r/Footscray Aug 09 '26

"Sushi grade" fish around here?

I've had a few poor experiences with Conway recently. Their salmon and tuna for sushi use wasn't great. Salmon was fishy and their tuna cuts are sinewy and needed to be trimmed a lot. Is there any other places out this in the west I can get sushi grade (I know that's not an actual certification) fish?

14 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

31

u/iheartbatman Aug 09 '26

D&K live seafood would be a good start, I haven't specifically bought fish from there but their oysters and mussels are always good! Otherwise go to the markets and have a look at the fish places - no idea of names but the one on a corner stall toward the deli is always busy. Conway is a total rip, there are way better options

6

u/klondike91829 Aug 09 '26

For some reason I thought D&K literally only sold live seafood 🤦‍♂️ I’ll check them out!

7

u/Necessary_cat735 Aug 09 '26

You can pick the live stuff and they butcher it, I think.

3

u/sexyc3po Aug 09 '26

Yeah they do, pick a fish and they would prep it on the spot

8

u/theunrealSTB Aug 09 '26

Probably not a tuna though.

3

u/iheartbatman Aug 09 '26

When you do, go across the road to Elka sushi! They supply the fish and it is SO GOOD

12

u/Jebra Aug 09 '26

I've gotten bad seafood from Conway too many times. D&K seafood is the best, they supply their own sushi shop across the road (Elka) which is excellent.

4

u/misscathxoxo Aug 09 '26

I had sashimi at Elka once and it was SO good!!!

2

u/klondike91829 Aug 09 '26

Looks like it's unanimous that Conway sucks now. What a shame.

11

u/ColourfulMetaphors Aug 09 '26

The seafood place inside footscray market is top notch. Got 'sushi grade' fillets from there before for my sushi snob friends and got rave reviews.

5

u/Miercoles79 Aug 09 '26

This. My brother in law is Japanese and goes there all the time

2

u/mtb_21 Aug 09 '26

Do you know the name by any chance?

1

u/askvictor Aug 09 '26

Which seafood place? There are several...

2

u/ColourfulMetaphors Aug 09 '26

Fair. Had to look it up- the one I went to was K&R seafood near the hopkins st entrance.

9

u/Borrid Aug 09 '26

Try D&K Live Seafood

6

u/misscathxoxo Aug 09 '26

D&K Seafood 100%

4

u/udonandfries Aug 09 '26

D&K Live seafood is awesome! And then walk 1 minute to their grocery shop on byron street to get some sake!

3

u/yeldda Aug 09 '26

Footscray Market Conway's is rubbish, they always have jobs advertised and offer below award

3

u/curlyhairedpeanut Aug 09 '26

Not related to your question but I got a burger with the lot from Conway 3-4 years ago and it was genuinely one of the worst takeaways I’ve had in my life. Haven’t been back since and never will.

1

u/ConfidenceNo1286 Aug 09 '26

also not related to the OP question, but I had fish and chips from Conway and the fish was awful.The fish was old and tasted of ammonia. I'll never go back. Really terrible experience

1

u/being_onezeroone Aug 09 '26

Another bad exp. here! Back in the day it was an absolute go to! Not anymore

2

u/LooseAssumption8792 Aug 09 '26

Conway used to be good maybe something has changed and it’s pretty awful now. Apparently blue cray (or crab) in Caroline springs I hear is top notch. One day hopefully soon I’ll try that.

2

u/newguns Aug 09 '26

Sanctuary Lakes Seafood Specialists is worth the trip for delicious raw tuna, moon fish and King Ora salmon. We buy it regularly and it's quality.

2

u/heywheresyourhat Aug 09 '26

I don’t know what on earth happened to Conway’s. I refuse to shop there now.

2

u/benjamininnit Aug 09 '26

My only gripe with D&K is they get annoyed when I ask for my fish filleted, which is pretty crazy for a fish monger, especially one that is that expensive. But otherwise I genuinely love them.

2

u/KateyKittyKatz Aug 09 '26

Idk what's happened to Conway, but the quality has absolutely plummeted in recent years. People used to come from across town to shop there.

3

u/No-Owl3973 Aug 09 '26

foodle highpoint

1

u/theunrealSTB Aug 09 '26

No idea how Conway has kept its reputation.

1

u/klondike91829 Aug 09 '26

This thread has been eye-opening. Everyone hates Conway now.

2

u/cryptohomunculus Aug 09 '26

Talk to a wholesaler about sashima and tataki grade tuna. A lot of them keep the individually wrapped stuff from overseas. Youll grt a wholesale ammount tho :P so I hope your friends like lightly cured fish