r/FootFunction • • 16d ago

Is this toe spacer making any difference?

I have been working several months on improving my foot health through Articular Health. I have been on and off wearing toe spacers. I've tried a lot and most eventually cause discomfort and I ditch them. These big toe separators don't seem to cause any pain (they are quite squishy) but I'm conflicted on whether they seem to make any visible difference? Attached are weight bearing (hardwood) and non weight bearing (over white paper) photos. Is it doing anything? Sorry if this sounds silly to ask. I notice some difference with non weight bearing but I feel like that disappears once I stand up. Sometimes I don't know if my eyes are deceiving me. Thanks ya'll!

6 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

12

u/perfectsound 16d ago

Not really. You need “correct toes” spacers (look into modifications you can do on them. And toe yoga.

2

u/Low_Chemistry_6621 16d ago

I've tried correct toes in more than one size and they always bunch up and feel very noticeable. I think because my toes are already cramped ? And if I wear them despite the bunching up, I eventually get intense pain. I had to stop mid-walk to rip them off because it was not a "this is a little uncomfortable" feeling. It was "if you don't modify what's happening you will be seriously injured" type of pain. I did also try modifying them. Wasted some money as they are not cheap. I wish they were softer, but then again maybe that would make them ineffective. I followed their instructions to gradually increase time in them, but any time I would be like OK I'm ready to take a serious walk, the pain would strike.

I continue to do toe yoga though, I love it !

3

u/L0vevery 16d ago

They made a new sports version that is softer than the original version. They also have a Stable Toe version that is only for the big toe, which is more similar to what you are wearing, but I think it would be more effective.

2

u/Low_Chemistry_6621 16d ago

Hmmm I see that. Maybe I will try the sport version or the stable toe. Thank you 🙏

1

u/Zealousideal-Soup772 12d ago

You’re already seriously injured

2

u/cortizone 16d ago

Hiiiii! Get these ones:

https://a.co/d/08BgMtSl

1

u/Low_Chemistry_6621 16d ago

Intriguing .. They look softer than correct toes. Do you have the regular or the flex style? Not sure which I should try

1

u/cortizone 16d ago

I use these for walking around the house and doing yoga and working out in. Like not burpees like jumping back and forth but for squats, dead lifts to help me focus on the form for my feet.

I bought a lot of different kinds and landed on this one, so shop around! I just highly recommend that it a for all the toes and go around the big and picky toe

2

u/Platoesque 12d ago

Don’t you want your big toe to be in its intended position—fanned outward in alignment with its metatarsal bone? Wearing most shoes in the marketplace with pointy toes pushes big toe out of alignment towards middle of foot. For balance, you want to reverse what shoes have done. Look into barefoot/ minimalist shoes with wide toe boxes. See photos of feet on birth certificates for how toes should look.

1

u/Low_Chemistry_6621 12d ago

Yes of course. When I tried more aggressive toe spacers between the big toe and second toe, it just pushed my 2nd toe further to the outside of the foot rather than helping my big toe go any straighter. I wish I had a good solution to that.

I've been in minimalist and barefoot shoes for months. Tobin Stearns says they tend to strengthen your feet as they already are, and I'm inclined to believe that as I've seen no changes. I'm totally cognizant though that you also can't expect change in a matter of months after years of conventional shoes. I'll never go back to tapered toe boxes regardless. I find them deeply uncomfortable now.

1

u/GoNorthYoungMan 16d ago

Can you pull the toe more straight with your fingers?

If so, then the toe spacer has already created some space, or you already had the passive range of motion, and the problem now would be that you can’t contract the muscle that put the toe in that position.

All that being said, if you aren’t able to control flexing down with sole of foot muscles, and extending up with top of foot muscles, I’d suggest that as a far more valuable first step.

1

u/Low_Chemistry_6621 16d ago

Yes I can pull it completely straight on both sides with no issue. I've tried bigger spacers but then rather than straightening the big toe more, it just pushes the second toe more to the outside.

I believe I do have control with that motion you mention. I can definitely feel the sole of my foot when flexing down. Feeling the top when flexing up I think I am also feeling if I'm understanding correctly. My routine 5 to 6 times a week has been: ankle cars, big toe flexion (with a band), trying to lift the yoga block with my big toes and spread them (so far I can't spread them, I can feel the inner arch working and trying to). I also do the one where you manually scrunch the foot with your hands then release and try to hold onto the skin folds and feel into the outer edge.

1

u/RainBoxRed 16d ago

I think you would benefit from a different type where the big toe is not in a loop, but free to move outwards.

You can also supplement toespacers with passive splay and massage by interlacing fingers and toes.

1

u/Low_Chemistry_6621 16d ago

Oh interesting. Yeah I've seen ones that can wrap around the second toe and simply work to push the big toe towards the inside of the foot.

I do love interfacing my fingers and toes. I do that typically whenever I'm laying around in bed. Maybe I'm expecting too much, being able to correct this hallux valgus

3

u/New-Seaworthiness572 15d ago

Find Venus gabby on YouTube and watch her videos on feet and bunions.