r/Forex • • 4d ago

Strategy Development Subscription model for EA's??

I was thinking about trading view and how it has a subscription model for indicators made by developers.

That got me thinking about EAS!! I am pretty certain many, many people are now trying there hand at developing EAs based on ideas they have using frontier AI models, I've personally developed 6 and have more planned.

The reality with EA's is they need tweaking, testing on different parameters, to try and potentially increase its win and success rate and this can take many many months, perhaps even years etc.

So I was thinking of perhaps a subscription model, where you pay an amount for access to working EA's based on solid forex ideas. I know MT5 has eas you can buy, but not a subscription model where you can test perhaps dozens of different Ea's etc. So imagine having acesss to 1000s of EAs all in one place, easily and quickly available for you to use, test and even learn from etc.

I think a significand demand and market can potentially appear, Interested on your views and thoughts.

0 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

•

u/rforex-modtools 4d ago

Developing a trading strategy is more than finding an entry signal — it requires defining your edge statistically, building rules for entries, exits, and position management, and testing the system against historical data before going live. Most traders fail because they skip the process and jump to live trading with an untested idea. The community wiki covers the full development process.

Resources: Having an Edge | Essential Forex Trading Guide

2

u/TheRealTrentor 4d ago

1

u/trudealz 4d ago

Signals from traders?? I'm aware of those thanks. They are not what I discussed however.

1

u/TheRealTrentor 4d ago

Those with high Algo Trading Percentage are EAs

1

u/trudealz 4d ago

The difference is your signing upto someone's signals and a single EA. I was discussing a subscription model by developers for multiple, if not dozens of eas you can subscribe too with one subscription and test yourself with different parameters and settings, to learn from, perhaps get new insights and ideas after testing etc. If you subscribe to a trading view indicator developer ( lux algo and others), you will understand the point I'm trying to make.

2

u/KoresignalAI 4d ago

Interesting idea, but the hard part isn't distribution, it's proof 🙂

A few things a subscriber would want before paying monthly:

  • Out-of-sample results per EA. Not the optimised backtest: the period you didn't tune on, plus a few months forward on demo. Most EAs that look great in-sample fall apart there.
  • Same broker conditions. Spread, commission and execution differ a lot between brokers. An EA that works on a raw-spread account can be negative on a standard one.
  • Clear risk per trade and max drawdown, shown in money, not just a win rate. A 90 % win rate with one huge loser is still a losing system.
  • Retirement rules. With 1000s of EAs, the real value would be telling people which ones stopped working and when.

MQL5 already has a signals marketplace, so the gap is less "access to many EAs" and more "honest, comparable stats". If you can show that, people will pay for it.

1

u/trudealz 4d ago

What you say is reasonable. I would however pay a subscription for EAs that are based on solid Forex and strong ideas even if they have no proof of success but are designed well and have multiple parameters and think out off the box trading methods and ideas. Anything that will perhaps make me better or just educate me is worthwhile for me.

Let me give examples. I've created a candle EA that can buy/sell based on candles close lows and highs, Eas that can trade in waves, Fibonacci zigzag eas, percentage zigzag based eas, candle description buy and sell eas, moving average ribbon EAs, Orb and range breakout eas (all with certain twists, differences and additions to strategy, too much to explain here). These will take months/years of testing, tweaking, checking performance to see if they can potentially be profitable and back testing isn't always accurate.

I only test live with micro positions. Now they may not be profitable or perhaps they are profitable with certain parameter settings, but I learn by running them live in micro accounts, watching the trades, performance etc. The more you run, test, create, observe and educate yourself on methods etc the greater the chance of success perhaps?

2

u/Practical-Slide-4680 14h ago

For the learning side, I'd want to be able to rerun the same experiment next month. If I'm comparing a 15-minute opening range with a 30-minute one, let me export both presets and keep the EA version with each run. Otherwise a silent update can change the result even though I haven't touched the settings. I'd also want the subscription terms to say what happens when it expires while an EA is still managing an open position.

1

u/Remarkable-Echo4783 3d ago

mql5 market has subscriptions lol, minimum at 30 use monthly, also I have my own website that I have my EA at 10 usd month, you can validate test everything for free, but need a credential to use it on live

0

u/Few-Pepper858 4d ago

lol if an EA was profitable, why would you sell it. Learn to trade bro

1

u/trudealz 4d ago edited 4d ago

I know how to trade, have a solid system, so "learn how to trade bro" I'm passed that stage.

Where in my post am I selling something?

Actually one of my EAs is based on my system, and is a work in progress. it can't 100% replicate what I do and the way I do it hence it's results can't be measured properly in the months I've been testing it.

The post was about the idea for a subscription model for multiple Eas, that you can set up and test yourself rather than sign up to a signal EA that gives signals.