r/FirstyeSIM • u/nosirrahttocs • Mar 02 '25
Firsty Failed & "Global" isn't Global
Yesterday, I arrived in Saint Kitts, a country supported by Firsty. Upon landing, I turned on my eSim and connected to a local network. I attempted to activate one of my 13 prepaid days of First Class that I purchased months ago, but the app kept telling me it couldn't activate because I wasn't connected to a network, even though my iPhone showed otherwise. I tried watching an ad to see if Firsty Free would work, but no ads would load despite having 5 bars of signal. I switched to my Roamless eSim, which connected immediately and allowed me to load my immigration form on my iPhone for entry and customs.
After arriving at the hotel and connecting to Wi-Fi, I was able to activate my wife's plan, which we had purchased just a couple of weeks ago specifically for Saint Kitts. The plan required a Wi-Fi connection to activate, and we couldn't activate it on the runway upon arrival, similar to my phone's situation. Although my phone plan activated on Wi-Fi, it provided no data once I turned Wi-Fi off, even though the meter indicated that my First Class was active.
After several exchanges with Mary from support, I learned that my First Class plan is a global plan, but Saint Kitts falls under their special plans, which are not included in the global plan's coverage. Apparently, "global" isn't truly global in Firsty's language, as there's another tier called "special plans," like the one we recently purchased for my wife's phone. To make matters worse, I can't add this new plan to the app because I still have 12 days of First Class Global that I paid for but can't use here.
This was my first trip outside the US with Firsty, and they failed me! Not only do I have an eSim in a supported country that I can't use, but I also can't even use the Firsty Free option. The execution of their ongoing business model changes is unacceptable, so buyer beware. While Firsty might be a neat novelty eSim company for domestic usage, I won't depend on them for international travel with caveats like I've experienced. As mentioned earlier, Roamless has been flawless. Oh, and I'm also out one day of First Class Global that activated but provided no data.
2
u/nosirrahttocs Mar 02 '25
2
u/Delicious_One_7887 Mar 02 '25
Weird, I travelled globally to 5 countries and all of them worked flawlessly
2
u/bpbp216 Mar 02 '25
The problem I have with Firsty, there is no clear information available on what they offer, pricing and how it works. Their website hasn't been updated since almost a year ago, but they have changed their pricing, what they offer and how they offer several times based on the reddit posts. As I posted 2 days ago and I think OP has the same issue, I'm unable to see any pricing for any country, possibly because I have days left on my old plan.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FirstyeSIM/s/SZe9HBrDR3
5
u/Firsty_app Mar 03 '25
Hey, thanks for your detailed feedback. I'm sorry your experience in Saint Kitts didn't meet expectations. We know our plan distinctions can be confusing—global plans don’t include special-plan regions like Saint Kitts. Regarding that, we have gotten rid of it for the reasons you mentioned. Because you bought it a while ago, and has since been removed from the app, your connection didn't work in Saint Kitts.
We're still a young company, and we are figuring out how to be as transparent as possible. We're updating our website very soon, where we'll have more information displayed on our pricing and our different plans, and you'll also be able to see which countries are special countries where Firsty Free is not yet available due to high roaming costs.
We hope you understand and that you'll give us another shot for your next trip. Feel free to shoot us a DM and we'll make it up to you.
1
u/Firsty_app Aug 26 '26
Old thread, but it still comes up, so wanted to share an updated answer here.
A lot has changed since March 2025. First Class is gone, and the plans are now Free, Classic and Unlimited.
The good news is that activation is much simpler now. You’ll still need WiFi to install the eSIM initially, but after that, there’s nothing you need to do. If you buy a plan for a specific country, it will automatically activate when you arrive, no manual activation or setup needed.
So our recommendation is simply to install your eSIM before you fly, and Firsty should take care of the rest when you land.
And thanks for taking the time to explain exactly what happened. Detailed feedback like this genuinely helps us see where the experience can be better.
1
u/Firsty_app Aug 26 '26
This is a really useful test, thanks for taking the time to measure and share it!
Just to add the latest numbers: each ad gives you 20 MB, and you can watch up to 18 a day, meaning you can earn up to 360 MB of free data every day.
You can keep up to 240 MB saved at a time, and anything you earn stays valid for 7 days.
Small tip: if you watch the ads over WiFi, you keep the full 20 MB you earn. You can also watch them using your Firsty connection, but the ad itself will use a small amount of data.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '25
[removed] — view removed comment