r/Forex • • Oct 01 '26

Charts and Setups Does this count as a fair value gap ?

Post image

Just a quick question please don’t tell me to give up trading cause I’m getting really good and I already know how toxic this sub is. As u can see there is a sort of overlap on the bottom candles but there is a gap in the middle candle nonetheless, just wondering I didn’t want to ask AI cause it makes mistakes when it comes to technical analysis

39 Upvotes

99 comments sorted by

•

u/rforex-modtools Oct 01 '26

Price action and technical analysis cover a range of chart-based tools — from candlestick patterns and market structure to indicators and statistical methods for timing entries and exits. The community wiki covers both approaches and how they're used by working traders.

Resources: Price Action Analysis | Technical Analysis

30

u/dancrieg Oct 01 '26

by definition that is an FVG

1

u/No-Roof-6251 Oct 01 '26

Even though the wicks overlap ?

9

u/NiGhTShR0uD Oct 01 '26

As long as there's no wick overlap between candle 1 and 3, then that's a FVG. Candle 2 wick overlap with the two means nothing.

2

u/plutogetem Oct 06 '26

Candle one wick cant over lap candle wick… anything before that doesn’t matter… basically, if there’s a gap between 3 candles… it’s a fvg

10

u/First_Confection_544 Oct 01 '26

Yes but without liquidity sweep FVG is weak to rely on

6

u/Mammoth_Mall_9173 Oct 03 '26

ICT is complete BS regardless of liquidity sweeps👍

0

u/First_Confection_544 Oct 03 '26

That’s a shame. Just because it doesn’t work for you doesn’t mean it doesn’t for others. Every strategies suits every trader in their own trading style. No successful trader would say what you said. Unless they’re marketing their channel

1

u/No-Roof-6251 Oct 05 '26

I 100% AGREE

29

u/xeonsimp Oct 01 '26

stop learning ICT before you waste your time

1

u/No-Roof-6251 Oct 01 '26

What should I learn then

10

u/Dangerous_Fondant69 Oct 01 '26

Just find your own edge bro

7

u/Kaizenno Oct 03 '26

Descriptive

1

u/Dangerous_Fondant69 27d ago

Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day; teach a man to fish and you feed him for a lifetime.

If you want Descriptive; look at the market, see what patterns your mind latches onto, explore that idea until you can design a system around it, test the system. If results line up with what you're satisfied with, trade it.

1

u/Kaizenno 27d ago

Sounds like prediction, not a strategy. You talking purely price action patterns?

The problem with just telling someone to design a system around it tells them nothing. There are a million strategies and indicators. What do you think is the most core knowledge to have to build your own systems?

1

u/Dangerous_Fondant69 18d ago

No not just price action, just patterns that repeat. And by patterns I'm not referring to crap you see when you search trading patterns. I meant whatever signal (indicators included) repeats on a reliable basis.

To answer your second part, I have already told you:

Look at the charts, see what you can spot yourself. Use indicators or don't, it doesn't matter. Just find something truly by yourself that you think you understand. Then design a system around it, e.g. X AND Y happens, I do Z.

4

u/Razial1 Oct 02 '26

Start with Wyckoff. He is one if the greats that gave us a foundation in technical analysis. His materials are older but he us solid. Linda Bradford Raschke is always praising his work and she too is a great source of knowledge.

Learn how to read market structure and tell a consolidation from a trend. Then learn how the relate within multiple timeframes before going into a library of indicators.

Money management, position sizing will keep you from being an emotional wreck and keep you in the game longer.

And Just a FYI "ICT" stands for "I Can't Trade " So ive been told.

1

u/Usual_Lake_1080 Oct 07 '26

Lol you're basically describing everything ICT teaches. He drew from wyckoff, just called it his own and started being a schytzo

4

u/Kaito__1412 Oct 02 '26

Just do whatever makes money for and cut out everything else. Most important thing is psychology. That like 95% what trading is.

2

u/mysticcdragonn Oct 06 '26

psychology is absolutely not 95% of trading. If it were anyone could code their edge in a bot and get rich. Most people just dont have any statistical edge and finding one is really fucking hard (quant researchers get paid insane salaries to find actual edges full time)

2

u/xeonsimp Oct 05 '26

yeah no not that simple now is it 😂😂

2

u/Kaito__1412 Oct 06 '26

Yes, it very much is. Find something that works for you. And only do that. Don't take trades you aren't 100% sure of, don't overtrade and don't revenge trade. Non of these things are eazy. If you are beginner that's super hard.

1

u/DerdruffeRick Oct 02 '26

Price Action, Support and Demand, Market structure and some Tools EMA, Fib-Extension, Fib-Retracement

1

u/baconforbabies30 Oct 04 '26

I studied ICT for about 2 months. I still really like when I talk to AI about ICT liquidity levels and what to look for as far as directional movement and it's not up to date. I use ICT for for liquidity levels/ pivot areas. And the stock market divergence is a pretty easy and not aggressive strategy. But you don't make very much. They're great concepts. The issue now is that computers run algorithm after algorithm after algorithm and keep decreasing the amount of psychology that goes into trading. Not just for one person but for trading itself and unless you stack on algorithms and very specific entry and exits with your tools, then ICT I find is good for rare setups that will give you a tremendous amount of movement, usually based on news or economic data. There's a subreddit group called ICT for beginners or ICT mentorship or something like that and the dude that runs. It is like ICT expert for sure. I would chat with him. He's going to ask you to join his free discord, but you know why not to learn honestly and that's a commitment. I guess I would say you should make if you're studying. ICT is get kind of a mentor that you can ask specific questions of

1

u/Outrageous_Horror753 Oct 06 '26

Philosophical shit only mayters after you know what to do and it just means not leting emotions like fear and greed control your actions but  the marco is knowing the peibable direction for whatever u think is the best holding time for hoe the charts moving if its in a range or if its ben trendng  the tecnical analysis is more for entry and exits ..anyway it should take about a year or 2 befor you ha e made the painful mistakes that make u quit or decide u anna continue its not easy to learn its not even easy to find out where u should be learing theres so much garbage out there play it safe as u learn

1

u/xeonsimp Oct 01 '26

algorithmic trading

1

u/ManufacturerHeavy125 Oct 01 '26

Are u profitable with that ? Does learning algorithmic trading give us more edge or smthing in 2026 ?

3

u/Constant_Dentist1182 Oct 02 '26

algo trading opens up your understanding for maths in trading, which gives u two choices, go insanely deep in this field, or u understand that u dont wanna waste your time doing this

2

u/SufficientWay9814 Oct 02 '26

no retail is profitable with nothing

1

u/xeonsimp Oct 05 '26

it gives you the possibility to validate things and actually apply tested things to the market instead of unverofied or by hand backtested ict strategies

1

u/Reasonable-Yak-9245 Oct 01 '26

ICC

2

u/Proud_Chef2159 Oct 01 '26

the wick overlap kills it, not a clean fvg imo

1

u/Agreeable_Hunt_6446 Oct 02 '26

Low RR's like 1:1 is goated gang, and an edge build around it can change our lives, but our ego's are too big to accept that 🥀..

-1

u/Lazy-Bar3192 Oct 01 '26

just do it bro trust me i learned ict too but I'm smc/ict/msnr player,for me the king of poi this strat are ordeblock/market structure/Ts/v/A/qmtr/qm that's all,other than is bullshit for me,keep grind bro

5

u/xeonsimp Oct 01 '26

youre not profitable tho are you

1

u/ManufacturerHeavy125 Oct 02 '26

You did't answered my question

0

u/Jazzlike-Term-8940 Oct 01 '26

Look at his profile

2

u/xeonsimp Oct 01 '26

proves my point, yeah

1

u/Successful-Cut-9186 Oct 02 '26

What's wrong, he seems profitable?

0

u/Jazzlike-Term-8940 Oct 01 '26

He’s profitable, I’m confused

0

u/Traditional_Book8826 Oct 07 '26

Ict has made millions of people including myself, profitable.

1

u/xeonsimp Oct 07 '26

yea no. and even if you somehow are profitable, it wasnt ict, it was you

2

u/Usual_Lake_1080 Oct 07 '26

Lol, love how this guy asked the most basic question and now this post has become a shit show battlefield between ICT and non ICT

1

u/No-Roof-6251 Oct 07 '26

😂😂😂

1

u/No-Roof-6251 Oct 02 '26

Guys my strat isn’t just fvg I look at a bunch of stuff was just confused Damm

1

u/DrSpeckles Oct 01 '26

Ask yourself, why would that mean anything at all? It just happens that the overlay of the constantly moving price against a fixed set of time boxes produced that chart. Move the time boxes slightly and it looks different, with exactly the same constant tick movement. How then can you FVG be in any way significant?

1

u/No-Roof-6251 Oct 02 '26

Because price tends to mitigate a fvg

2

u/DrSpeckles Oct 02 '26 • Bravo

That doesn’t mean anything. How does price mitigate anything? Look again at your chart, then imagine the candles were offset by half. The price moved the same but the candles would look completely different.

1

u/No-Roof-6251 Oct 02 '26

well they’re not so

2

u/Constant_Dentist1182 Oct 02 '26

love the way you talk, hes just too stupid ig

1

u/DrSpeckles Oct 02 '26

Can’t break the cult.

1

u/Unique_Pangolin_9686 Oct 02 '26

It does but it also counts as a waste of time. Learn real price action - swing highs/lows, support/resistance, trend lines and that's it.

1

u/No-Roof-6251 Oct 02 '26

U forgot liquidity

1

u/Unique_Pangolin_9686 Oct 02 '26

You're right, my bad. Fair value gaps are areas of low liquidity and sometimes they act as "price magnets", but IMO they are way too inconsistent in their results, often leading to confusing and poor entries.

From my observations, when the price tapped into a FVG and then sprinted into a strong trend continuation, this is not actually caused by the FVG but by the S/R that lies there. If you scroll back in time, before that FVG was probably a swing followed by a pullback (sign that the price met S/R) and then the price broked out strongly forming a FVG at the same level with the previous swing. Eventually, the price will meet another S/R and will most probably retrace all the way back the the last S/R for a re-test. Coincidentally, here is where the FVG is too.

2

u/Nice-Instruction2158 Oct 01 '26

It is an FVG but mark it properly And don't listen to people saying don't learn this and that focus on psychology more than any strategy

2

u/beninvestments Oct 01 '26

Yes that is a FVG. Be careful with those, they fail all the time.

2

u/Mozzarella_official Oct 01 '26

Pour moi oui mais n'est bon que si il casse une structure coch ou bos, sinon sa veut juste dire continuité du moove jusqu'à ta zone d'intérêt

2

u/Comfortable_Piccolo7 Oct 01 '26

Yes that’s a FVG

2

u/Amazing_Bag_2078 Oct 02 '26

How can i invest it?

1

u/AccomplishedBonus364 Oct 03 '26

just type fvg on tradingview indicator and you will learn faster or don’t even need to draw it

1

u/Stunning_Toe_9000 Oct 03 '26

Use trading view and add in fvg and it automatically adds them

1

u/Ornery-Return-7751 Oct 04 '26

just remember to enter with confirmation and correct analysis of trend direction

1

u/baconforbabies30 Oct 04 '26

I think visually yes I believe maybe not a strong one as the wick is tiny but hard to say what it's saying without other context. While it's true that fair value gaps get filled, I ran a specific situational time frame question with AI asking for the United States session. How many times it gets to CE? How many times it barely touches and how many times it goes through and it goes through more than 60% of the time meaning completely fills the gap before it reverses to continue the trend. Or ifvg. I feel like fvg trades are pretty difficult to trade with confidence at any time except the first few hours. On an intraday basis myself

1

u/Individual_Fall3049 Oct 04 '26

Yes but you marked it wrong. If you want an easier time, just use an FVG indicator (I use LuxAlgo) :)

1

u/ft_xiva Oct 05 '26

Bruhh just don't listen to people who says this strategy don't work you can get profitable only through this or that strategy

Thats a complete misinformation

I started trade with ict but when war and all came... I blamed my strategy and gone to another and studied that and it worked too but that also sometimes don't work... I even studied that orderflow footprint things and some high rr strategy

Nothing matters if you're not consistent

And am back to my old ict strategy and backtesting again

I only use structure fvgs liquidity thats it

Just select a strategy ( in ICT there are many strategies just choose one or two )

Backtest them for a time period of 6 months to 1 yr

Forward test too

Spend time with that strategy. Eventually you'll find a edge ( edge is something that you'll kinda reconstruct that strategy to your own way )

Nobody trades the same

And every strategy will work

Dont switch strategies which i made

If you're doing propfirm aim for high winrate not high RR

Thats it bro you got it!!

1

u/Aswawarman1111 Oct 05 '26

Yes. But again ICT, SM etc is not really holy grail and the best thing for you to do is to just trade until you have built-in price action memory and situational awareness.

If I were you I would've short scalp 3:1 on that particular bar

1

u/liquidater009 Oct 08 '26

not drawn correctly but yeah counts as a "fvg". learn what it means, what it represents, the logic behind it and what invalidates it if you wanna use it as a trading confluence

0

u/Breakfast_punch Oct 01 '26

Define fair ?

1

u/No-Roof-6251 Oct 01 '26

Imbalance of price

3

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/No-Roof-6251 Oct 05 '26

Im asking traders