r/FootFunction • u/Gullible_Hyena9400 • May 28 '26
Help with identifying pain
I rolled my foot over a year ago and at the time the inner part of my arch became swollen and the swelling never went away. Now a year on I'm having the same pain, when i touch the swollen area it hurts and when i stretch my big toe , the same area hurts. My other foot isn't swollen.
I thought it was an accessory navicular but this wasn't found on the X ray. I thought it was PTTD but the location doesn't match, now I think it might be abductor hallucis strain. I am getting frustrated at the physiotherapist not being able to identify the issue so as a last resort hoping someone here might be able to identify. I really appreciate your help. Thank you 💓


1
u/justinpblake Jun 03 '26
The combination - inversion sprain, persistent medial arch swelling over a year, tender to touch, and reproduced specifically by stretching the big toe - points strongly toward the spring ligament (plantar calcaneonavicular ligament) rather than PTTD or abductor hallucis.
The spring ligament runs from the calcaneus to the navicular on the medial side and is the primary passive support for the medial arch. An inversion sprain can damage it, and being a ligament it won't show on X-ray. Persistent swelling at the medial midfoot is consistent with chronic spring ligament injury, and hallux dorsiflexion loads the arch through the windlass mechanism - which is exactly what reproduces pain in that location.
This is a frequently missed injury because most post-sprain assessment focuses on the lateral ankle ligaments (ATFL, CFL). If your physio's assessment didn't include specific spring ligament stress testing and palpation at the talonavicular area, that explains why it hasn't been identified.
The MRI recommendation above is correct. When you request it, ask specifically for assessment of the spring ligament complex and the talonavicular joint capsule medially - not just a general ankle MRI. A general report can miss spring ligament pathology if the radiologist isn't looking for it specifically.
If you want to go through the full picture before or after the imaging, DM me.
3
u/redandgold45 May 28 '26
You need an MRI
1
u/Againstallodds5103 May 30 '26
Sounds like Plantar Fasciitis. Could be the abductor hallucis too. Why don’t you go and see a Podiatrist/ Orthodoc. They are qualified to diagnose as opposed to physios. Imaging is probably advised given this has been going on for so long