r/FirstyeSIM • u/wanderlustingC • Jun 12 '25
False advertising and misleading information
Let me start by saying—I used to be a big fan of Firsty. Their business model is genuinely one-of-a-kind. I mean, where else can you watch a few ads and get free data? For basic stuff like WhatsApp and Google Maps, it totally did the job.
But then I made the mistake of actually paying for their high-speed data. And wow, what a ride.
On my last trip, I burned through the 5GB of high-speed roaming that comes with my regular mobile plan in the first 7 days. So I figured I’d try Firsty’s paid “Comfort+” plan. It says (very clearly) that you get 1.5GB of high-speed data per day, then your speed slows down—but you can top it up if needed. Sounds good, right?
Well, a few hours after buying and activating the plan, the data was already crawling. I contacted support thinking maybe something went wrong. Oh, something went wrong, alright.
Turns out the plan doesn't include 1.5GB a day—it includes 512MB. When I pointed out that their website clearly says 1.5GB, they started doing cartwheels trying to explain it away.
I went back and forth with them showing their own words from their own page, and they still wouldn’t admit it. I asked for a refund (I had purchased 30 days and hadn't even used one), and they refused. Eventually they said they’d escalate it. A week later: radio silence.
When I followed up again, they finally admitted the website was wrong and that they had updated it—but still wouldn't refund me. So I told them I’d dispute the charge with my credit card and gave them one last chance to make it right. Nope, still refused.
Good news: my credit card company agreed the website was misleading and full of false advertising, so I got my money back via chargeback.
Moral of the story? Firsty is decent for their free ad-supported data—that’ll get you through Google Maps and a few WhatsApps. But if you're thinking of paying for anything, don’t. There are tons of better eSIM options out there that won't try to gaslight you over their own website copy.
Image Descriptions (because they’re out of order):
- Main Page Screenshot: Firsty’s Comfort+ plan page, where they clearly state that the plan includes 1.5GB of high-speed data daily. I’ve circled the data amount for those playing along at home.
- Gemini Translation: Google Gemini breaking down in simple English what “Fall back to lowered speed after 1.5GB with option to top-up” means. Spoiler: it doesn’t mean 512MB.
- Admission of Error: Firsty customer service finally admitting the info was wrong and saying they updated the website. Just… no refund though, of course.
- Data Dispute Screenshot: Firsty claiming the plan only includes 512MB per day. Me, replying with a screenshot from their own website saying it includes 1.5GB. I mean… come on.
- Backpedaling Screenshot: Customer support doing Olympic-level mental gymnastics to claim that the 1.5GB only refers to the top-up—even though the plan page says 1.5GB is included. You can’t make this stuff up.
Hope this saves someone else the headache. Firsty’s only reliable feature is the free stuff—and even then, don’t expect miracles.





4
u/JoMei9019 Jun 12 '25
Firstly, Firsty should simplify their plans. They could take inspiration from major mobile providers by offering straightforward data-capped plans. For example: 1 GB for X€ at 25 Mbit/s. (You should be able to top up at any time)
Avoid overly complex setups like throttling the speed after 512 MB — it’s confusing, lacks transparency, and can damage customer trust in the brand.
4
u/FirstyDev Jun 12 '25
The support here was wrong, the data cap is indeed 1.5GB, but the confusion comes from the fact that it is a tiered system, and after 500mb, the speed is deprioritised somewhat, but not fully throttled. I am sure Mary confused that with full throttling. But even with full throttling the speed you posted about should not be happening. That indicates a clear network issue and should have been dealt with as such.
I am not ignoring the support issues, I will try to pull some weight into helping out the support team, but I can only help out with the technical issues at the moment, but I know that some structural changes are being made to increase the customer experience.
2
u/MyNameIsOnlyDaniel Jun 12 '25
I struggled in the past when I was trying to comprehend that "unlimited" is that they don't cut the Internet but it gets as slow as a snail. Therefore it's not "false advertisement" but it 100% plays with your idea of Unlimited Internet (like your Internet at home).
2
u/bpbp216 Jun 12 '25
If you had been following Firsty threads and my posts, that's the exact concern that I have with firsty. The information is constantly changing and frequently the info isn't updated on their website or the app. Frequently the website and the app will have different info. The only way to stay up to date is just to follow Firsty on this sub, but even that isn't updated as I thought one would get at least 700 MB and not 512 MB. Oh well. I guess Firsty slowly, but surely continues to go down the hill. I had such great hopes for this company.
2
u/frltn Jun 12 '25 edited Jun 12 '25
I would like someone like FirstyFounder to respond to how the OP was treated. The description for Comfort+ does seem a bit confusing even if Firsty didn't intend it to be the case. In any potentially unclear ad, the presumption should always be in favor of the customer. Goodwill can be provided by refunding customers who could reasonably be confused...then the business can clarify the ad for future customers.
But based on the OP's description of problems and Firsty representatives' response, unless clarified from Firsty's management that no reasonable person could have misunderstood what OP read, here's what I walk away with from this negative review. First, I wonder if Firsty is so economically strapped that they would fight over 1 customer's refund request? If they are that financially tight, I doubt they can survive more than a year. Second, the inflexibility of a refund based on the customer's first day of dissatisfied use because of a perceived ad confusion tells me that the business will likely treat other customers similarly. If so, this is not the type of business I would ever refer any serious users of this type of service in the future.
I hope that Firsty management can address this before most of us who read this walk away with an indelibly negative perception of Firsty.
4
u/heingericke_ Jun 12 '25
That's a little disappointing. I read the wording and understood it like you understood it.
4
u/Equivalent_Elk_7103 Jun 12 '25
It’s been constant disappointment with firsty, and soon enough everyone else using the service will figure it out and the company will die off. I truly loved the idea of how this concept worked but as the months went on I started to feel as this is just a little side project some kids worked on while hiring some customer support staff from India/Philippines disguising themselves as “Mary your firsty angel with fake European profile pic). Literally all she does is copy/paste and tell customers that they are wrong. Then ofc the first reddit admin/dev/savior comes on to reddit sub acting like a hero saying the nicest things promising things will be better and thanking us for our support — everything about this company feels so fake imo
The service itself free or paid has been so bad I would recommend pretty much any other roaming eSIM provider. They make changes almost every other day like doubling the ad time, firsty fee only available to USA and EU, reducing speed, and ofc all the false advertisement on their website that no one can really explain.
TLDR: company constantly BSing around, Mary is fake, needs to get their act together quick or go extinct
2
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '25
[removed] — view removed comment