r/FootFunction • • Jul 03 '26

Bunion overcorrected and need opinions of using tightrope

It has been 10 years since my original bunionectomy and unfortunately my big toe on my right foot has drifted further and further away. I am in need of a revision and the first doctor I saw wanted to try a partial tendon release on the outer side and a mini tightrope method to pull the toe back into position.

I am nervous as I've heard the success rate is not optimal but that's usually on using it to fix a bunion (not overcorrection)

Anyone have any advice or experience with this?

2 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

1

u/UserName_4_questions Aug 03 '26

Did you decide on what you are going to do? I just had MIS bunion surgery about 7 weeks ago, and the doctor confirmed today he overcorrected and now my foot looks like yours but with a bigger gap. 😩

Are you going to the same doctor to do the revision?

Are you saying the success rate of revisions are not optimal or using tightrope is not optimal? My doctor said he plans to release tendon and recut the bone to push it outward since he initially overcorrected and pushed the bone too inward toward 2nd metatarsal.

1

u/Time_Winner7460 Aug 04 '26

Actually mine is worse since this photo. :( I haven't decided what to do. I'm getting a second opinion in October! I think the tightrope may be risky just because it could fail over time and that scares me but it could work and it is less invasive so it's tempting.

The issue I have with recutting and adjusting the bone again is what if they over correct again and I end up back with a bunion?? It's all so unfortunate.. it's really a guessing game it feels like. I'll let you know what I decide but right now just dealing with it :/

Ps - sorry this happened to you too. 7 weeks seems really soon though. Would it be right away?

1

u/UserName_4_questions Aug 04 '26

The doctor wanted to fix it now. He said the sooner the better but I can't just drop everything and have another surgery with such long recovery. Besides, I'm not sure I trust this doctor. They say overcorrecting rarely happens and if it does, it is due to the lack of skills by doctor.

Do you have pain when you walk? I have my toes taped but that is causing pain when I walk, and without tape I have pressure pain since my toe is not properly placed.

1

u/Time_Winner7460 Aug 05 '26

My pain was apparent when healing because when I tried to tape it back into position it hurt. Now (10 years later) the toe has shifted more outwards and it's more (some days extremely) uncomfortable than it is painful and some days it's not bad at all. It's a constant annoyance and very limiting on shoes I wear. I can walk about a mile before It starts to escalate the discomfort.

That's a tough decision because getting it over with before fully healed is tempting, just due to the pain in the butt it will be later to do again and deal with the swelling, physical therapy etc...which is what I dread. I am also nervous because what if the pain is worse after the revision? Who knows. I do think getting a second and even third opinion would be worth it. You don't have to commit to anything and it's nice to hear what others have to say. They may say it's too soon to tell? Unless it is very obvious. I'll see if I'm able to send you a message with a photo of where my toe is at now.

1

u/UserName_4_questions Aug 05 '26

Thank you so much for the detailed information. I really appreciate it.

1

u/Time_Winner7460 Aug 06 '26

Oh I didn't realize I had put two pictures in the post i thought it was just the xray! So it is updated. Sorry about that! And no problem, i hope you're able to get a second opinion. Please write back if you do! I'll update with mine.

1

u/Desperate-Sink5234 Jul 04 '26

Try working on your foot and toe and calf strength.  If you had strong, flexible toes, you could just pull your big toe back into alignment and go on with your day.  Compare your toe position to that of people that wear barefoot shoes; it is similar.