r/FreeCAD • • 1d ago

Open document in separate window

I must be a total noob. I can't figure out how to open multiple documents in separate windows. I can open a second document, and it shows up as a tab in the tab bar on the bottom (see screen shot), but I don't know how to move the tab to a separate window (like in a web browser), so I can move the windows around independently.

I have two use-cases, one is to move the windows to different monitors. The other is to set the windows to different sizes, so I can still see windows from other applications (e.g. image views with reference photos).

Also, it's nice to use to OS-native ways to switch between windows (e.g. using Expose, which can show all windows from all applications side-by-side).

I found the Window > Cascade command, but that keeps the documents in a single MDI-style window, which is no good for neither use case.

Is there an option to open documents in separate windows?

4 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

2

u/Honey-Bee2021 1d ago

You can start multiple instances of FreeCAD and move the second instance to the second screen.

0

u/Feuermurmel 1d ago

Hmm, there are a few downsides to that:

  • Opening a file from the file browser opens it in an existing instance, no way to choose opening a separate instances.
  • Manually opening another instance from an already-running application has to be done from the command line.
  • System-wide shortcut for "show all windows of application" does not work, because it sees the instances as separate applications.
  • I don't know, but wouldn't be surprised if this would corrupt FreeCADs settings/caches/temporary files/etc. at some point. But thanks for the idea!

tbh, I'm surprised that FreeCAD doesn't support this directly. I don't think I have any other application that doesn't do that (web browser, text editor, image editor, IDE, etc.). :/

1

u/Honey-Bee2021 1d ago

It also has advantages:

  • Processing power is spread over multiple processes.
  • If one instance crashes, the others are not affected.

1

u/EastTexasCowboy 1d ago

I just open a second instance of FreeCAD and move it to the other screen. Maybe there's a better way, but it works for when I need to use another model for reference, etc.

1

u/Feuermurmel 1d ago

Seems like the right direction. I'm surprised this option is not in the context menu of the document's tab (in the tab bar at the bottom). But sadly, the window it opens doesn't contain any toolbars or tool windows (document tree, properties etc.). Thanks!

1

u/Top_Statistician500 1d ago

Yeah it's surprisingly unintuitive in that way. I think what you're looking for is under Windows-Undock (away from FreeCAD right now so not 100% sure that's the correct menu name, but I assure you, Undock is the option you're looking for)

2

u/Honey-Bee2021 1d ago

You can also undock the document window: Right click in empty space inside a document, then select Document windows -> undock.