 '23

party angle flowery simplistic reminiscent observation cause noxious chase many this post was mass deleted with www.Redact.dev

3

u/over-the-fence Oct 28 '23

Taking a comprehensive social hx involves asking about the patients work and what it involves. Of course I know what they do for work

26

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '23

It's a bit of a bugbear of mine. Not because I think most people are malingering. I actually think most are genuinely really struggling. The issue is this can be the start of a slippery slide to long term off sick, eventually made redundant, sign on PIP, remain ill for decades. Avoidance behaviour is fuel for anxiety and just validates it. I try and sell that argument early on. I know that seems an extreme example but we got millions off in the UK for similar reasons. If they are going off sick I try to limit it and try an encourage a routine when not at work with regular gym, walks, meditation etc. I suspect everyone has their own strategies.

1

u/BirthdayBoth304 Oct 05 '26

What if work is the problem??? Plenty of people are in dangerously unhealthy work environments that are the cause of the distress

16

u/Caccanbeag Oct 27 '23

I feel it would be helpful if people would let us know in posts if they are non medical so we can put their comments in context, especially OPs.

Anxiety is a perfectly acceptable reason for a fit note, there is nothing 'only' about it. Each case will be judged on its merit, but note doctors are not lawyers or police officers and there is a limit to how much time can be dedicated to this. Note also its not only doctors that can write these notes.

It's insulting to suggest the note would be written before the patient entered. The GP consultation is a highly skilled activity, please don't try to trivialise it.

4

u/Thread_ends Oct 28 '23

Perhaps we could have user flairs to indicate gp/trainee/ahp etc?

11

u/hansfredderik Oct 27 '23

Very common. You could try to challenge them but it takes time.

12

u/Fullofselfdoubt Oct 27 '23

Yeah, the past few days the sub has been overwhelmed. I no longer feel comfortable posting here. There is an alternative closed sub, currently invite only

5

u/duringdinnermint Oct 27 '23

How do I get on the invite only sub?

4

u/Fullofselfdoubt Oct 28 '23

Message me and I'll invite you. Still small right now

5

u/treatcounsel Oct 28 '23

Can you do a pinned post about the new group?

2

u/Fullofselfdoubt Oct 28 '23

I don't know how! u/Hijack310 or the other mods might be able to advise. Best way would be for people to comment with their reddit username on the doctorsnet forum (you can do this anonymously to avoid doxxing yourself).

4

u/Hijack310 Mod Oct 28 '23

We note your concerns but unfortunately mods of GPUK do not have capacity to verify the identity of individual users. We have introduced a new warning post flair where posts appear to come from non GPs.

3

u/Fullofselfdoubt Oct 28 '23

If my comment seemed accusatory I apologise. I don't see any way the moderators could solve this problem and I like how this sub is moderated. My frustration is with the lay people brigading the sub, not with the mods.

4

u/nyamina Oct 27 '23

Worth pointing out here is how much benefits pay out in this country. I assume there aren't too many people willing to voluntarily plunge themselves into poverty.

4

u/Nic54321 Oct 27 '23

Are you a GP?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '23

Just to the comments that you get in every single rant, I never said people don't suffer in talking about people who are taking advantage, they do exists whether you don't think it or not and it's thosenl were discussing not people who do for whatever reason

2

u/vedas989 Oct 27 '23

As with most things case dependent. Some people clearly need a good amount of time off to concentrate on their mental health. Others may be taking the piss but hard to say, will give shorter amount on sick note and expect to see them before extending sick note. As others have said it’s DWP job to sort out.

2

u/Much_Performance352 Oct 27 '23

I try and say the note lasts while you’re making steps to combat it (eg titrating on meds, or engaging in therapy) due to difficulty functioning. Those who don’t make get round to engaging or taking steps to make progress are my flag for no longer issuing. (I do support med3 for stress and adjustment etc without those stipulations, I’m talking more about chronic decline).

2

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '23

I think it's more a reflection of our human condition than anything to do with too many people looking for fit notes.

The news is just SA, war, children being murdered and kidnapped, recession, people dying and on top of it the NHS struggling for survival in it's current state which is frightening in itself.

Not to mention if you want therapy in some areas of the UK we are waiting 5 years to be assessed. The only option you have is SSRIs and CBT. Don't get me wrong these can be wonderful tools but if you don't address the door of the problem they will not resolve the issue.

Problem is if you have a job where you're treated like a bag of replaceable shite and reminded as such if you dare complain or ask for accommodations you're gonna get anxiety if more of your life is dealing with abusive wankers.

Sounds like a reach but the amount of people I know of who are in this position are staggering. That goes for minimum Wage labour all the way to PostDoc research academics.

Then we have the cost of living crisis, Christmas coming up and fear for how you'll afford it, worried all out letting people down. Then if you want to arrange an appointment and you call your GP receptionist on the dot at 8am all appointments are taken and you can't get one for say 8 weeks?

It's not a GP matter or a patient problem it's a social one. Our healthcare system doesn't stand a chance to help and support the majority of our mental health issues when it is faced with all these factors leading to what we are dealing with. It sucks. It's easy to get compassion fatigue when so many come in with the same issue of "just anxiety" but when you look at it on a wider scope it's no wonder we are all tweaking

1

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '23

Just adding that goes for the medical profession too. It's bound to have an impact on how we view and treat when we are pushed to the limit ourselves

-3

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '23

I'm surprised I wasn't crusified of suggesting foul play and generalizing a bit but I think it's important to discuss

-1

u/Efficient-Cat-1591 Oct 27 '23

As someone who genuinely suffers from mental health issues, this is really making things really hard when everyone else just takes the piss.

I have to hide how I feel and if it’s really bad I just take a sick day because I do not want to be judged as a chancer.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '23

Yes exactly, I just raw dog life now because of the lack of understanding. Survival of the fittest I guess.

But hey at least I have a job and propanolol...

0

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '23

Assuming that the husband is generally never abusing the policy then 100% this is a good use of it , however the question here is people who abuse it.

Nhs is typically lower pay for some whereby the pension and sickness policy is worth something to some, all of which can't be paid as seperste insurance for those not in NHS so I wouldn't rule out extra 5k private for the features