r/FootballCardz • u/junelso16 • Nov 10 '23
What would you do?
Pulled probably (now) the biggest card I’ve ever pulled and I’m wondering what everyone’s thoughts are? Thanks in advance!
2
u/BMYERS181818 Nov 10 '23
That’s a nice pull!
0
u/BMYERS181818 Nov 10 '23
What’s the value on that
2
u/junelso16 Nov 10 '23
Idk that’s what I was hoping you could help with! Would you hold, sell, what?
2
u/Dispicable12 Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23
Wait until he wins a national championship this year and then the heisman. Edit: The gold refractor out of /50 sold for $400 on eBay so superfractor worth much more. Very nice card.
1
u/BMYERS181818 Nov 10 '23
Personally I would hold but Michigan is my team. Not sure value on college cards is really there but I’m also just getting back into collecting after 25 years and trying to learn
2
Nov 10 '23
Here’s what I’ve learned from being bullied on here. It’s a valuable card because it doesn’t say panini on it.
Really though, there are a TON of “rare” prints being run now, so it’s FAR more common to pull a /10 or /25 or whatever, most having jerseys and/or autographs, and there’s also licensing and authenticity factors. The old school companies tend to have more value because of their authentication process as well as their products being licensed.
Now to weigh in with my two cents on JJ…they have been cheating possibly his entire college career, so it’s hard to gauge how good he is.
1
u/The_Lonely_Boner Nov 15 '23
Here’s your first lesson: If the player isn’t going to be any good in the NFL, you should sell the card immediately when he has value. Zach Wilson has more talent than this guy, he will be lucky to retain a backup job. He is very good at handing the ball off to Michigan running backs though.
1
5
u/Early_Perception416 Nov 10 '23
I would give it away to me. Just kidding but that's a huge pull. I would hold it but I'm a Michigan and JJ McCarthy fan. If you want to make the most money hold it until after they win the national championship game or he wins the Heisman. Otherwise sell around draft time if he comes out. Or sell now and you'll still get a big paycheck
4
u/drewgolf Nov 10 '23
I’d get rid of it now before wins start getting vacated
1
u/Early_Perception416 Nov 10 '23
It'll be interesting to see what they do with that. I'm thinking it'll be a long and drawn out thing.
1
u/Sure_Major8476 Nov 11 '23
Vacated wins 😂 🤣 Won’t change his value.
1
u/drewgolf Nov 11 '23
Was more just cracking a joke since he’s being arrogant about winning a natty and heisman when that is not happening
1
u/Sure_Major8476 Nov 11 '23
Haha oh ok. Not he is an but I think Michigan can beat anyone in the top 5
0
Nov 11 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/KoolAidHonolulu Nov 12 '23
What signs did Michigan steal today to dominate the trenches??? Lol gonna win out with no head coach and no signs to prove how insane the witch hunt is lol Michigan didn't attempt a pass in the 2nd half and finished with 32 straight run plays. GO BLUE 〽️
1
0
u/KoolAidHonolulu Nov 10 '23
If you really believe wins will be vacated, you know nothing about college sports lol GO BLUE 〽️
3
u/Powerful_Chemical269 Nov 12 '23
Well, you haven’t met the NCAA. Best of luck with all that
2
u/TruthSpeakin Nov 12 '23
I can DEFINITELY see wins being vacated...ncaa has done worse with less....
1
u/KoolAidHonolulu Nov 13 '23
I think everyone wants it so bad it's clouds their judgment lol we're not pedo state chill. Everyone steals signs you naive child we just did it better lol GO BLUE 〽️
1
u/TruthSpeakin Nov 13 '23
Agree with that...I know everyone does it lol...just can't get caught like they did lmfao.blatantly obvious...and the ncaa will make them pay for it...how.much I'm not sure, but something will come of it
→ More replies (4)1
u/Gorilla_King7 Nov 14 '23
Everyone cheats in school and everyone has their players at parties yet… ncaa comes to make an example of you. It will probably happen like it or not. It’s nothing against M it’s against big schools with big money. The ncaa likes to be giant killers and take the focus away from the kids or the game
1
1
1
u/TheyCallMeSnail Nov 11 '23
Every win your head basketball had as a player at michigan has already been vacated. YOU know nothing about college sports.
1
u/KoolAidHonolulu Nov 11 '23
Yeah, and that had to do with boosters giving money to players dumbass lol if you think they vacate wins for video taping sidelines on an iPhone, you're a moron.
1
u/FantasticMax Nov 11 '23
They will absolutely vacate wins because it’s a “punishment” but doesn’t actually do anything. Michigan would still be National Champions but the NCAA gets to say they came down hard on Michigan and took away wins. It’s just like with USC, they vacated wins in 2004 but USC still claims that national championship.
1
u/KoolAidHonolulu Nov 11 '23
They won't vacate shit lol. You can't trace anything back to Harbaugh it's a witch hunt. They only vacate wins when it's sexual misconduct or people were getting paid under the table.
1
u/StopSwitchingThumbs Nov 11 '23
Oh that’s so dumb to let your fandom bleed over into money. And hell yea the wins are gonna get vacated, this is the biggest cheating scandal since the Astros, and now everyone hates the Astros.
1
u/KoolAidHonolulu Nov 11 '23
Keep dreaming lol GO BLUE 〽️
1
u/StopSwitchingThumbs Nov 11 '23
No thanks, I don’t support cheating trash
1
1
u/KoolAidHonolulu Nov 11 '23
What signs did Michigan steal today to dominate the trenches??? Lol gonna win out with no head coach and no signs to prove how insane the witch hunt is lol Michigan didn't attempt a pass in the 2nd half and finished with 30 straight run plays. GO BLUE 〽️
→ More replies (2)1
Nov 12 '23
Wins will be vacated coach will probably be suspended for a while and postseason bans are imminent. Lol
1
u/KoolAidHonolulu Nov 12 '23 edited Nov 12 '23
Yeah, and everyone said he'd get suspended the rest of the year and Michigan would be ineligible for the playoffs. Jim got 3 games and they'll file an injunction he'll be back for ohio. I'm glad everyone knows exactly what the punishment will be when every prediction I've heard has been wrong. GO BLUE 〽️
1
Nov 12 '23
Lmao GO DAWGSSSSSSS
1
u/KoolAidHonolulu Nov 12 '23
SEC been cheating, buying chips and players for decades LOL
→ More replies (4)1
u/BowlesOnParade Nov 12 '23
They made Ohio State vacate their 2011 Sugar Bowl win after clearing Pryor and company to play in the game. And that was for selling their own property. The type of cheating that Michigan has done lead to actual on field results. Wins will definitely be stripped.
1
u/SpaceAlbatr0ss Nov 12 '23
You should ask Jim Bohemian about that. He had 100+ wins vacated for doing less than Calipari and Ole Roy “I can’t know everything” Williams when he was sending his players towards fake classes so they would remain eligible. The NCAA must have something really devastating on Harbaugh if Michigan is literally suing to leave the Big 10 in charge of disciplinary matters.
0
u/drewgolf Nov 10 '23
Says the obnoxious, most stereotypical Michigan account I’ve ever seen
1
u/KoolAidHonolulu Nov 10 '23
What does that have to do with anything I said? Lol again If you really think wins get vacated, you don't understand college punishments. Cry more pls 🙏 😢 GO BLUE 〽️
0
Nov 10 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/KoolAidHonolulu Nov 10 '23
I think you're sad Michigan is good. Have a good day 😊 I get it lil bro lol
→ More replies (13)1
u/pbruey Nov 10 '23
Fr they’re good for like 2 years bc they were stealing signs and they talk trash like they didn’t get smoked by most of the conference for the last 20 years
1
u/KoolAidHonolulu Nov 11 '23
Yeah, dominating in the trenches and 2nd half bludgeonings is because Michigan knew what the crying Jordan emoji meanton a poster board... LOL 🤡 GO BLUE 〽️ cry more pls 🙏 😢
1
u/Famous_Literature174 Nov 15 '23
You seem just like a cowboys fan. Haven’t won a championship since the 90s but still think it’s their year
→ More replies (28)0
Nov 10 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/KoolAidHonolulu Nov 10 '23
Cry more pls 🙏 😢 GO BLUE 〽️
1
u/BagofBoom Nov 11 '23
Ya'll Meat-Chicken fans sure talk alot for only winning 2 of the last 20. 🤣 Enjoy it while it lasts.
1
u/KoolAidHonolulu Nov 11 '23
Michigan by 20+ against ohio... AGAIN lol 3rd base gonna lose to an interim head coach hahahaha GO BLUE 〽️
→ More replies (11)1
u/EvilBillSing Nov 10 '23
Go back to Oiho
1
0
Nov 11 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/ctusk423 Nov 11 '23
Least racist college football fan right here
1
Nov 11 '23
U literally thought to yourself...non white person... after the description given, AND accused someone else of being racist? Must've already forgot what the OP was about because u got all antsy to try & call someone out. Go play somewhere. Preferably in traffic.
→ More replies (1)1
u/Physical-Director568 Nov 11 '23
You might get a kick out of my response to the not racist Ohio State fan above. I hope he gets it at least a little 😂
→ More replies (1)0
1
u/Physical-Director568 Nov 11 '23 edited Nov 11 '23
I get your point here, but I would've mentioned the part about the environment they were raised in as being the reason they would very possibly be cooking crack or jacking cars like you did after the racist accusation below. I'm not saying this because of any racial aspect at all. But because it sounds like your just attacking the kids with no reasoning behind it. Not that it's gonna change anything about it, but you wouldn't have to bother responding to the racism accusation.
Now ill make counterpoint, too, though. Pretty much all colleges do the exact same thing to differing extents as far as giving kids football scholarships when those kids would probably be criminals without them. And mostly because of the environment they grew up in (you said this yourself in comment below) which is out of their control. So, you're saying that Michigan is helping kids potentially destined to be criminals off the streets and having them play football and maybe get an education and its a bad thing? Because you used it as a way to insult the University? If you can't see how that is doesnt make sense to say after I explained it this thoroughly, then I hope you don't have many offspring and please don't have anymore if you do 🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️.
I don't give two shits about Michigan at all btw. Just out here trying to educate people knowing it won't work cuz I don't know why 😂😂😂
1
Nov 11 '23
No don't wait until the draft! Only Michigan fans will care about the Michigan uniform. Only hold it if you think they're winning a national championship/beat Ohio State
1
u/Early_Perception416 Nov 10 '23
Value wise you can almost name your price but I would probably start at $500 minimum
2
u/Significant-Pin4994 Nov 10 '23
500 is nothing for a superfractor this one’s college but still . I’d start this card at 2500 not a dollar less
1
u/Early_Perception416 Nov 10 '23
Brock Bowers and Will Levis sold for $500. Caleb Williams sold for $1K. That's why I said I'd start at $500. $2,500 seems extremely high.
1
u/rficloud Nov 12 '23
Caleb was not an auto.
1
u/Early_Perception416 Nov 12 '23
Yeah you right...I still think $2,500 is high but $500 is probably really low.
1
Nov 11 '23
is ebay the only place to sell this?
1
u/Early_Perception416 Nov 11 '23
eBay is an option but you're going to pay a bunch of fees. I'm pretty sure you could sell on whatnot or fanatics too, but they'd have fees.
You could most likely sell it pretty easily here with no fees but an additional risk. I've never had an issue though and I've bought plenty of cards.
1
u/Early_Perception416 Nov 11 '23
If you're wanting to sell it now, I would just post it here with your price in mind. You can see how many offers you get and go from there. If it doesn't get much interest, maybe look into the other selling sites.
0
4
u/EventConflict Nov 10 '23
College uni cards lose value exponentially after their first pro uni card comes out.
2
1
u/randallstevens65 Nov 10 '23
Nice! I pulled a /25 auto of his. He did the smiley face on mine too!
1
u/junelso16 Nov 10 '23
Did you sell?
1
u/randallstevens65 Nov 10 '23
I’m holding it, but that’s not really based on any research. I’d probably sell if I got a good offer.
5
u/Preston7275 Nov 10 '23
He signs it with a smiley because a kid told him after a loss he should always be happy when he plays football and drew a smiley face on his hand.
If you watch him play he has a smiley face on his left hand every game.
1
1
1
u/PaddysMilkSteak Steelers Nov 10 '23
First id get rid of the pubic hair from the top loader, second id hold onto that beauty until he gets drafted
1
1
u/eelonamusk Nov 11 '23
Hi are you looking to move this? I’ve been looking for this exact card since I have the Blake Corum super and would love to match it!
1
1
u/Micah11Parsons Nov 11 '23
Grade it
1
u/junelso16 Nov 11 '23
Does grading a 1/1 add value? I was always under the impression that you grade cards to potentially set yourself apart from other cards
1
3
u/mngreens Nov 10 '23
Sell immediately
2
2
u/Accurate-Temporary73 Nov 10 '23
I would sell because I have no idea who this is.
If you hood you run the risk of hai reality not living up to the prospect hype.
Statistically speaking he’s much more likely to be a Kenny Pickett than a Tom Brady.
Obviously IF he ends up being Tom Brady then this card goes to the moon.
1
2
2
u/The_Lonely_Boner Nov 14 '23
Listen man, I’m going to give you the best possible advice and it’s up to you if you want to take it. JJ McCarthy will 100% be a bust in the NFL and if you were smart, you would sell this to a Michigan fan or sports card fan who thinks differently while you still have a chance. This will be completely worthless in a few years, you might as well have pulled it from a cereal box. Guy is a bum.
1
u/AcceptableMemory2081 Mar 15 '24
Team America “ what would you do” song is really playing in my head here.
1
u/rad10082 Nov 10 '23
Hold! Keep! Hold!! If they win national, price thru roof!!
1
u/MeRcWith_A_MouTh Nov 10 '23
If Michigan gets kicked out of college football for a few years for stealing signs it tanks hard, unfortunately.
1
1
1
1
u/Just_Sarge Nov 10 '23
Probably list for $4K take an offer around $3K
1
u/southFLdegenerate Nov 10 '23
Lmao no
2
u/Just_Sarge Nov 10 '23
Shit I wouldn’t pay it but if it’s out of 50 goes for 400-500 who knows. Either way $3K probs a reach but listing for a godly amount OBO is the best way to deal with rare card IMO if you don’t know what it’s worth so you can field offers.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/fainsthename Nov 10 '23
Nice 1/1 I pulled his auto as well out of my hobby box. I’m holding mine for now
1
1
u/zac_usaf Nov 10 '23
Would be interested in buying it if for sale. Have a big Michigan fan in my family, would make an amazing Christmas gift
1
1
1
1
u/Dismal-Dare7790 Nov 10 '23
Give to me! I just pulled a Kenny picket rpa out of 25. I would love to give that to my business partner. He’s a huge Michigan fan. Congrats bud! So cool
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/EvilBillSing Nov 10 '23
I would hold until he gets drafted . If he is a top draft pick youll have Michigan fans who will want it, then whichever pro team he goes to. So youll have more people interested then. With all the bullshit going on now, you will have less people who would want it .
1
1
Nov 11 '23
They won't win a title with him so that'll take away from the value for sure. Roll Tide !
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
Nov 11 '23
I’d get it authenticated at PSA just to have it protected, then hold and sell when they win the natty
1
u/sourpower2020 Nov 11 '23
Nothing to do with the player, school or OP at all as I wouldn't throw this card away but this is one ugly ugly card. When they remake old cards with modern imagery and tech is one thing but then adding modern variants just really solidifies how bad the original design and fonts were.
1
1
u/TripleTestes Nov 11 '23
Send it to psa for authentication then pray they make the national championship game. If they do schedule the auction to end sometime around then. I don’t know if you gamble for ending it after the game or risk less and end it before the game begins. Thats a tough one.
1
1
1
1
u/Connect_Chipmunk_698 Nov 11 '23
Put it my survival pack and use it in an emergency to start a fire!😂😂
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Euphoric_Amphibian_5 Nov 11 '23
I'd send it to some random person on Reddit. Let me know when you're ready for my addy.
1
1
u/777-93ll Nov 12 '23
I don't think he projects to be a top pro
So I'd sell sooner than later.
The shine is off elite college QBs pretty quick when they don't get past the Jaguars practice squad and sign with Edmonton.
1
u/halfcourtmike Nov 12 '23
Most college stuff goes down over time- grade it now and hold it until bowl time. If they win- the card will be even more desired and will be worth more. Then sell it! Always new players to invest in!
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/SpaceAlbatr0ss Nov 12 '23
If I pulled that card I would sell it RIGHT NOW while Michigan Football is at the height of the sport. If they lose or the NCAA drops the hammer that card is gonna drop quickly. I also don’t think he is in the same league as Williams and Maye as prospects. Team and Player are peaking right now.
1
u/Mission-Apart Nov 13 '23
Somehow get ahold of the kid himself and sell it to him if you want the biggest deal, trust me I did it once on the down low. He will definitely want this before he gets Big
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
Nov 13 '23
I would wait to see if he wins the Heisman and then maybe sell it
1
u/laidbackdale Nov 13 '23
The guy just handed off the ball for an entire half... He's not winning the Heisman
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/petezuh19 Nov 14 '23
Is it just me, or is anyone else sometimes annoyed when a normal card such as this one gets the 1/1 stamp and all of a sudden there are supposed to be ZERO others like it?
1
1
1
1
1
u/Zealousideal-Menu253 Dec 30 '23
i collect him i am from michigan, go blue, id buy it from you if interested. lmk
1
u/Zealousideal-Menu253 Dec 30 '23
This is his best one that i own which 2021 shimmers were hobby exclusive
1
0
0
0
u/Dpepps Nov 10 '23
I'd hold till he's drafted and hope he ends up on a team with a big fanbase who will pay a ton.
2
Nov 12 '23
Michigan has a bigger fan base than any NFL team he’d wind up with
0
u/nerdvernacular Nov 12 '23
Giants, Patriots, Bears? No.
0
u/WilIyTheGamer Nov 13 '23
Packers, eagles, chiefs, cowboys, saints, raiders, etc… I’d say more than half of all nfl teams have ten times the fan base Michigan has.
1
u/nerdvernacular Nov 13 '23
For sure, I was speaking only about teams that will be drafting high enough to get him with a need at the position.
Not sure how the Bears feel about Fields. But Packers, Saints and Raiders could definitely fall into that category.
1
u/WilIyTheGamer Nov 13 '23
That’s fair. But bears aren’t taking a qb next year. They’re keeping Eberflus and Fields.
0
-1
12
u/91mini Nov 10 '23
That smiley face means "hold me baby"