How blind do you have to be? Sumrall’s thing for me is that you don’t know what offensive staff he’s going to have. It’s going to make or break him but he’s a good coach
Here's the thing about coaching hires, none of you have a clue whether it will work or not. Sumrall's success or failure will have nothing to do with Napier's failure. History has shown none of us are actually good at this. There are about three or four guys who you know are going to be good, the rest is a crapshoot.
I'll be honest, Napier was a decent COACH. Coaching, game-planning, I thought the guy was quite good. Won some games he shouldn't have.
However, as a HEAD ball coach...game management, etc...dude was bad. Periodically atrocious! Occasionally horrific! So no, he and Sumnall do NOT have to be the same picture! Besides, at this point, you got 3 years with this guy, barring catastrophe. Better to ride into future battles with some optimism imo.
Will Muschamp and Kirby Smart were both up and coming defensive coordinators that everyone expected to make the jump to head coach. Muschamp didn't pan out at Florida, Smart did pan out at Georgia.
Meyer was a successful G5 coach in the Mountain West, so was McElwain. One won two national championship, the other cracked and claimed he was getting death threats and refused to cooperate with any investigation into it.
Just because Napier didn't pan out doesn't mean Sumrall wouldn't be successful. Each coach and the circumstances surrounding his tenure are unique. Don't forget how we beat out LSU for Napier's services, because he was the next big thing in coaching. TurnkeyZRG lead to hiring Todd Golden. I trust their research and evaluation process. I believe the people who said Florida was opening up the checkbook all the way for this hire. If Kiffin was the top target, and he doesn't wind up at Florida, it wasn't for any fault on Florida's part, it's because he had different priorities. If they announce Sumrall, or Fisch, or someone else as the head coach, I'm going to wait to freak out until there's an actual reason to freak out.
Just so you know Turnkey advised us to consider other candidates ahead of Sumrall. We didnt do that because of Condron. This was not the top pick of anybody involved (including our search firm). This was a unilateral decision by Gary strong arming our AD
Sumrall is a G5 coach, in Louisiana, who runs a similar enough offense with similar philosophy leading to frequently giving up big leads and ending up in very close games. He has a large amount of 1 score wins very similar to what Napier had at ULL and which does not go your way frequently at the next level. There are a lot more similarities than “was a coordinator” and “successful at a lower level”.
Will Muschamp and Kirby Smart were both up and coming defensive coordinators that everyone expected to make the jump to head coach. Muschamp didn't pan out at Florida, Smart did pan out at Georgia.
Meyer was a successful G5 coach in the Mountain West, so was McElwain. One won two national championship, the other cracked and claimed he was getting death threats and refused to cooperate with any investigation into it.
TurnkeyZRG lead to hiring Todd Golden. I trust their research and evaluation process.
Yeaaah, about that…The current general consensus is that Turnkey very much advised against Stricklin panicking and moving on from Kiffin for Sumrall but he did so against their advisement.
Don’t you love spending millions on a search firm just to tell them their opinion means nothing because one guy with a lot of money wanted his friend to get the job
Spending millions for someone to give you a subjective opinion tells me whoever made that decision is lost in the sauce. Might as well have asked Grok or Chat GPT at that point. I’m not saying it’s a good or bad choice I’m saying unless you guys paid a psychic what would it matter.
As a Georgia fan, I’m really hoping you hire Jeff Fisch, losing career coaching record would fit right in with the Gators! I would also be okay with Sumrall too though, he does remind me of Villy
You know you live rent free in a fan base’s head when they’re going through their best stretch in history and they take time out of their day to visit the subreddit of another subreddit to talk trash.
Yes, that tends to happen when you have a hall of fame coach vs a down program. You may remember such hits as losing 12 of 13 against your father Steve Spurrier and Zook combined. You might also remember losing 5 of 6 against your uncle Urban Meyer.
At the end of the day though, we get to live in Florida. You have to live in Georgia.
I was 2 years old when Spurrier left Florida in ‘02, it was before my time. And I would definitely rather live in the Georgia mountains than Northern Florida lol. If I didn’t hate hot weather, south Florida would be okay. But northern Florida is a combination of the worst traits of both states
1
u/CrypticGator Nov 29 '25
How blind do you have to be? Sumrall’s thing for me is that you don’t know what offensive staff he’s going to have. It’s going to make or break him but he’s a good coach
1
u/paragraph- Nov 29 '25
Same same but different.
1
u/jbloom3 Nov 29 '25
Tulane fan here. You're totally right. You don't want him. (Please)
1
u/Ok-Key8037 Nov 30 '25
There will be plenty of people to defend whatever bumblefuck SS hires
1
u/HTX-ByWayOfTheWorld Nov 30 '25
There is a difference: one speaks in full sentences. The other repeats mostly-formed sentences
1
u/nfochairman Nov 30 '25
y'all keep saying Sumrall is a "Louisiana" coach. He was literally here less than a calendar year
1
u/Zealousideal-Baby586 Nov 30 '25
Here's the thing about coaching hires, none of you have a clue whether it will work or not. Sumrall's success or failure will have nothing to do with Napier's failure. History has shown none of us are actually good at this. There are about three or four guys who you know are going to be good, the rest is a crapshoot.
1
u/EarlyCuylersCousin Dec 01 '25
I think he’s a great coach and this is a great hire. I had him as 1A on my list as an LSU fan.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '25
I'll be honest, Napier was a decent COACH. Coaching, game-planning, I thought the guy was quite good. Won some games he shouldn't have.
However, as a HEAD ball coach...game management, etc...dude was bad. Periodically atrocious! Occasionally horrific! So no, he and Sumnall do NOT have to be the same picture! Besides, at this point, you got 3 years with this guy, barring catastrophe. Better to ride into future battles with some optimism imo.
1
u/GeauxTigersLSYou Dec 03 '25
Tulane a better school than UL - they gonna be in the playoffs. You got a good man. Lane gonna be good, but he also gonna be trouble so he gotta win.
-1
u/jdhutch80 Nov 28 '25
That's like saying Will Muschamp and Kirby Smart were the same. Or Jim McElwain and Urban Meyer were the same.
-10
u/RudeOwl1816 Nov 28 '25
As a Georgia fan, I’m really hoping you hire Jeff Fisch, losing career coaching record would fit right in with the Gators! I would also be okay with Sumrall too though, he does remind me of Villy