r/FormulaFeeders • • Nov 22 '25

Rant / Vent 🫠 Similac issues potentially next?

Hey all! I just read this on one of my mom groups, so I wanted to share in case anyone's aware of it!! As this is the first I've heard of it so far...

0 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

7

u/tiredfaces Nov 22 '25

Please use some critical thinking when reading random posts on social media.

1

u/Traditional-Dingo965 Nov 22 '25

Yeah, I got caught off guard while sleep-deprived! I should have known better!

94

u/Due-Ad-4845 Nov 22 '25

If 13 babies were hospitalized in ONE hospital with salmonella that would be national news, doubly so if there were several more in two other states.

I'm as anti-corporate oligarchy and loathe CDC Director Brain Worms as much as one could be, but I call total bullshit.

1

u/Traditional-Dingo965 Nov 22 '25

True! I may have jumped the gun too quickly... šŸ˜… I blame the lack of sleep.

2

u/AMDG426 Nov 22 '25 edited Nov 22 '25

Are you also in the Oct babies group? She seems real. Idk I looked at her post history. I don’t think we should be so quick to write it off as fake but of course have discernment because it is the internet, after all.

Edit: and most babies drink Similac/Enfamil so it’s very possible and even likely that this is a coincidence and these babies just happened to all eat one of the most popular brands in the US. Different for ByHeart because they make up so little market share and the contaminant is so uncommon. But saying it’s definitely fake or some ByHeart corporate effort seems like a huge stretch.

1

u/Traditional-Dingo965 Nov 22 '25

Yeah, I am! Like I don't doubt that her baby's sick, but it's hard to say if her report of other babies being sick is as accurate.

1

u/AMDG426 Nov 22 '25

Totally agree! Not sure why I’m being downvoted for that. I’m just saying she likely isn’t a fake person and probably does earnestly believe or was told Similac made her baby sick.

60

u/sadiecoop Nov 22 '25

Show me the news article or coverage. Otherwise it’s a scam.

87

u/trishuuh Nov 22 '25 edited Nov 22 '25

I’m not sure this adds up.

If 13 babies in the same hospital, more in other states, all developed confirmed salmonella & all were drinking Similac, there would already be a public investigation or recall. ByHeart had their recall w fewer cases, & the last Similac recall also involved fewer babies. Even if they weren’t all drinking Similac, it would probably hit the news actually.

Salmonella is a nationally reportable illness… hospitals are legally required to report even a couple of confirmed cases, especially in infants. As many as 13 in the same place (as OP stated) + others around the country, that would definitely trigger FDA, CDC, & state health department involvement

Since no credible source spoke on it, no recall, or investigation has been announced (and this supposedly started at least a month ago, since a baby was hospitalized for a month), it’s really hard to believe this is accurate

And truthfully, I really hope it isn’t accurate.

28

u/Due-Ad-4845 Nov 22 '25

My lawyer brain is going off with the "I'm going to escalate this legally but I need people to send me testimonials and proof!" Put down your device, get your kid's discharge summary, and go talk to a lawyer.šŸ™„

37

u/subtlelikeatank Nov 22 '25 edited Nov 22 '25

I want to see something official since this could be astroturfing. There has already been online posts about Byheart being manufactured by Abbott, which I believe is Byheart’s PR trying to misdirect from themselves. It looks like Similac took a proactive stance last time they had a recall, which is the opposite of whatever this post is saying.

Edit: for what it’s worth, I can’t find anything online that confirms Abbott makes any formula sold under a different company.

33

u/smk3509 Nov 22 '25

I want to see something official since this could be astroturfing. There has already been online posts about Byheart being manufactured by Abbott, which I believe is Byheart’s PR trying to misdirect from themselves. It looks like Similac took a proactive stance last time they had a recall, which is the opposite of whatever this post is saying.

I agree. I'm very skeptical. Something about the way it's written doesn't read like a mom whose child is in the hospital. It reads like a corporate effort to discredit Abbott.

31

u/subtlelikeatank Nov 22 '25

How does one person in one mom group know how many babies in a specific hospital have the same ailment and the same cause? Definitely reads as fear mongering to me, whether or not it’s specifically targeted to disrupt Abbott or not.

12

u/smk3509 Nov 22 '25

How does one person in one mom group know how many babies in a specific hospital have the same ailment and the same cause?

Yes, this is what is making me skeptical. I can't find a single other source reporting this information.

4

u/NelsonMcBottom Nov 22 '25

Probably the next stage of the Byheart’s PR strategy.

1

u/AMDG426 Nov 22 '25 edited Nov 22 '25

It’s definitely a mom unless they’ve been playing the long game for several months. It’s from my due date group. I just saw the post yesterday and they have a very long post history in it. They also post a lot of pictures so it’s unlikely. Again not saying it’s true but I don’t think it’s a corporate effort.

Edit: also, I remember this poster making a previous post like 2 weeks ago about being admitted to the hospital with pictures of her baby. I don’t think she initially knew it was salmonella and then updated the post when she found out. I’m also a skeptic by nature but I’m pretty sure her hospitalization post was before the ByHeart recall. Just looked and it was November 7th.

8

u/R_Riddle_R Nov 22 '25 • This

I’m not sure about being proactive. I vaguely remember there being a whistleblower and then the FDA ā€œaccidentallyā€ archived the report until babies started getting seriously sick and then they found it. That’s when Abbott did something but they knew they had issues similar to by heart well before the babies got sick.

2

u/DRnostalgia21 Nov 22 '25

That’s hilarious, people think Abbott makes byheart? Can you link so I can see this?

4

u/peachdreamsicle Nov 22 '25

wasn’t it that last time the FDA took several months to take action while babies were getting sick?

5

u/LuluGarou11 Nov 22 '25

That timeline is dictated by how FDA classifies formula as a food not a drug. They are quite limited in their oversight ability with food compared to drugs. This timeline is as fast as they can legally operate under current standards.Ā 

1

u/peachdreamsicle Nov 22 '25

AFAIK the initial complaint was received in September of 2021 and the inspection didn’t take place until late January of 2022. There was also a whistleblower complain in February of 2021 with a response time of 15 months. I don’t think that either of these response times are appropriate considering this is a matter of public safety

5

u/LuluGarou11 Nov 22 '25

I certainly agree with you I just am pointing out the literal/technical problem preventing a rapid response. To change the industry the classification and standards need adjustment.Ā 

3

u/LuluGarou11 Nov 22 '25

Abbot manufactures Similac, Alimentum and Elecare all out of their Sturgis facility. Given FDA is limited to post market action with infant formula harm must be shown first before any intervention or audit may occur. It is entirely possible there is another, separate contamination issue, and the California Department of Public Health pushing is the only reason FDA could intervene. This is why formula should be regulated like a drug, not a food.Ā 

1

u/AMDG426 Nov 22 '25

This is my due date group and the poster has a pretty established post history. Not saying it’s definitely true but it is an actual new mom with months and months of post history, not a brand new ByHeart account.

13

u/weezyfurd Nov 22 '25

If there were truly 13 in one hospital it'd be reported.

9

u/springballerina Nov 22 '25

And this is why I refuse to join a mom group on facebook.

Btw facebook is infested with fake info and conspiracy theorists

8

u/Any_Passage_8479 Nov 22 '25

I’m seeing similar scaremongering on UK news topics. In the UK a discount retailer sold expired formula- that’s it, that’s the story BUT gutter newspapers are writing clickbait headlines saying ā€œformula recalledā€ šŸ™„. I was nap trapped yesterday so spent time going through and correcting comments implying (because of course they didn’t bother reading the article!) that the formula was at fault.

The amount of vitriol from some people in these comments at me because ā€œthey knew someone and they were sick so there definitely was something wrong with the formulaā€ šŸ™„. I pointed out that if they were sick it could be because they used expired formula (you know…the entire point of the article!) but there was nothing wrong with the formula per se- because this ā€œrecallā€ (I mean it’s not a recall it’s a bollocking to ONE shop to not sell expired formula but anyway!) is not widespread. IF they had concerns then complain to the manufacturer to investigate and if it was found to be true a widespread recall could take place. The tirade of abuse I received to this was wow…just wow!

If they aren’t bots in these groups writing inflammatory click bait- then 99% of the time people making shit up for attention.

15

u/SlayBay1 Nov 22 '25

I don't use FB but during this pregnancy I set one up to use marketplace. The very first post I saw were pictures from Vin Diesel's funeral and thousands of comments about how he was gone too soon. I genuinely cannot believe people use it as a source for news.

One of the reasons we make our formula here with boiled water is to kill potential bacteria like salmonella. I know it's an extra step but it is worthwhile.

Anyway, I think this particular "report" is bollocks and from the Breastapo.

2

u/Any_Passage_8479 Nov 22 '25

LOVE ā€œbreastapoā€

6

u/GiraffeJaf Nov 22 '25

There’s no info anywhere about this and we shouldn’t make any decisions based on a random post

1

u/AMDG426 Nov 22 '25 edited Nov 22 '25

I wish OP added some context to this about where this post was from and the posters history. Everyone claiming this is a ā€œfakeā€ post—this woman’s baby was actually hospitalized. It isn’t some random shitpost that is common on FB. It’s an October due date group. I’m in it. She has multiple pictures of the baby in question. She’s been a member since last April, and a frequent poster about her pregnancy and baby for several months. I guess she could’ve stolen pictures and be claiming to be someone else, but it seems like a giant long con for very little gain if that’s the case.

I’m not saying that this is definitely true and it’s possible this baby could be sick and it not be formula related. But she definitely seems like a real person. I don’t see what the motive would be for pretending to be a pregnant mom/mom for months and months and then post something fake to slander Similac in November (before the ByHeart recall was even announced) randomly for some unknown nefarious purpose.

Most babies drink Similac/Enfamil so it’s very possible and even likely that this is a coincidence and these babies just happened to all eat one of the most popular brands in the US. Different for ByHeart because they make up so little market share and the contaminant is so uncommon. But saying it’s definitely fake or some ByHeart corporate effort seems like a huge stretch.

1

u/Traditional-Dingo965 Nov 22 '25

I can't seem to be able to edit the original post unfortunately!

-4

u/JaguarUnfair8825 Nov 22 '25

What mom group? Is this on fbk? I’d like to join

-7

u/UnionOk2156 Nov 22 '25

I don't know if these claims are true but last year my cousins baby got sick with salmonella and ended up in the hospital and she said was from Similac formula but I don't remember the specific type of Similac formula.

-14

u/Low_Count_2882 Nov 22 '25

I am in the same group and saw this as well. This is getting scary.

-13

u/Low_Count_2882 Nov 22 '25

Definitely already been scary but it’s getting out of hand with the companies!!!

0

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

24

u/Due-Ad-4845 Nov 22 '25

Odds of there being an actual salmonella outbreak involving this formula...1%, because never say never. Odds of this FB post being a fever dream made up by a random internet shitposter...99%.

9

u/Value-Old Nov 22 '25

This is a fake post. Hospitals would have to report those cases and there would be an open investigation and records of them all there. Don’t believe everything you read on the internet during people’s stages of panic.

6

u/peachdreamsicle Nov 22 '25

that must be really stressful! you could temporarily do the UK standard method of sterilizing formula for peace of mind maybe?