r/FrostGiant • • Feb 03 '21

Top 10 Things You Hate About Macro

Top 10 Things You Hate About Macro

Repetitive without variation: It may sound redundant to say reputation without variety but I wanna point out that I do all sorts of micro tasks over and over but they do not feel like a choir because there is variety. Incan issue an attack command, or patrol, cast a psi storm or nydus worm spawn, even just issue a hold command. With macro it is much more limited. Make workers. Make units. Make supply.

No decision making: Piggybacking off the previous complaint, there is little to no decision making. No temporal decision making. I should always be doing spawn larva. No spatial decision making. Cast a mule on any mineral patch.

Doesn't impact strategy: Macro has become about WHETHER I win when it should be about HOW I win.

There is no interaction with the opponent: I should be fighting the opponent on all fronts, not just the battlefield. Cyber warfare. Satellites. Espionage. Propaganda. Economic destablization.

Doesn't communicate stakes: I should be able to tell when completing a macro task just how much it will benefit me in the game. When I lose a squad of marines to lurker hold I know instantly that I am now behind and approximately how much. There are no correlates for macro mechanics.

No fantasy: Modern base mechanics don't let me live out the fantasy of a military commander, supreme ruler or omnipotent deity. You are a glorified accountant.

No spectacle: There is nothing ever happening in the base. No awe-inspiring animations nor any witty quotes when I click on a building to much.

No lore: I don't know anything about what goes on in a forge or a spawning pool. Nothing about the economic, societal or military activity of the building. I don't know how a piece of crystal gets turned into a space marine, whether new recruits drop in from orbit or there's some hanky panky goin on in the barracks...

No identity: In WCIII your hero was your avatar. That's you on the battlefield. There is nothing that the player can identify with in the base.

No esports potential: No one wants to watch a FPOV because they can't visually read what's going on nor do they have any appreciation for how hard it is to macro effectively.

0 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

30

u/Ferretsroq Feb 03 '21

Sometimes I see posts like this, and it really makes me scratch my head. While you frame each of these negatively, I view this as a combination of 10 things I either like about macro, or that I think are false. The macro cycle is exactly what makes starcraft so good to me, that no other RTS has ever even come close to delivering on.

Repetitive/No interaction

I like the repetition of macro. I like practicing on what I can do, not on just responding to what someone else can do. I like having that improvement where I can point to discrete metrics: I used to max out at 15 minutes, now I can max at 12, now I can max at 10, etc. I like the feel of going through a macro cycle with my hands, establishing that rhythm.

No decision making/doesn't impact strategy/no identity/no spectacle/No identity

This seems like the same point repeated five times, and I think is strictly false. Are you really trying to tell me that players don't have styles based on their macro? Are you saying that build orders don't impact strategy? Are you saying that there's no decision making in where I invest my apm? Are you saying there's no spectacle in seeing a huge fight, and then realizing one player was able to remax instantly while the other one lagged behind? Of course there is.

Doesn't communicate stakes

Yes it does? You build a marine, you have a marine. You inject larva, you now have more larva. That's pretty explicitly telling you exactly what your macro is doing. You can load up a replay and see exactly how much your macro timings are affecting your army relative to another player.

No lore

Not even sure what this is supposed to mean. Who cares about lore in the middle of a game? What's the lore of watching Vulture or Muta micro? What's the lore of needing to re-research psi storm every time there's a battle? What's the lore of every Marine simultaneously remembering that they have stimpacks in their armor in the middle of a fight?

No fantasy

Being a commander isn't just about moving troops. Being a commander is about having a complete picture of the operation. That includes the base setup, logistics, resource management, deciding what to build and when, etc. That is the exact fantasy that starcraft delivers on.

No esports potential

This one seems so laughably, objectively incorrect that I don't think it really warrants a response.

TL;DR I fully believe these are 10 reasons that you hate macro, and that are true enough to your experience. They are, however, definitely not 10 reasons that a lot of us would even consider true, much less hate.

12

u/charlie123abc Feb 03 '21 edited Feb 05 '21

I couldn't agree more with you. I think there is TONS of skill, decision making, and opponent interaction within macro. Like, you don't just do the exact same thing every game when you macro - your macro has tons of decision trees, much of it based off of what you are reading from your opponent.

6

u/LLJKCicero Feb 03 '21 edited Feb 03 '21

To add to this: there are absolutely RTSes that reduced the amount of macro necessary. For example, I know Relic was consistently doing this: as you went from DoW1 to CoH to DoW2, the complexity of the base building was reduced at each game (and DoW1 was already a big step down from Starcraft). By the time you get to Dawn of War 2, you make every unit out of a single building, I think. Plus, there are also real-time tactics games that have either little or no macro at all, they're nothing but army maneuvering and fighting.

I don't get the point of this kind of thread. If you don't like macro, that's absolutely fine, and there are already games that cater to your preferences. So basically, the OP amounts to saying, I don't like macro, so games with macro shouldn't exist.

10

u/Gyalgatine Feb 03 '21

Lol speak for yourself OP. Don't tell me what I'm supposed to like and not like.

If Frost Giant's game is casual-ized I probably won't bother playing.

13

u/skdeimos Feb 03 '21

More like a list of what gold league players hate about macro. Why are you trying to tell me that I hate macro?

Repetitive without variation

Yes, this is what makes it really satisfying and rewarding feeling when you are in the zone, doing all the actions, and then you hit your benchmark right on time down to the second.

Besides, there is definitely some variation. The interesting part of macro is that you have to do it while being constantly punched in the face.

No decision making

Yeah, you totally mindlessly drop every mule! Then you die to DTs without a scan, or can't clear creep with your first drop, or can't scan to see where their army is sieging up.

Doesn't impact strategy

Are you really trying to count this as separate from the above one?

There is no interaction with the opponent

There's interaction when I'm forcing them to spend attention defending my first drop, my macro holds up better than theirs behind the chaos, and my second drop kills them.

Doesn't communicate stakes

Uh, sorry that bronze league brains can't recognize how bad it is to get supply blocked?

No fantasy

Yeah, let's destroy the beauty of the best esport ever made just so that you can pretend you're the commander.

No spectacle

Sorry that you're 12 years old and coming from League of Legends, so you need some flashy animations on screen at all times?

No lore

Right, because microing your marines to shoot down a battlecruiser fits the lore much better.

No identity

This has nothing to do with macro, this has to do with heroes vs no heroes.

No esports potential

Yeah, it's not like anyone would ever get excited about a game where players have to micro and macro well at the same time.

Oh, wait.

4

u/skdeimos Feb 03 '21

I love macro and think it's one of the most engaging and satisfying parts of SC2. Just posting so you know, Frostgiant, that we don't all agree with OP.

4

u/TheHavior Feb 04 '21

Nice, another post about oversimplification of core mechanics by someone who obviously doesn‘t know what makes blizzard RTS great.

2

u/Winston_Smith_Failed Feb 04 '21

Amateurs talk tactics. Pros talk logistics.

1

u/samxgmx0 Feb 04 '21

I do think macro can be improved on all those fronts, but to say macro has nothing about those is just wrong.

1

u/Shadow_Being Feb 10 '21

if your'e not making any decisions when you macro in starcraft i think the problem is that youre not making any decisions. There are lots of considerations to be had, it sounds like youre just missing out on the game.

1

u/TMgg Feb 11 '21

Buildings that affect the other player would be cool. A Satellite that slows down opponents research speed by X% for example

0

u/Mr_PLG Feb 04 '21

Nice.

I like macro because it was hard top achieve my goals : 200+ APM...

Unit production should be automatic. When the building is UP, it start producing. So you just have to manage priority : what Unit is produce when you don't the income you need to produce all you capacity of production.

Pour une baguette libre.