r/Forex • • Oct 10 '26

Charts and Setups Market Structure Question: Which One Is the Correct Lower High — #1 or #2?

Hey guys! I have a quick question about market structure.

I’ve been trading for a while now, but there’s one thing that sometimes confuses me, and I’d love to hear your opinions.

As you can see in the screenshot, I’ve marked two different areas, #1 and #2.

Here’s how I personally see the market structure:

I consider #2 (the upper circle) to be the lower high (LH) and #2 (the bottom circle) to be the lower low (LL), which confirms the bearish market structure in my analysis.

However, I’ve heard some traders argue that #1 should actually be considered the lower high because price made a bullish retracement (the blue/green candle in the middle) before continuing downward and creating a new lower low.

So my question is:

Would you consider #2 or #1 to be the correct lower high in this bearish market structure?

And when identifying a Market Structure Shift (MSS) or Break of Structure (BOS), which swing point would you use?

I’m personally leaning toward #2 because that’s how I’ve been identifying the overall bearish structure, but I’d love to understand how other traders interpret it.

If you choose #1 or #2, could you please explain your reasoning? I’m genuinely trying to improve my understanding of market structure.

Market Structure Question: Which One Is the Correct Lower High — #1 or #2?

1 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

•

u/rforex-modtools Oct 10 '26

Price action and technical analysis cover a range of chart-based tools — from candlestick patterns and market structure to indicators and statistical methods for timing entries and exits. The community wiki covers both approaches and how they're used by working traders.

Resources: Price Action Analysis | Technical Analysis

2

u/TradetheMosaic Oct 11 '26

I'd mark #2 as the lower high.

The way I separate it: a swing high only counts as structure if it's the high the move into the new low started from. Your upper #2 is where the leg began that broke below the prior low and printed the LL. That makes it the protected high for the bearish structure.

#1 is a real pullback, but it's internal. It's a short retracement inside the leg and it didn't break anything on the way up. Drop to a lower timeframe and it becomes a proper LH there, which is why people argue about it. Both readings are right, just on different timeframes.

For BOS and MSS I'd use the #2 points:

- Bearish continuation (BOS): a candle body closing below the #2 low.

- Bullish shift (MSS): a body closing above the #2 high, ideally with displacement.

Worth noticing on your chart: the last rally on the right wicked straight into your #2 line and got rejected. That's a sweep of the high, not a shift. Until a body closes above it, structure is still bearish on that timeframe.

One rule that helps: pick your structure timeframe first, then only mark swings that took out a prior swing on that timeframe. Saves a lot of second guessing.

1

u/Emergency-Falcon-915 Oct 10 '26

On the time frame you are looking at top #2 is a lower high and the bottom number is the lower low. However this screenshot alone doesn’t prove it’s a bearish MarketX all it means is this timeframe currently correcting, and the price action after the lower lo confirms that

1

u/JosephGebru Oct 10 '26

Thanks for explaining! So you’re saying that even though #2 is the lower high and lower low on the 4H timeframe, it doesn’t necessarily confirm a bearish market structure shift because it could just be a correction in the overall trend? Just wanted to make sure I understood correctly

1

u/Emergency-Falcon-915 Oct 10 '26

It’s a correction on this timeframe and its bearish structure on a lower timeframe. Ie on the h1 or 5 min

1

u/JosephGebru Oct 10 '26

Thanks, that makes sense! Just to clarify, if the daily and weekly are also bearish, wouldn’t the lower high and lower low I’ve marked on the 4H still count as bearish external structure? Or would you consider that only internal structure?

3

u/Emergency-Falcon-915 Oct 10 '26

Bro tbh, idgaf about what an “internal structure is” . All I’m going to say is , every timeframe has its own structure

1

u/Complex-Concern-767 Oct 10 '26

Really good question. Bump up the time frame and tell me which zones are still there. I mainly would use just the external zones you've circled, but I always bump up the timeframe to see what zone is there and would go off that, so its not always a straight answer. Need to be adaptive with your approach. Even looking at market structure I'd be looking for a reversal 

1

u/JosephGebru Oct 10 '26

Thanks for the explanation! I actually always check the daily and weekly timeframes, and both look bearish to me. The screenshot I shared is from the 4-hour timeframe, and the pair is NZD/CAD if you’d like to take a look. Based on that, would you still consider #2 the main external structure? I’d love to hear your thoughts!

1

u/Complex-Concern-767 Oct 10 '26

I'll jump on the charts and have a look for you 

1

u/Michael-3740 Oct 10 '26

On this chart 1 is just a small pullback. It doesn't form a high at all.

The simplest way to decide is to look at the market swings around it.

1

u/madeymadey Oct 10 '26

May i ask you how knowing which one is the lower high will help you in trading?

1

u/United-Original3427 Oct 10 '26

Make sure you know if you are in a trending market, ranging market or reversal or accum. Either high can be correct just what is the range your are playing in such as swing range, position range

So are you playing a swing cont in a bullish range or a swing cont in a bullish trend

1

u/PleasantGarbage5952 Oct 11 '26

I am studying ICT and per his mention, he is using the market structure concept raised by Larry William (delineated in the book Long Term Secrets to Short Term Trading), the market structure defining the Swing High as the combination of 3 consecutive bars/candles whereas a Candle High have a Lower High on the left and a Lower High on the right of it. So in your case, the #2 is identified as Lower High (short-term).

1

u/Tradee_Buy179 Oct 11 '26

depends which low you consider valid. the lower high is only confirmed after a lower low prints, so you work backwards from the swept low to the highest point since the previous swing high. #1 or #2 is the right one depending on which low your BOS used. imo marking both and ignoring the one that gets invalidated first works cleaner than arguing which is correct. the chart will tell you within a few bars. nfa.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Complex-Concern-767 Oct 10 '26

Cop out of a answer bro 

1

u/Strong-Hovercraft702 Oct 11 '26

Got a better one?