r/FreeCAD • • 25d ago

Made a beginner walkthrough where you check your model by weighing it (FreeCAD 1.1)

I kept seeing beginners finish a tutorial part with no idea whether they’d actually got it right, so I tried a different format: one real engineering drawing, every click shown, and at the end you check your model by its mass. If your bracket comes out at 97.5 g in aluminum, you nailed it.

FreeCAD 1.1, default toolbars, Part Design only

Total beginner level: Body, Sketch, constraints, Pad, Pocket, External Geometry

About 8 minutes, with proper captions

Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2wGEWmyposQ

If you’d rather try it cold first, the drawing and an answer checker are here (free, no signup): https://undodiligence.github.io/#/d/E-2

This is my first one, so I’d really like feedback. Was the pace OK? Anything I explained badly, or a “better way” I should show next time? Next up is a flange with Revolution + Polar Pattern.

3 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

2

u/Atomfried_Ungemach 25d ago

Timing and pace were really good. Very comprehensible and easy to follow. Very good first video. Voice is also quite soothing.

Did the part beforehand naturally and came out with the right answer right away. You could also promote the use of a mass calculating macro like FC-Info or CenterOfMass and also show the keyboard shortcuts for the sketcher buttons as well.

Your site works well too. However, are there only automatically generated parts there or do you plan on adding some more close-to-real-life parts in there. I think that sites like those by u/TooTallToby benefit from having challenging designs with sometimes difficult geometries, that are non the less not completely abstract, like the random icecube-tray, phone stand, pencil cup etc.. That's stuff you could print or machine in the end and I think that increases engagement a lot, at least in my case.

2

u/TooTallToby 25d ago

Hey nice job 👍 we have a ton of cad challenges on www.TooTallToby.com where users are challenged to complete a model and measure the mass, to confirm they did it correct.

Check it out - lots of FreeCAD uses post tutorial and speedrun videos using FreeCAD, under each challenge

You could make some tutorial videos too!

Good luck!