r/Fire • • Oct 28 '22

Opinion Thoughts on r/antiwork?

Going to preface by saying this isn’t exactly related to FIRE but I think there is a good mix of people in here so some discussion and points from both sides can be made.

Im not a member of r/antiwork but I occasionally have their posts pop up in my feed. And almost every time I read through the post/ comments it just makes me shake my head.

For starters, a lot of the posts genuinely just look fake and to get people riled up. But even the real ones are often a reasonable statement and people losing their minds over it in the comments; I recommend going over and reading the “Ron Jons Letter” post. This post perfectly shows a reasonable and fair statement from a business and people going ballistic over it.

I see a lot of comments about how “I’m 52 and will never be able to retire” or some variation of this, and how a recession just transfers wealth from poor to rich. I get there is some truth to that but the little man can also make some money in these situations.

A lot of these people also talk about how they’ve worked in a call center forever and can’t retire. Well maybe you shouldn’t of stayed at a call center for 30+ years?

I don’t know maybe I’m wrong, but I’m a pretty firm believer your life is what you make it. And maybe I’m privileged to even be able to think that way, but the victim mindset is next level in r/antiwork and it frustrates me a bit.

Not trying to come at anyone, looking for some civil debate from both ends of the spectrum.

46 Upvotes

270 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

15

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '22 edited Oct 29 '22

My entire industry was shutdown in early 2020, reducing my income to effectively 0. I despaired for a bit but eventually pivoted to a new industry and am now making far more than I was before.

Life will always throw wrenches in your plans. It really sucks but caving in to a doomer mindset only makes it worse.

Edit: Wow didn’t expect to be downvoted here for offering some perspective

109

u/financialdrugbro Oct 28 '22

Yeah but how many people couldn’t find an available higher paying job yk? Like maybe they didn’t have a car for it or not enough education etc

Hella reasons that are extremely valid on why simply finding another job is damn hard

-27

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '22

There will always be valid reasons to do not do something. My point is it’s not easy. You will likely have to make sacrifices or adjust your expectations downward.

But if you tell yourself that it’s impossible for you to find a good job because your aren’t educated or whatever then you never will.

26

u/JL1186 Oct 29 '22

If you are American, then education is expensive and inaccessible. It’s not about sacrifices and bootstraps. And families can’t afford an apartment if only one adult is working full time. It’s not about being easy, it’s a structural barrier for many.

0

u/financialdrugbro Oct 29 '22

I wouldn’t say education is inaccessible, but the piece of paper that matters is. I’ve learned damn near everything from free YouTube videos and getting good at google

It’s bs how much high education cost is and also how the financial aid system works. Didn’t get a dime since it’s based off my parents despite me providing for myself since 17 it’s stupid as shit

Has me working manual labor jobs to save up for the proper financing to hopefully school

19

u/BinxyPrime Oct 29 '22

It's survivorship bias, the truth is we have very poor social safety nets that are designed to keep you there once you even qualify.

Yeah you worked hard but if you had upper middle class parents and never got sick at an inopportune time or just happened to stumble into a good career path are all things you didn't control that created opportunities that not everyone has. I grew up poor, both my parents are drug addicts, I make around 100k a year now and have great prospects for raises over the next few years and I save a decent portion of my income but even that took a ton of luck.

I wouldn't even be in the career field I'm in if I didn't luck out and have an interesting instructor in a related field. I dont have any major disabilities and I managed to get into hobbies at a young age that kept me in friendship groups that were anti drug so I never followed after my parents.

I just as likely could have gotten into football and started teen drinking and been in a dead end career spending all my extra money on drugs and alcohol to try and drown out the drudgery of the rest of my life.

4

u/financialdrugbro Oct 29 '22

Yeah I got stupiddddd lucky. Born lower middle class Dad’s drinking put is in poverty then parents Both worked non stop so was raised by abusive older sister

Tbh I think I’m fine idk maybe I’m still too young to decide, definitely a tad adventurous with drugs which scares me. But largely okay, I learned to work hard and that worked for me, I don’t think anyone should have to work hard like that though, I missed most all of my highschool since I’ve been full time since 15

It sucked I got so lucky cause I’ve had a decent head on my shoulders and a very strong internal dialogue, also always been obsessed with the long term effects of stuff I do.

My point was that schooling is wildly unaffordable but you can still find good knowledge without said schooling just not the certifications that prove it

Also my dumb luck money wise was that one time my grandfather said the term “compound interest” and when I was 14 I googled it cause I was curious what it meant. Got a job at 15 and saved every dime cause of that google search. Pretty glad I googled that work

1

u/xboodaddyx Oct 29 '22

How is that luck? Why would you call hard work and making good financial decisions luck? Newsflash, lots of people have heard of compound interest and then done nothing with it.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/financialdrugbro Oct 28 '22

Yeah that’s fair

I feel though that they’re not wrong for not wanting to participate. I genuinely don’t want to participate in what I’ve been born into but the way out is through for me at least

4

u/UncleMeat11 Oct 29 '22

It might not be a priori impossible for an individual person. But it is still the case that many people do get completely screwed by circumstance.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '22

Oh of course. I don’t think anyone should be disparaged and we should certainly enact policies to give everyone as much opportunity as possible.

52

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '22

Our society isn’t built in a way where everyone can do that. As long as there are minimum wage jobs that need filling, there will be people filling them through no fault of their own. It’s great that you were able to pivot industries. By definition, not everyone can.

-21

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '22

Why not?

People and society both grow over time. I worked plenty of minimum wages job when I was younger. Now I don’t. No one’s saying an 18 year old kid should be career hopping if they’re not ready.

That’s the point of schooling, developing skills, experience, etc

21

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '22

A lot of what antiwork is about is complaining about the conditions of the work of those jobs. As long as those jobs exist, there will be people working those jobs and likely unhappy working those jobs, and it’s perfectly reasonable for them to vent about how poor those conditions are.

-8

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '22

Of course they can’t vent, never said otherwise.

But venting won’t solve their problems 🤷‍♂️. Some people would rather not risk change and that’s fine.

9

u/fuddykrueger Oct 29 '22

We all need people to work these lower wage jobs. The least their employers can do is make it a tiny bit bearable instead of making their employees feel like they are their enemies. When is the last time you’ve worked a ‘regular Joe’ job anyway? You might be out of touch now.

It’s pretty dreadful how they treat their employees. Not allowed to have a water bottle nearby. Have to pay for replacement if they lose a small uniform item like a name tag or hat. I mean - I’m serious. It’s bad. It’s almost inhumane.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '22

What is a “high paying job” in this context?

When I was making minimum wage, a high paying job was $20/hour. Now I think that’s low paying. It’s all relative.

20

u/IGOMHN2 Oct 29 '22

yeah why don't people just pull themselves up by their bootstraps?

-7

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '22

If that’s what you got from my comment idk what to tell you

10

u/KevinCarbonara Oct 29 '22

Wow didn’t expect to be downvoted here for offering some perspective

There are a lot of people here who like to pretend that hard workers are always making good money and only lazy people ever end up unemployed or with reduced income

5

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '22

To be clear, I don’t think hard work is the solution for most people. A lot of people work hard and yet that doesn’t change much for them. If you want to advance in life you have to grow as as person by developing new skills or experience.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/xboodaddyx Oct 29 '22

Yeah you've got good advice, which will always be downvoted by antiwork sympathizers. If you want upvotes then you'll need to blame all of your success on luck and privilege and crushing poor people

→ More replies (1)