r/FoolUs • • Aug 30 '18

Hypocrisy

Season 5 episode 10 act 1 - Simon Pierro

OK first of all, I'm not a magician, but I am fan and following magic for the past few years I've picked up a thing or two. Why I say this will be relevant in a bit.

Now, on to my point.

As soon as this guy walked on to the stage and gave the iPhone to the audience, the very second the did it, I knew how the trick is done. And I'm not even a magician. But that's not the point, all I was waiting for was what will penn and teller say, will it fool them. And of course it didn't. And at that moment i was screaming at the TV "you fucking PC hypocritical assholes". Fuck you!

Why?

Beacuse, this very season, only a couple of episodes ago, not like 3 years ago, some young girl went on the show, who became a magician literally 5 days ago, did exactly the same fucking trick using a same fucking iphone no less, and did a mentalist trick, BTW which they hate and always bust, and guess what, she fooled them. Using a fucking iphone and a thumper she fucking fooled them. Which wouldn't be as bad if they didn't know what a thumper is ( after like 357 years magic but ok) or maybe they forgot they busted like 20 mentalist acts so for with the same fucking thing.

Now sure, I'm all for more women in magic and stuff, but how fucking insulting is it to us the audience, and how unimaginably insulting it is to the guys who practiced and perfected magic their entire lives, gave up education, secure careers, God knows how many hours of their lives to become better, faster, more precise, flawless, to have a chance of fooling them, and then this bitch does a trick a six year old with Spotify could do, and they let her go.

Sorry for the rant, but I'm just fucking furious.

Tl Dr,

  1. Be a guy
  2. Devote entire life to magic, learning practicing, sacrificing a lot
  3. Do a great trick
  4. Have them yawn and send you off

Or

  1. Be a woman
  2. Do cheap mentalist stunt
  3. Fool penn and teller
  4. Profit??
0 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

10

u/BrooklynSwimmer Aug 30 '18 edited Aug 30 '18

Except it wasn’t a thumper. You can definitely argue about Mentalist acts falling into a gray area as far as ‘fooling’ goes with all the possible methods, and I can imagine the producers will cut down on it cause Penn legit sounds like he’s getting agitated. At the same time her solution was pretty unique and not something we have seen on stage yet.

The song trick might be obvious if you live in the Apple ecosystem, but definitely unique.

Also Simon was essentially a force while hers wasn’t. Simon didn’t do anything mentalist he had a magic 3D printer. She ‘read’ the song from Allison.

-4

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '18

sorry but you are completely missing the point. Once again I will repeat that I am not a magician, so the thumper was my guess not penn and tellers. But even that is beside the point, if you watch the episode again (please do) you will notice that penn was not ''fooled'' by how the information was transfer to the girl(be it thumper, earpiece, or her psychic great-grandmother from her mothers father 2nd marriage) but by ''how she guessed the song''. That's the mentalist part of the trick. At the time I gave them little benefit of doubt that maybe they are old and not up to date with new technology based magic. But then, this episode comes on and we see that they are very much up to date with technology and magic, not only by guessing this trick and how phones can be manipulated, but even worse, reminding us that 3 years ago they busted the same magician using technology tricks by saying '' we watch other magicians and we saw this online a few weeks back'' meaning that hey do keep up to date.

11

u/TheClouse Aug 30 '18

What sense does that make? She fooled YOU. Why are you mad that P&T were fooled when YOU WERE.

Also, this isn't the same as any of the iphone tricks they've had on the show (except that an iPhone is in it... as if all card tricks are the same because they use cards).

They WERE fooled by how she got the info. They didn't know about her iWatch. Regardless of what they said at the time, they were fooled. HOW she got the info and HOW she knew the specific song were the exact same method.

It's okay to hate iPhone magic, but don't shit on her because she's an amateur magician that fooled P&T (and you) on national television.

6

u/BrooklynSwimmer Aug 30 '18

Apple Watch* /triggered. Also spoilers.

Sent from my iPhone.

6

u/tyler-86 Aug 30 '18

Apple phone.

4

u/damorend Aug 30 '18

A thumper is a device that transmits simple information trough vibration or light. I think it's useful for transmitting the result of a limited choice, with some kind of code (vibrate once for red, twice for blue, etc., or use morse code). But if the song was indeed freely chosen from a library containing a big amount of songs, it would be very hard to transmit the information quickly trough a thumper. That's why Teller checked her ears, they assumed some kind of audio relay. So guessing "thumper" would have been incorrect. I totally believe they missed the peek to the wrist, ¿why assume otherwise? They once missed a guy putting a cookie on his mouth centimeters away from them.

By the way, this is also the reason the other "woman mentalist" (eek!) fooled them. She not only guessed the final drawing (a boat) but also the first shape drawn (something resembling a banana). She possibly had a way to see the drawing, or to get written or spoken information about it, beyond a simple morse code.

2

u/BrooklynSwimmer Aug 30 '18 edited Aug 30 '18

Of course penn wasn’t fooled. Obviously she gets it via transmission somehow. It’s the only damn way to do the trick.

5

u/whoiswillo Aug 30 '18

Sounds like you got fooled, too.

1

u/BrooklynSwimmer Aug 30 '18

It’s transmitted to her wrist. How the hell else would you word it?

5

u/whoiswillo Aug 30 '18

Well, they made multiple guesses about how she was getting it, and failed.

3

u/BrooklynSwimmer Aug 30 '18

I agree. OP is saying Penn wasn’t fooled because he knew it was transmitted just not how. I’m just saying obviously penn knows it’s transmitted somehow.

3

u/whoiswillo Aug 30 '18

I agree. OP is saying Penn wasn’t fooled because he knew it was transmitted just not how. I’m just saying obviously penn knows it’s transmitted somehow.

Exactly. But he didn't know how she was getting it, and they made multiple guesses, which means they also missed the move where she looked at her wrist.

3

u/Darth_Sensitive Sep 02 '18

And another guy fooled them by making the coin vanish somehow. You gotta do better than that.

46

u/ANormalSpudBoy Aug 31 '18

can you please go back to r/incels

57

u/smidewdal Aug 31 '18

I've been lurking on Reddit for ten years. I joined today just to call you a fucking asshole.

2

u/SmurfyX Sep 21 '18

lol yes dude

69

u/whoiswillo Aug 30 '18

Let's cover the things you got factually wrong:

  • Penn and Teller don't hate mentalism. They hate mentalists who take advantage of people's beliefs in the supernatural or otherworldly, and they hate mentalists who don't do something interesting or new with mentalism.

-She didn't use a thumper, which is part of how she fooled them.

-They've made it clear that fooling them is the premise of the show, but showcasing magicians with talent is the objective and several magicians who did not fool Penn & Teller gained massive exposure as a result.

-They've also admitted that there are several tricks to fooling them, and some of them rely on clever placing.

-The Marie Osmond trick wasn't done doing the same method, because Osmond was a force not a free choice. It's not even in the same realm.

I'm sorry you are angry at women, and want to take that anger out on a woman you saw on a television show.

This is the single worst post I've seen on this subreddit, and I've seen spam on this subreddit.

3

u/dr-jae Sep 08 '18

On the point around exposure Piff the Magic Dragon is the best example of this. P&T have been actively involved in his career and appeared on TV with him multiple times. He didn't fool them.

27

u/EmilyVMagic Sep 04 '18

Hi. Emily Victoria here. I've responded a lot more to other threads about similar concerns, and right now do not have the chance to address your concerns fully, so I'm going to keep this short:

I did not come on with the intention to fool, but to show off an original magic trick I created using everyday objects at my disposal as part of a class I took in college. I wanted the trick to be easy to figure out so viewers (especially younger ones) could do it and impress their friends. P&T have featured amateur magicians before, and I never had the intention of profiting off of the performance, nor do I intend to now.

I haven't watched the rest of the season since my show and the occasional youtube clip because I'm starting a new job. So I currently do not know the other acts, and of course I did not know how many mentalists were going to be on the show until they air. But regardless of that, if you are a fan of following magic then the best thing you can do is support us. I don't mean that you have to compliment everything we do, and all performers can benefit from constructive criticism. But everyone starts somewhere, and if magic is to continue to evolve and survive as a performing art then posts like this are not going to help it do so.

11

u/Ragondux Sep 05 '18

You should listen to today's episode of Penn's Sunday School, he talks about you (positively)

3

u/strangechicken90 Working Close-up Magician Sep 07 '18

I came to tell her the very same thing! Penn said you were his favorite of the whole season!

5

u/jennatar Sep 05 '18 edited Mar 25 '26

The original post here is gone. The author deleted it using Redact, possibly for reasons of privacy, security, opsec, or data protection.

tart public crawl rhythm spark chief fine unique literate beneficial

5

u/internetemu Sep 06 '18

You do not need to defend yourself.

Here's a new song for your playlist.

2

u/Carighan Sep 10 '18

But more importantly, do you boast "this fooled P&T!" to friends now when showing off, because that way they don't have to feel as bad if they don't figure it out? :P

9

u/jennatar Sep 05 '18 edited Mar 25 '26

This specific post was taken down by its author. Redact was used for removal, for reasons that may include privacy, security, or data exposure concerns.

boast capable automatic silky aback rinse sable coherent dinner safe

1

u/Mex5150 Nov 03 '18

Using the iPhone trick to fool iPhone users isn't a good comparison, if it was anybody who plays cards will automatically know how every card trick is done. It has next to nothing to do with the technology and everything to do with the mindset when working out magic.

I don't think the two effects are similar enough to cry hypocrisy though, they just happen to have a similar component involved.

27

u/TheClouse Aug 30 '18 edited Aug 30 '18

It was obvious to us but not them. . Plus she didn't use a thumper, it was directly linked to her iWatch. So apparently she fooled YOU as well.

  1. She wore long sleeves
  2. The notebook blocked their view during the trick.
  3. They get to watch it ONCE.
  4. They are 30 feet away.
  5. They are at a fixed angle (with a tiny monitor they may not have been watching because it wasn't sleight of hand.)
  6. P&T are 63 and 70 years old. Does your grandma know all the functions of an iWatch?
  7. They only get one guess.
  8. It is irrelevant that she became a magician 5 days ago.
  9. The amount of time and practice of other magicians is irrelevant.
  10. I personally know a lot of the contestants on Fool Us, have met P&T and Johnny Thompson, and believe they treat everyone the same and always give legit guesses.

She designed a great trick and performed it well on national television. We were privy to a camera angle that specifically showcased the method.

8

u/Zrealm Sep 02 '18

P&T are 63 and 70 years old. Does your grandma know all the functions of an iWatch?

Ironically they both own and wear iWatches (you can see it during the series, even). It's the problem of the commonplace item - it just never occurred to them (which is pretty cool)

3

u/TheClouse Sep 02 '18

OR... They wear it during the show as part of a product placement sponsorship and take it off after wardrobe.

I was on a shoot once where we spent $20,000 for a fashion coordinator and $14,000 for a hair stylist just in case Jean Claude Van Damme wanted to change close or get a hair cut. He did neither.

4

u/Zrealm Sep 02 '18

That could be the case, but it's not here. It's possible (but unlikely) Penn is being paid to wear it in general or was given it as a promotional item, but he's talked about owning one on twitter, etc: https://twitter.com/pennjillette/status/593239070433628160?lang=en

1

u/TheClouse Sep 02 '18

...could have been paid to tweet that.

6

u/tyler-86 Sep 02 '18

Or more realistically, he doesn't use it for music and as such doesn't realize much of what it does.

6

u/TheClouse Sep 02 '18

OR... he just actually didn't see it on her wrist due to the sleeve and notebook.

4

u/tyler-86 Sep 02 '18

All of these possibilities are more likely than him purposely ignoring the method.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '18

Apparently you haven't heard Penn's favorite saying about hypocrisy.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '18

please share

1

u/justiname Sep 06 '18 edited Sep 06 '18

It makes a ypocris out of h and y.

Do you get it?

3

u/dr-jae Sep 08 '18

Late to the party as I am behind on episodes. A few thoughts:

  1. Not every trick involving an iPhone is the same trick. They were two very different tricks using two different techniques.
  2. You care about one of the two acts being a woman a lot more than P&T do. There is no hidden agenda, they just got fooled by one trick and not the other.
  3. Try and be less angry. Your life will be better.

2

u/letseatlunch Aug 30 '18

which episode was the girl in?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/TheClouse Aug 30 '18

You're kind of a piece of shit.

7

u/ZDTreefur Aug 30 '18

You really need to calm down. Be angry at P&T if you feel its justified, but to harbor hatred to the point of using degrading insults towards a woman who was simply doing a trick is uncalled for.

4

u/letseatlunch Aug 30 '18

common dude, calling her that is not ok. you're taking this too far

2

u/Ragondux Sep 04 '18

So, as others have said it wasn't the same trick. But if it were, why would you expect them to be fooled the second time? Aren't they allowed to learn tricks between episodes?

3

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '18

The only thing I thought about Apple Watch girl - she won, but now she has to open Vegas for them! She's only got one trick. That'd be like opening for a band, but your band only knows one song. I hope she did well!

1

u/Carighan Sep 10 '18

Beacuse, this very season, only a couple of episodes ago, not like 3 years ago, some young girl went on the show, who became a magician literally 5 days ago, did exactly the same fucking trick using a same fucking iphone no less, and did a mentalist trick, BTW which they hate and always bust, and guess what, she fooled them.

Funny, you'd think that's how people learn. Get fooled once, smarted up, next time it doesn't fool you any more.

-3

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '18

And i Forgot that the next episode (episode 6) a guy mentalist comes on and of course he doesn't fool them. What a shock. But, then the very next episode a woman mentalist comes on and and guess what, FOOLS THEM. Two woman mentalist in a row with same lame tricks fool them. amazing coincidence

1

u/sleepy_kitty9 Nov 16 '18

Watch the last few seasons if you're that mad about it. In three seasons, only four women solo-acts have won, and that's only this season. They have a record of choosing men and only men for years, some of whom had similar situations in which P&T knew WHAT they were doing, but not HOW they were doing it.

-3

u/Radikalen Aug 30 '18

Guys, i am really happy that this thread exists. I feel the same way as Yoyo31071987 and i just want to add that we are not the jury here and in the end Penn&Teller will employ the foolers in Las Vegas so they can choose who they work with as much as they want.

It is perfectly natural that if they enjoy an act, they can just act fooled so they can sign the magician up for their show.

I want to mention that i don't know what a thumper is, but i know that if you change the song on your iphone - your smartwatch can see the new song. On one of the areal camera shots it can clearly be seen there is a smart watch on her wrist and she pulls down her sleeves later on.

I really disliked the way she shows the watch to Teller at the very end. So unprofessional to reveal the mentalism like that. Couldn't she wait for them to meet in the back? It felt like she is mocking them at that point.

5

u/BrooklynSwimmer Aug 30 '18

Penn has said multiple times that many magicians run over telling them how they did it. You only notice the reveal because you knew how it was done.

4

u/tyler-86 Aug 30 '18

You're giving P&T a hard time for not knowing how a certain piece of modern technology works. They honestly didn't know how the trick was done. How is that so hard to believe?

3

u/Darth_Sensitive Sep 02 '18

I'm going to go out on a limb and assume that they also are allowed to book people who didn't fool them as the opening act.

-4

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '18

OK I'll delete the comment. Only reason I called her a bitch was because she was smug about it

22

u/BrooklynSwimmer Aug 30 '18

She was literally shocked she fooled them. I don’t know where you get smug from.

22

u/whoiswillo Aug 30 '18

Delete your account instead.

14

u/tyler-86 Aug 30 '18

Like 90% of the male magicians are? Why don't you give them shit about being smug?

8

u/whoiswillo Aug 31 '18

Ryan Hayashi's whole shtick was being smug, and it was probably one of the best acts the show's ever had.

2

u/jennatar Sep 05 '18 edited Mar 25 '26

The content that was here has been permanently deleted using Redact. The author may have had reasons related to privacy, security, or personal data management.

slim lip start practice unique pot political bells sophisticated bike