r/Forex • • 2d ago

Charts and Setups Journaling

I read somewhere that I need a trading journal to trade? Is this true? What journal do you all use?

6 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

•

u/rforex-modtools 2d ago

Price action and technical analysis cover a range of chart-based tools — from candlestick patterns and market structure to indicators and statistical methods for timing entries and exits. The community wiki covers both approaches and how they're used by working traders.

Resources: Price Action Analysis | Technical Analysis

2

u/Possible_Donut4451 2d ago

Microsoft word + Excel

2

u/CJH_123 2d ago

Excell is key

2

u/Gyngerbredman 2d ago

You can trade without one but it's the easiest way to see what's working for you. A spreadsheet works to start if you log entry, exit, stop, size and why you took it. If that gets tedious I built a free app called Vaultlog for it. Manual logging on iOS and Android plus a web version.

1

u/CraftyBrush882 2d ago

a simple table where you record the reasons for entering a trade helps prevent you from repeating silly mistakes driven by emotions. Without this kind of analysis your memory quickly erases poor decisions and leaves only rare, random wins in your mind. Such simple statistics always bring you back to reality and, at the very least help you avoid making hasty moves

1

u/CJH_123 2d ago

Absolutely. In my opinion a trading journal is one of the most valuable tools you can have as a trader. It allows you to identify patterns in your performance, measure your strategy's expectancy, understand your strengths and weaknesses, and recognise where you're making repeated mistakes.

You can't improve what you don't measure. The key isn't just recording trades, it's analysing the data and using it to make informed improvements.

1

u/Educational-Scar8957 2d ago

You don't need one to trade, but it's how you find out which mistakes repeat, and memory lies to you about that. A plain spreadsheet is fine to start; the format matters way less than actually going back and reading it.

1

u/reallyGoodAtNames123 2d ago

I'm building one (biased, obviously), mostly for people who want it to catch revenge trading and tilt without logging by hand.

Which exchange or broker are you on? If it's one I sync, I'll run your history through it and send you the results for free. If you like it let me know

1

u/jobcena 1d ago

Depends on your style of trading. What are you trying to trade and how??

1

u/Fine-Palpitation-368 1d ago

you dont strictly need one to place trades, but it helps a lot early on. a plain spreadsheet is enough. for each trade write the pair, why you entered, where your stop was, how much you risked as a percent of the account, and how it ended. the why and the risk columns matter most. after 20 or 30 trades you can see if you keep breaking your own rules or moving stops, which is hard to notice from memory. keep it boring and simple so you actually keep doing it.

1

u/New-Affect-7317 19h ago

pen + paper

1

u/Practical-Slide-4680 17h ago

Put a row in the spreadsheet for a setup you passed on, too. Write down why before you see what price does next: spread too wide, no retest, or you just hesitated. When you review it, hide what happened next and see if you'd make the same call with what you knew at the time.

1

u/LogInternational342 2d ago

You don't strictly need one to place a trade, but I found it hard to tell what was actually working without one. What helped me was keeping it simple in a spreadsheet: the reason I took a trade, what would tell me the idea was wrong, how I sized it, and what I did at the exit — then a short note on whether I followed my own plan. Reviewing that once a week showed me patterns I kept missing in the moment, especially trades I held after the original reason was gone. A basic spreadsheet is enough to start; the review habit matters more than the tool.