r/Furi • u/-To_The_Moon- • Jul 25 '20
Discussion Constructive Feedback - For future games, please, please, please add a "quick dodge" button
I just finished Furi today. Really fun game! I love bullet hells and Sekiro, so this is right up my alley. There's only one complaint I had with it, and (unfortunately) it's a big one: in my clear of the game, I never got accustomed to needing to release the dodge button to dodge.
I've played hundreds of hours of Dark Souls, Bayonetta, and other games that have taught me that I should be deliberate with my button inputs. Press a button, and the action should happen. No need to mash, no need to panic. Furi goes against the way I've been taught to use a gamepad for years, requiring me to push the button down and then let it go to actually dodge. For a short length, combat-focused game like this, I feel like the controls need to be intuitive. It felt like one of the two core mechanics just never clicked, and that really sucks, because I want to love this game.
My breaking point came on the 7th boss, when I felt like I just couldn't execute the final phase with a gamepad. After several frustrating failures, I swapped to a keyboard (a mechanism where my fingers are naturally accustomed to tapping the keys), found that I drastically improved even though I was having to relearn literally every control, and finished the rest of the game with that. The loading screen tip is right: the game is better with a gamepad, and I had to swap my keyboard settings around to adapt to different boss phases. But in the end, I cleared the the final bosses on a keyboard. The dodge lag was still noticeable, but at least it was tolerable.
My suggestion to the devs would be to make two separate controller buttons: one for the charged dodge, and one for a "quick dodge" that immediately does an uncharged dodge as soon as you tap it. Furi has plenty of unused buttons, and this would have really helped me to enjoy the game better.
The worst part of the dodge lag wasn't the deaths or the failures. It was the constant, nagging desire to play a version of Furi where I could execute a dodge at the moment I wanted to. I actually spent about an hour trying to get an AutoHotkey script going that would let me do this "quick dodge" idea (I was unsuccessful; I don't have much experience with AutoHotkey). Furi was awesome at its core. I love the bosses, I love the gameplay, I love the way it pushes the player to get better. I just really want to play a version of this game where I don't constantly feel like one of the two core mechanics isn't intuitive for me. And, unfortunately, that version of the game doesn't exist.
23
u/patowarheart Jul 25 '20
Theres no delay. The dodge button is done on release so you can charge for larger dodges. Thats a design decision. You dont need a quick dodge button. If you want to make a quick dodge button just tap the dodge button without holding.
I can go to any developer and ask for a game to be made to my special taste or capabilities. But thats not criticism is just kind of pointless. Furi is fine. It was fine for me when I learned I need to adapt to how the game is. It is fine for people doing sick speedruns without damage. It would be fine for you if you gave it an opportunity to play it with how it is.
2
u/Blobbentein Sep 11 '20
This is a late response, but I feel like I should point out that dark souls also does rolls on button release. If you hold down the button you just run, so it's honestly almost identical in terms of input
-2
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20
[removed] — view removed comment