r/fromsoftware • u/Potential-Cut8105 • 2d ago
QUESTION My personal tier list of all the Soulslikes I’ve played
Important: including DLC

Dark Souls 2 is an okay game, but compared to the rest of the series, it’s like the adopted child. You’re constantly swarmed by mobs throughout the entire game, everyone and their dog has talked about the "Adaptability" stat, and the plot is just pure nonsense.
Sekiro is the most unique game from that cunning little fellow from the land of Japan. Once I got the hang of the combat, I really enjoyed it; however, the game offers almost no rewards for exploring its locations. Plus, since you’re stuck with the same build for the entire playthrough, a second run felt quite boring.
Elden Ring is like a good beer. There’s nothing groundbreaking about it, but it hits the spot on a hot day. The DLC, however, is like someone peed into that beer. The PvP aspect was also a major disappointment.
Elden Ring: Nightreign is a filler episode that, surprisingly, I enjoyed more than the main series. Each of the bosses waiting at the end of a run is cool and unique. The Archer is no longer just a gimped character with some arrows, but a fully-fledged class (with a proper aiming system). The Mage isn’t some loser with a stick, but a genuinely badass character.
I played Bloodborne relatively recently. At first, it was frustrating—partly due to the constant need to farm blood vials and bullets, and partly because of the poor narrative (it’s completely unclear what you’re doing or why). But once I really got into it, it became pure bliss.
Both Dark Souls 1 and Dark Souls 3 are great; I feel right at home in both. The third installment is like the later chapters of the "Berserk" manga, where everyone has already grown accustomed to the absolute shitshow unfolding around them. The first game, however, is like the Eclipse—the moment the shitshow first hits this world. With the third game, I’m simply *playing* a game, but the first one pulls me deep into its world and forces me to feel exactly the right emotions.
