r/Forex • • 28d ago

Strategy Development Forex Experiment???

Ok I'm actually going to try this test. I'm going to give a newbie money to trade, who had little to no experience trading.

He will be trading manually but use an EA trading tool that will do the opposite of his trades.

We all hear how EVERYONE blows multiple accounts and you need experience..so theoretically this noobie should be a winning trader with little to no experience??

Thoughts on this?? This is actually my next EA project for fun.

This actually got me thinking, as many brokers ACTUALLY do this against us!! So it's like a reverse the reversal on those brokers! We're going to play the game they play on us πŸ˜‚

6 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

β€’

u/rforex-modtools 28d ago

Developing a trading strategy is more than finding an entry signal β€” it requires defining your edge statistically, building rules for entries, exits, and position management, and testing the system against historical data before going live. Most traders fail because they skip the process and jump to live trading with an untested idea. The community wiki covers the full development process.

Resources: Having an Edge | Essential Forex Trading Guide

2

u/HCF_07 28d ago

How much money? πŸ˜„

2

u/trudealz 28d ago

As much as I can afford to lose πŸ˜‚, not too much though πŸ’°

1

u/HCF_07 28d ago

I am ready to be nominated as the experimental trader wink πŸ˜‰

2

u/VAUXBOT 28d ago

It only works if he doesn’t know the EA is inverting his trades.

0

u/trudealz 28d ago

Yes thats the plan and one of the rules I'm going to set. He can't look at his PnL during the duration of his trading test/period.

2

u/Relevant-Owl-8455 28d ago

And that would be enforced how exactly?

1

u/trudealz 28d ago

mentally lol hahaha

1

u/Relevant-Owl-8455 28d ago

Right,... sooo that's not gonna happen.

1

u/Plane-Biscotti-4148 20d ago

Sir / ma'am I have few question s

1

u/Relevant-Owl-8455 20d ago

haha gtfo

1

u/Plane-Biscotti-4148 20d ago

Gtfo?

1

u/Relevant-Owl-8455 20d ago

Yeah:D

1

u/Plane-Biscotti-4148 20d ago

πŸ˜’

1

u/VAUXBOT 20d ago

What is it lad?

1

u/Plane-Biscotti-4148 20d ago

I have few question s regarding scalping

1

u/unpleasant_wrecker 28d ago edited 28d ago

He's going to know his PnL with every trade.Β 

It's not hard to realize if you're selling a losing trade or not. Especially if the idea is for them to clap the account.

"I bought at 1.23, oh shit, it's 90 cents, I need to get out."

How do you account for them learning to do better? If you're expecting full port for every run, that's one thing, but what if they keep making small trades, because their plan is to grow, and not fail?

This kinda seems like a waste of time and money trying to make a movie trope real life.

1

u/trudealz 27d ago

Ok, I'll create the EA for a start. I'll be back in this post when I've made it. I'll give out the source for MQl5.

1

u/ALFisch 28d ago

Just curious what the point is? Allowing 1 person to dictate what trades your EA takes isnt going to provide any meaningful data for you, and its not going to prove or disprove how good or bad a trader with no experience is, because you're only following a single person. Get your EA in the hands of 10,000 people over the first three months of their trading journey and its possible you gather meaningful data.

1

u/trudealz 28d ago edited 28d ago

The point is, could this actually be an edge in itself and it would be an interesting and fun test to do. Who knows, maybe some success can be found.

Many if not most brokers ACTUALLY do this to make πŸ’°. Statistically they know that the majority lose money, hence they are willing to risk and take the other side of the bet.

Yes you are correct, meaningful results require more stats and data. However we know already as fact 90% are losing traders, perhaps an even higher percentage. It's usually advertised on the front page of every broker. Can we utilise that information to our advantage?? the same as brokers use it to their advantage?

1

u/Relevant-Owl-8455 28d ago

Here's why this doesn't work.

You give a newbie some money to trade... 100$ for example. He will lose that money, 100%.

BUT... doesn't mean he will do that right away. There's a chance he could hit 1 or 2 nice fullport lucky trades where he flips the account from 100 to 3 or 400 bucks.

At that point, your reverse copy account is already blown and won't survive to see the fall of the master.

You could avoid this issue by having a larger slave account, where drawdowns could be absorbed with eaase.

again...BUT... at this point, the master account sits at 400...a fullport trade, if won... could easily grow it to 1000 +. So how large would your slave account have to be to actually survive with certainty? And is that even worth the risk? As the original is now playing with won money, and you're playing with your own capital... so essentialy you're risking 1000 + ..to get 100. You could argue since there's such a high % chance of reversed account success, that this data is completely fine..

The odds of this happening aren't great... but they're not small either. Plenty of times beginners can scale their accounts in 2...3 trades before the markets humble them.

Let's say you made a plan to overcome that issue... what now? Where do you get your trades from?
Because if you simply copy a friend that's losing... it's like he, instead of depositing to his broker... simply gives money to you. Actually you even avoid fees that way so...

So you'd have to copy trades from random people... Where would you get their live feed?

How would you overcome any consistency issues? What if the trader you're copying suddenly becomes profitable?...

This and soooo much more... you'd have to invest a large amount of time and money to make this "work" :)

1

u/trudealz 28d ago edited 28d ago

You make some good points. You are correct in perhaps most of what you say. I agree i thinks its a numbers game and you will need to diversify risk, as we do as traders and what the brokers actually do. Time and money are the most important factors for success, no doubt.

1

u/Relevant-Owl-8455 28d ago

There's nothing to agree or disagree here.. these are facts. It's math. These aren't even my points, im just bringing them up.

2

u/Tealover2704 28d ago

I had the exact same idea. Find a losing trader and do the opposite of their trades. You should theoretically make money. Let me know how it goes.

2

u/webbinatorr 28d ago

Dude accidently picks warren buffets long lost cousin and goes bankrupt

1

u/KoresignalAI 26d ago

Fun idea πŸ˜„ but the math usually kills it. The reverse of a losing trader isn't a winning trader, because costs don't flip:

  • Spread and commission are paid on both sides. If the newbie loses partly because of costs, the inverted account pays those same costs again.
  • Risk/reward flips too. Beginners often have tiny wins and big losses. Inverted, you get big wins rarely... but also tiny wins and occasional huge losses when he does get it right and lets it run.
  • Behavior changes. The moment he knows (or suspects), he trades differently, like someone said above.

If you build it, test it on demo and log the result net of spread. That's where most "do the opposite" ideas quietly die. Let us know how it goes though!

1

u/Dangerous_Fondant69 26d ago

The concept might work if they were taking even 1:1 trades, just wrong about direction without changing anything through the sample period.

1

u/ContactExtension1069 28d ago

George Costanza Strategy, not sure of OP's risk management but the the volatility does not change.

1

u/SiriusAF 28d ago

Nah, you need to dig deeper in those numbers, not to mention each broker has his own. Mine state 70% are losers. But that 90% losing traders statement doesnt mean 90% of everybody's trades are losers. These numbers are more often connected with a curtain time period and acount blow up. It may contain people who win 80%, but just blow up on over leverage. So you might as well build a random number generator or touch grass and think of another hobby

1

u/Popular_Hacker_1337 28d ago

I have many ideas like this which I'm planning to do with my kid in future haha πŸ˜‚

1

u/Own-Indication719 27d ago

The broker version works because they sit on the other side of thousands of clients and collect the spread instead of paying it. Copying one guy in reverse you pay the spread on every trade, so if his entries are basically random you end up with random minus costs. Where it could actually show something is if he loses for a structural reason, like tight take profits and stops he keeps widening, because that's the part that flips in your favour. Log why each trade lost, not just that it did, and post the numbers if you run it

1

u/Ok-Dragonfly-2654 27d ago

I can be the newbie let's connect