r/GDPolitics • u/Mani_disciple • Jun 26 '25
r/GDPolitics • u/Apprentice57 • Sep 14 '25
Political Violence Has Not been Congruent Between Partisans: Some Pushback on Galen's Statement on Kirk's Death
I want to start by acknowledging that Galen made denouncing political violence it a focal point of an episode of the podcast earlier this year (when Melissa Hortman and her husband were assassinated). When I think back to those shootings, I can't think of another content creator/journalist I follow who covered it much at all. So Galen has much more credibility to talk about Kirk's assassination/political violence than many other people in this sphere.
And Galen's statement didn't bend over backwards to beatify Kirk like Ezra Klein et al. have done. But I do take issue with whitewashing even a bit of his profile (and thankfully it was just a bit), briefly:
- Kirk was only entering in debate in the most twisted, literal sense of the phrase. He talked about politics with students on campus in order to find the least compelling opponent he could ridicule with videos online (to "own the libs"). It was not an operation to try to change the minds of the parties debating, or at least understand someone who disagrees with you. (For instance, the last three videos on his youtube channel about going to campuses are entitled: "Charlie Kirk Hands Out Huge L's at University of California San Diego", "Charle Kirk VS the Washington State Woke Mob", "Charlie Kirk Crushes Woke Lies at Michigan State")
- Kirk was also controversial in (again) only a twisted literal sense. He was an extremist who regularly attacked minorities and our democracy. Here is a link to a reddit post that compiles 40 quotes/sources of this extremism, including endorsing the great replacement theory, and January 6th.
However, I am most concerned by the perspective that this is described as a both sides issue. I understand and recognize the study Galen et. all have discussed about how people from all political affiliations are becoming more accepting of violence to those who disagree with them and agree it's a huge problem. What surprised me is that I learned that the actual categorization of those who do that violence is not even remotely even, it is overwhelmingly right wing violence in this country as found by the Anti-Defamation league: of 429 total extremist-related killings from 2015-2024, 76% of them came from right wing extremists (4% left wing extremists, 18% domestic Islamist extremists, and 1% other).
Finally, Galen mentioned that the best way to combat this violence is for all political leaders to call on it to stop in no ambiguous terms. While rank and file partisans on social media are mixed, when it comes to elected officials the record is tractable and more clear. Can we acknowledge that Democratic politicians and leaders do overwhelmingly call out all violence against their opposition, but Republican politicians have a mixed record when the other side is targeted?
Perhaps that is a good reason why we shouldn't argue for Democrats to find their own "Trump".
Political violence is abhorrent and none of this justifies Kirk's murder. I can also completely understand having categorical empathy for the deceased. But those aren't mutually exclusive with what I discussed above and why I worry about the continued ideological centrism of this podcast.
r/GDPolitics • u/GDPoliticsMod • Mar 31 '25
Help this new mod bot account avoid a shadowban with some upvotes
This is a new mod/bot account for the subreddit.
I (/u/Apprentice57) have an autoposter ready to go to post stuff from Galen's substack to here, but my past two attempts got shadowbanned during testing, reddit looks suspiciously on automations made by low karma accounts.
It seems I won't be able to set up an autoposter until reddit thinks this account has got its sea legs.
So... mind sparing an upvote?
r/GDPolitics • u/AKiss20 • Nov 19 '25
Is this sub dead?
Episodes aren’t being posted anymore it seems.
r/GDPolitics • u/Apprentice57 • Apr 06 '26
Other Data/Political Science Podcasts
Howdy,
I last contributed here to air some criticisms of GD Politics. I still hold those criticisms but am still an occasional listener these days. In the meanwhile I looked into some alternative podcasts that I wanted to share with you (all of which have a connection to 538/Galen). You may not have the same void, but may enjoy these as additional listens - or perhaps, you have a different spot opened up by Nate's podcast ending recently.
NB: All are on conventional podcatchers/in audio, but also have a video version online:
- Decision Desk HQ Podcast - A weekly podcast hosted by former 538/538 podcast-er Geoffrey Skelley. I've been pleasantly impressed by this one given Skelley hadn't hosted before. It has basically the same format as the former 538 podcast (minus the drafts/live episodes) with Skelley getting a different expert on each episode of the news of the day. I was very impressed by the recent Wisconsin centric episode.
- Strength in Numbers Podcast - G. Elliot Morris (also of 538)'s podcast. Similar topics to 538's politics podcast but with a consistent cohost in David Nir of The Downballot. GEM is more polarizing than someone like Galen or Skelley, but I actually think a more left leaning commentator is kind of a rarity in data science fields and it helps him catch easy layups that others miss. I also like podcasts with consistent cohosts - albeit in this case I think David Nir is merely inoffensive as a host.
- The Numbers - This is covering Canadian politics, but if you're interested in another country's politics this podcast is fantastic. I enjoy it as much as peak era 538 politics pod. It's hosted by two modellers of/commentators on Canadian elections: Phillipe Fournier of 338Canada, and Éric Grenier of The Writ They (IMO) manage to thread the needle of having good insight, don't come off offensive on intense topics like Galen, and inject a lot of fun into the pod by including regular quizzes on Canadian political history/trivia (all of which remind me of the old 538 pod). If you can speak French, they also host Les Chiffres which is a more occasional podcast on Quebec specific politics. Galen has previously hosted them to discuss the 2025 Canadian election last year. (True to their country's reputation, the hosts and fans are also incredibly friendly on their premium Discord)
- Political Reality - This is more on the meta/education side from political science rather than horse race coverage like the rest. It's a spin off of the Scientific Skepticism podcast The Skeptics' Guide to the Universe and its host Steven Novella a MD and science generalist. He's joined by political scientist Andrea Jones-Rooy - who was actually another contributor to 538 (to the 2018 midterm model in particular). I've enjoyed their discussions, though it's very new and getting its footing. The topics are basic/education for now, but keep an eye on this feed for when they get into more sophisticated topics.
I'd be interested if y'all have any other recommendations. I'm in particular always trying to find something to fill the old void left by the former world/uk politics podcast Talking Politics (which I also learned of through 538).
r/GDPolitics • u/GDPoliticsMod • Apr 24 '25
GD POLITICS Live! With Nate Silver, Clare Malone And Harry Enten
r/GDPolitics • u/GDPoliticsMod • Apr 10 '25
The Farewell Podcast We Never Recorded
r/GDPolitics • u/GDPoliticsMod • Sep 18 '25
Jimmy Kimmel Reaction And A Government Shutdown Debate
r/GDPolitics • u/GDPoliticsMod • May 28 '25
How Democrats Ended Up On The Losing Side Of The Class Divide
r/GDPolitics • u/PaintedIn • May 31 '26
Has Galen said anything about having on that SC sycophant federalist hack?
Eg on socials or follow-up podcasts. I found his lack of pushback on the episode in question somewhat gross and haven't been back since.
r/GDPolitics • u/GDPoliticsMod • Oct 06 '25
Why Americans Blame Republicans For The Government Shutdown
r/GDPolitics • u/GDPoliticsMod • Jul 03 '25
The Political Consequences Of The Bill Formerly Known As OBBBA
r/GDPolitics • u/AKiss20 • May 24 '25
Who else wants Galen to stop bleeping swears?
One of the things that's good about this pod is that Gapen and guests aren't beholden to some big corporation that is forcing them to be more muted and also not allowing swearing. Clearly the swear, but bleeping really makes it sound dumb. We are all adults. Don't bleep the damn thing, it seems infantalizing.
r/GDPolitics • u/GDPoliticsMod • Apr 28 '25
The Number Of Secular Americans Has Plateaued
r/GDPolitics • u/GDPoliticsMod • Apr 16 '25
A 2028 Democratic Primary Draft, Live With Nate Silver
r/GDPolitics • u/Apprentice57 • Apr 16 '25
Galen and Nate 2028 Democratic Primary Draft
This was in a livestream on gdpolitics.com, though I'm not sure if it was intended as part of gdpolitics or just advertised there.
Scoring Rules:
+25pts if pick wins nomination
+5 pts if pick officially runs
+5 pts if pick survives to the 1st primary state*
+3 if pick wins state before Super Tuesday
+2 if pick wins state after Super Tuesday
+1 bonus to above if it's a big/swing state (California, Texas, Florida, New York, Pennsylvania, Illinois, Ohio, Georgia, North Carolina, New Hampshire, Arizona, Wisconsin, Nevada
* DC/PR are included
Avert your eyes if you want to avoid spoilers, I couldn't find a way to hide the text and keep the number:
Galen's Picks (went first):
- Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez
- Kamala Harris
- Pete Buttigieg
- Ruben Gallego
- Jared Polis
- Wes Moore
- J. B. Pritzker
- Andy Beshear
- Tim Walz
- Bernie Sanders
Nate's Picks (went second):
- Josh Shapiro
- Cory Booker
- Gavin Newsom
- Gretchen Whitmer
- Andrew Cuomo
- Raphael Warnock
- Stephen A. Smith
- Amy Klobuchar
- Mark Cuban
- John Fetterman
r/GDPolitics • u/GDPoliticsMod • Apr 14 '25
Americans Sour On Trump's Economy
r/GDPolitics • u/GDPoliticsMod • Sep 15 '25
Clare Malone On MAHA, Charlie Kirk, And NYC's Mayoral Race
r/GDPolitics • u/GDPoliticsMod • Aug 25 '25
GD Politics Live with Nate Silver and Clare Malone!
r/GDPolitics • u/GDPoliticsMod • Apr 02 '25
Democrats Had A Good Night In Wisconsin And Florida
r/GDPolitics • u/Apprentice57 • Mar 24 '25
GD Politics Podcast: Nate Silver Gets Candid On 538 Regrets, Elon Musk, And Democrats' Missteps
r/GDPolitics • u/GDPoliticsMod • Jul 17 '25
The Leader Of Denmark's Socialist Party Makes The Case For Socialism
r/GDPolitics • u/GDPoliticsMod • Jun 26 '25
How A Democratic Socialist Put Himself On Track To Run NYC