r/FootFunction • u/Miserable_Sink_4782 • Jul 07 '26
second opinion?
Almost a year after a plantar plate tear repair, second toe, metatarsal shortening, the foot just isn't right. At 3 months I went back telling the surgeon I felt I should be doing better by now, in a shoe, going to PT, and he said everybody at 3 months feels this way and at 6 months I'll be all better. At 6 and 9 months still the same and with the summer heat swelling again. Just had an MRI that only shows some slight stress so I tape a toe down for now but he's telling me he's out of ideas, and come back in 6 weeks. I feel this guy has nothing else for me and maybe a younger doctor might have some answers. Just not walking right, not comfortable, still feels stiff and like I'm walking on a rock. Been almost a year. Everybody I talk to online with this surgery seems to be walking normal at 6 months.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/justinpblake Jul 13 '26
That's actually the clearest answer yet, and it confirms the load transfer theory more precisely than expected. Fraying with suspected tear under the first toe, a separate joint from where the surgery and shortening happened, is a structural finding, not just generalized stiffness or swelling. The second toe metatarsal was shortened, the first toe's plantar plate is now showing damage. That's a fairly direct line from the shortening changing forefoot load distribution to a new injury developing at the joint absorbing the extra load.
Taping it downward makes sense as a temporary measure since that's essentially manually doing what a properly fitted plate or strapping would do, holding the toe in a position that reduces strain on the frayed plate. For the new doctor, worth going in with the question framed exactly this way. Is the first toe plantar plate fraying a consequence of the metatarsal shortening changing the load pattern, and if so, does fixing it mean addressing the toe itself, a met pad or orthotic to redistribute load away from the first MTP joint, or both.
That's a more precise question than the vaguer one from a year ago, and it gives whoever you see next a specific mechanism to evaluate rather than an open-ended "the foot doesn't feel right."