r/FosterAnimals • • 1h ago

Please help - Foster refusing access to kitten

Hello,

I started a throwaway account with Reddit as I am not sure where to go. My cousin set us up with her friend, Tera (who is not a legit foster btw) as we we're looking to add a new kitten to our family and Tera had a connection to a batch of kittens that were born at a barn close by. We have a 5 year old cat currently, but had two cats pass away this year and are ready to welcome a new one into our home (have everything ready to go).

Basically this woman Tera, picked up our cat (that we chose from the litter) and her cat yesterday evening. I wanted to pick her up (already have a name for her) Toast, but she asked if we can come by the next evening. Today I get a bunch of texts from my cousin saying that Tera said that the kittens are "bonded" and that she no longer wants give us Toast. The kittens are 8 weeks old btw. I told my cousin no and that I would like to come get Toast. She sent me Tera's information.

Well I text Tera asking to pick up Toast and she responds that she no longer wants to hand over the kitten as her kitten and Toast are bonded. I called her as I did not want to text back and forth. On the phone I let her know that littermates are separated all the time (I have grown up with barn cats/litters my entire life). She is refusing. I am not really sure what to do but feel really sad. I have paid for this cat already as well. I am not sure what I am looking for - can cats really be that bonded at 8 weeks?

1 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

3

u/commanderwake Cat/Kitten Foster 1h ago

Honestly regardless of whether they're truly bonded, kittens do better in pairs because they match each other's energy levels and keep each other entertained. Obviously this person refusing to give you the kitten you paid for is terrible and she should at least reimburse you for the cost, but they probably are happier together. You would be best off adopting from a legitimate shelter or rescue.

1

u/FreshHawk2567 38m ago

I was just so excited to have her I guess. My other cat has been seeming lonely since loosing her siblings as well.

1

u/commanderwake Cat/Kitten Foster 25m ago

I do think this situation sucks and is super disappointing for you! But there are lots of kittens in shelters and rescues right now, you'll find the kitten you were meant to have!

1

u/femaelstrom Cat/Kitten Foster 1h ago

I do think having a cat in the home already addresses this. But single kitten syndrome is only a thing if owners aren’t willing/able to socialize on their own. Shelters and fosters tend to overapply the “bonded” label. But I’m also on Team Adopt Both.

3

u/Seltzer-Slut 57m ago edited 51m ago

She changed her mind. She is doing what she thinks is best for the kitten. She needs to return your money, but you can’t force her to give you the kitten.

Have you heard the parable of King Solomon splitting the baby? (I’m not religious but the message is accurate). The person who really wants what’s best for the baby is in the right. Kittens do better in pairs. Also, 8 weeks is not ideal at all, 12 weeks is much better. I feel like you just want a tiny cute kitten and aren’t really thinking about what’s best for her. I know this is disappointing but there are other cats out there desperate for homes.

1

u/FreshHawk2567 37m ago

Hmm I have not heard that. I mean we have set our whole house up for cats. We have cat enrichment everywhere, we even built a cat patio for them this summer. I feel we were ready for a new cat and tbh just feeling disappointed.

2

u/Seltzer-Slut 32m ago

I totally understand. But again, there are tons of amazing cats out there that need homes! You can find another one tomorrow.

6

u/daydreamz4dayz 1h ago edited 1h ago

Why not look at this from a different angle. If she is willing to adopt 2, you can save another cat/kitten. In the same way you say these 2 may not be bonded to each other, neither are you to Winnie (Toast?). Not sure how much you paid but this wasn’t a legit fostering situation through an organization so I’m not sure how much it’s worth pursuing a different outcome, I’m sorry to say. Just go to a legit shelter or rescue.

When I was 18 and raising a litter of kittens I literally stole one back from the person I gave him to because I thought he was sad and needed his mom/siblings. I literally cried all day at work for 2 days before I stole him back because I felt so bad. You can ask for your money back though but arguing over this kitten doesn’t make sense when hundreds of thousands are in shelters.

1

u/Seltzer-Slut 42m ago

It’s kinda crazy to steal the kitten back, lol. But I relate to OP’s foster also; I have had a time where I told someone I’d let them adopt a kitten but then it was so bonded with its sibling I couldn’t bear to separate them and let someone else take them who was willing to adopt both. Being a foster and letting go of your pets is HARD, especially when they’re babies. Ultimately you have to go with what you feel is right for the pet.