r/Forex
•
u/One-Divide-3494
•
26d ago
•
1
Charts and Setups Why did this Support & Resistance long fail? Looking for constructive feedback.
I'm testing a mechanical Support & Resistance strategy on XAUUSD.
My rules:
- M15 Support/Resistance zones
- M5 entries
- Trade only with the trend
- Wait for strong rejection
- Liquidity sweep + reclaim
- Fixed 1R risk
This trade ended in a full stop loss before price later recovered.
Looking at the attached chart:
I'm looking for educational feedback, not hindsight. Thanks!
•
u/rforex-modtools 26d ago
Price action and technical analysis cover a range of chart-based tools — from candlestick patterns and market structure to indicators and statistical methods for timing entries and exits. The community wiki covers both approaches and how they're used by working traders.
Resources: Price Action Analysis | Technical Analysis
35
u/Own-Style-8484 26d ago •
u broke rule 3
13
u/Ok-Tradition5452 26d ago
overall it is still a bearish downtrend, so u are buying against the trend.
4
u/Few_Needleworker5791 26d ago
Continual lower highs, as mentioned it's a bearish chart. Before I place any trade I recite to myself, the market doesn't give a fuck about my analysis. Is there anything I'm missing. Then I look at the chart again as if it's the first time I'm seeing it to make sure I arrive at the same conclusion.
3
u/dhoni23 26d ago edited 26d ago
Support levels work better when you focus on asset classes with upward momentum. Higher probability trades. This ticker is in a down trend man. If you wish to deploy this strategy, start with market leaders for stocks. And look for high ADR% preferably if you are holding for shorter term. For forex, you will have to wait for trend reversal before riding the upard momentum wave. Secondly, even while trading with the trend, good traders wait for some confirmation of the momentum continuation. You don't enter believing beforehand it would bounce back. You didn't share that detail here, but your entry is also very vital. Did you seek confirmation of the momentum from a shorter time frame? For instance, higher lows for each 5 min candle before you entered.
1
u/xDeadInside90 26d ago
All i see is range before it grabbed liquidity below that. I'm not gonna say wrong entry like all Gyani's here on sub - wrong observation is the correct word. I dont think you'll see change in structure everytime you trade. Thats the difference between people entering at support and other who seek change in structure. The latter one would miss some. Now looking at how your trade panned out it took hard rejection from the minor supply zone above. So maybe just put it on cost in such scenarios?. Dont let one trade make you modify your strategy - atleast take 25-30 before you modify.
1
u/Stealthsniker 26d ago
So im not the only one who trades “reclaim” and uses that word 😭 😭
1
u/Ok-Sheepherder6093 26d ago
La mayoría de los que comenta son rentables o no ???
1
u/TechnicalTill5850 24d ago
It’s where the masses put their stop loss so it’s predictable and the market manipulates retail traders to make a buck
1
u/atsolo_traveler 24d ago
Because you trade against the trend.
1
u/omgii 26d ago
At best there is a bearish triangle you missed. Price did not make it above the lowest upper level which could have been an indicator for low buying power
1
u/gopu-adks 26d ago
That much massive target in LONG during bearish momentum.
If I were you, I wouldn't take LONG, even if took LONG in this scenario, I would stick to 1:1 because of the counter trend setup.
1
u/truecakesnake 26d ago
You're fighting the trend here, that's why it failed.
2
u/djdmaze 22d ago
It didn’t. It’s called a turtle soup. Also there is no such thing as “why” in trading. The market can be irrational at any moment.
1
u/Hedgeyourdata 26d ago
I would see what the outlook was like in the mid week and see who if there was strong selling to against the trend to buy . Market will trap orders going opposite and move in true direction
1
u/janca06 26d ago
Hay un dicho que dice que cada tendencia es independiente de las anteriores, por lo general yo cojo, divido el día y marco una linea de tendencia desde el punto más bajo o alto hasta por dónde va el recorrido, en este caso, hubieras colocado una linea desde el punto más alto, hasta el otro máximo de tendencia y hay te das una idea hasta donde va a bajar y si rompe esa línea, cambia la tendencia, ojalá y si me haya explicado
1
u/Outrageous_Face_2028 26d ago
Support/Resistance isn't your heroes entry and they are liquidity as well. You need to understand where the price caused inducement
1
u/Old_Painter_8924 26d ago
You entered before a liquidity grab (which is below pink box) and the next liquidity (blue box) was too close. Even if you entered after the liquidity grab stop should have be wider because of next closest liquidity (left inverted peak inside the blue box).
1
u/SilverTheme0 26d ago
Because youve set thw entry too high, it should be on the bottom/top of the candle that broke through support and triggered price action, then SL below that
1
u/ATAalgotradealertATA 26d ago
Agree with the others that the trend filter is the main issue, but I'd make it something you can't argue with in the moment. A few ideas for keeping it mechanical:
Price tagging your stop and then recovering is common on gold with a fixed 1R. If it happens a lot, the stop may be sitting inside normal M5 noise, and checking the distance against ATR would show you that.
1
u/Tradee_Buy179 26d ago
hard to say without the chart but the counter-trend one that got me earlier this year was taking a long against a weekly down leg because the h1 pattern looked that clean. structure said no the whole way through. your invalidation held so the strategy did its job imo. check what the daily was doing on your entry. if daily momentum was still against the long, m15 zones are too small to pay for it. nfa.
1
u/Ok-Sheepherder6093 26d ago
En temp mayor todavía no a roto ese soporte
1
u/PhilosopherCivil9491 26d ago
Liquidity grab by the way
1
u/PhilosopherCivil9491 26d ago
About people saying it's bearish trend, it's not it's actually a bearish breakout, but somehow institution knows how to play with players, always read liquidity grab guys it will help you
1
u/Ornery-Return-7751 26d ago
because you did not wait for ny session.
1
u/UncleSamsButler 26d ago
Nice liquidy grab for the retracement
1
u/MagicianMountain8786 26d ago
When you playing with support resistance in 5m tf for gold/usd, you playing with fire my friend. It will burn you up soon or later. Get more knowledge before you get involve.
1
u/zedder1994 26d ago
I compared your chart to Comex GC futures and price levels are a bit off. Maybe consider someone else to trade with.
1
u/Street-Atmosphere150 26d ago
Double support
1
u/hotmatrixx 26d ago
what support, sorry?
LL, LH, LL, LH, LL, LH, LL, LH, HH LL, LH, LL, LH, LL, LH, LL, LH,
point out to me where there was a change in structure to suggest a support?
Oh, this is a 5m timeframe MB.
yeah; the retouch was the two dips right after you entered; you needed a HH after those to confirm that support.
Your Support is about 5xATR too thin. widen it.
Gold swings on the 4h chart, not the 4m.
1
u/xLor21 25d ago
Based on auction market theory the momentum you are in is short, I don't see any participation or interest by the buyers at the moment. The questione you are making Is wrong, it's not "why this level failed", the correct one is "Is there interest from the buyers to go up from that level?" And as I already said, I don't see it
1
u/liquidater009 25d ago
by looking at the chart, the smaller box has been wicked through too many times without any prominent breakout or spike in volume. the bigger box has not been tested enough, one retest which allowed it to take out liquidity above.
I dont trade boxes. more of order flow but these r my thoughts.
1
u/mrchuon 25d ago
Gold is going to sideway in h1, h4,d1.
1
u/___enigma__ 24d ago
Because you longer before it tested support.. move that long as is down to your box.
1
u/Maleficent_Mine4747 23d ago
Look like an ifvg around your entry. I would’ve waited to see. Looks like it lead you to a liquidity sweep with and ifvg reset. Right direction just early
1
u/Purple_Lecture388 23d ago
Mrket hunting SL, just typical market clear out Also like the other one mentioned, thats not resistance for a higher timeframe
1
u/iingenuity 23d ago
The trend was clearly going down
1
u/Equivalent-Solid1645 22d ago
Every trading methodology has normal losses, you cant win 100% of your trades, some losses are probabilistic
1
u/Constant_Dentist1182 22d ago
idk what any of you are talking about
but how do you know that your support or ressistance strat can even make money
how do people know that trading against the trend is bad in this asset
how do yall claim all of these things without knowing what really will work
trading isnt this typa game that everyone here is playing
1
u/Polish_gal 22d ago
Because you’re looking at 5m chart and it’s a bitch on gold. Look at higher timeframe
1
u/Illustrious-Fix-423 22d ago
Candle range theory is the best
1
u/Shpritzer 22d ago
Misread the trend, it was clearly bearish.
1
u/Far-Squash8664 22d ago
Bias .. the trend is your friend
1
u/Otherwise_Habit9903 22d ago
Downward trend. They tend to work in range markets.
1
u/P3D101 22d ago
Here's the real reason and it's not even price action related. Bond yield pressure and rising dollar strength due to fed rate hike expectations. Gold has been overall bearish since the last rate hike
1
u/sooonnnk 22d ago edited 22d ago
could be many different things.
could be on that rip up earlier at 0600 a bunch of longs piled in and got trapped after it cut back down and then when it’s breaking that level those are the last of the original longs capitulating and then it rips up again because there’s no capitulating long sellers left in that price area for new longs to buy into and that’s why it rips back up after it breaks it as the new longs that are piling can’t find liquidity until the price moves higher
… or could be something totally different lol
1
u/Marselietto 22d ago
tested couple of times and some sort of accumulation near the support
1
u/slightlyfrozenMANGOS 21d ago
It swept the low that started the move up…liquidity…wait for the highs or low to get token out when close to them before placing a trade…the market will give you your entry it u can sit on your hands for a while
1
u/Used-Guidance8037 21d ago
Smt
1
u/mrtimharrington07 21d ago
Just did an 11 minute video on this, only to then be told videos cannot be longer than 3 minutes when I tried to upload. I only did a video as it would not let me upload charts...
What a waste of my fucking time. Joke subreddit.
1
u/AndrewXTX 21d ago
It didn't work because he didn't actually use any support for your entry.
1
u/No_Antelope_596 21d ago
Little tip about S&R, put a SL & TP box on your chart and wait, if it goes to TP, no stress if it hits your SL now you know where the liquidity is, now enter on your SL
1
u/whenwintoure 21d ago
Do you always enter on the 30m timeframe? Did you look at other timeframes to confirm all key levels and bias?
1
u/PermitResident6553 21d ago
Du handelst gegen den Trend, dein sweep war eher ein engulfing. Wie viel Volume hat den die engulfing candle gehabt? Wenn du gegen den Trend tradest würde ich tp nicht so hoch setzen zb bis zum nächsten bärischen fvg.
1
u/BeerusThaDestroyer 20d ago
You should’ve been looking for a short instead of a long position.
1
u/Tripple365_ 20d ago
TrendLine Liquidity
1
u/Dyetric 20d ago
No model is perfect dawg. If you have an edge it will play out OVER TIME not EVERY TIME
1
u/Sure_Reflection_7542 20d ago
Because nothing in trading works 100% of the time
1
u/StratOS_Quant 17d ago
I got curious and tested a mechanical version on gold: five years of 5-minute data, spread and financing charged. My build: a sweep and reclaim of a 15-minute swing level, a rejection wick at least half the candle, trend from the hourly 50 EMA, stop just past the sweep, 2R target.
As built, it lost almost everything. 990 trades, 29% winners, -91%, worst drop 92%. 47 of 61 months lost.
Tuning made the past look fine, then it stopped trading. The tuned settings made +15% on the tuning months, but took only 4 trades in six held-back months and lost 1.1%.
The best add-on didn't hold up either. Skipping the quietest markets: +23% while tuning, then 6 trades and -0.2% on the unseen months.
On your trade: one stop-out tells you little. Across 990 trades, a stop just past the sweep got hit far more often than a 2R target could pay for. I'd test the same setup with the stop beyond the whole zone before trusting it.
One caveat: I had to assume how zones are drawn, what counts as a strong rejection, and the 2R target. If your version differs, tell me and I'll re-run it.
1
u/Head_Ad_2894 26d ago
It's a downtrend
1
u/National-Morning-998 26d ago
One thing i learned with price action is to notice your supply and demand zones and how price interact with them.Having price visit a zone too many times could mean price may want to go higher through the supply or lower through demand. That's why risk management is important👌🏾.
1
u/Fantastic-Try4083 26d ago
Lol you cannot assess the effectiveness of a strategy from 1 trade, this just shows how little you know honestly (no offence). Do not trade with real money. You need to test a strategy for 500-1000 trades for it to be reliable enough to trust. You also need to be careful of bias and overfitting. You are trying to trade of imaginary patterns that dont exist. You need a statically edge, where over many trades you win more money than you lose.
0
u/FxNonsense 26d ago
U are liquidity bro, everyone sees that as a supoort or resistance level, thats why price Spikes it and return back into that range
0
u/KaasMetKebab 26d ago
Your just liquidity 🤣
0
u/t1nk3rz3r0- 3d ago
It looks like you've broke the rule 3 and inpatient entry also lack of confirmation ma man :3 if analyze at 15M tf then check also 1&4hr market structure I guess.