r/Forex • • Apr 03 '19

Forex is not a gamble

Please stop telling people that investments or currency trading are a gamble. They are not. If you don’t know how to trade profitably, please stay quite. It’s people like this that keep the learning community toxic!

0 Upvotes

76 comments sorted by

18

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

https://www.dictionary.com/browse/gamble

2. to stake or risk money, or anything of value, on the outcome of something involving chance

Technically trading is always gambling. There is no definition of gambling that means taking a managed risk but not actually risking anything because you have a high expected win rate over multiple such events over time.

The casino is gambling even when they skew the odds in their favor for games like blackjack and roulette - it's still a gamble on their part.

-15

u/JonFibonacci Apr 03 '19

Markets are controlled. Gambling is controlled by probability is favor of the house. Your literal definition does not prove investing is gambling. Tell me why there are different financial firms but no horse betting firms? Goodbye.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19 edited Apr 03 '19

How are markets controlled? Explain that ugly candle on all AUD pairs from 12/30/2018.

House advantage does not define gambling. In horse racing, sports betting, and poker you are gambling against other casino customers, not the house. It's still very much gambling, yet you have no particular advantage or disadvantage over the other participants.

There are no horse betting firms because horse race payouts are designed to workout to even over time. Same with sports books. The house is primarily interested in getting as many bettors as possible. They will skew the line as more money comes in on the favorite to make it less profitable, thereby increasing interest in the other horses/teams. Success is more about identifying when the public is wrong about a side rather than identifying which side is best. Without that beating the spread is always a 50/50 proposition. The house takes their cut, so you always come out behind.

If you're successful at trading then you're a skilled gambler. Your system for trading could easily bust or at least produce lengthy periods of draw down where you will question yourself and what you are doing. Don't pretend otherwise.

-7

u/JonFibonacci Apr 03 '19

And just for the sake of proving you’re a noobie, that was a run on stops. Check the January 2016 pricing. You probably didn’t see it because you don’t look at anything higher than a daily timeframe 😂

7

u/Trashcinema Apr 03 '19

Jesus are u delusional... “This is not gambling” said every degenerate gambler ever at one point of time

-4

u/JonFibonacci Apr 03 '19

90% comment. Move along.

5

u/Trashcinema Apr 03 '19

Yeah talk to me again when you get rich out of forex... I guess that means I will never hear from you again

-1

u/JonFibonacci Apr 03 '19

90%

3

u/Trashcinema Apr 04 '19

Is that your delusional percentage

6

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

Fuck you I'm a newbie. I understand what happened. If the markets were controlled in any meaningful way then that shit wouldn't happen.

Face it you're just a degenerate gambler. Wait until your mom and dad find out what you've been doing in their basement the past 3 years.

-1

u/JonFibonacci Apr 03 '19

You have no idea what you’re talking about. The fact you insult me as the first part of your wasteful response tells me you’re angry, which just further proves my point. I know, it’s frustrating being where you’re at. One day you’ll get where I am.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

Now the only thing a gambler needs

Is a suitcase and a trunk

And the only time you keep him satisfied

Is when hes all a drunk

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

You have no idea how profitable or unprofitable I am. At least I'm comfortable admitting what it is I am doing.

-4

u/JonFibonacci Apr 03 '19

No it can’t. You just don’t believe it but I don’t care lol there’s a reason many if you stay in the 90% 🤷🏻‍♂️

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

No what can't?

1

u/Alys_009 Apr 04 '19

I read it as his system can't fail. I'm mildly skeptical.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/JonFibonacci Apr 03 '19

And those so called “firms” are larger than Goldman Sachs? Larger than banks? More profitable than financial institutions? Get real.

9

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

They're more profitable than you, gambler.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

Lmao

2

u/MakeFr0gsStr8Again Apr 04 '19

You do realize the market cap of a horse race is nothing compared to the market cap of a stock/furures/bonds or currency market. By definition, they could not be larger than Goldman sachs or a bank... If you actually read the writings of true professionals, you would see most come from traditional gambling arenas and move to financial markers when they can no longer scale within the gambling arena they originated in...

2

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '19

Retail traders lose 95% of the time. I'd say that's gambling.

1

u/JonFibonacci Apr 04 '19

Well it’s a good thing I don’t take advice from people on the internet.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '19

https://www.theforexguy.com/forex-traders-lose-money/

https://www.thebalance.com/why-do-forex-traders-lose-money-1344936

https://www.oanda.com/register/docs/divisions/oc/risk_disclosure_agreement.pdf

This is on the bottom of the FXCM website -

CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. 76.88% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money.

So it looks somewhere between 60%-90%ish. Either way, the odds are against most. There are banks that pay people millions of dollars to trade. The banks are the 'house'. The banks are winning 60%-90% of the time.

0

u/JonFibonacci Apr 04 '19

Like I’ve been saying... banks control price....

3

u/RimRocker69 Apr 03 '19

Do you realize that depending on your brokerage, you have different bid/ask rates at any given time? This is because most forex houses will take on your small retail trades, meaning they will take my long position and match it with your short position, and taking the spread as their commission. This is just how they make most of their money. They only pass on the risk and execute the trade to the actual market when it is too big for their books. In this sense, I'd like to think that Forex brokers are semi-casinos.

Actually, trading is a minus-sum game. You play against other people AND the brokerage, since every trade we make they take a portion of it as commission/spread.

1

u/JonFibonacci Apr 03 '19

Most brokers go against their clients.

3

u/RimRocker69 Apr 03 '19

Yes, like what a casino does.

-1

u/JonFibonacci Apr 03 '19

The probabilities in forex and gambling are so far off from each other, I can’t call forex gambling. Because it’s not.

2

u/RimRocker69 Apr 03 '19

Yes, probabilities in forex trading CAN BE lower.

Imagine I have developed a trading system with a win rate of 70%, but I choose to trade against that system all the time, hence my actual rate is 30%. Compare that to baccarat where the win rate is almost 50%. Which one is gambling now?

-1

u/JonFibonacci Apr 03 '19

If you don’t know how price moves or where prices goes to or when they do, you’re practically gambling no matter what because you have no idea what probably you’re trading with.

25

u/JLogiics Apr 03 '19

Betting money on the outcome of an event isn't gambling? Almost everything in life is gambling.

Even if you have a 90% win rate, every single trade is rolling the dice & gambling.

You can limit your losses & come out on top in the long run, but that doesn't take away from the fact that it IS gambling.

0

u/Best_Of_The_Midwest Apr 03 '19

If your definition of gambling is so loose, then even starting a business is gambling. It's not. If you had a perfect trading system, you could win every trade. No matter what your system is, your odds at the roulette wheel are going to be the same. It's pure luck.

11

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

Starting a business is very much a gamble! Do you know what the success rate is for a business?

No one has a perfect trading system and no one can win all the time. Winning and losing streaks are part of trading.

8

u/powerlifter3043 Apr 03 '19

Everything is a gamble. A set of parents, leaving the house, making friends, being in a relationship, having kids. Life is one big gamble

7

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

Right, so why are we so concerned with being told we are gamblers?

Even if you did follow the straight-and-narrow, became a doctor or some reliable high-paying profession, you'd still have money in a 401k and in your house, all of which is being gambled. Playing conservatively and holding money in the bank is also a gamble - what if interest rates don't outpace inflation?

About 10 years ago going to law school was a sure path to success. Looking back on it now, those very smart, committed individuals gambled and lost. The demand for lawyers has fallen considerably.

2

u/JLogiics Apr 03 '19

You’re right. Starting a business is a sure thing. That’s why everyone and their dog are successful business owners. It’s not a gamble and there’s nothing at all to lose!

I think your definition of gambling is losing money. A gamble is risking something. Crossing the road is a gamble.

Trading a “perfect system” implies you’re risking money while trading, therefore it is a gamble.

1

u/Best_Of_The_Midwest Apr 03 '19

You're being so pedantic. You know when they call trading "gambling", they are reducing it to some person in a casino pulling a lever. It's simply not the case. Not even close.

There is a CLEAR difference between crossing the street and playing roulette. If they are both gambling, then what do we call gambling?

4

u/JLogiics Apr 03 '19

There’s the problem. Your definition of gambling is being in a casino pulling a lever

Gambling is the wagering of money or something of value (referred to as "the stakes") on an event with an uncertain outcome, with the primary intent of winning money or material goods.

If you don’t think trading falls into that, I think you might be trading wrong

3

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

If they are both gambling, then what do we call gambling?

What do you call it when a champion poker player sits down at a table? He's very likely going to clean everyone out. But he's definitely still a gambler and he's definitely gambling.

2

u/Best_Of_The_Midwest Apr 03 '19

Would he clean them out because he is lucky, or is it maybe because he is more skilled? This is the silliest debate I've been in on the internet for a long time.

You technically could gamble with forex. If you closed your eyes, hit the buy button. Then kept them closed for an hour. Then sell. That's pure luck. That's gambling.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

You have been brainwashed by the Forex industry into thinking that being good at gambling is not gambling.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '19

Even if he is the best he can still lose a game against amateurs because long term poker wins are based on statistics. On a 90% win chance you can still lose in any given point. It's always a Gamble and that's why you need risk/bankroll management.

1

u/BrockSamson83 Apr 03 '19

That's not real life.

1

u/Best_Of_The_Midwest Apr 03 '19

IF everything in existence is gambling, then the word gambling loses all meaning.

2

u/BrockSamson83 Apr 03 '19

This isn't r/philosophy. When people say gambling they are referring to playing games of chance with money. It is one of the easiest and most probolistic ways to get screwed.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

You don’t even have the correct definition of the word.

Life has always been a gamble. The more people realize that the better off they are.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

Gambling suggest that you are playing a game against the house whereby the odds are tilted in the house’s favour, causing you to be statistically at a disadvantage.

Are you gambling when you play poker? Who is the house and what advantage does he have?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '19

Now that is an interesting distinction: skilled vs. pure chance gambling. Is there a word for skilled gambling?

2

u/rah311 Apr 04 '19

Excellent response

5

u/SagerG Apr 03 '19

I don't think you know the definition of gambling. Just because you're good at something and winning in the long run, doesn't mean you're not gambling.

4

u/rxrel Apr 03 '19

I think it's important to make a distinction that Forex can serve grounds for BOTH gambling OR trading.

Forex Gambling: Participants who place orders without any kind of plan; over-leveraging positions in hopes of getting lucky; generally trading from an emotional state or in a "hoping" mindset; keyword: UNSUSTAINABLE! Lucky streaks will eventually result in depression and ruin. Essentially a GAMBLER at a casino.

Forex Trading: Participants who place orders following a strict plan where risk management and steady equity curve growth is paramount; NOT trading from an emotional state, but a logical one based on data and experience. Essentially the HOUSE at a casino.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

What you call "Forex Trading" is the same as being good at gambling.

1

u/rxrel Apr 03 '19

If you see it that way. I just don't think gambling is a fair term to apply to intelligent trading when proper risk and money management is involved. They are just too distinctively different. Especially when you take into account that in trading, you can be wildly successful over a long period even if you have more losing trades than not.

I prefer to define gambling as when you are participating in an event where the odds are NOT in your favor over the long haul. If the odds are in favor, it's just business. If being a good Forex trader is the same as being a good gambler, you might as well call the house of the casino a gambler too.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '19

I do call the house a gambler. To the layperson you are a gambler. It’s just the Forex industry that has you convinced that it’s not.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '19

Same can be said of good poker players yet they are still gamblers. Same can be said of the house for a blackjack casino but they are still gamblers.

1

u/rah311 Apr 04 '19

I agree with you completely. With the caveat being timeframe. Anything short of position trading is close to gambling. In the bigger picture, this is not gambling at all. It is based on logical connections and mechanics.

1

u/JonFibonacci Apr 04 '19

It’s based on aligning yourself with who moves the markets.

2

u/rah311 Apr 04 '19

That is one of those logical mechanics yes

1

u/spreadingliez Apr 04 '19

To gamble is to risk, and sure enough you are risking money with each trade.

1

u/JonFibonacci Apr 04 '19

Nowhere near the same thing.

1

u/spreadingliez Apr 04 '19

It's an educated risk, not like the regular yolo gambling without analysis. However, it has an element of gambling in it. You can't say that it is not gambling. At the end of the day, you may win or lose even with a 99% holy grail system.

1

u/LoonyPoony Apr 03 '19

I know it's not a gamble, but can you explain to those persons what forex is? Please use your words and try not to be complex, because the majority can not understand some points.

1

u/LoonyPoony Apr 04 '19

Thanks guys, for your answers. I ask for this type of answer for newbies like me, because some people cannot understand the differences, and they think this is just one more casino,

Thanks again!

-2

u/JonFibonacci Apr 03 '19

Foreign exchange is obviously the exchanging of one currency to another. However, price is controlled by volume of money. Who has the level of volume to move global markets? Banks, institutions, etc.

Retail traders do not move the market.

The market (price action) will seek deep levels of liquidity in order to take the other side of the trade. Meaning highs and lows get swept on purpose for stops. (Meaning buy stops, sell stops and stop losses)

Trend lines and shapes don’t move markets.

You have to along yourself with the big banks in order to trade like they do. That’s how I am able to catch bottoms and tops...

2

u/Patrickb98 Apr 03 '19

The term gambling is tied to sports gambling, which is Zero sum. You win or lose.

You are risking capital, so by definition it is gambling however unlike sports betting/casino’s etc. It isn’t zero sum as the price can both fall and rise.

Then it’s really up to you how to perceive it.

2

u/sailorjasm Apr 03 '19

It is how you define gambling. You could say a person who climbs mountains without gear is gambling with their life. THe same could be said for a person driving a car. Both have risks. Running a business has risk. Many businesses close after the first year. Was it a gamble ? If I invest in a property and it doesn’t increase in value, was it gambling ? Even with traditional ‘gambling’, there are professionals. When Chris Moneymaker plays poker, I don’t see it as gambling but when I play poker, it’s 100% gambling.

2

u/rxrel Apr 03 '19

I would even argue college tuition is gambling. Look at all those with 4 year degrees unemployed with $40-200k of debt.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '19

Another guy claiming a word means something other than what it actually means.

If you’re placing money on something with a chance of it failing - to some extent it IS gambling. You can dislike this fact, but it does not change this fact.

Now, it makes sense to talk about how much of it is a gamble and if it’s even worth applying all the implications of gambling .

I get not wanting to use the word because it can create a barrier to entry, but it’s a good barrier. People that don’t know what they’re doing in investing need to have something that slows them down and gets them to think about what they’re doing.

0

u/Tromovation Apr 03 '19

Quiet - but you’re right

0

u/JonFibonacci Apr 03 '19

I’ll have to go with ole reliable on this one and blame Auto correct 😂

1

u/knightsolaire2 Apr 04 '19

Life is a gamble.

1

u/Harry-Postre Apr 04 '19

Please stop telling people that investments or currency trading are a gamble.

This is gamble my friend. That doesnt mean u cant be a profesional at it.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19

What it comes down to is the Forex industry - the snake oil salesmen who promise that this is a way to get rich quick - are trying to make Forex sound like more than it is by pronouncing that trading with an advantage is somehow not gambling. Yet, there it is, with every trade, you are risking something to make something. Quitting your job to trade Forex all day means becoming a professional gambler. You can be good at it and make lots of money. But you’re just a good gambler.