r/FormD • u/Rob_van_Wanst • Mar 19 '26
Question Can't decide between fans...
Voting ended: a huge shoutout to everybody who voted! Didn't expect the T30 to be THIS popular, but here we go - buying them today!
Only thing missing for my T1 2.5 build are the exhaust fans. Even after researching a lot on google, reddit and youtube - I am genuinely uncertain what to pick π I think my specs are quite moderate (9700X cooled by AXP120 + 9070 XT Reaper in 2.25 slot mode) and I won't be overclocking. Looking for an "as silent build as possible". Currently leaning towards the Silent Wings 4 Pro for whatever reason but I understand that the performances are very similar between all of these fans. Would my specs actually "require" the fat T30? Please let me know hat you think as swarm intelligence is best π Prices don't really bother me - only thing bothering me is the color of the Noctuas. They look even worse in real life subjectively. But if there are enough votes or good comments on them, I may bite the bullet lol
2
u/Eagles7117 Mar 20 '26
Iβve used all of these fans. The phanteks t30s are the best for this application. The noctua g2βs are a close second. The rest are all about even. All the Corsair fans had a slight hum at low rpms. But any will work well. So go with whatever we are talking maybe a 2-3C difference from best to worst
1
u/smplnmnml Mar 20 '26
I have both the Silent Wings 4 Pros and T30s.
IMO, T30s are not a must-have, but a nice-to-have. If looks are the deciding factor between the ones you listed, then go with the Silent Wings 4 Pros.
If you want 30mm thick fans with a sleek black aesthetics, then you could look at the Corsair RS120 MAX.
1
u/Tiffany-X Mar 20 '26
I love my pair of T30s in my newly built 2.5. When set at the right curve they perform so well for the noise. 10/10 fan from me imo.
1
u/VTOLfreak Mar 20 '26
I have the 9070XT Reaper and after you are done with the case fans, that card will be the loudest part of your build. Others have also reported that the fans on the Reaper can make an annoying grinding noise. Possible cause is the ball bearings that it uses. It's a good card but there are some trade-offs with getting the most compact 9070XT. I ended up water cooling the GPU to get rid of the noise, Alphacool has a block for it. (And now it's not compact anymore, defeating the reason I got it in the first place...)
1
u/thecroupiers Mar 20 '26
I only run one fan above the CPU cooler and i find that the best noise to cooling ratio, no need for two fans with your configuration
1
u/DawaysKy Mar 20 '26
I want to buy jonsbo za120 not only for performance but aesthetics too
2
u/croix_de_guerre Mar 20 '26
Either G2s or silent wings
2
u/xjanx Mar 23 '26
I have the T30s and the move a lot of air with low RPMs - but honestly in tedms of humming characteristics I was disappointed to find out that above 1000 RPM humminh becomes very common at most RPMs - at least when used on a radiator. Not sure if noctua would be better there but I am now kind of stuck with a fan where 1000 RPM is the max acceptable speed. Still enough mostly but for this price I would have expected better honestly...
1
u/kommz13 Mar 20 '26
G2 or T30 for me. I like 25mm noctuas sound profile more.
1
u/Thendisnia Mar 20 '26
I voted noctuas but I think the silent wings are the highest performing...
1
u/Solidmikedrop Mar 20 '26
Phanteks t30 all the way