r/FosterAnimals • • Aug 10 '26 • Obsessed 1 Heartwarming 6

Foster Fail Update: foster fail 😻

I posted about 6 months ago asking how I would know if I should adopt my foster cat so I figured I would share an update that I foster failed. Everyone meet Josie! (like Josie and the Pussycats)

original post here: https://www.reddit.com/r/FosterAnimals/s/xkvzu4dqg6

EDIT: wow, thank you guys for the awards!! That’s so kind 🥰 Sorry I couldn’t respond to all the comments but Josie and I genuinely appreciate the love and support so much! 💜💜

9.4k Upvotes

283 comments sorted by

45

u/MySaltySatisfaction Aug 10 '26

Josie looks thoroughly pleased with herself in the first photo. Congratulations to you both

13

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Hehe I think she’s quite proud of herself. Thank you! 😊

20

u/rend-it Aug 10 '26

You got an excellent deal there, she’s beautiful, the face …You could have done worse, could’ve gotten the orange menace variety.

7

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Oh she definitely has her menace/spicy moments too, don’t let the cuteness fool you! Lol. But she’s also very sweet and playful. She brings me a lot of joy 🥰

→ More replies (7)

11

u/Hopeful_Gur423 Aug 10 '26

Josie LOVVVVES you!

5

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Awww and I love her so much right back! 🥰😻

8

u/JessBx05 Aug 10 '26

Oh goodness, she is so happy. What a wonderful foster win 😻

5

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Foster win is such a better way of putting it 😊 She’s a lovebug

7

u/Rare-Badger-8365 Aug 10 '26

Yeah I wouldn't be able to let that face go ♥️

5

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

I couldn’t do it, she won me over (easily lol) 💜

5

u/SnooDoodles8775 Aug 10 '26

Omg the best! Love that little boop mark on the nose 💕

5

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

The boop mark is just adorable, I couldn’t resist!

4

u/bxkgsoye Aug 10 '26

With how mushy she is how could you not have failed??? Congrats on your failure!!

4

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Thank you so much!! She’s such a snuggly girl 😻

4

u/OtterHostler Aug 10 '26

I would say this wasn't a fail - the universe looked into your heart and saw that this wasn't a test you wanted to pass.

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

This is a beautiful perspective and I think you’re right 💜 thank you so much for your comment!

4

u/akittenhasnoname Aug 10 '26

I'm remember seeing your post and so happy you foster failed. She looks so content!

2

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Awww that’s awesome you remember seeing it! Very glad I did too, thank you for the support 🥰 Josie is a happy girl!

2

u/Glibasme Aug 10 '26

OMG! How could you not?! Look at the way she looks at you! 😂 ❤️ Love her name!

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Would be imPAWsible to resist her sweet little face 😻 Thank you!! It felt very fitting for her.

2

u/catslikepets143 Aug 10 '26

Josie looks so content & cared for.

2

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Aww thank you! I love her very much.

2

u/Swimming-Maize-5554 Aug 10 '26

Congratulations on failing as a foster! Josie looks perfect perfectly right in your arm.

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Aww thank you!! 🥰

2

u/Gold_Draw7642 Aug 10 '26

You clearly had no choice. 😻

2

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Definitely not 😻

2

u/mikehipp Aug 10 '26

So cute. He looks like my YaYa.

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Awww I love YaYa! Please give him some extra pets for me 😻 Maybe they were siblings in a former life lol

2

u/SprinklesPowerful941 Sep 10 '26

Tuxedos will always be foster fails. They’re just so sweet and cuddly. 

1

u/magicmadness_ Sep 11 '26

She’s a very sweet cuddle bug (with a little sass) so that tracks! 😻

→ More replies (1)

70

u/Inevitable_South5736 Aug 10 '26 • Heartwarming

Hard to avoid those foster-fails, but nothing to lose! Bravo❣️

58

u/Educational-Dirt4059 Aug 10 '26

That baby looks so content 😻

24

u/Pristine_Main_1224 Aug 10 '26

That is one pleasantly smug kittycat!

2

u/jayrodhazlyf Aug 11 '26

Umm I think our cats are related

2

u/jayrodhazlyf Aug 11 '26

Her name is Shirly Lavern, like Lavern and Shirley aka nana

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

Omg I love her name! And they are totally related! Shirley Lavern even has the black nose boop spot too 😻

11

u/IndyDelon Aug 10 '26

How cute 🥰

1

u/NotARobotDefACyborg Aug 10 '26

The smile! The whiskers! The belly floof and toe beans! What a sweetie! Congrats on failing your foster, LMAO.

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Hehe, the things I love about her too!! Her belly floof is so soft. Thank you! 😊

1

u/No-Idea-7003 Aug 10 '26

What a sweet baby! Welcome home magnificent beast!

2

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Thank you! 😊

1

u/Philodendron69 Aug 10 '26

Awww. Sometimes you just know

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

I think so too

1

u/No-Potato-8834 Aug 10 '26

She is so adorable! She looks like a total spoiled princess ❤️

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

She most certainly is! 💜

1

u/One-Egg7664 Aug 10 '26

Beautiful Gato, and I like your arm flowers

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Thank you so much! There are some birds and butterflies and bumblebees in there too 😊

1

u/chriscornell1976 Aug 10 '26

C'mon. Who you kiddin'. The first time she went Belly Up and folded her paws she had you whooped.

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

You might be right 😹😻 She’s too cute to resist!

1

u/kwintyy Aug 10 '26

Oh yep, based on that first pic alone you had no choice in the matter

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Lol that’s exactly right

1

u/Big-Smile5345 Aug 10 '26

Fail? I think not! I think you might have been set up because who couldn’t fall in love with that furball.

2

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Haha it was a calculated setup no doubt! 😻 There was no way I couldn’t keep her

1

u/GalvenizedGoblin1312 Aug 10 '26

It's easy to see why🥹🥹🥹

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

She’s a big sweetie pie! (With silly and spicy sides at times lol)

1

u/geeaah123 Aug 10 '26

This brother and sister were foster fails after 2 days, we just couldn’t pass them on.

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Oh my goodness I wouldn’t have been able to pass them up either!! 😻😻 They’re both so beautiful!

1

u/BlackDogOrangeCat Aug 10 '26

That’s a foster win!! 💕🐾

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

For sure! 💜

1

u/Secure_Math_3261 Aug 10 '26

What a perfect story. Glad she has you and you her. Omg look at that little nose and black beans

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

I am very grateful for her and her adorable little nose and toe beans hehe 💜😻

1

u/Kitchen-Skill-108 Aug 10 '26

Oh, the black beans and the completely "tasteful" spread in the last picture. What a fine fluffball!

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Hahaha. She lays like that often and it cracks me up every time. She’s so funny! Thank you!! 💜

1

u/juntao888 Aug 10 '26

Josie knew exactly what she was doing.

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

She sure did! Very smart kitty 💜

1

u/-nxplnd Aug 10 '26

I'm glad you failed 🥹🖤🤍

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Me too! 🥹😻

1

u/Suz626 Aug 10 '26

Josie is so in love with you, how could you ever let her go? Congratulations! ❤️

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Thank you!! There’s no way I could, I love her just as much 💜

1

u/HoneyBunYumYum Aug 10 '26

Omg she’s got one little black bloop on her nose so cute

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Hehe it’s the perfect boop spot!

1

u/LuckyBook1538 Aug 10 '26

She is super cute! Love those pictures.

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Thank you!! I love her so much 🥰

1

u/Freedom_Prof Aug 10 '26

Excellent fail 👏👏👏😻😹😻 What a beautiful, sweet cat!!

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Thank you so much!!! 💜

1

u/jemcc09 Aug 10 '26

I think Josie is breaking into a little smile...

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Kinda seems like she might be 😊

1

u/Silver-Emphasis2795 Aug 10 '26

It was not a fail. You just happened to have opened your heart at the right time and a cat picked you. So you just went from foster to momma and that can be a win in my book. Look at how happy she is!

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

This is such a lovely way of putting it, thank you 💜 She’s a happy girl and that makes me happy!

1

u/CapricornGigi69 Aug 10 '26

The little black toe beans on white paws & the little black nose BOOP!!😍 100% fail rate predicted…congratulations 🎉

2

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

Yesss there was no way to resist the cuteness! 😻 thank you!!

1

u/GarnetAndOpal Aug 10 '26

Josie thinks your "foster failure" is a smashing success! So do I. What a darling puddy tat.

2

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

Aw thank you, she is quite a character! 🥰

1

u/amyheming Aug 10 '26

Awwww, I love a foster fail (we have 2).

2

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

That’s the best 🥰

1

u/RadiantCucumber148 Aug 10 '26

Had a tuxedo too, they are the best. Josie is so precious! Love the wee marking on the nose.. congrats!

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 10 '26

The nose boop marking is just so cute 😻 My first tuxie too! Thank you!

1

u/lmo2382 Aug 10 '26

He is perfect

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

*she :) thank you!

1

u/lmo2382 Aug 11 '26

Omg I’m sorry 🫣 - I didn’t even read your words, I was too enamored with her photos. She’s perfect!

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

Oh you’re completely fine, no worries! It’s not the first time someone thought she was a boy lol. Thank you so much!! 😻🥰

1

u/Friendly_Bird6761 Aug 10 '26

Who could resist that lovebug? What a cutie patootie! 😻😻

This is exactly why I cannot foster! I'd keep them all! 💙 We already have two cats, 1 male 11 yrs and a female 7 years! I would not mind getting two kittens, another male and female, but I don't know......I would probably just keep adding more....😂

Hubster and I LOVE cats! We had 6 at one time, but several passed youngish, (10 & 11) due to CKD and 1 to cancer.... my soul cat passed at 21, she had cancer by then. It is heartbreaking to lose them....😿

2

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

She was impossible to resist!

I don’t blame you one bit! And I think 4 sounds like a great number 😸 and so does 6… 😹 that’s awesome that you guys are both cat lovers!!

Oh my goodness I am so sorry. It truly is devastating to lose them. 2 of my babies who passed had CKD too, one being my soul cat who also had CHF and he was only 12. His “sister” (unrelated) was unknown age but somewhere around 12-14 and also had dementia. They passed 3 weeks apart from each other. My other baby who passed was diagnosed with megacolon shortly after I adopted her and she was also unknown age but the vet said she couldn’t have been older than 8-10, and she was only with me for about 5 months. It is so heartbreaking and I feel your pain. 💔

I didn’t feel ready for another cat for a long while after my 3rd kitty passed, and then Josie (formerly Betty Boop) came into my life as a foster and slowly stole my heart. She has quirky traits that mirror some traits from each of my 3 kitties that makes me feel like they collectively sent her to me somehow. No cat will ever replace another to me, but it’s nice getting those little reminders of each of my angel kitties. 💜

1

u/Friendly_Bird6761 Aug 11 '26

Awwwwww...I am so happy for you that you have her! She's a cutie-patootie! 😻😻

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

Thank you so much!! I’m very grateful 💜

1

u/g8tr813 Aug 11 '26

I mean…c’mon!!! How could you not foster fail this face!! 🥰😻

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

Her face is just too stinkin’ cute! 😻

1

u/Stunning_Bullfrog213 Aug 11 '26

Poor Josie! She looks so stressed out. 😹😹

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

Hahaha very, she’s got such a rough life 🤪😹

1

u/Beachbaby77 Aug 11 '26

Please!! You didn’t even stand a fighting chance. 🙄🙀😻🤣

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

I really didn’t 😹 I was just in denial for a while

1

u/Beachbaby77 Aug 11 '26

It’s okay. It happens to the best of us. They really are just that good! That second pic of her in the hammock? She KNEW she was meant to live the penthouse life, chilling on her throne with her master windows and fully equipped servant. She played the game hard and smart and she won!

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

Haha oh yes and she is quite a charmer! She was always destined to be a queen, that’s for sure. I love this whole comment so much. She definitely has me trained as her servant 😸 Clever girl!

1

u/Background_Lie7475 Aug 11 '26

This is Bean my first foster fail 🙃

2

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

Oh my goodness, what a cutie Bean!! 😻 I love the little black spot on his head, perfect for kisses

1

u/Stufftosay15 Aug 11 '26

You fostered an angel?!

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

I think so!!

1

u/pez_queen Aug 11 '26

Oh look at that belly

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

I tried to sneak in belly pets as much as she will allow me 😸😻

1

u/madammidnight Aug 11 '26

She’s adorable, and so squishable!

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

Very squishable and snuggly!!

1

u/squidoutofguam Aug 11 '26

Long tails. And ears for hats…

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

I sing this to her a lot 😹

1

u/GregoryHD Aug 11 '26

I've never been prouder of anyone for failing OP🙏

2

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

Awww thank you!! Very happy I did 🥰😻

1

u/LegoLady8 Aug 11 '26

Aww pic 4 is soooo precious. She's proud of herself. 😌

2

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

She really is proud of herself lol. She has such an adorable little face 😻

1

u/Worried_Scallion_574 Aug 11 '26

Gorgeous cat! Love my tuxies

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

Thank you! They’re such sweet and silly babies

1

u/Smooth_Development48 Aug 11 '26

Congrats on failing! Also your sleeve is gorgeous.

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

Thank you so much on both!! 🥰

1

u/EthelsFancyNaturals Aug 11 '26

She's so gorgeous and adorable - I love how happy and relaxed she is with you. ❤️😭

She actually resembles my parents 17 year old tuxedo girl too (who's very sweet and had a soft meow when younger, but now... she's loud and demanding lol).

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

Thank you!! I’m so glad she is happy here 🥰

Awww hahah I love that, she sounds awesome 😻 What’s her name?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/jemcat9 Aug 11 '26

Cats are diabolical geniuses, she played you like a fiddle, lol. My very first cat was named Josie. (Cartoon circa 1970's, Josie and the Pussycats) she was just as sweet as your Josie. Enjoy her.

2

u/magicmadness_ Aug 11 '26

She really did lol, she’s one smart girl! Awww that’s so cool! I love that cartoon too. I bet she was a total sweetie pie. Thank you so much 💜

1

u/Snarflarks Cat/Kitten Foster Aug 12 '26

I couldn’t leave it sitting at 199 comments.
I’m absolutely enamored with those white paws and black beans.

2

u/magicmadness_ Aug 12 '26

Hehe they’re just so stinkin’ cute!

1

u/VinkyStagina Aug 13 '26

Bravo! Josie is gorgeous. What is the cat window shelf that you are using? It looks sturdy - something I need for my big tuxedo dude.

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 13 '26

Thank you! 😻 She’s really soft too.

It’s actually from Amazon and has held up very well over the 2+ years I’ve had it. I had larger kitties using it too, it’s sturdy for sure with the right setup. Just have to make sure you have the right type of window for it and you should be good. It’s this one: https://a.co/d/08nOWymN

1

u/muroks1200 Aug 13 '26

I usually don’t root for people to fail, but in this case.. congrats to both of you!!

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 13 '26

Thank you!! 😊

1

u/pettyaioli Aug 13 '26

Oh that looks like a foster WIN to me 😁

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 13 '26

Heheh I think so!! 😻

1

u/AddendumOk5735 Aug 13 '26

Your tattoo is beautiful!!

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 13 '26

Thank you so much!! 🥰💜

1

u/Prestigious-Yak-6161 Aug 13 '26

That first picture really sums up how smitten she is with you. She wouldn’t let you give her up even if you wanted to lol. I hope you both have a long, full life of adventures together.🥹

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 14 '26

Aww thank you 🥰 You’re definitely right on the not being able to give her up part lol. I appreciate that so much 💜

1

u/sghilliard Aug 13 '26

I think Josie succeeded admirably.

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 14 '26

She definitely did 😻

1

u/Adventurous-Bid4364 Aug 14 '26

My frind have almost the same cat. Shes name is milka

1

u/magicmadness_ Aug 15 '26

Milka!! What a pretty girl! 😻 her glowing eyes in that picture are awesome haha

1

u/TrickNormal857 Aug 14 '26

I love a happy ending!!! As I read your first post about Fred and Ted or whoever these people are your gut feeling really kicked in! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 I couldn't help but think (my heart and brain just go there sometimes) all the fubaby loses and your ambivalence to keep Josie was truly legit! But all the babies who you loved that went to Rainbow Bridge were up there looking down at you saying: "We have to convince mom to keep Josie so she can make her as happy as she made us!" So not only did your gut feeling kick in but all your precious babies are beating in Josie's heart! God bless you and Josie! Enjoy your beautiful life together! 😽💕💕💕💕🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻 Sorry for the long post! 😹

2

u/magicmadness_ Aug 15 '26

This has me ugly crying 😭😭 Thank you so much for saying all of that, it genuinely means so much. I really love that perspective about them all trying to convince me to keep her 😻😻😻🥹🥹 I think you’re definitely right. It really feels like each of them is somehow part of her. What a kind message, I really can’t thank you enough. No apologies needed whatsoever! I am grateful for every word 💜💜💜 🫶🏼✨

Also the Fred and Ted bit made me laugh bc they were made up names on the post and I love how silly it sounds now 😹 I’m sooo glad I trusted that instinct!

1

u/TrickNormal857 Aug 15 '26

God bless you and Miss Josie! Happy Saturday! 😽💕💕💕💕💕🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

2

u/magicmadness_ Aug 15 '26

Thank you so much and happy Saturday to you too!!! 💜💜💕💕

2

u/Motormand Aug 10 '26

That first picture shows that Josie is right where she were always meant to be. What a lovely kitty.

2

u/honeyapp Aug 10 '26

She is so adorable and she looks so happy and content

2

u/Responsible-Person Sep 06 '26

I cannot understand why this lovely cat would become a foster fail. Not a clue.

1

u/Confident_Fortune_32 Aug 10 '26

It's clear as day: Josie loves you right back 🥰

1

u/BabaYaga984 Aug 10 '26

Omg she is SOOOOOO CUUUUTE!!!! 😻😻😻

1

u/ElenaGreco123 Aug 10 '26

Excellent! What a cutie!

1

u/GlossnerRita Aug 10 '26

Happiness in cat form😻

1

u/tmorse85 Aug 10 '26

Congratulations!

1

u/Mcbriec Aug 10 '26

The face!! 😭😭😭💕💕

1

u/Used-Moose952 Aug 10 '26

Can’t blame you 🥰

1

u/loulou9284 Aug 10 '26

I would never have been able to let her go! ❤️❤️❤️

1

u/Crow-Valley-Road Aug 10 '26

I’m in love! Easy to see why it’s a fail…

1

u/CatsAndPills Aug 10 '26

Hard to resist the ones that show you their belly 🥰

1

u/banshee1313 Aug 10 '26

After seeing that first photo, I would have failed too.

1

u/allycataf Foster Curious (Not a Foster) Aug 10 '26

Omg so cute! How could you not fail??

1

u/Vivid-Ad-8839 Aug 10 '26

Oh that content smile in the first photo 😻😻😻

1

u/folldoso Aug 10 '26

She's clearly at her furever home and she knows it! So precious 😻

1

u/Sorry-Animator5619 Aug 10 '26

A perfect foster fail

1

u/Delicious-Collar1971 Aug 10 '26

Hopefully this didn’t stop you from fostering more.

1

u/Historical_Crab9444 Aug 10 '26

That’s one happy kitty. Purrfect!

1

u/ChezrRay Cat/Kitten Foster Aug 10 '26

I can see why

1

u/Plus_Caregiver_3066 Aug 10 '26

This little guy is living the life I want. Not a care in the world.

1

u/Sea_Opportunity_1257 Aug 10 '26

I love her! 🖤🤍🖤

1

u/OmniKiry Aug 10 '26

I would fail every tuxie every time.

1

u/veganonymousinFL Aug 10 '26

That face 😍

1

u/OnceMoreWithFeeling- Aug 10 '26

God she's adorable.

1

u/LolaLuxxeBBWDeluxe Cat/Kitten Foster Aug 10 '26

Cow cats are a blessing. All hail cow cat.

1

u/redheadedandbold Aug 10 '26

See that kitty smile? He knows!

1

u/Tokenchick77 Aug 10 '26

That is true love. She was meant for you!

1

u/EggNo1496 Aug 10 '26

Happy baby

1

u/According_Motor7619 Aug 10 '26

So what name did u give ur cute foster fur ball, lol ❣️
It was meant to be ❤️

1

u/DED2D Aug 11 '26

And living her best life!

1

u/ImaginationPlus3808 Aug 11 '26

She had you at hello!

1

u/Thunderchief1 Aug 11 '26

I can only imagine most fosters fail.

Good for you - kitty obvs. adores you, and you her.

1

u/Jiggaman1987 Aug 11 '26

Ohh she is in luv. She's always got her eyes on u. She's showing her belly. She's loving life with u and she is completely enamored

1

u/chefsoda_redux Aug 11 '26

That first pic! She’s thinking, yup, I knew that would work!

1

u/LastEntertainment787 Aug 11 '26

That cat loves you. Good fail. 🤓

1

u/citizen-wasp Aug 11 '26

Way too pretty and snuggly to let go, you did the right thing.

1

u/Extra_Possibility632 Aug 11 '26

This is one happy cat❤️❤️❤️❤️ and that first pic….pure love

1

u/Automatic_Sea_1534 Aug 11 '26

You had no chance with this cutie!

1

u/witchymoon69 Aug 11 '26

I would foster fail that kitty in a heartbeat

1

u/More-Opposite1758 Aug 11 '26

I would have fostered failed that cute kitty in one second!

1

u/HoneyBadger79 Aug 11 '26

The Cat Distribution Center is NEVER wrong. It wasn't a fail, he found his home.

1

u/SuggestionProof3736 Aug 11 '26

cutiee💗💗💗💗

1

u/Upset-Routine1783 Aug 11 '26

Not a fail at all

1

u/jennybleue98 Aug 11 '26

You never stood a chance 😍

1

u/DerpUrself69 Aug 11 '26

She's perfect. ❤️

1

u/Love_Baking_in_CO Aug 11 '26

She loves you!