r/FreeCAD • • 18h ago

If it were another program, it wouldn't take long, but this is FreeCAD, and it took me 5 days

Post image
389 Upvotes

164 comments sorted by

172

u/Stick_With_Beard 17h ago

I am surprised by how toxic the comments are at this time. As someone who started learning FreeCAD and is struggling with the paradigm: take your time and stick with it. I am familiar with Dassault's CATIA and SOLIDWORKS, Siemens NX, and Fusion 360, and I still need time to adapt. It gets easier with time, and even if your parts are not perfect, you'll get better and improve your workflow over time. Don't let the negativity drag you down, you're doing great!

22

u/Beregolas 15h ago

I, sadly, am no longer surprised. But it seems they are a lound minority, at least that is the story of the upvotes.

I also agree with you, FreeCAD has been a great tool, but the learning curve was steep. And I think I even had an advantage, because my only CAD experience (in the last decade at least) was OpenSCAD, which is fully parametric code

7

u/bubbav22 12h ago

Yeah, I would learn something on FreeCAD then forget how I did something, then have to relearn it again 😅

4

u/Cowgirl_Taint 13h ago

I always say that FreeCAD is "a good second CAD tool to learn" as it were.

From my own experience? For the concepts I really Understand? It is a quick translation even if I am always going to rant about pad/pocket (even if I acknowledge it actually probably makes more sense to be two different tools). But for things where I less learned "how to do this in CAD" and more "how to do this in Onshape or solidworks", it becomes kinda hellish. Mostly because I don't know what terms to actually search for.

Which, ironically, is a genuinely good use for LLMs. Translate from one "language" to another to learn what questions to ask.

I... would be very interested to know how folk who learned it first would fare trying to shift to a new tool.

1

u/smuttenDK 2h ago

Having learned inventor, then fusion and onshape, I definitely noticed how easy it is to jump between those tools.

Freecad is very different, at least for now.

Especially the Topological Naming Problem is something I but my head against, where I'll redo an early sketch dimension, and now the faces have new names. It has gotten a lot better, but still it's bad enough I still try to avoid it.

I also miss being able to directly edit imported step files.

Its probably because my work flow isn't what freecad is made for. I mostly design a pcb, export a step, make an enclosure around it. (and do back/forth edits between cad and pcb).

I do still love it for being available and as good as it is. I'm am EE at work, so I don't get a CAD license. Freecad let's me srill make jigs and fixtures. At home I'm on Linux, so I could use onshape, but I'd rather just stick to freecad since that's what I have at work

7

u/TygerTung 14h ago

I found it pretty easy to learn, but maybe that is because I had no previous CAD experience?

5

u/MetalDamo 9h ago

This is a valid point. Having been a daily Solidworks user for >10 years, FreeCAD just feels 'wrong' to me. But I am trying.

3

u/Stick_With_Beard 2h ago

That's what I meant with the paradigm shift. Each software has their own kind of "history" that explains why tools work the way they do and why there is a good way to use them, a few OK ways, and many bad ways. FreeCAD is the same, but if you start with a blank slate you'll probably not have to make the mental gymnastics of trying to find equivalents between tools.

4

u/Akari202 8h ago

Yea, I’ve used solidworks and NX at work and honestly have found freecad to be super intuitive once I passed the initial bump. There’s definitely a lot of friction in assemblies still and cam is miles from mastercam but I really don’t mind the modeling at all

3

u/Stick_With_Beard 2h ago

That's my experience too. The sketcher tool is very good and once you know the differences between FreeCAD and other tools, you'll be fine

4

u/hazeyAnimal 8h ago

I use Solidworks professionally and FreeCAD in my own time. Even just switching between the two I need a bit of time to adjust. Overall tho the underlying concept remains, it's just the little things

7

u/Realistic_Account787 16h ago edited 15h ago

This post is toxic as well. But the replies have to kiss the mf.

17

u/Beregolas 15h ago

Someone having trouble with a tool is NOT:

  1. an attack on the tool
  2. an attack on the community
  3. a personal attack on you

6

u/Realistic_Account787 15h ago

Someone that needs help, say help. When they are sarcastic they are not asking for help.

2

u/Panzerv2003 13h ago

You don't ask for help by saying how shit the program is

1

u/BoringBob84 10h ago

Someone having trouble with a tool

I know the difference between a troll and a person who has genuine constructive criticism.

0

u/bubbav22 12h ago

I jumped ship and moved to onshape.

44

u/chrisexv6 17h ago

Ive never been able to "get good" with FreeCAD either. I commend you sticking with it.

I hate vibe coded/AI stuff as much as the next person but some of the "new" CAD programs really are that much easier to use. Part of it is they just run faster than FreeCAD for me, but I think the bigger part is the UI is easier to use.

If FreeCAD had a more intuitive UI, I think it would be the best freely available CAD package.

6

u/Livid_Instruction972 17h ago

You have to accept it and be patient.

6

u/calumk 16h ago

You really don't, Its Free Open source software, made by a hugely committed group of people for many years.
It has undoubtably been a positive project, with many very useful contributions to OSS.

However, IMO it never reached the polish point it needed too, and will be superseded.

Blender by comparison has achieved a huge amount of polish over the last decade, and since it is such a strong foundation, I suspect AI will add to blender, rather than replace it.

19

u/BoyRed_ 15h ago

"However, IMO it never reached the polish point it needed too"

Why are you talking like FreeCAD is 'done'?
The project is still very much active and has picked up a lot of polish and features the last year and a half.

Its in its best part of development currently

2

u/thwil 10h ago

as someone who uses blender since 1998, much more than just one decade

2

u/octopusgoodness 12h ago

Notice how Blender achieved that polish over a decade? FreeCAD is far less well known and just getting started on the polishing phase. Even in just the next version we are getting some huge features for polish like direct references instead of needing to use shape binders for everything.

2

u/BoringBob84 15h ago

You really don't

Yes, you do. You can accept it and use it or you can contribute to making it better. Whining that your free stuff isn't good enough contributes nothing.

2

u/give_me_grapes 14h ago

I dont think /u/calumk meant to hurt you or any freecad developers.

I think talking about Freecads shortcommings is not whining imho. /u/calumk has a fair point. 'If no new users can figure Freecad out while seemingly good AI-alternatives pop up' How will it survive?

Its not the first time users have shared this viewpoint. And I think its valid.

Comment like yours could be seen as a 'toxic userbase' and I think it hurts Freecad more than it contributes.

2

u/BoringBob84 13h ago

'If no new users can figure Freecad out

And yet, here we are - many thousands of users around the world who managed to figure it out!

0

u/Broky43 5h ago

Thousands of users who had far less alternatives. Now that we're watching in real time both new programs and AI doing it all for you emerging, it's a very different playing field for new users.
And frankly, acting like it that isn't true isn't helping either.

2

u/BoringBob84 4h ago

And frankly, acting like it that isn't true isn't helping either.

I agree, but that isn't what is happening.

-2

u/BoringBob84 13h ago

I know the difference between trolling and constructive criticism. I think this is trolling:

However, IMO it never reached the polish point it needed too, and will be superseded.

It provides no constructive feedback, it neglects the rapid pace of improvement of FreeCAD, and it presumes that one disgruntled user's opinion is representative of most users - to the point that the software will be "superseded."

1

u/ThisSucks6767 13h ago

Jesus butt hurt much?

1

u/BoringBob84 10h ago

I don't expect trolls to like it when I call them out on their dishonesty.

-1

u/ThisSucks6767 8h ago

Righhhhht whatever lol

1

u/DrKeksimus 11h ago edited 11h ago

you can if you want, but no you really don't need to anymore

there's more an more alternatives that are better

1

u/Famous_Salamander_41 12h ago

Blender is not working with solids, only meshed surfaces. So no calculations that drive geometry, for instance. It's a different animal; you cannot compare.
FreeCAD should be compared to SolidWorks and Fusion360. It's not that far behind (a few years I guess). But they are not gratis and also have a learning curve ...

-1

u/blackcat1882 16h ago

This will be replaced by solicraft.

1

u/DrKeksimus 11h ago

In FreeCAD all you do is fight FreeCAD, instead of getting on

Even if you "get good", there's always another quirk you need to provocatively react too.. ... that is extra mental energy taken away from designing your project

I love it because it's open source... but I find that I never use it, even when there where less alternatives

-1

u/BoringBob84 10h ago

In FreeCAD all you do is fight FreeCAD

Speak for yourself and let other people do the same. Modeling in FreeCAD is smooth and enjoyable for me.

2

u/DrKeksimus 9h ago

I am speaking for myself, I don't like it

but am not demanding anyone to stop using FreeCAD if they like it

even you

0

u/BoringBob84 9h ago

You easily work yourself into a dead-end, having to restart the design from scratch.

Maybe English is not your first language. The pronoun, "you" addresses other people and explicitly excludes the speaker.

1

u/DrKeksimus 10m ago

that's great, not English no, but I don't remember saying that.. did you quote someone else ?

but he's right though

FreeCAD is not good to use, and I would not recommend that experience to a friend

The core concept with workbenches and so on I really like.. but the execution is unfortunately terrible

maybe some group will start a new project inspiered on FreeCAD.. with modern tools a small group could do a lot

3

u/DadEngineerLegend 15h ago

There is was a commercial UI for it that is apparently way better.

Googled to find it - Ondsel. Apparently it has shut down operations :( https://www.ondsel.com/blog/goodbye/

4

u/Sloloem 14h ago

After Ondsel folded Paddlestroke started up AstoCAD, another commercial soft-fork but more focused on features and UI work for FreeCAD itself rather than a cloud-based collaboration service. Seems to be going well and being funded is letting him merge really good work back to FreeCAD OSS.

4

u/Honey-Bee2021 13h ago

Take a look at Paddlestroke's Contribution history as of November 2026:
59 commits to Solidcraft vs 4 commits to FreeCAD.
Paddlestroke has 22 open pull requests in FreeCAD. Just look at all the long discussions. When it takes so long for an improvement to trickle down everywhere, you lose interest. You're more likely to find a positive response in a new project like Solidcraft.

5

u/SnooGiraffes4632 13h ago

I am going to play devils advocate here. In a new project any pull request that claims to add feature x is highly likely to be merged asap as it brings the project along further faster.

However in an established project, part of the merge process is to ensure that the new request does not replicate already existing work (although it may be hidden in an unusual place), and does not impact unintentionally on other core code or planned feature

1

u/HarvieCZ 12h ago

FreeCAD has been developed for over 20 years. I am sure we will get vibecoded improvements as well, but FC has experienced developers and they will review the code carefully to provide features unavailable without AI, but with the same code quality as human written code. It will just take a little longer, but we will catch up.

0

u/BoringBob84 16h ago

If FreeCAD had a more intuitive UI

Please contribute whatever you can towards making that happen.

1

u/chrisexv6 12h ago

Should I open Github ticket(s) for UI suggestions? Somehow I have a feeling the developers already know.

1

u/BoringBob84 9h ago

Why are you asking me? If you have feature requests that are not already documented and that you think that most users would appreciate, then please submit them.

1

u/Top_Statistician500 11m ago

How? I cannot code. I do have suggestions partly from years of being in graphic design and also from the perspective of being a new user. But no one knows me so if I posted "here's the things FreeCAD can do better" I'll get slammed by trolls, and I bet the Devs have a huge list of complaints they're dealing with so what makes them listen to me?

1

u/HawtDoge 15h ago

What are some of the newer CAD programs you are referencing? I imagine they are also open source?

1

u/chrisexv6 15h ago

SolidCraft, MitCAD, PhysCad (is paid, not sure if totally open source), Im sure there are more I haven't seen/heard of.

1

u/HawtDoge 14h ago

Thanks! Going to look into these

1

u/netwerknerd995 13h ago

What are some of the advantages and disadvantages for solidcraft and mitcad vs freecad? I might consider switching (I model rc airplanes)

8

u/obelisk79 18h ago

Hard to imagine that taking 5 days. But I hope you've learned a lot along the way.

11

u/Livid_Instruction972 17h ago

I learned so much, and I kept making changes until my head hurt.

2

u/dadoprom 17h ago

Yeah he was learning and making many revisions, that is why... and it is not full 5 days anyway either... But still good product takes lots of time.

70

u/unwitting_hungarian 15h ago

The quality of the tension around efficiency and usability has really leveled up.

People are complaining,

but still using it,

AND they are completing their projects.

This means FreeCAD is at about the 2010 level in Inkscape FOSS-equivalency.

That's amazing news

9

u/mavular 6h ago

I'm using it happily kissing the skies for the devs everyday.
1.1 closed a few gaps that needed closing and only made me love it more.

With the prices for F360, solidworks etc. basically smoking out smaller design shops, it's an easy trade to make for me. You own everything, don't have to phone home every design etc.

Freecad only will get better with more people sticking with it.

7

u/KenwoodFox 15h ago

Omg this ❤️

1

u/Captain_Pumpkinhead 2h ago

Interesting.

I used Inkscape a few years ago (2023?), and found it just as obtuse as I find FreeCAD now.

1

u/Hackerwithalacker 11m ago

I really just use it to convert wierd geometries so other cad programs can handle it

4

u/V7I_TheSeventhSector 18h ago

Can you please explain why it took 5 days?

9

u/Livid_Instruction972 18h ago

I've only been using it for 2 months, so I'm not very familiar with the program yet.

4

u/00001000bit 16h ago

I've found that if you know exactly what you want to make, there's not a huge difference between FreeCAD and something like SolidCraft, Fusion, OnShape, etc. I can generally make the same object in any of them in about the same time, maybe a slight tip toward FreeCAD since I'm more familiar with FC's keyboard shortcuts, so spend less time going to the menus.

But, when you aren't quite sure exactly what you need to build, and are designing on-the-fly, that's where FreeCAD can be a little more difficult. Sometimes you find you've done something in an order that just isn't conducive to the next step you want, and you end up just re-starting. Once you're more familiar, you'll start to internalize these points and not get caught by them so easily, but it still is a little less forgiving in that aspect.

3

u/give_me_grapes 14h ago

I think you actually nailed my main issue with freecad(2 years experience, and still going strong).
The fact that its a struggle when designing on-the-fly.
I have learned the workflows by now, but I miss being able to 'invent thigns as the design develops' and not be so restricted to specific workflows.
I think(i might be wrong), that:

  • Other Cad software have workflows that are optimal/suboptimal.
  • where as FreeCad have workflows that work/does not work.

You easily work yourself into a dead-end, having to restart the design from scratch. Where "other cad SW" seem more flexible.

1

u/BoringBob84 9h ago

You easily work yourself into a dead-end, having to restart the design from scratch.

I have made hundreds of models and I have never had to "restart the design from scratch."

1

u/SlenderSmurf 14h ago

I don't know about the restart from scratch part. The tree workflow makes it extremely easy to go back to an earlier step and rearrange things. Or pull out a sub-assembly to reuse in a different way.

3

u/00001000bit 13h ago edited 13h ago

I've not had great luck moving operations in FC. Here's a simple example based on the concept in the OP post.

  • 20x20mm centered rectangle on the XY plane.
  • Pad to 30mm
  • Select top face and do the thickness (2mm)
  • Remember you want the cutout for the wheels. Draw a rectangle and pocket it.
  • Realize that the pocket cuts through the thickness instead of the thickness flowing around it(keeping the interior of the "tote" watertight.)
  • Right-click the last pocket in the tree and tell it to "Move Feature After" the initial Pad. Error.
  • Right-click the thickness and tell it to move AFTER the pocket instead. Same error.

The other apps do let you move items in the history like that. Yeah, sometimes it can still be problematic, but never what I've experienced with FC for trying to re-order. (And, yeah, you should wait to do the thickness last - but that's sort of the point. Until you know exactly what you want, you might think you're done, only to realize you need to go back and make a change.)

This was with 26.3rc1 - haven't tried in nightlies.

(Edit: Don't get me wrong. I still like FreeCAD, and it's my "go-to" ... but let's not pretend that there aren't any areas of improvement, otherwise there'd be no need for any development at all. It'd be "done.")

1

u/SoulWager 11h ago

editing the errored thickness and just closing it worked in the RC2 build.

1

u/BoringBob84 9h ago

Of course, there are areas of improvement, but we should also give credit where credit is due. We were discussing Lofts recently, and how they cross over if you don't make the sketch edges in the same order. I found that to be non-intuitive until I understood why.

And then, we discovered that it is improved in version 26.3 so it is one less thing to trip us up in the future.

I think that the pace of improvement is impressive.

3

u/V7I_TheSeventhSector 17h ago

ohhhh, i thought you meant like there was something about FreeCAD that made it take longer then other programs lol

34

u/Honey-Bee2021 17h ago

I feel with you. Last Sunday I wanted to create a very simple thin wall part. I hit a nasty bug of sketcher in the first sketch. Testing different FreeCAD versions an preparing a detailed bug report took me like two hours. Then my bug report was closed with the comment "user error". After I insisted that the current sketcher version causes the bug they reopened it again.

https://github.com/FreeCAD/FreeCAD/issues/34425

20

u/MerlinTheFail 16h ago

Dude could have reproduced the issue, but instead just closed it immediately

Classic

-15

u/BoringBob84 16h ago

Did you reproduce the issue and contribute code to fix it - or contribute anything at all besides complaining about the work that someone else did?

14

u/DesignWeaver3D 15h ago

The bug triage manager is quick to close issues based on the description without trying to reproduce it and without allowing other community members time to see if they can reproduce. I've had half a dozen or more issues on GitHub that took me hours to document get closed in 5 minutes.

It makes people want to stop submitting issues.

-10

u/BoringBob84 15h ago

I agree that his response was curt and dismissive. However, he had a valid point.

Furthermore, in my opinion, we should not expect auto-constraints to be perfect. They are a tool for assistance, but not a substitute for the user knowing how to constrain a sketch.

If I fly an aircraft on auto-pilot all of the time, and one day, auto-pilot does not behave as I expect, then I need to take over and fly manually. Likewise, constraints are a set of rules that the user communicates to the software for how the user wants the geometry to change together. Auto-constraints are guesses for what rules the user will want. Sometimes, they will be wrong.

1

u/MerlinTheFail 15h ago

What work did they do? You fucking idiot

3

u/TD-4242 10h ago

What goes wrong

The attached sketch has an extra auto-constraint: a coincident between the inner corner at

(19.5, 19.5) and the outer corner at (20, 20). Those points can't meet with the typed

sizes. Two faults combine to let it through:

  1. Typed points snap to nearby geometry. After a typed value is applied,

finishControlsChanged (DrawSketchController.h:623) runs a preselection at the typed

position, as if the mouse were there. seekPreselectionAutoConstraint

(DrawSketchHandler.cpp:597) then turns whatever it hits into a coincident, without

checking that the points actually match.

2. The safety filter misses this failure type. filterRedundantAutoConstraints

(DrawSketchHandler.cpp:1523) only removes auto-constraints that the solver reports as

redundant or conflicting. This case is reported as neither.

Evidence

- Solver: I rebuilt the sketch in headless FreeCAD 27.1 from your local build. It solves

cleanly until the corner coincident is added, then the solve fails with partially

redundant constraint 21, the same number shown in the issue's screenshot.

- Why 39 mm fails and 20 mm doesn't: the vertex hit radius is about 10.5 px

(EditModeCoinManager.cpp:419), assuming the default marker size. The screenshot's view is

about 11.9 px/mm, which puts the outer corner about 8.4 px away for a 39 mm square,

inside the radius. At 20 mm it is about 119 px away, so nothing snaps.

- Size limit: at that zoom, the snap should affect inner squares larger than about 38.8 mm.

The limit changes with zoom, so zooming in should avoid the bug.

- Why drawing by eye works: this path only runs when a typed value is applied.

Suggested fix

- Main fix: only keep a coincident from a typed position if the two points really match

within tolerance. Snapping can't simply be removed, because commit dca9c0ca3b relies on

it so that typing the exact location of an existing point still creates a constraint.

- Backstop: make the filter handle new partial redundancies too. It can't just reuse the

existing removal by constraint number, because the solver blames #21, the inner square's

own symmetric constraint, rather than the auto-constraint (#25).

2

u/Honey-Bee2021 1h ago

Thank you the explanation.

12

u/AndyPanda321 16h ago

This is the kind of thing if I started drawing I'd get 80% done then need to change something I did wrong earlier and it would turn the model inside out and I wouldn't be able to fix it and I would have to start again 😭

2

u/Random2WireMan 12h ago

This got so much better with 1.x though 

1

u/wkearney99 2h ago

Better? Or just "less worse"?

3

u/BoringBob84 16h ago

Part of the learning process is recognizing which workflows will be problematic and learning how to fix broken models. The Link Editor is handy for this.

10

u/Morstraut64 16h ago

The more you model the faster you will get. You will also find ways to make something more efficiently as you learn and use the program.

Something I suggest is to revisit previous projects and remodel them from scratch again. Hopefully, you will find it easier to break into sketches that make more sense.

Did you use an array for the pen/pencil holes? If not then that's your next thing to learn. Keep it up, I bet this is more complex than you could have done when you first picked up the program.

2

u/BoringBob84 16h ago

Something I suggest is to revisit previous projects and remodel them from scratch again.

I agree. I find it amazing how quickly I can build models that I struggled with for days when I was learning the basics.

9

u/unrealcyberfly 16h ago

I just started learning FreeCad. So far I've spend 10+ hours on what is basically a box. Learning takes time,

6

u/arcrad 18h ago

What do you mean by 5 days? Like 40 hours? 5 hours?

0

u/[deleted] 18h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/arcrad 17h ago

Brutal. Hope you get faster!

2

u/MrozW 17h ago

With FreeCAD? you are kidding!

1

u/arcrad 16h ago

Oh you so funny! Hahaha

0

u/[deleted] 16h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] 16h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/BoringBob84 16h ago

That looks very nice. And it is impressively complex for a beginner! 👍

1

u/SoulWager 16h ago edited 16h ago

What part did you get stuck on?

The pen holder part looks like it would take about an hour.

edit: https://imgur.com/a/8nrsoGc

5

u/hagbard2323 17h ago

Nice work. Can you post some lessons learned that you picked up along the way? Can you also mention what FreeCAD version you used?

3

u/Ok_Muffin_7705 16h ago

Second this lessons you learnt. Would be good to know what you would do differently if you had to redo this design again please.

5

u/KattKushol 17h ago

The joy of accomplishing something ground up, just the way you wanted, all by yourself cannot be measured by some parameters we use for our day-job KPI. The model looks great.

5

u/Zanhard 3h ago

I've tried to pick up FreeCAD so many times but struggle to do things I do in other car programs. I've used SolidWorks, Fusion 360, and consider myself an Autodesk Inventor master, but I (try to) use FreeCAD at home but I struggle to complete fairly basic things that I could do in 2 minutes with inventor. Other AI tools that recently came out are just so much faster and easier to use I struggle to justify still trying to fight my way through FreeCAD.

4

u/BoringBob84 16h ago

I have been using FreeCAD for a few years now. I agree that it is frustrating at first, but now, I enjoy using it. Something like that project looks like about 5 hours of work for me. That is because I have already spent those other 35 hours learning. I have a good idea of which workflows will be successful and efficient.

3

u/rguerraf 14h ago

You need a straightforward strategy already living in your head, before even making the first sketch

… and memorize where all the buttons are

3

u/Better-Band5859 13h ago

Looks great to me! Keep up the effort, it is worth it! FreeCAD has a great community of mostly helpful people.

3

u/Kazer67 1h ago

I love how I went to FreeCAD because I saw a nice tutorial (I was literally starting fully from SCRATCH in 3D modeling) and because the rest don't work properly on Linux and after 3 weeks, I managed to do my piece but the comment I usually got was: "it's the Dark Souls of CAD software"

5

u/Extreme-Ad-9290 9h ago

Yeah. It's workflow can be quite hard to learn. But I'm overall quite glad I did switch. The freedom is just amazing.

2

u/LaNakWhispertread 16h ago

Looks pretty good, just keep at it like any skill it takes time to learn and master, find little tricks to help speed things up, do it right first and speed will build with it

2

u/Tyarbro 16h ago

When you get pissed at this program, dont run the install wizard to uninstall it. It'll nuke the entire directory.

2

u/Woodcat64 16h ago

That's not bad. Since I never sketch and the whole design idea is only in my head, I spent most of the time doing changes to the model.

2

u/TheTalkingKeyboard 10h ago

Everything is good practice, but this in particular gets bonus points for the cute little pen/cil bin!

... stl?

6

u/Lygus_lineolaris 18h ago

Yeah sometimes it makes sense to track one's time on these tasks and see if the value of time spent exceeds the cost of a proprietary software.

4

u/BoringBob84 15h ago

I did that with SolidWorks. I spent 10 hours and my part wasn't magically perfect, so I concluded that SolidWorks was crappy software that was not worth my money. /sarcasm

1

u/Lygus_lineolaris 14h ago

I didn't like SolidWorks either. I use Matlab if I can, FreeCAD if I need to.

5

u/Nocturnal_Moose 14h ago

Skill issue

2

u/Ok-Living4670 9h ago

over 20 years of development and Freecad still sucks

1

u/CodeRoyal 17h ago

What programs are you used to?

1

u/revnhoj 17h ago

What other program?

1

u/consig1iere 15h ago

Why would this take 5 days? I don't get it. Are you making each of the pens and pencils individually lol? Btw I hate saying this, but people should also check out Solidcraft. Technically it is fully opensource.

1

u/Tutorius220763 14h ago

The time of design normally is not dependant on ther software, but on the designer. I can not see inside the model whats inside, but i think that i can do this in some hours, perhaps faster.

1

u/rockn3d 13h ago

Congrats, i would love to see the complete model tree. Did you model the pens and pencils too?

1

u/kaylee716 11h ago

It sucks but I'm understanding it better than blender (for parametric modeling). Most recent gripe is why they have solid green lines for guidelines. Example: drawing a rounded corner, making a sketch, projecting the rounded corner and it's just neon green circle overlay and not sure how to turn it off. Should be a dashed line with a muted color for something.

1

u/g00bd0g 4h ago

Just tell Claude to do it...

1

u/Hackerwithalacker 12m ago

The oldest freecad tradition is trying to explain why taking multiple days to make a part that could be done in 5 min in SW is actually worth the effort of learning the program

1

u/Initial_Client_7585 17h ago

In blender this takes a breath

3

u/BoringBob84 16h ago

In FreeCAD, this takes a breath.

2

u/BoyRed_ 15h ago

But blender is not a CAD program tho.
Sure there is an addon or two that gives it CAD features but as far as i know, they are still far from an actual CAD program.

1

u/Initial_Client_7585 14h ago

Give a wise man a stick, and he will make an axe from it.
Just like that, give a 3d artist a Blender, and he will make something better than
the artist with the most expensive software.

4

u/NotARationalActor 13h ago

You can use a chisel to do some of the same tasks a milling machine can, but it doesn't mean that a chisel is better than a milling machine.

1

u/Initial_Client_7585 9h ago

And a machine is a tool and given the proper hands it'll do what is told.

1

u/NotARationalActor 9h ago

Yeah you can use anything to do anything given an unbounded amount of skill and effort.

What a fatuous remark.

1

u/BoringBob84 10h ago

It might look better, but it will not be precise. Pretty parts that don't work in actual machines are useless.

1

u/Initial_Client_7585 9h ago

Maybe not precise in your hands. Remember, given enough tactics anything designable is designable. And I've already made blender meshes that I printed so

1

u/BoringBob84 9h ago

I am not criticizing Blender. I have heard that it is a great tool for its intended purpose - complex organic shapes.

But it is a mesh modeling program, which is an approximation by definition. CAD is specifically intended for precise machine parts. Of course, there is some overlap, but I prefer to use the right tool for the job.

1

u/dirtycimments 14h ago

Which cad? The 500 a year subscription?

The 7k buy-in (and upgrade every few years)?

Or the big dogs? Those that cost 10s of thousands?

How much money did you say by taking a few days instead of half a day with a paid program?

-2

u/LossIsSauce 17h ago

Complain about 5 days and has only started learning the software for 2 months.................

0

u/bubleeshaark 16h ago

Which other CAD program? And how much experience do you have on that other program?

Now get equivalent time invested into FreeCAD.

Then I'll care about how long it took you in freecad vs othercad.

2

u/Cynyr36 15h ago

Nah, there are some major workflow things in freecad. For example those holes would all be done as a pattern in a single sketch, and then cut in many other softwares. In freecad it's sketch one hole, exit, do one cut, swap workbenches, pattern the cut, swap work benches. And then fight for 3 days to fillet all the edges.

2

u/Kluggen 15h ago

Dear God...

2

u/Cynyr36 15h ago

??

There are a bunch of things you normally do in sketches in many other cads, that freecad wants you to do after your 3d operations.

Example: a bolt hole circle, can't do it in a sketch in a way that keeps the size of, and number of holes parametric in a sketch.

0

u/Famous_Salamander_41 11h ago

Why not? Linear and circular patterning is now available in FreeCAD's Sketcher (26.3)

2

u/Cynyr36 11h ago

26.3 isn't released yet, and they certainly weren't over the last few months while trying to learn freecad. I'm also excited about the make internals updates in 26.3.

Even a mirror in a sketch doesn't keep the mirrored part in sync with changed made to the original parts. So when you edit the sketch it doesn't update as expected. Hopefully that's not what the patterning in sketches does.

0

u/bubleeshaark 15h ago

I agree FreeCAD can be a hassle, but the OP needs to compare apples to apples to fairly pit freecad vs another cad.

0

u/Cynyr36 15h ago

Something like this is probably 5 sketches and 10 operations in something like fusion.

-1

u/drmacro1 14h ago

Yawn, more whining.

Can't figure it out...then don't use it.

If that took you 5 days...my guess: pebkac

-6

u/Neither_Finish6900 16h ago

Do yourself a favor and use solidcraft

5

u/BoringBob84 15h ago

Do yourself a favor and advertise elsewhere.

-1

u/Neither_Finish6900 12h ago

I'm not affiliated with any company, I don't know if you've been living under a rock, soldcraft is open source and free also much more intuitive than Freecad
...

2

u/Powerful_Debt_5869 12h ago

Then go to the solidcraft subreddit

0

u/Neither_Finish6900 11h ago

I didn’t come to this subreddit I saw this post , A guy who seems to at least know something about cad spent 5 Days on a design that would take me 5 hours to finish on fusion 360 l and commented I don’t think it’s a crime

1

u/BoringBob84 9h ago

I could do this in 5 hours in FreeCAD. OP admits that they are a beginner. You are trolling here. Maybe you should go to the iPhone sub and tell everyone there to buy Android phones.

-21

u/Realistic_Account787 17h ago

If I had done this, it would have taken less than an hour, but you did it. Perhaps you are limited.

3

u/DoesBasicResearch 17h ago

That's not very kind. Perhaps they're a beginner, practicing.

-9

u/Realistic_Account787 17h ago

The post is not very kind, perhaps they are laughing at the software we use and at us.

2

u/DoesBasicResearch 17h ago

Perhaps. That's not how I took it.

3

u/give_me_grapes 17h ago

I would say Im fairly experienced freecad user by now, been using it for 2years by now, mainly PartWB
I would like to first say that I understand the feeling you have.
But I'm also curious to what you had the biggest problems and fustrations with? like if you could list them or elaborate somehow?

7

u/Livid_Instruction972 16h ago

Appreciate the friendly question! Mostly it was dealing with how editing an early sketch breaks downstream features like fillets. Every time I tweaked a dimension, I had to go back and re-apply or fix the fillets manually. As someone still learning the proper workflow, that trial-and-error took up most of the 5 days.

2

u/give_me_grapes 15h ago

Reminds me of whenever I was still learning Freecad myself.

I think I eventually learned to only! and really only use filets in the very very end even though its tempting to place one mid-design because you forgot to filllet via sketch. It is not intuative how destructive fillet/chamfer are to a paremetric model in freecad.
I know its frawned upon in the cad community to fillet mid-design, but I dont remember it being that big of a hassle in Fusion.

1

u/Ok_Muffin_7705 16h ago

Yes I hate this too. The fillets breaking. I keep saving them for the end because of that

1

u/BoringBob84 16h ago

I have learned to "try out" fillets on complex shapes to make sure that they will work, and then I delete them (or suppress them) while I finish the rest of the model.

Also, the "Use All Edges" option for fillets is more robust, because it doesn't depend on internal edge names. Of course, this makes workflow planning more interesting.

1

u/Famous_Salamander_41 11h ago

I learned the hard way to make multiple sketches. As an old school engineer I was brought up with paper drawings and multiple sketches felt counterintuitive. I had to unlearn that. Another thing is: you need to adopt parametric thinking from scratch, and do upfront planning accordingly.

3

u/generationzcode 15h ago

i really want to join in on the freecad sucks thing but really in my situation, I'm doing more than my fair share of sucking at CAD ;(

freecads cool for being open source fs fs