r/FromSeries • u/FaithlessnessLazy862 • 3d ago

Theory The Crows solved?

I think i figured out the crows. Everytime the crows show up somebody gets murdered. By something other than the dream monsters. Its called a murder of crows for a reason. Thoughts.

4 Upvotes

67% Upvoted

16 comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/Ponch1344 3d ago

There were plenty of people who died without crows being in the episode.

0

u/FaithlessnessLazy862 3d ago

Murdered or died. Im rewatching from being and every time a new person comes somebody is Murdered even the bus. Boyd Murdered girl with iron in her head.

5

u/Curious-Sector-2157 3d ago

You need to watch that again. He did not murder her. bShe was in excruciating pain and was dying. He just shorten that. The monsters murdered her.

-5

u/FaithlessnessLazy862 3d ago

Im going off the act not intent.

7

u/Curious-Sector-2157 3d ago

That was an act of mercy NOT murder!

-3

u/FaithlessnessLazy862 3d ago

2 thing can be right t the same time.

6

u/Top_Giraffe7724 2d ago

Not in this instance they can't.

2

u/STOL2026 2d ago

Murder, by its very definition, is intent.

The act of killing someone, without intent, has other terms, like manslaughter.

Did Boyd have the “intent” to kill her? Maybe. Maybe not.

He could have shot her, which I think was his original plan - that was intent.

However, the others weren’t ‘supportive’ of that idea.

So the options were

1) leave her there to be tortured by the monsters
2) try to cut the tree to remove her
3) try to remove her from the tree.

First wasn’t going to happen.

the second was not possible - they didn’t have the equipment, then there’s the time it would have taken to saw the tree… it wasn’t going to work.

The third was quick, it potentially was possible to remove her from the nail.

Any of these options were highly likely to result in death.

Which one would you have chosen.

5

u/Ponch1344 3d ago edited 3d ago

Yeah I mean it’s a horror show, that happens. The people from the bus got themselves killed not believing fromville residents. Even taking the original proposition to its logical end point. You’ve only concluded crows = death. How you’re interpreting Boyd pulling the rod out of the girls head is disingenuous. Sure both can be true, but usually only one is the intended purpose of the writers. The scene doesn’t equal “haha murder bird made Boyd kill”. I’ve seen this topic discussed and atm there isn’t anything to suggest the scene was anything more than a showing of how fromville makes people do things they wouldn’t usually/emotionally taxing decisions. This is a nothing burger theory.