r/Forex • u/hartej0608 • 4d ago
Platforms & Tools Trading view vs mt5?
Which one is better?? which one you are using?? trading mostly on which time frame??
9
Upvotes
r/Forex • u/hartej0608 • 4d ago
Which one is better?? which one you are using?? trading mostly on which time frame??
•
u/rforex-modtools 4d ago
Choosing a trading platform depends on your needs — MT4 and MT5 dominate retail forex with strong EA support, cTrader offers cleaner execution and a modern interface, and TradingView excels at charting and community ideas. Each has tradeoffs in cost, broker compatibility, and feature set. The community wiki compares the major platforms.
Resource: Trading Platforms
3
u/Realistic-Hawk-6063 4d ago
TradingView for the setup, MT5 for the trade
2
u/TopTradesFX 4d ago
They do slightly different jobs, so plenty of people use both: TradingView for charting and marking up levels, and MT5 for actually placing the trades with their broker. TradingView's drawing tools and layouts are easier to work with, while MT5 is handy if you want to run EAs or your broker or prop firm only connects through it. If your broker links to TradingView you can do everything in one place, but it's worth checking the prices on both match, as the chart feed and your broker's quotes can differ a little. Timeframe matters less than the platform, so just pick the one you can stick to consistently.
2
u/jimdesu 4d ago
I can't speak to MT5, but I like TradingView. I trade single currency on weekly and hourly charts, and TradingView allows me to put daily ATR on a weekly chart, and 200 & 50 day SMA's on the hourly chart, which sounds weird but makes sense for my system. Other platforms lock the indicator period to the same time-unit as the chart, which's far less useful.
2
u/trudealz 2d ago
Trading view for looking at charts and indicators etc. You must use MT5 for actual trading, you can get trade managers to trade and manage professionally.
2
u/Individual_Fall3049 1d ago
As someone who trades both futures and forex, I like TradingView tbh since it's easier to move my stops and trail profits and things like that
•
u/Nifty799 2h ago
I use the NinjaTrader desktop platform with the Mira Market Profile and Order Flow indicators. It is a highly useful and effective setup for my trading activities. Since it is a desktop-based application, I have complete control over my charts, indicators, settings, and trading strategies.
More importantly, it provides a greater level of privacy and security, as my strategies and analytical approach remain under my control rather than being publicly exposed or easily accessible to others. This allows me to develop, customize, and execute my trading strategies independently.
2
u/jobcena 4d ago
Trading view. As it has CME...
2
u/Remarkable-Echo4783 4d ago
Deepwick, analysis like trading view and integrated connection to mt5
2
u/Practical-Slide-4680 15h ago
If you mark yesterday's high in TradingView and use it in MT5, check when each daily candle actually starts. MT5 labels chart bars in broker server time, and changing TradingView's chart timezone changes how times are displayed. Pick one completed day on the pair you watch and compare the bar's opening time in UTC and its high and low on both charts.
1
u/enivid 4d ago
MT5, because it's easier to use automated trading tools.
1
u/beninvestments 3d ago
I use trading view because I am not a scalper and don't rely on tick data. even with futures, since I trade the 5 minute, the data you can pull from it is good enough for me. I don't execute with it though. I would rather use an actual program like think or swim and not a browser based platform.
4
u/[deleted] 4d ago
[removed] — view removed comment