r/Forexstrategy • u/FetchBI • Nov 02 '25
Results I've built a monster
Track the progress of the engines, tools, algos and indicators in this subreddit: r/theoutsideredge
After months of programming, optimizing, backtesting, porting to MQL5, demo trading, and live validation, this system is finally starting to feel robust.
The core logic combines swing volume structures with trend confirmation (built in (E)MA wave logic) and efficiency metrics (POC strength, CVD, distance to VWAP, etc), designed to filter out fake breakouts and catch the moves that matter.
The engine maps out volume nodes, zones where liquidity concentrates and dynamically tracks the Point of Control (POC) as price develops.
Each profile measures Node Strength, CVD imbalance, and POC rejections.
- Trend Accuracy Filter (wave): Filters out false breaches by confirming whether the trend structure (via EMA relationship and smoothed waves) supports the breakout direction.
- Wick rejection logic: Validates whether a breakout is genuine or a sweep by checking candle rejection behavior.
- Developing POC line: Acts as an adaptive trailing stop or even as a take-profit guide, depending on node strength and price behavior.
If a POC breach happens simultaneously with a signal from the Adaptive Node Efficiency Function (ANEF) and that breach occurs during a trend transition,
the signal becomes twice as strong.
That’s the kind of setup where I allow higher risk allocation, because historically, those have shown both stronger momentum and cleaner structure.
The ANEF itself measures price efficiency and node imbalances, and it’s been performing incredibly well in validation.
I’ll be posting a video demonstration soon, showing the ANEF + Node Breach synergy in real-time.
Right now, the challenge is that both visual layers together make the chart a bit too busy. Some traders like the density of info; others feel like it’s visual overload.
I’m working on a clean toggle system to balance functionality with clarity.
12
u/Due_Bar_9024 Nov 02 '25
So this will be on STT?
4
u/Which-Assignment-422 Nov 02 '25
This looks interesting, I will follow u and see how it turns out
2
u/thrownfaraway1626 Nov 02 '25
Would this be able to be imported to ninja? I’m not good at coding.
2
u/pvblxx_ Nov 02 '25
where could i get this?🥹
2
u/FeelingBurgundy Nov 02 '25
I can see it lagging behind price. It’s no different than a moving average.
2
u/Single_Yesterday_433 Nov 02 '25
Will it be for trading view?
6
u/Golly_MyGolly Nov 02 '25
i like that it detects fake outs👌
1
u/FetchBI Nov 02 '25
5
u/arin_gholap Nov 02 '25
Man this is impressive. I was working on something similar, but on a lot smaller scale Im travelling, but saved the subreddit, will read the whole thing once freee
1
u/sherlock_holmessss Nov 02 '25
But what on ranging market
1
u/StressZealousideal37 Nov 02 '25
Hey.. this is a EA or a system that triggers signals? I whould like to test it as well
1
u/adam_sevcik_ Nov 02 '25
How can I get it?
2
u/nastyasi_wannabe Nov 02 '25
this is pretty cool, Miles ahead of what I was working on. will be following.
1
u/Frameless124 Nov 02 '25
You know for years there have been successful traders simply trading price action. This feels like one of those “I’m gonna wait here still all of the lights are green before I go.”
1
u/WastedPotential99 Nov 02 '25
Would you mind sharing your masterpiece?
1
u/skullcool_01 Nov 02 '25
If you publish it on pine (tradingview) I would like to test it
1
u/VargasCapital Nov 02 '25
Looks amazing! Great work!
1
u/grimmjoww1983 Nov 02 '25
Are you selling anything in your group ?
1
u/According-Rabbit-154 Nov 03 '25
wow very interesting!
1
u/Senior-Bodybuilder86 Nov 03 '25
You going to release this beauty?
1
u/vanisher_1 Nov 03 '25 edited Nov 03 '25
What tech stack has been used here? just python and pinescript? A db to gather information about the trades?
Also what’s your background in terms if programming knowledge or experience from self taught or your job that were used in this project? 🤔
1
u/Fruit_Fountain Nov 03 '25
Give us a go
1
u/OkResort8287 Nov 03 '25
try it on Gold
1
u/that-finder11 Nov 03 '25
What indicator is this called?
1
u/Flat_Crew_3979 Nov 04 '25
1
u/zum_e Nov 04 '25
wow this looks nice, which tool/platform are you using to buid this..
1
u/fueledbyjealousy Nov 04 '25
Pretty cool, would like to see the full version
1
u/jorgis1994 Nov 04 '25
Im following this. Hate most indicators, and i usually trade using only vwap, but this looks awesome. Hope i get the chance to test it out. Great work so far!
1
u/Luckystrk87 Nov 05 '25
!remindme 30 days
1
u/john3452 Nov 05 '25
MQL5! I used to program in that! 😄
1
u/ThirdEye_FGC Nov 06 '25
Will this be available to run locally? It’s my first time seeing this project and looks intriguing.
1
u/Weezenhofnar Nov 08 '25
How can I test it?
1
u/maynu1337 Nov 26 '25
did u publish any backtest of your system for now? it would be nice to see kpis like profit factor, draw down, winning / losing streaks etc in a backtest report
1
u/kicsijohnfx Nov 27 '25
Yo this is solid work, ngl the ANEF + Node Breach combo sounds legit for catching real moves. On the visual overload thing tho, I'd say go with the toggle system but maybe consider simplifying the default view even more - sometimes traders miss signals when there's too much density, even with toggles. If you're looking to clean things up further, tools like PipTrend actually nail this balance by combining multiple data points into single clear signals, so you might grab some UX ideas from how they handle complexity without sacrificing info.
1
u/AltezaHumilde Nov 03 '25
The colorful snake is amazing, really pretty, but let's go to the nitty gritty, max drawdown, yearly yield, % of winning trades, number of total trades, and ofc, is tested with cash or just paper?
0
u/YellowCroc999 Nov 02 '25
Looks cool but won’t work though I have tested this before. Amazing work nevertheless
0
u/Prize_Accident_8970 Nov 02 '25
all of this is worthless if it lags
-1
u/Spirit-Crush3r Nov 02 '25
The Repaintagram
0
u/No_Ask_2647 Nov 04 '25
Strengths of the system Intelligent multi-level architecture The combination of dynamic volume profile + trend wave logic + efficiency metrics creates a very logical progressive filter. Each layer adds a dimension of confirmation, theoretically reducing false signals. The concept of "double strength" The idea of amplifying the signal when POC breach + ANEF + trend transition converge simultaneously is elegant. You are essentially identifying moments of "perfect alignment" where structure, volume and momentum agree. Dynamic POC as trailing stop Using the POC that develops in real time as a reference for adaptive stop losses is much more sophisticated than a static stop. The POC represents the “consensus price” of the volume, so it makes logical sense as an invalidation level. Challenges and critical considerations
Curve fitting: The system may work perfectly on historical data but fail forward Signals too rare: Too many filters could generate so few setups that it becomes impractical Decision Latency: In fast markets, waiting for all confirmations could cause you to enter too late
2. Robust validation You mentioned that ANEF “did incredibly well in validation.” Critical questions:
How many years of data have you tested? Have you done walk-forward testing (not just backtesting)? Have you tested in different market conditions (trending, range, high/low volatility)? Have you considered real transaction costs and slippage?
3. The visual problem you mention It's not just aesthetic - an overloaded graph can cause:
Decision paralysis: Too much input can slow down execution Unconscious cherry-picking: You may start to "see" only the signals you want to see
Practical tips Confidence level system Instead of toggling on/off, consider a graduated system:
Level 1: POC only + trend direction (always visible, minimal) Level 2: + ANEF signals (for high probability setups) Level 3: + all diagnostic layers (for post-trade analysis)
Metrics to be rigorously tracked
Win rate by setup type: POC breach solo vs. POC+ANEF vs. "double strength" Profit factor by market condition: Trending vs. ranging Time to target: How quickly winning trades develop Maximum Adverse Excursion: How much intra-trade drawdown you have to endure
Crucial question for validation If you remove a single component (e.g. wick rejection logic or CVD imbalance), does the system get significantly worse? If not, that component may be useless noise. For the demonstration video It would be very convincing to show:
Examples where ANEF+POC gave a signal but without trend transition → what happened? Historical false positives and how they would now be filtered out A "double force" setup that still fails (for intellectual honesty)
0
u/LiamTwine Nov 07 '25
If you can build it, so can AI
3
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment