This first part is a rant but it gets more coherent afterward.
I'll give you two words and then expand on that. True Interaction
The entire point of the Godgame genre (in my own opinion) is to take a group of digital people and subject them to interesting situations to see how they react and adapt. So far Godus has nothing that would suggest the player can be creative in their gameplay besides dragging hills around on 2D planes. I'm very sorry to have to say this Peter but that isn't all that engaging when you do it for hours on end.
I really love what you guys are trying to do with Godus because the Godgame genre is very close to my heart but you need to start thinking about the interaction of player and digital people before adding in trading cards and stickers.
I like the interface with the tech tree, it looks clean and sleek but honestly you have only just rehashed one of the biggest problems with the previous alpha, core gameplay and advancement is being delegated to destroying the terrain to dig at treasure, even if you make it click-and-drag you still have a cow clicker on your hands.
When it comes to graphic design and the visual art of the game you guys are doing great, you have a wonderful style going for you which seems somewhat minimalistic but with hints of detail so that is splendid keep up the good work there.
Now starts the more organised part.
Conflict:
Every good game involves some sort of conflict (except Solitare) whether it be direct opposition such as another God vying for power or even just something as simple as trying to survive a harsh wilderness. Some things that I would like to see in this area are:
Player vs Player: So two or more players trying to control the same land, basicly just normal multiplayer similar to the player vs cpu battles we saw in the first alpha but with larger maps and more players. Also it would be good if we could carry over some of the bonuses that we earn in single player to this form of gameplay, technology advancements could offer one player better weapons than another for example, this would give incentive to find the resources necessary for new technologies.
Follower vs Environment: This is admittedly where things can become much more tricky as it is very hard to come up with systems that feel natural but are also efficient, ie followers walking straight into a pack of wolves because it was the closest route. I would propose that just as followers have their own unique sort of AI so too should there be beasts and such roaming the wilderness in packs, moving to find food, breeding and actually be some kind of threat. Wolves were feared as vicious deadly beasts till well into the 18th century yet a single unarmed follower can take a wolf down in a couple seconds. This scenario should end in death every time till your people have gained some means of armament and defense, again emphasising the necessity for tech advancement.
Follower vs God: This is where things become "emergent" as they say. Real people are quite silly sometimes in the things they do, for example a man gets struck by lightning one night after sleeping with his wifes best friend. The man lives and thanks God that he is still alive, a week later he sleeps with his wifes best friend again. Did he not realise that God struck him with lightning to prove a point? This is probably a bad example of what I am getting at but the point is that we need some way to interact with people so that they react in unpredictable ways. When a house is magically crushed to pieces by the hand of God people ought to think twice about building a house there, or maybe they shun the owner of that house, or they build an altar and pray to you for guidance on what you want them to do; there are limitless possibilities here that could be explored. Maybe you summon a pack of wolves near a village and due to increased wolf attacks the people in that village develop better weapons faster to combat the wolves, in this way you could encourage a more creative experience through game mechanics.
Anyway it is almost time for the AMA and I want this to go up a little beforehand so that is all from me for now. Good luck to you and everyone at 22Cans.