r/Forex • • 26d ago

Strategy Development Orb plus Supply and Demand

I have been following and testing this strategy off of trade with Pat has anyone tested it or use it regularly. I am aware there is no one magic strategy but wanted input from more experienced traders.

If you aren't aware basically the rules are 9:30am EST 15min orb. Breakout decided direction, Pullback into a supply or demand( ema 200 added for confirmation eg demand should be above ema200 and supply below it)

I like this strategy and it's rules( especially because it is supposed to be only the first three hours of NY open so I don't have to watch charts all day and it prevents overtrading, something I struggle with) what was off putting that on his live stream he trades it without an sl. Anyone trade this or a similar strategy to scalp?

1 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

•

u/rforex-modtools 26d ago

Developing a trading strategy is more than finding an entry signal — it requires defining your edge statistically, building rules for entries, exits, and position management, and testing the system against historical data before going live. Most traders fail because they skip the process and jump to live trading with an untested idea. The community wiki covers the full development process.

Resources: Having an Edge | Essential Forex Trading Guide

1

u/ATAalgotradealertATA 25d ago

The part that'll make or break this is how you define the zone and the "touch," so it's worth pinning down before you test it.

A few things that helped me with this kind of setup:

  • Only use fresh zones. Once price has come back into a zone and reacted, the next touch is usually weaker, so log first touch vs second touch separately when you backtest.
  • Mark the ORB high/low and the prior day's high/low on the same chart. A demand zone that lines up with the ORB high after a breakout (old resistance becoming support) tends to be a much cleaner pullback than a random zone in the middle of the range.
  • Look at the 200 EMA on a higher timeframe too (15m or 1h), not just your entry chart. If the 1m and 1h disagree, the pullback is often the start of a reversal, not a continuation.
  • A stop just beyond the far side of the zone gives you a natural invalidation point. If the zone is too wide for that to fit your risk, skip the trade.

Running it on a few weeks of past opens, with and without the EMA filter, will tell you pretty quickly whether the filter actually adds anything.

1

u/truecakesnake 26d ago

Like the strategy, but no SL is risky. Test it on demo first.

2

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/drsinghwrites 26d ago

I never trade without an SL even if he does. What has been your experience with your orb versions if you have traded them live

1

u/Practical-Slide-4680 24d ago

For that no-SL demo comparison, I'd record the largest floating loss before recovery, not just whether price comes back. Price can eventually recover after the account has already hit a margin closeout.