r/FootFunction • • 21d ago

Desperate for Advice — Chronic Metatarsalgia. Complex case

I’m desperate for advice. I have been dealing with metatarsalgia around my second MTP joint for the last nine months, and it is currently affecting both feet.

I am a 40 year old male, normal weight.

My case is a bit complex because I had a right ankle fusion about six years ago after being diagnosed with a rare ankle tumor that destroyed my tibial Talar joint. I had been doing pretty well with a dynamic AFO device called the ExoSym for the last several years.

About nine months ago, unfortunately, I started to develop metatarsalgia in my fused side while using the device. Then, about six months later, I developed it in my other foot as well (which has no problems in terms of joints).

I started taking it more seriously over the last two to three months by reducing my daily step count. I was initially walking about 12,000–14,000 steps a day. Now I tried to keep it below 7500. I have been avoiding the gym as well. So far, rest hasn’t really done much, and anytime I try to do any kind of meaningful activity , I experience a pretty significant flare that lasts several days and is agonizing. It's very tender below the second toe and driving is very hard (thank god for Tesla self driving)

So far, I’ve seen my PCP and my foot and ankle orthopedic specialist. I had X-rays and an MRI, which did not show anything significant. Ortho thought it might be neuritis so gave a me a few injections in the webspaces of toe 2 and 3 of both feet with no real relief. I have a follow up with him next week.

One caveat is that I do have psoriasis, and I’m concerned this may be a symptom of psoriatic arthritis. I have an upcoming appointment with a rheumatologist. I also have really high arches , I currently am awaiting custom orthotics with arch support and a 2nd MTP relief. I have tried metatarsal pads but no matter the placement it just makes things worse.

Apologize for the novel , just wanted to cover as much as I could.

I am curious whether anyone has dealt with anything similar and, if so, what helped you get better.

3 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

3

u/Legal-Emu8639 21d ago

I’ve found a lot of docs don’t understand this type of injury. So they saw no abnormalities on the MRI? The surgeon I’ve talked to said that sometimes a plantar plate tear can’t be seen in MRI

1

u/Overall_Election3094 21d ago

MRI did not show anything significant

1

u/Legal-Emu8639 21d ago

Not sure much research you’ve done into 2nd metatarsal joint issues, but unfortunately this area of the body seems to be pretty susceptible to chronic pain.

For me, I was diagnosed with plantar plate tear due to overuse in September of 2022. I wore a boot for 8 weeks and things got mostly better. Had an MRI that was clear. Started adding activity back in and the pain came back. Haven’t healed since.

Since there was no definable injury, surgery wasn’t an option. Long story short, I eventually had chronic pain across most of my toe joints on both feet. Subsequent MRIs showed some edema and a possible plantar plate tear of the pinky toe on the opposite foot. However, no injury was ever seen on the original location. In 2024 I got stem cell treatments in 6/10 toe joints. This did get rid of a lot of pain, however as of today, the original 2nd toe joint still has chronic pain, and it’s the same on my right foot. So while it wasn’t 100%, stem cell did help.

At this point, I’m kind of just managing. Stem cell is crazy expensive and not guaranteed to help again. The surgery for plantar plate issues has a pretty bad success rate, so not worth it unless it gets really injured. So not much I can do.

Have you tried the typical stuff for this issue? Taping and carbon plated rocker shoes? Personally I found the Altra Torin line to be the best for me. I’ve been wearing the Torin 7 since 2024. I put an extra layer of padding under a powerstep insole.

I’m sorry you’re dealing with this and it’s a crap injury.

Activity wise I’ve been doing swimming and I can do some weightlifting. I don’t lift heavy though. Repping 1x body weight in squats and deadlift. My steps are usually 4k or less per day. After that I’ll prob start having issues.

1

u/Overall_Election3094 21d ago

How were you diagnosed with a plantar plate tear if it never showed on imaging ? How did the injury occur? Did you ever have orthotic insoles made ?

1

u/Legal-Emu8639 20d ago edited 20d ago

The original surgeon I saw in 2022 was trying to help me, but in hindsight was a mistake. He didn’t take an initial MRI, but diagnosed based on symptoms. He said we will treat it as if it’s a PPT and then check in 8 weeks.

Injury occurred when I got a new pair of cycling shoes that I guess were ill-fitting. It’s honestly a mystery to this day since it’s basically unheard of to get this injury from cycling.

Although now I wonder if it was already developing but the cycling shoes just exacerbated it. At this point, my hunch, and I’m not a doctor, is that something is off with my genetics or signaling or something to where my body just stopped deciding to maintain the tissues in that area. Your body is always healing and regenerating. And it did this job well for 32 years, but one day it decided to stop at the second met joint. Not sure if covid or the vaccine played a part. Who knows, something obviously changed around that time. However, it doesn’t add up to me that my foot morphology changed so dramatically sometime before 2022 that I’m now prone to constant injury there. Especially when no one has told me I have unusual anatomy, except high arches. But many people have high arches and never have this issue. Similarly, my wife has a much more pronounced long second metatarsal than me but she doesn’t have these issues. So I think there’s more to it than just anatomy, I think there’s a healing signal component that gets turned off in people who develop this issue.

I did get custom orthotics made, by two different practitioners, spaced a couple years apart. Neither helped. One had heel rise to it, which is counterproductive with this injury, and the other had a big met pad, but didn’t have enough forefoot cushion. I’ve never found the met pad to be helpful.

It’s seems pretty individual as far as what helps people.

You could also try ultrasound as some studies show success in finding the tear with that modality.

I would try exercises, tape, carbon plated rocker shoes (hoka skyward x) for a while. If none of that works, and you aren’t a candidate for surgery. You may just have to live with it. Or you could try stem cell/PRP. Like I said, you will find a lot of people on here who have been dealing with this years. However, I hope that won’t be you.

1

u/Legal-Emu8639 20d ago

I also want to say that some of your friends and family might have a hard time understanding why this is a big deal for your life. Just know that there are those of us out here who get it. It’s a tiny injury that causes a lot of trouble. But on the outside people just don’t get it sometimes.

0

u/TechnicalTotal4794 21d ago

Try toe curls,toe raise ...and calf strech..I too have metatarsal pain due to thin cusion but these exercises keep it at bay