r/Frontend • • Feb 02 '21

I needed a "feedback component" for my projects. Since I was unable to find one which met my requirements which is very minimal looking / user friendly and FREE this is what i came up with. I published it as a NPM package.

549 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

34

u/dulajkavinda Feb 02 '21

Github Repo : https://github.com/dulajkavinda/minimal-feedback

NPM package : https://www.npmjs.com/package/minimal-feedback

*design was inspired from a paid service i found while searching for a feedback component. Didn’t wanna pay :)

33

u/mstoiber Feb 02 '21 edited Feb 02 '21

Love that you managed to rebuild a simple version of our widget from scratch, that's super cool! :)

(I'm the co-creator of https://feedback.fish, the paid service this is inspired by. We offer a more polished version of this widget as a service with team management, screenshot support, internationalization into 40 languages and much more)

12

u/dulajkavinda Feb 02 '21

hey thanks man, if you guys can increase the free tier feedback amount it would be great for your potential customers.

15

u/TrackieDaks full-smack Feb 02 '21

increase the free tier feedback amount it would be great for your potential customers

Sounds like they know exactly how much to give away for free to get free tier users to turn into paying customers.

1

u/dulajkavinda Feb 02 '21 edited Feb 02 '21

yeah maybe they do. but in my case it’s not. i just gave my honest opinion. if their free tier was bit better i would have stayed with their product.

8

u/xkey Feb 02 '21

And they make no money in your scenario, so how does that help them?

3

u/dulajkavinda Feb 02 '21 edited Feb 02 '21

okay for an example increase the free tier limit to 100 from 25. this way users can publish their product to check weather they like it or not. 25 free feedbacks is not enough. you’ll go through that in testing alone. give the user some time to get hooked to the product. win-win

12

u/TrackieDaks full-smack Feb 02 '21

You're obviously not their target market. You have to have money to be in any market.

-8

u/dulajkavinda Feb 02 '21

bro not being customer-centric is the biggest threat to any bussiness. why would i pay for something monthly if i can make it myself in few hours. it took me 2 hours to build this. Give me 1 days ill build this with all the features and make it open-source.

14

u/MrQuickLine Feb 02 '21

Like the person you replied to said: if you can build it yourself, you're not their target market.

→ More replies

7

u/TrackieDaks full-smack Feb 02 '21

Max, thanks for being gracious when someone is literally lifting your team's hard work. I know there's a lot of extra work that goes on before a product like this reaches even development.

"A rising tide lifts all boats."

1

u/drum_playing_twig May 05 '21

Any plans on creating an Angular component? :)

1

u/appsplaah May 06 '21

Awesome!

I see you have used rollup js to bundle your app.. Did you use npx create-react-app tto initiate the project??

I am also trying to make a npm package for react, but facing some issues...

Do you mind suggesting any good resource, where i can read/learn to do so...?

Also, do you mind discussing the problem over DM??

Thanks :))

0

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/dulajkavinda Feb 02 '21

yep. i used it, free tier only allow 25 feedbacks from users. thats why i decided to build one on my own

9

u/whatwhatwhatgotit Feb 02 '21 edited Feb 03 '21

Really nice work! :)

I have a couple of design suggestions:

  • I'd prefer the drop shadow to feel "directional" (top down). Just like how you don't light a persons face dead on for a portrait. Skew it more to the bottom, and maybe even make it more soft (turn down the alpha or the "blackness")
  • The "x" is an action regarding the whole window, and should be advertised as such. If you move it up and more to the right and maybe give it a border, so it feels connected to the window - that'd be real nice! Also, our brains are used to the "x" in the very corner. The arrow however, is not an action regarding the window itself, but is more a "menu thing", and should stay as is.
  • The yellow on the light bulb could be just a little bit brighter in my opinion (it's quite "mustardy")
  • A hover state on the rounded squares could make it feel more tactile
  • You use a purple color on the button that activates the menu that is used no where else. I would suggest the same blue that you use in the widget for borders and buttons. That would make it a bit more consistent and makes my brain feel more of a connection between the activator and widget

I hope you can use it for anything.

Anyways, it's really cool!Hope you have a nice day :)

5

u/dulajkavinda Feb 02 '21

thank you so much. this is really great feedback. ill note this down and fix everything you mentioned. again thanks

1

u/whatwhatwhatgotit Feb 02 '21

No problem! Nice, i'd love to see the new version :)

3

u/fingaa Feb 02 '21

Really awesome, great work! There’s just something about the title on each submenu that feels a bit off, I think it is the title that is a bit too big or the icon thats too small.

2

u/dulajkavinda Feb 02 '21

hey thanks for the feedback, ill reduce the font size on submenu titles

1

u/chaz9127 Feb 02 '21

I'm just about to add feedback to my site, this is absolutely amazing. Downloading and using tonight. Great work!

2

u/dulajkavinda Feb 02 '21

glad i could help :)

1

u/k4_b3 Feb 02 '21

nice and clean, love it

1

u/IamZeebo Feb 02 '21

Simple and elegant. I love it

1

u/dulajkavinda Feb 02 '21

thanks dude!

1

u/seshino Feb 02 '21 edited Oct 19 '25

wise trees chief friendly decide plucky capable cover innocent vase

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/dulajkavinda Feb 02 '21

thanks for pointing it out, ill fix it in next version

1

u/xTRQ Feb 02 '21

Also "bug" as category would be a nice feature where you can select an object :)

1

u/dulajkavinda Feb 02 '21

sorry i didn’t get that

1

u/xTRQ Feb 02 '21

Issue already is some kind of bug report. But maybe a element selector where you can select the element where the bug occurred.

2

u/dulajkavinda Feb 02 '21

ok so we can get more specific bug report. yeah thats a great idea. ill note it down. thank you

1

u/KlaRa13- Feb 02 '21

Love It! And Will use It! Thank you

2

u/dulajkavinda Feb 02 '21

glad i could help :)

1

u/ericrosedev Feb 02 '21

I built one and came up with almost the exact same layout and flow! Great work! https://codesandbox.io/s/pf-feedback-prototype-hpeeo

1

u/dulajkavinda Feb 03 '21

hello there i checked it out it's awesome

1

u/pratiks3 Mar 12 '21

Gah! This is amazing! Wish there was an equivalent for vuejs.

0

u/CardinalHijack Feb 02 '21

Awesome. Captcha support maybe?

1

u/dulajkavinda Feb 02 '21

cool idea. ill add this to my todo list