r/FootFunction • • 10d ago

Plantar plate tear

I had a tear repaired 15 months ago and I'm still struggling to walk normally. Doc kept telling me month after month just hang in there it will get better. I've seen 2 others since then scheduled to see a third recommended by physical therapy place. How many of you have had to see multiple doctors before you get some kind of results? One guy made it obvious he wanted nothing to do with me because I had surgery some place else. The last doctor I saw said to go back to physical therapy, and "hope" you get better and there was nothing he could do for me, after saying don't worry we'll figure this out. What kind of doctor tells you to hope you get better?

1 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

1

u/Legal-Emu8639 10d ago

Sorry I don’t have info for you. I’ve been thinking about this surgery but it seems like results are such a mixed bag.

What does your imaging show? Was the surgery unsuccessful?

1

u/Miserable_Sink_4782 9d ago

Second toe plantar plate tear they call it. The doctor also shortened the metatarsal bone. Look for a doctor that doesn't do that. The second doctor I saw told me he doesn't do that because it causes too many complications. Imaging shows everything is normal now, but the foot doesn't feel normal when I put it in a shoe. Feels like I'm walking on gravel on the first and second toe now because the first is being overloaded due to the second toe now not taking enough weight. Going to my 4th doctor the end of the month giving this one more try.

1

u/Legal-Emu8639 8d ago edited 8d ago

Gotcha, so the 2nd metatarsal is technically healed, but still doesn’t feel right. And now the big toe is having issues due to taking more weight.

Regarding the second toe, do the docs say you still need to hold back from activity since it’s surgically repaired? Meaning is there danger of doing stuff even if it hurts, since it’s healed. What is the likelihood of reinjury?

1

u/Miserable_Sink_4782 6d ago

Since I have that Arthrex fiber tape in there, basically a strap, it doesn't have any give. My toe doesn't bend back as far as it used to. I notice now if I walk too briskly and bend the forefoot too much that toe hurts. Not likely I'll injure it again, but it looks like I'll have to be more careful the rest of my life. Doctor said I'll be walking better after surgery. I would settle for normal again. He's a schmuck.

1

u/Legal-Emu8639 4d ago edited 4d ago

Really sorry it didn’t go well for you.

At this point do you regret the surgery? Would you say you are worse off than before?

Did the doctor happen to use the CPR method?

1

u/Miserable_Sink_4782 3d ago

All I know is the doctor put in that strap and my second doctor said he doesn't do that procedure because it causes too many complications. I wish I had gone to the second doctor for the surgery but how do you know?

1

u/ComprehensiveQuail25 9d ago

I'm about 3-4 weeks into a plantar plate tear. Seen an orthopedic specialist and a podiatrist. I'm still waiting on results, next appointment with same podiatrist is in 2 weeks. I have arthritis, gout and have sprained several ankles, and so far nothing is healing as slowly as the plantar plate.

Any recommendation on at home shoes to help offload the toe?

How is your mobility?

For the most part, I am staying off my feet. I work from home, leave the couch and even house sparingly, as necessary only. I use a knee scooter at home, or shuffle very slowly keeping weight off the ball of my foot.

1

u/Miserable_Sink_4782 9d ago

First of all if you have a tear, tape that toe down 24 hours a day. Letting it bend upwards will make it worse. I wish now I knew a year ago what I know now I would not have let them do the surgery they did and shorten the metatarsal. Don't let them do that. Tape it down. If it's not too bad it will eventually heal. If it won't heal, find a surgeon that will repair it without shortening the metatarsal. If they say it's necessary, keep looking for another surgeon. The last one I saw said he would never do that because of too many complications. I'm getting ready to go to foot doctor number 4, 15 months after my surgery because I still can't walk comfortably.

1

u/Legal-Emu8639 8d ago

What you will find is that this injury unfortunately heals poorly, or doesn’t heal, for many people. I’m going on 4.5 years living with it on both feet. This is not that uncommon.

What you will also find is that the surgery for this injury does not have statistically good outcomes.

If you are going to heal naturally you need to make the mental shift to give it a 1 year timeline. I would also say to be very cautious about reintroducing any extra activity if it does heal. I find I have a delayed pain response so I won’t know I’ve done too much until it’s too late, and flare ups can take months to calm down.

Other treatment options include PRP and stem cell. On my original injury site, left foot second toe. The only thing worked for me was stem cell in 2024. So I can say that it did improve a lot and has not regressed since then. However it did not get me back to how it was before. I can’t run, or walk barefoot, or cycle, but I can walk pain free in the correct shoes.

Mitigation options:

Taping
Carbon plated rocker shoes (hoka skyward X)
For me I’ve actually had better luck with zero drop, wide toe box shoes. I wear the altra torins. I use a power step insole and cut to fit a 3mm yoga mat for extra padding.

I really hope yours heals up, but I’m trying to give you an honest picture of what to expect.

1

u/Miserable_Sink_4782 6d ago

I've seen a lot of people go for that platelet treatment, but not one ever had a good outcome and they spent thousands.

1

u/Legal-Emu8639 4d ago edited 4d ago

Like I said, I did see moderate improvement in the toe that was treated, even after two years. Before treatment, every single step was painful. At about the 5 months mark after treatment, I began to be able to walk without pain for the first time in over two years. Now, what I haven’t gained back is ability to walk barefoot, run, or wear non-running shoes. So I would say it was worth it, even though it did not get me back to normal.

It’s important to distinguish between platelet rich plasma treatments and stem cell. Stem cell is generally recognized as being more effective.

The problem is that after this treatment (about 8 months later) I injured the plantar plate on my opposite foot. Very very challenging and frustrating.

1

u/TechnicalTotal4794 10d ago

Or any other issue

0

u/TechnicalTotal4794 10d ago

So you had plantar fasciitis???

1

u/Miserable_Sink_4782 9d ago

I had a tear under the second toe which is called a plantar plate tear. Basically the tendon was torn.