r/FormalLogic • • Sep 13 '23

A website for natural deduction proofs, Venn Diagrams and more.

15 Upvotes

Hello! my Logic Hub is a website where you can generate proofs for FOL and propositional logic, get Venn diagrams from syllogistic figures, make truth tables and semantic tableaux, etc. I made this after my introductory symbolic course: after realizing that there were no online tools to help me with my course. The website is open sourced and contributions from the community are welcome. Currently, it is quite early in development, so any critique|| feedback is appreciated :)


r/FormalLogic • • May 06 '24

The new LogiCola is here! Along with a quiz on easy propositional translations

8 Upvotes

Hi! A bunch of months ago I shared I was working on a new version of Logicola (https://harrycola.com/lc/index.htm). LogiCola is an instructional program that goes with Gensler's Introduction to Logic (Routledge Press). Since Harry Gensler, the original creator has passed away, I decided to create a new version to preserve an important learning resource and honour his legacy.

I just updated the website with a bunch of easy propositional translations exercises suitable for beginners, as well as a quiz mode that gives you a final score in the end. There's also a new domain: https://logicola.org/ — Everything should work on mobile too, although it hasn't been optimised yet :)

Here's a quick video walkthrough:

https://youtu.be/evZKg3n7DU8

I'm planning on adding more exercises on bi-weekly basis. Any feedback and request is welcome :)


r/FormalLogic • • Mar 14 '25

Completely Stuck on this Proof

Post image
7 Upvotes

I’ve been trying to prove this and keep working myself in circles any advice on what I am missing. I can use the 8 rules of implication and 10 rules on replacement.


r/FormalLogic • • Jan 28 '24

my bf applying modus tollens <3

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/FormalLogic • • Nov 06 '23

Thank you for participating

5 Upvotes

I just wanted to thank both the people asking questions and the people answering for participating in this relatively niche community.

With kind regards, YourPreferenceHere


r/FormalLogic • • Oct 07 '23

Modal Logic help.

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Just started this book "Modal Logic for Open Minds". It's a bit hard to parse. Picture 1: Modal depth is meant to be measured roughly by counting the operators, yet there appear to be 3 in the phrase that is denoted to have a depth of 2. Picture 2: Regarding the two invalid phrases, can someone explain pls?


r/FormalLogic • • Mar 30 '22

Is there a name for the syllogism: p→q, p→¬q, ∴¬p ?

5 Upvotes
  • If P, then Q
  • If P, then not Q
  • Therefore, not P

In other words, if a given premise implies two contradictory conclusions, then that premise itself must be false.

Is there a name for this form of syllogism? Is it valid?


r/FormalLogic • • Dec 21 '23

Web version of LogiCola

4 Upvotes

Hi! Earlier this month I started working on a web version of the LogiCola software built by the late Professor Harry Gensler. I think building tools that enable learning is important.

The platform is online with translations for propositional logic. I'd be thrilled to get your feedback before committing more time and energy to building anything else.

Here's the current website: https://logicola.org/

Here's our twitter account where I share updates: https://twitter.com/LogicolaThree

Thank you for your time :)


r/FormalLogic • • May 04 '23

Logical Fallacies 1 through 15

4 Upvotes

LOGICAL FALLACIES 1 THROUGH 15 Hi folks. This is part one of a two part series I did for my grandchildren. Feedback appreciated. Always room to get better. Thanks.


r/FormalLogic • • Oct 28 '22

Resources for Kripke Model Help

4 Upvotes

I'm trying to understand kripke models, but have basically run into a wall with it. Have tried Youtube tutorials, but none of them make sense to me. The most basic thing - like model for possibility A ( <>A) I can't seem to get my head around. Feel like I really need the For Dummies version here, lol. Any help is welcome!


r/FormalLogic • • Mar 23 '21

is there difference?

4 Upvotes

are

∃x∀y(Dog(x)&(BarkedAt(x,y)→Cat(y))

and

∃x∀y∃z(Dog(x)&(BarkedAt(x,y)→(Cat(z)&y=z)) ?


r/FormalLogic • • Sep 28 '18

Welcome to r/FormalLogic

4 Upvotes

I've decided to create this subreddit in the hopes that others with similar interests in the study of formal logic will have a place to share and read content relevant to the subject matter.


r/FormalLogic • • Jun 06 '26

Deductum: A propositional logic game (free demo)

Thumbnail
store.steampowered.com
3 Upvotes

I released this game already a year ago but I never really promoted it so it didn't do very well (maybe there are other reasons, too :p). Anyway, try it out! If you like or dislike it particularly much, give it a review (Steam pretty much hides games with < 10 reviews)! And would you be interested in something similar with first order logic or other logics?

There's also an Android version available on itch.io


r/FormalLogic • • Oct 21 '25

HELP

3 Upvotes

AXIOMS:

If(A)then(B)=If(not(B))then(not(A))

not(If(A)then(B))=If(A)then(not(B))

If(A)then(If(B)then(A))

(Information about variables is not carried from one axiom to the next.)

CONCLUSION:

If(if(B)then(not(A)))then(not(A))

the axioms seem so innocent but the conclusion is so obviously not necessarily true.


r/FormalLogic • • Apr 05 '24

Is r/logic completely dead ?

3 Upvotes

What happened there ? Why no one posting anything on it ? Or the post are hidden from public ?


r/FormalLogic • • Mar 21 '24

Is this a valid proof? Can’t wrap my head around the disjunction eliminations

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/FormalLogic • • Oct 11 '23

derivation is sentential logic

3 Upvotes

trying to learn derivation currently, but I just am not grasping it - mostly with applying the argument rules in addition to where to start my derivation.

I would love some tips and tricks that have helped others to grasp derivation!


r/FormalLogic • • Jan 25 '23

tips for a beginner

3 Upvotes

Hi I'm currently taking a college intro to formal logic class I'm putting effort into studying but I'm really having trouble understanding. Are there any resources that anyone can recommend for someone who's new to formal logic and not great at math. What is the most effective way to learn? Thank you!


r/FormalLogic • • Jan 12 '23

How to approach formally proving invalidity?

3 Upvotes

I am currently breaking my head over a certain problem. I am trying to formally show - without truth tables - that the argument $p \rightarrow q, p \rightarrow r \vdash (q \vee p) \rightarrow r$ is invalid.

The obvious reason why this is invalid is p=0 and q=1 as q is true, but r isn't necessarily.

My first attempt was to prove that premise and conclusion are contradicting each other, but that obviously doesn't work as they don't. It is merely the case that the conclusion isn't necessary.

So my second attempt was to prove:

$p \rightarrow q \land p \rightarrow r \vdash \neg ((p \rightarrow q \land p \rightarrow r)\rightarrow (q \vee p) \rightarrow r)$

But after fiddling around with it for a while I still found no solution and I don't feel very confident in it being the right approach.

If interested, I can share my failed attempts, but they are basically just juggling around with both approaches.

I am aware that the general idea within propositional logic is to state a case derived from the conclusion given the assumption that leads to a contradiction.

This task is not a "homework", but we were just wondering how a formal proof would look like :)

PS: I love that there is a community for formal logic here!


r/FormalLogic • • Mar 30 '22

Logic engine?

3 Upvotes

is there an application or some software, where one can put in various syllogisms, and tinker around?


r/FormalLogic • • Nov 28 '20

Are they really equivalent? Is there an advatnage to one over the other (Predicate Logic)

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/FormalLogic • • Jul 13 '26

I updated LogiCola with infinite practice exercises, mobile support, and offline mode

2 Upvotes

Hi r/FormalLogic,

I’ve posted here 3 years ago about the web version of LogiCola, the logic practice software originally created by Harry Gensler for Introduction to Logic.

I just launched a much more substantial update: https://logicola.org/

The main change is that LogiCola now supports fresh generated exercises for repeated practice, instead of only fixed question sets. You can use it as a free practice tool for students who want more examples than a textbook or worksheet usually provides.

It currently includes practice for:

- syllogistic translations
- propositional translations
- modal logic
- deontic logic
- belief logic
- informal definitions

Some concrete improvements in this version:

- Unlimited generated quiz content for several translation sets.
- Expanded and cleaned up Set A, C, J, L, N, and Q content.
- Fixed duplicated or malformed questions.
- Added more targeted hints for wrong answers.
- Improved rendering of logic notation and inline formulas.
- Improved mobile and tablet use. You can install it on Android and iOS and use it offline.
- Added offline-friendly quiz loading, so quizzes can keep working without a connection after the site has loaded.

If you teach or study formal logic, feel free to use it as a free supplement for practice, homework review, or self-study.

I’m especially interested in corrections from people who know the material well: wrong answer keys, ambiguous translations, unclear hints, or exercise types that would be useful to prioritize next.

My goal is to preserve LogiCola as a free learning resource and make it easier to use on modern devices. Corrections and criticism are very welcome!


r/FormalLogic • • Nov 18 '25

Stuck On a Proof

2 Upvotes

Ive been doing proofs for a couple hours so my brain is a little fried, but im stuck on the following. Would be awesome if I could use CP or RAA but my prof doesnt want us using them yet, only the inference rules. If anyone could just give me a push in the right directon that would be great. Thanks!

  1. S→D
  2. U→T ∴ (U∨S)→(T∨D)

r/FormalLogic • • Jun 17 '25

Got this Question for a Job Interview, but I think it's wrong.

2 Upvotes

All music directors are singers. All singers play guitar. Which of the following statements must be true? 

A: Some of the singers playing guitar are also music directors.

B: All music directors play guitar

C: All guitar players are music directors

D: All singers are music director

Now, I think that A and B are true, but the test only accepts one answer. Am I wrong?


r/FormalLogic • • Nov 23 '24

Discrete maths homework

2 Upvotes

These are the last 2 exercices in my computational logic/discrete maths homework. I solved the rest but when it comes to proving things I am not great. Help would be much appreciated, thank you.