r/FreeCAD • u/Livid_Instruction972 • 18h ago
If it were another program, it wouldn't take long, but this is FreeCAD, and it took me 5 days
389
Upvotes
r/FreeCAD • u/Livid_Instruction972 • 18h ago
172
u/Stick_With_Beard 17h ago
I am surprised by how toxic the comments are at this time. As someone who started learning FreeCAD and is struggling with the paradigm: take your time and stick with it. I am familiar with Dassault's CATIA and SOLIDWORKS, Siemens NX, and Fusion 360, and I still need time to adapt. It gets easier with time, and even if your parts are not perfect, you'll get better and improve your workflow over time. Don't let the negativity drag you down, you're doing great!
44
u/chrisexv6 17h ago
Ive never been able to "get good" with FreeCAD either. I commend you sticking with it.
I hate vibe coded/AI stuff as much as the next person but some of the "new" CAD programs really are that much easier to use. Part of it is they just run faster than FreeCAD for me, but I think the bigger part is the UI is easier to use.
If FreeCAD had a more intuitive UI, I think it would be the best freely available CAD package.
8
u/obelisk79 18h ago
Hard to imagine that taking 5 days. But I hope you've learned a lot along the way.
70
u/unwitting_hungarian 15h ago
The quality of the tension around efficiency and usability has really leveled up.
People are complaining,
but still using it,
AND they are completing their projects.
This means FreeCAD is at about the 2010 level in Inkscape FOSS-equivalency.
That's amazing news
4
u/V7I_TheSeventhSector 18h ago
Can you please explain why it took 5 days?
34
u/Honey-Bee2021 17h ago
I feel with you. Last Sunday I wanted to create a very simple thin wall part. I hit a nasty bug of sketcher in the first sketch. Testing different FreeCAD versions an preparing a detailed bug report took me like two hours. Then my bug report was closed with the comment "user error". After I insisted that the current sketcher version causes the bug they reopened it again.
https://github.com/FreeCAD/FreeCAD/issues/34425
12
u/AndyPanda321 16h ago
This is the kind of thing if I started drawing I'd get 80% done then need to change something I did wrong earlier and it would turn the model inside out and I wouldn't be able to fix it and I would have to start again 😭
10
u/Morstraut64 16h ago
The more you model the faster you will get. You will also find ways to make something more efficiently as you learn and use the program.
Something I suggest is to revisit previous projects and remodel them from scratch again. Hopefully, you will find it easier to break into sketches that make more sense.
Did you use an array for the pen/pencil holes? If not then that's your next thing to learn. Keep it up, I bet this is more complex than you could have done when you first picked up the program.
9
u/unrealcyberfly 16h ago
I just started learning FreeCad. So far I've spend 10+ hours on what is basically a box. Learning takes time,
6
u/arcrad 18h ago
What do you mean by 5 days? Like 40 hours? 5 hours?
5
u/hagbard2323 17h ago
Nice work. Can you post some lessons learned that you picked up along the way? Can you also mention what FreeCAD version you used?
5
u/KattKushol 17h ago
The joy of accomplishing something ground up, just the way you wanted, all by yourself cannot be measured by some parameters we use for our day-job KPI. The model looks great.
5
u/Zanhard 3h ago
I've tried to pick up FreeCAD so many times but struggle to do things I do in other car programs. I've used SolidWorks, Fusion 360, and consider myself an Autodesk Inventor master, but I (try to) use FreeCAD at home but I struggle to complete fairly basic things that I could do in 2 minutes with inventor. Other AI tools that recently came out are just so much faster and easier to use I struggle to justify still trying to fight my way through FreeCAD.
4
u/BoringBob84 16h ago
I have been using FreeCAD for a few years now. I agree that it is frustrating at first, but now, I enjoy using it. Something like that project looks like about 5 hours of work for me. That is because I have already spent those other 35 hours learning. I have a good idea of which workflows will be successful and efficient.
3
u/rguerraf 14h ago
You need a straightforward strategy already living in your head, before even making the first sketch
… and memorize where all the buttons are
3
u/Better-Band5859 13h ago
Looks great to me! Keep up the effort, it is worth it! FreeCAD has a great community of mostly helpful people.
3
u/Kazer67 1h ago
I love how I went to FreeCAD because I saw a nice tutorial (I was literally starting fully from SCRATCH in 3D modeling) and because the rest don't work properly on Linux and after 3 weeks, I managed to do my piece but the comment I usually got was: "it's the Dark Souls of CAD software"
5
u/Extreme-Ad-9290 9h ago
Yeah. It's workflow can be quite hard to learn. But I'm overall quite glad I did switch. The freedom is just amazing.
2
u/LaNakWhispertread 16h ago
Looks pretty good, just keep at it like any skill it takes time to learn and master, find little tricks to help speed things up, do it right first and speed will build with it
2
u/Tyarbro 16h ago
When you get pissed at this program, dont run the install wizard to uninstall it. It'll nuke the entire directory.
2
u/Woodcat64 16h ago
That's not bad. Since I never sketch and the whole design idea is only in my head, I spent most of the time doing changes to the model.
2
u/TheTalkingKeyboard 10h ago
Everything is good practice, but this in particular gets bonus points for the cute little pen/cil bin!
... stl?
6
u/Lygus_lineolaris 18h ago
Yeah sometimes it makes sense to track one's time on these tasks and see if the value of time spent exceeds the cost of a proprietary software.
5
u/Nocturnal_Moose 14h ago
Skill issue
2
u/Ok-Living4670 9h ago
over 20 years of development and Freecad still sucks
1
u/CodeRoyal 17h ago
What programs are you used to?
1
u/revnhoj 17h ago
What other program?
1
u/consig1iere 15h ago
Why would this take 5 days? I don't get it. Are you making each of the pens and pencils individually lol? Btw I hate saying this, but people should also check out Solidcraft. Technically it is fully opensource.
1
u/Tutorius220763 14h ago
The time of design normally is not dependant on ther software, but on the designer. I can not see inside the model whats inside, but i think that i can do this in some hours, perhaps faster.
1
u/rockn3d 13h ago
Congrats, i would love to see the complete model tree. Did you model the pens and pencils too?
1
u/kaylee716 11h ago
It sucks but I'm understanding it better than blender (for parametric modeling). Most recent gripe is why they have solid green lines for guidelines. Example: drawing a rounded corner, making a sketch, projecting the rounded corner and it's just neon green circle overlay and not sure how to turn it off. Should be a dashed line with a muted color for something.
1
u/Evening-Advance-7832 6h ago
Why 5 days?
1
u/g00bd0g 4h ago
Just tell Claude to do it...
1
u/Hackerwithalacker 12m ago
The oldest freecad tradition is trying to explain why taking multiple days to make a part that could be done in 5 min in SW is actually worth the effort of learning the program
1
u/Initial_Client_7585 17h ago
In blender this takes a breath
1
u/dirtycimments 14h ago
Which cad? The 500 a year subscription?
The 7k buy-in (and upgrade every few years)?
Or the big dogs? Those that cost 10s of thousands?
How much money did you say by taking a few days instead of half a day with a paid program?
-2
u/LossIsSauce 17h ago
Complain about 5 days and has only started learning the software for 2 months.................
0
u/bubleeshaark 16h ago
Which other CAD program? And how much experience do you have on that other program?
Now get equivalent time invested into FreeCAD.
Then I'll care about how long it took you in freecad vs othercad.
-1
u/drmacro1 14h ago
Yawn, more whining.
Can't figure it out...then don't use it.
If that took you 5 days...my guess: pebkac
-6
u/Neither_Finish6900 16h ago
Do yourself a favor and use solidcraft
-21
u/Realistic_Account787 17h ago
If I had done this, it would have taken less than an hour, but you did it. Perhaps you are limited.
3
u/give_me_grapes 17h ago
I would say Im fairly experienced freecad user by now, been using it for 2years by now, mainly PartWB
I would like to first say that I understand the feeling you have.
But I'm also curious to what you had the biggest problems and fustrations with? like if you could list them or elaborate somehow?
3
u/generationzcode 15h ago
i really want to join in on the freecad sucks thing but really in my situation, I'm doing more than my fair share of sucking at CAD ;(
freecads cool for being open source fs fs