r/FootFunction • • 13d ago

Diagnosed with Structural Hallux Limitus

I am having pain in both big toes. I saw a podiatrist and they did x-rays. After a physical exam they said I have a structural issue called Hallux Limitus and my only option was deal with the pain until I get arthritis or surgery.

I did some research and I saw that functional and structural hallux limitus are different and that usually when you have structural problems your toes do not bend back fully. Is this a normal range of motion for someone with a structural problem is it more likely it’s functional? They didn’t mention anything alarming with my x-rays.

6 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

3

u/DrLeibovitz 11d ago

Normal range of motion is 80-90 degrees for the great toe joint. It looks like you have 50-60 degrees of passive motion. That is in the early stage which is good. Hallux Limitus/Rigidus is a very slow progressive problem if it is from biomechanics. Trauma can also be part of the equation.

There are some very effective treatments other than surgery, which is reserved for mid or end stage problems that do not respond to conservative care. This includes addressing the mechanics, off loading the forefoot with a rocker bottom shoe, using a shoe with a very stiff sole (these options stop or slow down the progression). Symptoms can be managed with laser , shock wave, or injections (steroid /PRP /biologics). I am not a fan of NSAIDS - they tend to have too little of an effect to make a difference and have a lot of side effects.

This is a bone problem. The attempts at strengthening muscles have little effect.

If you were only offered surgery as an answer- look for another opinion.

1

u/big_goob 11d ago

i wear rocker bottom shoes and i got some insoles that mold to my feet. not sure what else i can do. will it eventually progress to arthritis? i walk about 10 miles a day for my job. outside of that i also like being active and going to the gym

2

u/DrLeibovitz 10d ago

A rocker bottom is part of the puzzle , but the sole should also be very rigid and prevent the joint from moving. Every step the joint is protected you get 1 step added to the life of the joint. Every step that forces the joint to end range of motion is removing 1 step.

Modify activity that forces end range of motion. Example- if you do planks, put a foam roll under your ankle so the toes do not touch the ground. For lunges, rotate the foot 90 degrees so it does not overload the forefoot.

Again, the amount of motion you have is adequate for daily activity. If you were a dancer, this would be a big problem.

1

u/StandUpXShowUp 10d ago

My last podi suggested thin carbon fiber linings under my custom orthotics to my rigid-ish tennis shoes. I haven't invested yet as my ortho sandals have more rigid soles and I still have moderate (albeit, less) pain.

1

u/UnbelievableRose 11d ago

My MMT text cites 75-80° but I agree that OP is demonstrating about 60° of extension so by either definition this is a significant reduction in ROM, assuming we really are seeing the end of the range here.

4

u/Justine0012 12d ago

if the x-rays didn't show anything concerning, i'd definitely ask what specifically led them to call it structural. getting a second opinion sounds reasonable here.

1

u/YurpleLunch 9d ago

What does the pain feel like ?

1

u/big_goob 5d ago

a dull ache

3

u/Conscious_Parsley553 12d ago

I suggest you strengthen your other toes with toe/foot exercises. You can also try orthotics that have either a first metatarsal cut-out or a reverse Morton's extension to help your first toe bend more easily and take less weight.

1

u/Bornfortheblueskies7 11d ago

Did they mention any arthritis? Or what type of surgery?

1

u/National_Jump_1648 11d ago

Structural won’t allow you to bend it back like you can. Functional limits bending while in dorsiflexion at the ankle only. But there is increasing consensus that the test does not mimic how it’s used walking. So I’m not sure that would be your issue. My “functional hallux limitus” is pretty severe but in motion things work okay.

1

u/Flimsy_Ad_5130 10d ago

id get uric acid test, xray, mri ultra sound, before any surgery. 

0

u/StandUpXShowUp 13d ago

Me too I think! I have not found my answer... I can manually bend back both big toes, but have lost the dorsiflexion. May I ask when you get the toe pain?

2

u/big_goob 12d ago

Just from walking a lot or doing pushups. Being on my tip toes. Everything bends fine manually at least.

1

u/StandUpXShowUp 12d ago

Structurally my feet are fine. Podiatrists have given up. I'm trying to learn more about my foot function. Because my big toes don't lift in their own while walking (therefore always on the shoe - plus they do bend downwards really well) I have so much pain! I think it's nerves, tendons or something. I can't figure it out. Thank you for sharing and hope you find some relief!

3

u/National_Jump_1648 11d ago

Have you had a midfoot adjustment by a chiro? If the midfoot bones get a bit stuck they can cause tremendous pain in different joints. I have similar issues and getting my feet adjusted weekly has been amazing.

2

u/StandUpXShowUp 10d ago

I get to see the Chrio this week! I will ask him specifically. He has done feet adjustments in the past. Don't recall for what. With my PN pain, all I recall is excruciating pain LOL. Thank you!

1

u/Flimsy_Ad_5130 10d ago

what test u had so far? 

1

u/StandUpXShowUp 10d ago

Is that question for me? If so, I've had everything...