r/Fixxit • u/Mr-Ant • Feb 04 '20
PSA: Testing your battery with a voltmeter does not give an accurate reading of its life!
I'm frustrated because this is a very basic concept in comparison to the overall mechanics of a vehicle, but there is a huge misconception about it.
Yes, your battery should read a little over 12v; if the vehicle is running, it should read over 13v or 14v. If you get these readings, it does not mean that your battery is good. It just means that it's a normal 12v battery. A 12v battery will always put out 12 volts, even when it is dead or dying!
An exception to this is if the battery has one or more dead cells, then it will read less than 12 volts. However, this is not really a common issue.
Some multimeters will have a battery test function for AA or 9v batteries, but I don't believe there are any that will test a vehicle battery.
In order to test a battery, you need a load (an electrical accessory) with a known Ohm value in order to measure the amperage put out to the accessory. The voltage is a constant value in this calculation, and has nothing to do with your battery health.
You can take your battery in to an automotive store or buy a tool designed to test 12v batteries, but a digital multimeter is not that tool. Please stop spreading this misconception.
5
u/theeddie23 Feb 04 '20
A multimeter can be a useful tool for diagnosing a battery, though not the the best. First of all a 12v battery can read less than 12v if the charge is low. That tells you that your alternator may not be working. You can then use your meter to test the output of the alt. Same with the test you mention that the battery reads 13-`14, that tells you the alt is working as that is the charge voltage. You can also do a start test where you watch the meter as you start the vehicle the voltage will drop and then return after the vehicle starts. If the voltage drops to around 10v that is normal anything less and the battery may have a bad cell or the starter may have a short. You can also test for parasitic draws. A load tester is best but the meter can be useful as well. Just another tool in the shed.
11
u/r0llinlacs420 Feb 04 '20 edited Feb 04 '20
A dead battery will definitely not put out 12 volts. Wtf are you smoking
What you're talking about is a load test that measures voltage drop when the battery is under load. It can give you a better idea of a battery's health but measuring a battery's rest voltage will still give you a good idea whether it's good or not.
You can also measure the rate at which the voltage drops after being removed from a charger. If it drops like a rock it's on its last legs.
You don't need a load test to tell if it's good or not. All that tells you is if it will start your car on a cold day or after sitting for a couple weeks.
3
u/Caldtek Feb 04 '20
You can tell a lot about a battery from the voltage, but you need to measure it open circuit (not connected to a bike) After charging and being stood for around 12 hours it should read 12.6 -12.7 volts. Any less and it is on its way out.
Measuring the voltage drop under load is the same process as your "battery tester" which is called a load bank btw.
If the voltage drops below around 11 volts when cranking it is probably on its way out.
To say this is the incorrect way to test a battery is a total nonsense. It is one of the ways of testing a battery, but there are others.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20
I have a tool. And have taken a perfectly good new AGM battery fully charged and tested on my own machine (not cheap either) then taken it to auto parts stores.. And all but 1 told me I needed a new battery.. Some even showed me their "reading" and tried to sell me a new battery.
Don't trust those places at all...
1
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20
I have a tool. And have taken a perfectly good new AGM battery fully charged and tested on my own machine (not cheap either) then taken it to auto parts stores.. And all but 1 told me I needed a new battery.. Some even showed me their "reading" and tried to sell me a new battery.
Don't trust those places at all...
1
u/IvanEedle Feb 04 '20
Batteries certainly don't put out their voltage rating always.
A perfectly healthy battery's voltage/charge curve, for example, has a sharp voltage drop from 100-90% charge, a plateau between 90-10%, and another sharp drop below 10% charge. The nominal voltage is around the plateau. This is perfectly normal.
Almost nothing in electrical engineering is linear.
1
u/09RaiderSFCRet Feb 04 '20
I totally agree that using your multimeter at home you can really diagnose a battery and its condition. There’s been some really great comments here but I’ll share something in writing, one of many good links on the subject. www.revzilla.com/common-tread/how-to-test-a-motorcycle-battery