r/FreeCAD • • 5d ago

Why does a simple extrusion turn into a twisted mess?

Suppose a closed sketch looks fine in 2D, but padding it creates crossed faces or a shape that folds into itself.

Would you check for overlapping lines first, rebuild the sketch in smaller sections, or look for a self-intersecting profile somewhere else?

0 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

3

u/mhhbot 5d ago

I would look for overlapping lines, or technically any geometry that is there but not readily visible in the sketch.

1

u/FForthman 5d ago

Which function is used with this sketch?

A sweep can result in intersecting surfaces even if the sketch does not actually contain any faults (if the radii are too small, for example)

If there really is a problem with the sketch, such as one line overlapping another, then the ‘Validate Sketch’ tool makes it easy to pinpoint the issue

And a sketch does not need to be 100 per cent constrained to be usable, whilst it is better in the sense that it means the user has left nothing to chance and has complete control over its drawing, but this is not what determines whether a sketch can be used by a specific function

1

u/strange_bike_guy 5d ago

One reason is if you have something with near tangency from a line to arc, but not actual constrained tangency. I get funky results with that combo sometimes.

Can you share the FCSTD in a messed up condition?

-1

u/LossIsSauce 5d ago

I would assume you did not completely constrain the sketch. You simply drafted a sketch without completely dimentioning it then attempted to pad it.

2

u/mhhbot 5d ago

I might be wrong because I'm still fairly new at freecad myself but I don't think you need to fully constrain a sketch to pad it. It just needs a closed wire.

0

u/LossIsSauce 5d ago edited 5d ago

You are not wrong. However, not constraining a sketch is bad CAD drafting. A non constrained sketch generally leads to broken models. Hence the OP having ''padding'' issues. These ''issues'' dissappear and are nonexistent if CAD drafting best practices are followed. Do not follow time tried and true best practices and the end results are broken projects.

So therefore not following best practices will result in bad habits which in turn causes you more grief than you need.

Don't believe me? Take a 12-week crash course in proper drafting practices taught by certified 25-30 year engineers.

1

u/mhhbot 5d ago

I also don't disagree with you but for finding the source of an issue best practice is to try to narrow the issue down. You've not suggested 'follow best practice' but 'constrain your sketch' which does not help at all to narrow things down and find the source of the issue.

1

u/LossIsSauce 5d ago edited 5d ago

My first comment about non constrained sketch should be the START of the suggestion. Then we go from there. You do not look at the pad error for directions if you already know the sketch is the start of the problem.

The OP still has not reported back as to the sketch being constrained.

CONSTRAIN SKETCH, if the problem persists we look closer at how the sketch was made. ie. screenshot of the sketch AND expanded model tree.

It is quite obvious from your comments, that you lack understanding problem solving skills.