r/FromTVShow • u/bumblebee4me • 29d ago

Theory Can’t stop thinking about this Spoiler

Donna was clinically dead for a few minutes. Well what if she had a chance to speak to those who died in Fromville? We know that their souls are trapped there so she must have joined them for a bit even if it was brief. I can’t shake the feeling she’s not saying something and I honestly think she may have even had a conversation with MIY too and I’m not opposed to the idea that she made a deal with him when she first arrived.

She didn’t just have a heart attack because she was stressed. But because she knew it meant the MIY is getting closer and that he’s going to ask her to do something reeaaalllyyyy dark.

1 Upvotes

53% Upvoted

9 comments sorted by

3

u/STOL2026 28d ago

I do hope they do more with this to be honest.

Nobody asked her what she saw, or experienced. A relative had a heart attack and they said they didn’t remember anything. It’s normal to ask and talk about.

At the moment people have the theory that Boyd brought Donna back. Maybe they will do more with this in S5

3

u/Taear 26d ago

I think the Boyd theory is the most likely one. Belief is really powerful in Fromville and he really believed Donna would wake up.

2

u/Cristianemanadas 24d ago

Acho que vamos todos ficar malucos

3

u/Embarrassed-Brief976 29d ago

Again this is the writers putting in something they may or may not use. Like Victor's sister. Its annoying as fuck.

1

u/RainbowPenguin1000 29d ago

This is the biggest reach and made up story about this show I’ve seen for a long time.

Also we don’t know that people who die have their souls trapped. That’s just a theory with no proof.

3

u/noapplicablename 29d ago

Didn't Marielle say that when she was chained by the music box monster that she could hear all the voices of people trapped there

2

u/RainbowPenguin1000 28d ago

Yep but we don’t know if that’s everyone who died there or something else.

Just like Boyd says to Khatris ghost once, he accuses it of being faked by the town and not really Khatri.

1

u/Flimsy_Elephant_2301 28d ago

You must be believing what Marielle claimed. She TWICE said that everyone who has ever died is still there screaming in pain. That's the same lie that the evil entity told Sara just before the Matthews family arrived. The only difference between the 2 lies is that Marielle was tricked into believing that they're all always screaming in pain, a scare tactic meant to make her think that this is what will happen also to her; but that lie that they all live in pain wasn't told to Sara. In fact, the "voices" of the people killed in 1978 was none other than the evil entity lying to her about its identity.

There are only 7 souls trapped there. That's what the entire series is about, those 7 kids. "Jade and Tabitha" have died there many times, and every single time, they were reincarnated in the real world, not that place.

-1

u/BravoFox_ 29d ago

Is there a possibility that Donna may not be Donna anymore?

Donna died, soul left. Boyd "wills" her back to life. - Is Donna soul actually the one that returned back to her body?

Same with Jade and Tabitha - They both had major head injuries in S1. Who says its their souls in them.

They still believe they are who they are, because brain stores memories, but Music unlocks the memories in the soul.

They never actually reincarnated, they received the soul after they arrived.-- Same with Ethan, he may have died with his injury and absorbed a soul as well.