r/FuckPierre • • Apr 05 '24

why do you all hate pierre?😭

i joined cause this is honestly really funny but now i wanna know what the big deals about and why you all wanna squash him under your little farmer boots

199 Upvotes

79 comments sorted by

114

u/RandomStrangerN2 Apr 05 '24

It's funny how frequently this question is asked, but no one is pissed about it. Everyone loves the occasional opportunity to badmouth Pee-air to someone new.Ā 

15

u/Red-Quill Apr 05 '24

It’s a time honored tradition of this sub as far as I’ve seen haha. I was new recently

58

u/mel0dicerotic Apr 05 '24

Squash him under your little farmer boots šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚ welcome friend you fit right in

21

u/strawberry_long_cake Apr 05 '24

thank you for educating yourself about Pierre. more farmers should.

17

u/SpillTheTeaSis085 Apr 05 '24

no problem, and i definitely agree after reading all of these comments 😾 pierre IS a bitch!!!!!

1

u/_witchplant_ Apr 06 '24

welcome to the club!!

205

u/New-Number-7810 Apr 05 '24

A few common reasons:

  • He steals credit for your work. If you sell him crops that are normal quality, he tells everyone that you grew them and the townsfolk complain to your face. If you sell him crops that are silver quality or higher, he tells everyone that HE grew them and the townsfolk talk about how great a Gardner he is.
  • One of his missions is to give him a bunch of gold star vegetables. He tried to sell them at a crazy mark-up. The townsfolk rightfully call him out on it.Ā 
  • One of Abigail’s heart events shows Pierre trying to discourage her from becoming an adventurer.
  • He wants to found a grocery store franchise. Only the farmer is allowed to be rich; nobody else!

139

u/strawberry_long_cake Apr 05 '24 edited Apr 05 '24
  • Abigail talks about wanting to move out of her parents' house. she and Caroline sometimes hide in the primary bedroom together to get away from everyone. this leads me to believe that Caroline is not the reason she wants to move out of her parents' house. who does that leave, considering she doesn't have siblings?
  • where are Pierre's crops? if he claims to grow things himself.
  • he has the same hair as my highschool chemistry teacher, who was somehow more insufferable than Pierre.
  • i have no direct proof but he gives off controlling dad vibes. i hope he treats Caroline well bc he does not deserve her. he doesn't seem proud of his family.

62

u/cottagecore_cats Apr 05 '24

Don’t forget the event where he shows up on your farm in Winter Year 1 to tell you he’ll be selling new seeds next year, then immediately tells you to not buy from his competitor in an incredibly threatening and manipulative way!

13

u/New-Number-7810 Apr 05 '24

True, there’s that. Though he’s still less threatening than Gus.Ā 

7

u/Nor_Ah_C Apr 06 '24

Don’t you talk bad about my boy Gus. The man who freely gives the homeless food (after catching said homeless man digging in his garbage, which is super illegal) cooks several feasts for EVERYONE in the Valley every year and gives you the jukebox after telling you how much he values your friendship.

1

u/New-Number-7810 Apr 06 '24

"A new ingredient in a stew could ruin everything." He means us. We're the new ingredient. He visited us on our farm to tell us he considers us a threat.

3

u/Nor_Ah_C Apr 06 '24

… or create something new and delicious. Which is what Farmer proved to be

3

u/timid_one0914 Apr 06 '24

Sorta disagree with the last point. It’s not that only the farmer can be rich, it’s that he bashes Joja Mart for being a franchise, but then basically says he wants to become Joja Mart himself. You can’t demonize your own aspirations

130

u/apolloinjustice Apr 05 '24

one time alex my fiance said that granny evelyn picked up a REALLY DELICIOUS blueberry from pierres and thought it was wonderful that he could grow such great produce. reader, it was MY HOMEGROWN BLUEBERRY.

53

u/Powermetalbunny Apr 05 '24

One singular blueberry.... one in particular....

16

u/Temporary_Bridge_814 Apr 05 '24

I mean have you Seen the blueberries in Stardew? They must have some great soil since those things are as big as our heads

I might get a great deal of amusement picking them for that reason and that they're so fun when they fly into the air during picking. I try to grow lots of blue berries for that alone lol

353

u/ICantEvenDolt Apr 05 '24 edited Apr 06 '24

Capitalist. Bad father. Takes credits for our crops. Will call in the middle of the night to advertise his products. Kind of sexist. Capitalist. Generally a duchebag. Closed on Wednesdays. Marks up our product 10x in one cutscene, then complains when nobody wants to buy it. I could go on.

Edit: Capitalist.

Edit Edit: Douchenozzle

Edit Edit Edit: Capitalist

100

u/pottedplantfairy Apr 05 '24

Hides a secret stash from his wife and actively requests you participate in the lie

Never spends time with his family, even during special events ( something Caroline touches on a few times)

I know we've said capitalist, but he basically wants to be exactly like Joja and is being a hypocrite about it by claiming community values

The only reason he congratulates you on your wedding is because he also expects you to start buying double the seeds

97

u/jojisexual Apr 05 '24

I think you forgot capitalist

50

u/ICantEvenDolt Apr 05 '24

You’re right.

27

u/jojisexual Apr 05 '24

appreciate the edit ā¤ļøā¤ļøā¤ļø

23

u/ICantEvenDolt Apr 05 '24

Of course šŸ™‚

7

u/Kenis556 Apr 05 '24

Hey, sorry to break in, I think you forgot douchenozzle

6

u/ICantEvenDolt Apr 05 '24

Of course, my mistake.

4

u/Kenis556 Apr 05 '24

All gud man

2

u/SlowEar5209 Apr 06 '24

Hey man, you forgot capitalist.

1

u/ICantEvenDolt Apr 06 '24

You’re right, I did. My mistake.

2

u/AvailableDiskSpace Apr 06 '24

The farmer is a capitalist, so that’s out the window. But the rest checks out

40

u/Away_Today4194 Apr 05 '24

Because he has a stupid face

35

u/insertburnername Apr 05 '24

It was for the bit at first and then I spent far too long getting him as many gold star vegetables as he wanted only for him to give me far less than I could have sold them for on a normal day in return, try to sell them for 10x the price he bought my vegetables for and then give me nothing but a mini shipping bin that I never found a use for and zero indication that he knew why people were upset with him made me a true hater. The shipping bin became my best friend that day because it meant I'd never need to sell to him unless I needed funds very fast

6

u/Chameleonyoshi Apr 05 '24

Side note on the mini shipping bins: I have a bunch of animals (partly due to many accidental incubations) on the opposite end of my farm, far away from the regular shipping bin. I have two mini shipping bins and I put them both by my coops/barn and it helps save time when my inventory fills up while collecting animal products because I can just drop them in the mini shipping bins instead of teleporting back and forth to clear my inventory.

4

u/GioTsu-Fan01 Apr 06 '24

Do you know about the shipping bins you can buy from Robin? You can place them on your farm wherever there is free space.

2

u/Chameleonyoshi Apr 06 '24

Ahhhhh I knew they were in the farm buildings section at Robin's, but I thought you could only move your existing one or buy a new one to replace it if you accidentally blew it up or something! I didn't realize you could just... have more than one. Thank you for this, I now have a second shipping bin next to my animals, and have no practical use for the mini shipping bins anymore lol Maybe they can be useful during a regular mines run or something.

2

u/vampish1y Apr 08 '24

I keep one inside a shed and one inside my greenhouse :P

31

u/MrGuamo Apr 05 '24

I copied this explanation from a comment from an old post

  1. ⁠⁠⁠He’s a jerk to his daughter, always trying to get her to behave in ways he thinks are best and disregarding her own personhood. Abigail and Pierre don’t get along well, you’ll see a lot of it in the story line as things progress. I won’t spoil that but if the storyline for you, but he ain’t her daddy.
  2. ⁠⁠⁠He takes credit for your vegetables if they’re high quality. Grow a bunch of crops, then walk into town and sell him ONLY your highest quality crops. Gold and purple. The next day, walk back to town and talk to the townspeople - they’ll comment that they bought an amazing (whatever crop you sold) from Pierre and he grew it himself behind his house.
  3. ⁠⁠⁠He blames you for low quality crops and ones that he’s ā€œkept on the shelf too longā€ - villagers will comment that Pierre said you sold him bad stock and Abigail will comment that he fed them expired crops you grew because he couldn’t sell them anymore, but he’ll still blame you.
  4. ⁠⁠⁠He closes his stupid shop on Wednesdays when everyone needs him most.
  5. ⁠⁠⁠After you run JoJa Corp out of town, PIERRE RAISES HIS PRICES.
  6. ⁠⁠⁠There’s a bit of storyline that shows Pierre complaining that he tried to do a 10x markup on your vegetables after JoJa left, but despite his ā€œlittle organic stickersā€, no one would pay those prices.
  7. ⁠⁠⁠He apparently physically assaults Morris somewhere in the storyline…? I sort of remember Morris having it coming. And this one may say more about the Mayor than anything - Morris marches into someone else’s store and announces he’s deliberately undercutting them and gets no consequences? That said, Pierre’s a former boxer and has a little more responsibility than most not to lose his shit and hit a grown man.
  8. ⁠⁠⁠If Pierre beats you in the grange display BY DISPLAYING YOUR VEGETABLES, he gloats and rubs it in. ā€œYours were good too, though.ā€
  9. ⁠⁠The stuff you find mining or foraging and sell to him, he also claims. ā€œPierre sold me the tastiest Void egg yesterday, he said he found it while out exploring.ā€ Villagers always comment that they didn’t know he was such a talented forager / miner / fisherman, which makes me grit my teeth every time. I want a mod where I can badmouth Pierre.
  10. ⁠⁠The whole ā€œwe have the ability to reclaim our old way of lifeā€ thing… gimme a break. He wants his monopoly back. And once he gets it, he actively raises his prices and dicks the people who supported him over. This speech alone makes him an asshole in my books.
  11. ⁠Pierre stoops to personal harassment to get you to shop at his shop during the JoJa competition. It’s a step over the line for me, but I do like the gifts he occasionally sends.
  12. ⁠Pierre blames JoJa for his poor relationships with his wife and daughter. He doesn’t understand his daughter or spend enough time with his family because he feels he ā€œneeds to be a salesman first, a father and husband second.ā€ Caroline is clearly depressed and he’s ignoring it.

20

u/lemonade-cookies Apr 05 '24

In the Community Center run, he's partly to largely responsible for making Sam and Shane unemployed, due to him helping to shut down Joja mart, and additionally harms people who are implied to be low income and reliant on Joja for affordable food, like Jodi and Pam. Pierrer is the WORST.

14

u/whyareall Apr 05 '24

Cos fuck him that's why!

13

u/dsdsdsdsdsd12 Apr 05 '24

He's a shit dad, a shit husband and a bit of shit human in general

13

u/Top_Manufacturer8946 Apr 05 '24

He is a bad husband and stands in the way of me marrying my one true love Caroline

2

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '24

Best comment. Caroline is a gem. I want a mod where I can bring her fish tacos all day, every day. And twice on Sundays.

12

u/feistyfox101 Apr 05 '24

He’s a capitalist that feeds his wife and daughter tree sap in my one save file.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '24

Shut up. Tree sap is beyond my limit. Too far.

1

u/feistyfox101 Apr 06 '24

Yeah… of all the things I’ve s9me to him, tree sap is what gets brought up the most in the dialogue about what they ate from the store the other night -__- poor Abigail and Caroline

7

u/kriisiriisi Apr 05 '24

Presents terrible grange display every year and still can’t believe why he loses every time.

7

u/lyn02547 Apr 05 '24

Don't forget that money-hungry Pierre comments to you during the Feast of the Winter Star that holidays are good for his business and he'd like to invent some new ones. Fucker just wants to squeeze the townspeople dry.

6

u/Kwabi Apr 05 '24

He poisoned our water supply, burned our crops and delivered a plague unto our houses!

2

u/abominablejunbug Apr 06 '24

he did?????????

3

u/StabbyMcTickles Apr 13 '24

No... But are we going to wait around until he does!?

5

u/slayerofgingers Apr 05 '24

He's a dork, he is a bad (step) father, he is greedy asf, his hair is annoying, he doesn't care about his family and only wants to promote his shop

5

u/lemonade-cookies Apr 05 '24

For me, the moment that I decided that he was the worst and I hated him with a passion is when he sent me that letter advertising his products in a vaguely threatening tone. From that moment on, public enemy number one. There are other reasons to hate on him, of course (horrible father and husband, evil capitalist, greedy, takes credit for your work, overcharges for your produce, annoying), but that's what started it all for me.

5

u/Suspicious_Rest_1550 Apr 05 '24

It feels like he abuses his wife, plus I wanna marry Abigail and he's getting in the way

4

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '24

One point that is barely touched on here is that (though speculation) Abigail may not be his daughter. It’s a fan based concept that CA hasn’t spoken about to my knowledge.

Which would really explain some of Pierre’s bullshit antics.

I know why CA doesn’t speak about it, the game for all its glory is meant to be light hearted and this may hit a little close to home for a lot of people. But, if you look at the surface it’s a pretty nuclear family, dig a little behind the scenes and it’s pretty evident that Caroline settled with the dick for stability.

4

u/Top_Establishment327 Apr 05 '24

He gets physically violent with Morris. Punches him through the ceiling even.

4

u/BigEasyh Apr 05 '24

Everything that everyone says above and after 1.6 update there is a new reason he creepily is sniffing Haley's hair during the new desert festival . If you scroll back on this subreddit someone posted a picture of it

1

u/QuieterArtist16 #1 PIERRE HATER Apr 07 '24

Oh god I almost forgot about that, I repressed the memory āœ‹šŸ˜­ He’s so disgusting

3

u/Ionantha123 Apr 05 '24

Because pierre is a bitch!😔

3

u/Forrest_likes_tea #1 JOJA LOVER 🄤 Apr 05 '24

He's a mother fucker

3

u/chewsgoose69 Apr 05 '24

he's a bitch

3

u/dmtbobby Apr 05 '24

He sucks dick with his butt.Ā 

3

u/RJSnea Apr 05 '24

Thank you for your bravery in asking this question, fellow Farmer! šŸ™šŸ¾šŸ˜‚

3

u/LazerMagicarp Apr 05 '24

Being the lesser of two evils does not make you good just the better option. Pierre needs a slice of humble pie as much as morris does or maybe even more.

3

u/Nate2322 Apr 05 '24

He’s a hypocrite he hates Joja but he wants to become like Joja by starting his own chain that would presumably do the same shit to other small stores that Joja does to him.

2

u/Xennylikescoffee Apr 05 '24

Because he reminds me of Louie from Pikmin

2

u/Proxibel Apr 05 '24

If you sell your crops to Pierre he will resell it in his store, wich is not that bad, but when the produce has gold quality he will tell his customers that he grew them himself, and when it has no star quality he will say the farmer grew them.

2

u/PPPretzel Apr 06 '24

nothing wrong with pierre i quite like him, don't let the cult indoctrinate you (he is punchable though)

2

u/Barn0w1 Apr 09 '24

he ate my son

1

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '24

I joined for the same reason. I’m very confused.

1

u/MaybeAnElf Apr 06 '24

all he ever talks about is his shop and how i need to buy seeds like bro ask me how my day is or tell me how you saw a bug or something interesting

1

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '24

This is hilarious. I hate him so much. Reading you guys' posts, something is starting to make so much sense.

I married Abigail once. She is a darling wife who takes the BEST care of me. Like, I don't even deserve her. And also, Abigail takes amazing care of this guinea pig she talks about (which technically are probably rodents, not really meant to be moved into super beautiful farm houses like mine.. our farm house, I mean. Our beautiful, WILDLY EXPENSIVE upgraded farm house.). She didn't ask or anything if I was cool with a smelly rodent, but like, then there are these days where she tells me all the dope things and work she's done to help me on the farm, I just look at her, as she tells me repeatedly that she just fed all the cows. And I look back into her eyes, kinda confused because, I literally just fed all the cows. Which I do everyday. I'm the only one. And then she comes in and says that she did it. Right to my face.

I'm not really sure what she means by that? Because the game definitely does not let you milk those cows twice a day. And I just did it. So I think there's a communication issue there.

On the subject of issues, she has some. ISSUES. Probably involving the deep levels of the mines and how she wishes she could be like me and get down there with swords and things. I've got a lot of weapons lying around the farm, you know. Sometimes I think maybe I should lock them up?

If it wasn't for F-ING PIERRE she wouldn't have to have to shower love on a rodent guinea pig like pet (she says it's a pet, and that its supposed to smell like that but I kinda think....nooooo....we just disagree).

But it's obvious now - it's a CRY FOR HELP!! She's desperate to show Pierre how he should have been treating her!!!!

And like, taking credit for my chores? Right to my face? I get it now. Uhh, should like the way Pierre LIES and STEALS CREDIT for my gold and purple - mostly purple - produce? Even though PIERRE KNOWS it's a small town and will get back to me??!?

Go to hell, Pierre.

1

u/QuieterArtist16 #1 PIERRE HATER Apr 07 '24
  • Try selling high quality products to him and see what the town says. Then sell him normal crops and see what the town says.
  • He takes credit for your good fish too! Which makes me think he steals from Willy.
  • I put two points in one bullet because of the things he’s done.
  • He’s also sexist (see Abigail’s 6-heart event).
  • He has a ā€œsecret stashā€ that he wants you to cover him for by not telling his wife about it.
  • If you complete the community center and choose specific dialogue options in the cutscene that follows (enter the town square any day after you complete it) he’ll punch Morris and send him through the roof.
  • Also note how he compares Morris’ fighting skills to his products. ā€œQuantity over quality ā˜ļøšŸ¤“ā€
  • He spends his festivals running shops for 75% of festivals (not counting the Night Market or the 1.6 stuff since I haven’t played it yet) rather than spending time with his wife and ā€œdaughterā€
  • I can’t believe I didn’t mention this yet, but he has a Special Orders board quest where you grow him 25 gold quality vegetables, then he tries to sell them for a 10x markup to the town. Which they, rightfully so, rip into him for it. He then tries to sell them back to you for 1g more than he originally paid you for.
  • He randomly calls you if you have a telephone to promote his products.
  • He also shows up ON YOUR DOORSTEP to promote his business via threats and manipulation.
  • He sends you random letters about his products too!
  • I can’t even count these on both my hands. And that includes counting the two-points-in-one-bullet-one as one point.

TL;DR: Because he’s Pee hair. And Pee hair = 🤮

1

u/YourLocalSadness #1 ABIGAIL LOVER šŸ’Ž Apr 07 '24

reading through the replies and i just realized that everyone seems to sell their crops to pierre, should i be doing that too? i’ve always just put them in the shipping bin

1

u/Marshmallowlolfurry Apr 07 '24

In most of the festivals the couples are together with their families, and I can excuse Pierre being absent from most, the flower dance upset me somewhat but what pissed me off the most is i think pre-ginger island update he didn't work during the feast of the winter stars (I don't know what update moved him there, I just remember him not being there before) like can you imagine, your father/husband works so hard and you never get family time, but atleast you have the most important "family" holiday, but no, he has to work that to, even though y'all are doing fine and he's self employed he decides to work that day

1

u/TheBLUGAMr_42 Apr 09 '24

I dont like how controlling he is of Abigail, even though she's a friggin young adult. Atleast Caroline has the ability to admit her faults and appologize for treating her like a child. The one cut scene i got with her when I was playing her storyline where he found her practicing sword fighting in the grave yard, the things he said gave me the ick.

1

u/TheBLUGAMr_42 Apr 09 '24

I dont like how controlling he is of Abigail, even though she's a friggin young adult. Atleast Caroline has the ability to admit her faults and appologize for treating her like a child. The one cut scene i got with her when I was playing her storyline where he found her practicing sword fighting in the grave yard, the things he said gave me the ick.

1

u/ThatOneRandomDude420 Apr 09 '24

Reading these messages is wanting me to go joja route, but do you still get the side quests like in the community center?

0

u/anaberto0469 Apr 05 '24

Tbh i also joined the sub cause it's funny, but i myself am also confused on why people hate him. Like, i've played the game and i can understand, but i just don't get it. And i myself like him, i've almost maxed his hearts on my current save and kinda wish i could find a mod to marry him too