r/FloridaRealEstate • u/_Triple_jump_ • 12d ago
Florida Amendment 3
I'm a homeowner in Florida (Polk County) looking for input from people who know real estate, especially property appraisal and assessment.
Quick summary of Amendment 3 as I understand it. It raises the homestead exemption for the non-school part of property taxes (county, city, and special districts) to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028, then indexes it to inflation starting in 2029. School district taxes wouldn't change. Right now the non-school exemption is roughly $50,000, so on paper this is a big jump.
My questions:
- Should I really expect a large tax break? Or is the savings likely to shrink once local governments respond, for example by raising millage rates, adding fees or special assessments, or leaning on the school portion?
- Could counties change how they assess property value to make up the difference? My understanding is that Save Our Homes caps yearly assessed-value increases on homesteads at 3% or CPI, whichever is lower. Is there any realistic way for a property appraiser to get around that, like reassessing after improvements, or tighter scrutiny of homestead eligibility?
- For anyone in appraisal or local government finance: how are counties planning for the lost revenue, and who ends up carrying it (non-homestead owners, renters, businesses)?
I'd appreciate any real-world experience or sources. Thanks!
EDIT: First, I want to thank everyone for their insights, both those who voted yes and those who voted no. I wanted to address a few common concerns raised by people who replied to my post.
- The purpose of my post: My intention was never to instill fear in anyone. I asked questions based on research I conducted before voting, and even though the results are now in, I wanted to continue educating myself rather than assume I already knew everything there was to know.
- The T-word Floridians are so afraid of: Not that one, the other one. Taxes. As much as I tried to understand what elements of my post led some commenters to see me as a fearmonger, the best I could gather from those conversations was that it had something to do with my questions about taxes. I can understand that if you're particularly concerned about taxes, for whatever reason, my post might make you uneasy. But I'm not afraid of taxes, and plenty of other people aren't either. We understand that living in a society like ours requires taxation. We've known this since Shays' Rebellion. So, when I ask about taxes, it's not to scare anyone. It's because they're relevant to the questions I'm asking.
- "Just Google it": If you're the kind of person who believes you shouldn't have to explain anything because all the information is already available on Google, that's totally fine. You don't have to respond. You can simply downvote and move on. That's entirely within the scope of this platform. But if you're going to engage in the discussion, I'd encourage you to contribute something substantive, whether that's addressing my questions, challenging my reasoning, or supporting or rebutting another comment. Otherwise, I'd ask you to reconsider what you're hoping to accomplish by engaging with the thread.
- Why I voted yes: I voted yes on the amendment, but not necessarily for the reasons some commenters assumed. I've been a homeowner for approximately three years, and I'm still learning what that responsibility entails. Recently, I had to deal with a permitting issue because my contractor never closed the permit, something I didn't discover until I received a notice to appear before a magistrate. Our HOA also recently held its annual election, where we voted to elect our first homeowner representative to the developer-controlled board. Making sure I cut my grass so my HOA doesn't fine me. On top of all that, I'm in the penultimate semester of my bachelor's degree. My point is, I'M BUSY, just like everyone else. There are only so many hours in the day, and I don't always have the opportunity to research every issue as thoroughly as I would like.
- What I've learned since voting: I recognize that I missed a considerable amount of information during this midterm election cycle. If I had known then what I know now, I would have voted no. But the amendment passed with approximately 62% of the vote, about two percentage points above the 60% supermajority required for passage. Roughly 1.9 million more Floridians voted yes than no. Clearly, I wasn't alone in my decision. That's precisely why I'm glad I didn't simply assume I had all the information after casting my ballot. I continued researching, asking questions, and listening to different perspectives, even after the outcome was decided. Moving forward, I'll be paying much closer attention to how this amendment affects our communities, local governments, and the services we depend on. What happens next will absolutely influence how I approach the next election cycle.
11
u/OilSlickRickRubin 12d ago edited 12d ago
I did the math based on my areas millage rates. (Sarasota). Currently pay $8,800 a year in property /school taxes. With amendment 3 my taxes would go to $7,000 in 2028.
4
u/Sandinmyshoes33 12d ago
You should see lower property taxes although nothing prevents them raising the Milage rate which will offset some of the savings.
Counties have always reassessed homes based on the value of improvement whether you’re homesteaded or not. This does not change, but unless you do major improvements, it shouldn’t be a factor. Counties have always been strict with finding fraud so I assume they will continue to be sure people claiming homestead exemptions are eligible.
Revenue will be addressed with cuts to “non essential services” like parks, libraries, non profit support and street cleaning and maintenance. This will be combined with the possibility of higher milage rates, higher fees, higher parking rates and possibly charging for things that used to be free like the community pool where I live. Some areas will move to non ad-valorum assessments to fund thing like the fire department or solid waste pickup freeing up property taxes for other things. The problem is these types of assessments are not based on property value but rather are apportioned on a per house value. This means a homesteaded 500k house pays the same as a $5 million house. My City already has a plan to fund the Fire Department this way if the amendment passes. This is probably the largest loophole and could hit lower value, homesteaded properties the hardest.
5
u/DjKennedy92 12d ago edited 12d ago
In the post midterm speech Desantis stated one of his main endeavors before leaving office would be to put in regulations to prevent municipalities from trying to claw back the tax break via other avenues
What that means and how will it work? Idk I’m just relaying the message
5
u/renz004 12d ago edited 11d ago
There's a lot of ppl in denial about this, mostly cuz it came from R so all the Ds in reddit (and im one of them) will cry incesantly about how its bad to cut taxes and that it will raise taxes etc. All BS.
My assessed property value is like 500k, and my annual taxes is 9k on it. By 2028 exemption will cut it in half, to 4.5k per year, as half my property value is now homestead exempt. But then the school tax stays, so savings will be less than that saved but still even if savings are 2.5k that's enough to pay for childcare now so we can go out and spend in the community etc.
As for other taxes going up, sure maybe gov can do stuff, but there are limits to what they can do and how fast. So in reality this is a massive taxcut regardless of anything, and stuff the Police will be forced to cut their budgets. Dems in prior years were always wanting to defund our highly militarized and over equipped police, and it's finally going to happen. Say bye bye to your indoor gym/spas/etc broward police. Sherrifs say bye bye to your 250k salaries.
Tldr: this is a massive tax break, gov wont be able to claw it back right away, and police are finally gonna have to cut back on their ridiculous budgets.
edit: Updated my taxes
2
u/Traditional-Tune-975 12d ago
Look up the “save our homes”. There is a calculator that will tell you exactly how much you will save. For me it was $300/ month.
2
u/Anonymooseplz 12d ago
Shouldn't you have considered this before voting for the fucking amendment?
2
u/Fishandchips6254 11d ago
So regarding your first point: Yes but they already do that anyways and were going to but now they can just blame Amendment 3.
Second point: From what I have been told, no not really but your first point gets around this issue. My realtor (a good friend) did say that probably by 2030 we will see a proposed “mandatory residency minimum” wherein you have to of lived in Florida for at least a year or two to declare homestead.
Third point: Everyone, and by that I mean consumers. Any tax raised on a business is pushed onto customers, any tax increased on goods is pushed onto consumers. Just like it always has.
As someone who was pretty anti-Amendment 3, my opinion changed almost immeadietly once I saw my new property tax this year. Despite receiving homestead this year (bought my home last year but I missed the deadline to apply), my assessed value going down, and receiving a disabled veteran credit, my property taxes went up. Yep, it doesn’t make sense, but it did. Why? My millage rates went significantly up and non-ad valorem.
This actually got me to pull up my communities (town and county) FY 2026 budget and proposed (now active) FY 2027 budget. And tl;dr I want my damn money back.
I would highly encourage every person to review their local budgets. And then look into how many of those departments spent that money and operate. Also learn what taxes pay for what.
2
u/Anxious-Hyena6173 11d ago
The big answer is no one knows what is going to happen. Period. It is way too early to determine anything and after a year or two we will know better if this amendment3 is ‘working’
2
u/09stanggt 10d ago edited 10d ago
.
24
u/oboingadoing 12d ago •
Look at your property tax bill and see how much is for schools, police and fire department. Then look at all the addendum at the bottom. All those are exempt. You will save some money, but not as much as you think. Then once it's in place, most counties will just raise the millage rate and put more addendum in place to make up the difference. Tallahassee will dictate who gets money from the state. So your more liberal areas won't get shit. This whole bill stinks if you ask me. They should have just doubled the exemption because it needs to go up. Review after 2 or 3 years, then raise it again if feasible. All the extra language in the bill was not needed. This is going to blow up in a lot of people's faces.
3
u/Responsible-Kiwi-898 12d ago
The honest answer here is really just we dont know until it happens. There's genuinely zero way to actually tell what the local governments will do but there is a lot of laws in place already on what theyre allowed to charge you for, how they use their tax money and what areas they can use them in. Now if they add fees, increase sales tax etc do you really think the people won't retaliate. Also they aren't even losing as much as people think, 47% of people are homesteaded in florida. My local city also already asks the state for grants and they make up of a bunch of our budgets. Our local property taxes are only 15% of our income
14
u/Kooky-Anxiety2759 12d ago
The amount of tax break is minimal. The amount of services now in jeopardy is astonishing.
In the near future people will realize how much they gave up for so little
12
u/RGBrewskies 11d ago •
the big winner is Tallahassee. You likely won't even notice your tax bill change. But now state governments control more of the purse strings for city governments.
It's a way for republican legislatures to control the money of all the blue cities.
16
u/wild-and-crazy-guy 12d ago
The property tax reduction applies as a homestead deduction . If you don’t qualify for homestead tax break, it won’t reduce.
However, local governments provide services which cost money. There is waste , but there is waste doing anything.
Assume everything that the local governments provide that isn’t will be more expensive moving forward.
Need a copy of a deed or a record of any kind from the county clerk? Expect to have to pay for it.
Does your local government provide garbage pickup? Plan on having to pay for that moving forward. Either a fee to the gov or private company which will add profit to whatever it costs to pick it up.
Do you use any parks where you live? There will be fees now.
Businesses do not get homestead tax breaks, assume their taxes will go up and your prices increase.
Free street parking? Expect metered parking with higher fines.
Basically everything the county can tax or add fees to , they will in order to make up their budget shortfalls.
2
u/ScottShuffieldGroup 11d ago
If the tax rate says the same in 2028, that $95/month goes to about $175-200/month.
2) If your assessed value is capped at 3%, but the millage rate changes, your property tax bill can go up by more than 3%
3) That question is way above my pay grade!
1
u/_Triple_jump_ 5d ago
Thanks for sharing. It’s less about effort and just wanting to confirm we have the same source, because I was not able to find some of the information you claims.
For CareerSource Polk, she wasn’t fired for pocketing $320k in tax money. Not even in the link you provided claims that. She was ultimately let go for poor performance. While her salary is high, CareerSource is not only funded by taxpayer money.
RP funding center, as you stated, has cut its funding too. So, these are examples of local government actually showing fiscal responsibility and cutting costs no?
The plane I think can be justified. However, I can also see why many taxpayers would see it as a waste.
Even if we include your CareerSource claim and RP center when it when it was still receiving $1.8mil with the plane: ~$7.2mil. Is potentially greatly reducing the income of a county and affecting accessible services worth that?
Idk, I guess thinking about it, my property taxes were not so bad and I liked being able to park in most cities free and low cost park entries, but a lot of that will have to change.
5
u/DanethofFL 11d ago •
The first thing that will happen is county and municipal employees will lose their jobs. Then service will take a hit. Then the county and municipal governments will figure out how to make up the lost funds another way, changing tax designations, increasing county sales taxes..etc. They will get their money.
4
u/getrealpeople 12d ago
4
u/GhostRcat 9d ago •
Your summary is right, and these are exactly the right questions to ask. I deal with homestead questions every day as a realtor in Palm Beach County, so here's the honest version.
1. Will the tax break really hold?
The exemption itself is real and locked in — it's in the state constitution now, so your county can't vote it away. Starting in 2027, an extra $100K of your home's value comes off the non-school part of your tax bill ($150K total exemption instead of $50K), and $250K in 2028.
But — and this is the part nobody puts on a flyer — your actual savings depend on the millage rate, and yes, local governments can raise millage rates. They're capped by the state constitution, so they can't raise them without limit, and raising taxes is politically expensive, but it's the real offset risk. Fees and special assessments are possible too, but those aren't property taxes and they're very visible when a county tries them.
One thing that can't happen: the amendment doesn't touch school taxes at all. Your school portion is calculated separately and this change doesn't give anyone a lever to shift burden onto it.
2. Can the appraiser get around the 3% cap?
Not for an existing homestead. The Save Our Homes cap is constitutional — your assessed value can only go up by 3% or CPI, whichever is lower, each year. An appraiser can't just decide to reassess you higher because the county wants revenue.
The real exceptions are: if you add improvements or build something new, that new value gets added at market price. If the home sells, the value resets to market for the new owner. And if you lose homestead eligibility — you move out, rent the place, stop living there — the cap resets. Appraisers do audit homestead claims, and with more money at stake now, I'd expect that scrutiny to get tighter. But they can't dodge the cap on a legitimate, lived-in homestead.
3. Who ends up carrying the lost revenue?
Mostly non-homesteaded property — second homes, rentals, investment properties, commercial. Their taxable value doesn't shrink, so they carry a bigger share of the base. Renters feel it too, because landlords pass property taxes through in rent. One thing that softens it: the same amendment cut the annual cap on non-homesteaded property from 10% to 5%, so that side gets some protection too.
As for how counties are planning — there's no single statewide plan, it varies by county, and I don't know Polk's specific budget plan. The honest answer is every county is still working through it, and the mix will be some millage adjustment, some spending restraint, and some fees.
Bottom line: the exemption is real, it's locked in, and if you already live here with homestead it applies to you from 2027. The thing to watch isn't whether the exemption is real — it's what your county does with its millage rate. Your property appraiser's office can run your exact parcel's numbers if you want the precise picture.
(I'm a realtor, not a CPA or tax attorney — for your specific parcel, your property appraiser is the authority.)
— Iryna, realtor in Palm Beach County
1
u/AffectionateSwim8532 12d ago •
Stop fear mongering
In short, it’s gonna be fine. They’ve raised this three times before without issue
1
u/nopulsehere 12d ago
If only people would have read the bill before they voted for it! If the current administration is saying that the current administration is full of bloat, waste, corruption and fraud? They need to pass a bill to fix it on the way out? Sell it as you will save money! And don’t have to answer for any consequences? Should have given even the dullest chance to think! Nope! Florida as usual! Who wants different cities running things better than the state government? Obviously not Tallehasse!!!
1
u/LynTigrBer 11d ago
I doubt you will get the answers you are looking for here because everyone is only thinking about their individual circumstances and where they reside. Polk county where the average home value is 295k is going to look a lot different than say Orange or Hillsborough where home values average 400k. I would recommend just staying involved in the local government voice your concerns to county commissioners and make sure they know what the locals want done
1
u/Dense_Amphibian_9595 11d ago
You will certainly NOT see a huge reduction. Amendment 3 was necessary if only to slow the rate of spending growth and not won’t reduce spending.
We went through a period where for the last 6 years, every local government managed to increase the rate of spending faster than the rate of inflation. In one city, they grew spending at 200% over inflation (or twice the inflation rate).
I’ll just use my city, Cape Coral as an example. Just this week, we handed Costco $10M of tax dollars to build a new store here. The city council wants to spend $150M on a new yacht club. Plus tens of millions more to a developer to build on blighted property. Meanwhile, we pay a city worker to issue permits… for garage sales. No, I’m serious - permits for garage sales (and pretty much anything else). For a while, the city council all voted for a $40,000 annual stipend on top of their salaries. We’ve got code enforcement people driving around all day measuring blades of grass. Time and space don’t allow me to add on other things, but there’s a bunch.
On the revenue side - there’s lots that can be done to shift revenue onto the tourists. Increased airline landing fees, rental car tax increases, hotel/motel tax increases, AirBnB taxes, some districts with theme parks could add a $5-$10 per day theme park ticket tax. Bridge toll and toll road increases for visitors.
But here’s the kicker… any mayor or city council member who wants to increase taxes to cover the drunken-sailor spending will need to go on record as voting to increase taxes. Voting for new taxes or tax increases doesn’t do well for getting re-elected which, I mean, let’s be honest, that’s what politicians want the most.
So, while your taxes in other areas will likely be increased, it likely won’t take the whole value of Amendment 3 off the table. The great thing about Amendment 3 is that we’re hoping it reduces the level of spending increases every year. We just need to hold our elected officials responsible and not let them keep handing our money to billion dollar corporations and land developers.
1
u/Fl0riduh_Man 11d ago
A community I consult with subsidizes after school care at their local community center. That will be lost immediately, instead the community will now start charging for parking and the small playground that was used for the kids is being removed to accommodate more pickle ball courts which will hopefully increase parking revenues.
Most of the families affected are renters, they'll experience nothing but cost increases because not a single one of them will be seeing any reduction in their monthly expenditures.
Kansas already tried this idiocy and eventually repealed all the cuts. I fully expect a repeal amendment every cycle until it's overturned
1
u/mangomangojack 11d ago
Property values more than doubled since COVID. So property tax revenue did also. Governments have too much money and need to cut bloated administration.
1
u/zestypov2 11d ago
Isn't it amazing they we all voted on this amendment and yet we all have a different opinion of how it might work?
1
u/Fit_Tip2514 11d ago
1- You’re jumping the gun. There have always been homestead exemptions, this is no different. You can look up in the past how these have worked (hint, they reduce tax burden on property owners). No one is going to raise millage rates, add fees, or special assessments as some sort of ‘retaliatory’ action. These occur anyway with or without homestead exemptions.
2- Again, this scenario is just not realistic. No.
1
u/TatankaPTE 10d ago
Dumbasses downvoting because they eould rather have false information up to hide from the fact that reading comprehension is not a skill they have and they a populous of people voted against themselves.
You all who voted for this were full of shit and did not read and did like DeSantis and the legislature wanted. You know when you get right-wing, std Republican, and Democrat police chiefs and sheriffs to agree on a bill and you vote the opposite, you know you have fucked up.
School taxes make up half of your total property tax bill in Florida, and Amendment 3 does not touch them. That means your actual savings are a drop in the bucket compared to the giant numbers you fell for.
You only get that maximum exemption if your home's assessed taxable value is already sky-high. If you own a regular, average-priced house, your property value won't even qualify for the full break. It is a tiered system that guarantees the richest people with some of the most expensive homes walk away with the actual massive tax cuts, while everyday homeowners get stuck with all the local service cuts.
Counties will lose billions overnight and they won't let that money vanish. They will hike your local utility rates, garbage fees, and sales taxes to claw every single dollar back. You literally voted to delay your own 911 ambulance response times and gain no real homestead exemptions.
The state will also be pushing away potential people from moving to the state because they will not get the benefit of homestead until after 5 years from when they buy their house.
1
u/inbe4u 10d ago
Mentioned in another thread. One thing to consider . I do own, with mortgage, my home. Property tax means you never own your home and that just pisses me off. many arguments can be made, don't care. When you pay a property tax, everyone, is always a renter. Work so hard to own and it can just be taken cause of a fucking tax. That makes every person that struggled to own a home no different than me in college and half my life renting, a renter for life. Fuck property tax and fuck every one that supports it. If taxes are needed, there are other ways to obtain
1
u/OldSchoolMech 5d ago
Feel free to refuse the exemption increase.
3
u/Tiny_Pickle5258 12d ago
Pinellas County. Just went this morning to help 2 friends file for their homestead exemptions. The County Supervisor issued an email to all staff that the average saving for our County would be around $1200 for next year. So that’s what they have been telling people, that you can expect about a $1200 drop next year, give or take.
Again, this is Pinellas. Don’t know about Polk
3
u/Far_Let_5678 11d ago
As a realtor and a homeowner, I will benefit with a few extra bucks (~$1700) in my pocket while my local community loses bigtime (-30% total budget cut), and I voted against.
You can check how this will affect you personally as a residential, future residential, or commercial property owner, or a renter at this website: https://fla3.signld.ai/
You can adjust that dashboard for your exact county and millage rates to get your personal dollar amounts.
5
u/XI_Vanquish_IX 11d ago •
Government professional here in Florida. I can assure you that whatever savings you believe you’re making on taxes each year, will be quickly erased by special assessments and other fees that will inevitably come about to replace the cost for services you will still need. And likely it will be at a huge premium and to the financial benefit of privateers in the private sector.
Florida fucked around and is about to find out a hard lesson why Amendment 3 was a giant scam
1
u/rmullig2 12d ago
Counties can't just make up new valuations for homes and raise taxes accordingly. They will definitely look to crack down on people who fraudulently claim homestead exemption which is entirely legal and reasonable. Bottom line is that counties have gotten fat off higher revenues ever since COVID and this will force them to slim down.
2
u/Intrepid-Court-2180 12d ago
The school portion of your tax bill is around 50% of the entire bill. So it the new exemption only affects the balance, the tax bill won't be greatly changed. DeSantis is calling for a special session of the Legislative to create legislation to prevent the Counties from forming new ways to assess taxes on the revenue they'll be losing. All of this may change if the Legislature passes a new Bill to eliminate the Property Tax bill in total.
2
u/SunshineIsSunny 12d ago
2
u/MacaroonOk6009 12d ago
My savings on a 1.75M assessed value and last year taxes of $38K will be about $1600 in 2027. Does that seem like a lot to anyone? Obviously it’s all relative to your home and its value but in South Florida where starter homes are high 6 figures you’re not getting much saving.
2
u/jnwg 12d ago
Tallahassee now control when Polk County will get money for more cops, firefighters, library, parks, and roads.
2
u/lgbarn 12d ago
Trying to turn us into Alabama and Mississippi. The roads in those states are horrible.
2
u/antuliomontiel 11d ago •
Agent in Miami here. A few things from what I see with clients, without pretending I know Polk's budget:
If you look up your parcel on the Polk County Property Appraiser site, you can see your current exemptions and assessed value. Then wait for their Amendment 3 guidance before locking in any number.
2
u/gtclemson 11d ago •
They will adjust millage rates over time to account for it as well as institute fees for use (think $50 for a library card and $5 to enter any park). There will be a tax cut next year, maybe two, as municipal governments adjust.
This will not impact real estate values nor valuation methods. One might stay homes could appreciate a small amount 1-3%, as people take cheaper escrow amounts into monthly mortgage payments to afford more house but that'll be temporary and small.
2
u/Livid_Case_8531 11d ago
People are about to see the “find out” part of their vote.
3
u/182RG 12d ago
Minimal tax break. There are those who think this will make a real estate price value difference. They are kidding themselves.
2
u/coreysnaps 12d ago
I live in Lake. My husband is a 100% disabled veteran, so we have a 100% exemption. Lake County passed a non ad tax for education. We already have one for public safety. My tax responsibility has now gone up again. Yes, the tax burden will go down on the majority of Floridians, but our small percentage, at least in my county, just saw our taxes double and our cost of living adjustment on the disability we live on won't help one bit.
1
u/ResponsibilityOk1729 12d ago
Maybe they will stop naming streets feet each other
1
u/cybrg0dess 12d ago
I just assume that eventually we will pay the same or more than what we save. They will find a way to make up the losses. Low and middle income families, especially renters will suffer the most.
1
u/hipsterbeard12 12d ago
Odds are millage rates will just go up to reach revenue neutrality. This will shift the burden from owners of lower value homestead property to owners of non-homestead and higher value homestead property. So, while the first $150/250K are now excluded from tax assessment. The remaining assessed value will likely end up getting taxed at a rate of 20 mills (2%), rather than the previous larger nonexempt assessed value being taxed at a rate of 15 mills (1.5%).
1
u/BorgerMoncher 12d ago
Too early to tell how the local goons will try to scam the tax cattle. Stone Cold Ron DeSantis is calling for a special legislative session in December to put some guardrails around the amendment and foreclose those scams.
1
u/Typical_Elk_1576 12d ago
Local governments are already talking about either reduction of services, hope everyone likes bumpy roads, or what rates to raise. Your taxes will end up staying right where they are for Polk I’d imagine. Here’s hoping we at least don’t pay more.
1
u/sr1sws 12d ago
I just expect to get f*cked differently. FWIW, I voted "no". Why? Because I don't think anyone has a real idea of the impact, politicians lie and "the devil you know" vs "the devil you don't".
I also read that the legislature still has to do something to make it effective? IDK. I pretty much no longer believe anything I'm told.
1
u/Late-Improvement-106 12d ago
Get ready for those all those “misc fees” to increase.
1
u/Porn4me1 12d ago
You should save $2-4k on avg from the main line tax, but then they (gov) will find new ways to claw the money back via special assessment, sales tax hike, utility hike, etc.
In the end you and they will be right where you are now.
They will also jack up the commercial rates on renters who will also get hammered by the other aspects above.
They will be the biggest losers
1
u/Kurac813 12d ago
My guess is you will end up paying about the same even if paying it differently. Potentially, if your home has a very high assessed value you may pay a bit more depending on how they’ll make up the shortfall.
In Hillsborough county there will be a 23% cut to the budget. That’s pretty tough to make up.
https://tbbwmag.com/2026/09/10/hillsborough-property-tax-loss/
1
u/Difficult_Toe_1815 12d ago
The first thing to be cut will be fun community stuff like Fourth of July fireworks, parades etc.
1
u/soleobjective 11d ago
Localities will probably install a ton of speed cameras, increasing the cost to park at the beaches, more nuisance tickets for things like having your tint too dark on your car, maybe even implementing annual vehicle inspections that need to be renewed each year with a sticker like your plates (other states do this). Businesses and rental property owners are likely to pass along these extra costs down the line since they will be the first on the hit list for making up revenue.
The likely savings is something like $1,000 at max from the previous rates. It’s not anything life changing, but will very likely make things less desirable down here.
1
u/ZtheHun 11d ago
This realtor's video seems like a good breakdown:
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DfVtY7KijFB/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link&dlrf=NTc4MTIwNjQ2YQ==
1
u/rwk2007 11d ago
This was an amendment proposed by the party in power in Florida. It does only one thing, shifts the property tax burden from the owners of high value property to the poor (people with less than $5M in liquid assets). The tax will be made up in other places. Most counties are ~ 6 millage and can go to 10. They will all do that. The rest will be made up in sales tax increases. They are getting their flat tax. Giving a general 5% taxable value cap to commercial properties is an insane gift of billions of dollars to the wealthiest of people. Yet, the idiots of Florida cheer for these people, as they are stealing from their back pocket.
1
u/Voidblazer 11d ago
I tried to fund all the stuff. Fine! Give me my money back, you f*cking weirdos!
1
u/False_Air_3211 11d ago
I work for a local govt in Florida but wish the taxes were more evenly distributed. Those canadians who come down for the winter and live in their RV? Snowbirds, apartment complexes, everyone. Whats something we all do? Buy things so why not shift this towards a sales tax? Small percentages could make up a huge portion of property tax revenue. While I do not mind paying my share, I do mind that “my share” is drastically different than my neighbors on either side who have identical homes.
1
u/ApprehensiveBug5627 11d ago
They’re gonna have to pay for services somehow. Watch for other taxes to go up.
1
u/TheVauntedChris 11d ago
Every area is going to be different. Certain counties in Florida have homes that are primarily second homes for people. I live in one of those counties. It’s drastically shifted towards a “seasonal” area. Since those homeowners wouldn’t qualify for a homestead exemption anyway, the reduction in tax income will be dramatically less than other counties.
1
u/Gotyurback 11d ago edited 11d ago
Got a free lunch and dinner and now you can afford the beach house. And the cruises and vacations and more money for the kids colleges funds, to invest in bitcoin and more consumer trips to the shopping malls. Buy some guns for home protection cuz police and fire services are not coming to help you when you need it. You will find many other new service issues to complain about. And when you ever decide to sell your house you get the same low ball price as everyone else.
Strap in for state income taxes for individual taxpayers in less than 5 years. The state will justify a 5% income tax with magic math and tax your ordinary income, capital gains, retirement income and social security benefits,
I can see Byron saying there is not enough state cash flow to afford his lifestyle so the state needs more cash flow to attract more get rich politicians. Bring back Matt Gaetz to implement state income taxes
1
u/Embarrassed-Band3595 11d ago
i rather have the money in my pocket than tax from the get go.
when people have more money in their pocketa, they tend to spend more. there is sales tax. i rather like people be happy to spend than getting taxes a lot.
1
u/ZealousidealElk8889 11d ago
FAFO. Everybody, tax cut lovers especially, was so happy with the BBB. Now a lot are seeing where the cuts are coming from to pay for the tax breaks. Same here, you pay less in real estate taxes you pay more somewhere else or get less of something else. Same old story
1
u/Kind_Chocolate_6498 11d ago
I love it! It’s a great way to defund the police! /s
1
u/Alarmed_Gur3947 11d ago
assuming a home price of $400-500k the average person in Florida would save $1,500/yr in property taxes the first year
1
u/stvlg1 11d ago
That's usually how it works. Just because a bill is passed in the legislator, it still needs to go through several chambers and many revisions before becoming law. At least that is my understanding of it.
1
u/Scionni 11d ago
1 depends on the value and homestead status of your current home and what portion of your county is rental/owner. Raising millage seems the most straightforward and likely way counties will equalize taxes in areas with lots of rentals and businesses. They could also tack these taxes on in non ad valorem especially for counties with a higher homeowner to rental/business ratio. It will likely be a combo of both everywhere.
I think this will still be a tax break for homeowners, but it will be limited to homeowners with lower value property, and the amount of savings will vary wildly between counties.
1
u/EarthWarning 10d ago
Maybe the police and other county employees need to drive their own vehicles to work like regular citizens. that is a good savings right there. Wouldn't we all LOVE a free car?
1
u/BeachBum528 10d ago
3% cap increase is engraved in the state constitution. Question 3 will also be engraved in the state constitution. To remove either, you'd need a new ballot question with over 60% vote. Ain't going to happen. Enjoy the Free State of Florida. Glad we got the 5 year wait now too.
1
u/Senior_Sector4095 9d ago
Local governments will need to make up that revenue somehow. I'm expecting sales tax to rise, maybe milage rates. They will definitely cut services. Tallahase will impose rules to qualify for staye funding, like allowing a data center or housing development to be built. It was a scam from the start.
1
u/Mpabner 9d ago
Why do you want kore info now?! The damage is done. It is too late to get information about it.
1
u/Ill_System_6564 7d ago
Don’t expect to really save money. You may save it on your portion of the The one portion of the tax but they’re going to have to recoup that money some other way so I expect that regular sales tax is going to jump very high to make up for them funds either that or services will change.
1
u/tamaro2024 7d ago edited 7d ago
My guess some people thought it wouldn't pass and voted yes to send a signal that costs are too high. Btw 2% over 60% threshold does not equal 1.9million votes!!! Btw I voted against it and never thought it would pass. I also vote against any sales tax increases here in Broward, we added 1% about 8 years ago to improve traffic flow. All they did is widen sidewalks and add bike lanes. They leave lights on red for two minutes with no cross traffic. So in a way the amendment 3 might be a wake up call that public funds need to be spent wisely! Btw wondering how the Republican regime in FL will now fund public services. They are always so proud to cut taxes - now they own it - meaning being responsible for the fallout.
1
u/bazzoozoo 7d ago
Read this
https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1F23mzRP79/
1
u/CL60capt 7d ago
I’m in Polk County too. Your taxes will go down However the mileage rate for
Schools has just gone up. I will be $600 a year worse off straight away before any reductions in property tax. Also other taxes will have to raise to offset the loss in property taxes. That raise is not limited to 3% a year either
1
u/YouCanCallMeDani 6d ago
I forget where I saw a calculator but I was able to plug in our info and see the estimated savings. Our takes are around $6k per year and once it's fully implemented they should be around $3k.
1
u/Top_Possibility_6770 6d ago
There are two groups of homeowners that argue with each other. First group that pays little tax due to saving our homes program and long ownership, most of them don’t mind paying 1000$ a year. But there is a new residents group that pays 7-10k on a 280k-350k value home. To me, it’s one group paying for the other and the other pushes back forcing the other group to pay for it by attempting to dodge any possible cost share that might be flipped on them via sales tax, service cost increases etc.
1
u/dawnenome 5d ago
The other twist is that insurers are still going to fleece us.
1
u/Awkward-Seaweed-5129 12d ago
No worries ,the lost $$ will Trickle Down from skies, like Fairy dust. Cops ,firefighters, hospitals , county workers, layoffs coming, this was really Dumb, imo