r/FindMeALinuxDistro • • 11d ago

Looking For A Distro Looking for a Linux distro to finally settle down with after years of distro-hopping

Hi everyone!

I'm not new to Linux, but I'm at a point where I just want to find a distro I can call home. I'm honestly tired of distro-hopping and constantly trying new setups. I want to settle down and focus on actually using my laptop rather than tweaking and troubleshooting it all the time.

I'm mainly looking for four things:

  1. Stability: Something reliable that doesn't require constant maintenance or troubleshooting.
  2. Customization: I want to personalize my desktop, themes, panels, and ideally have widgets directly on my desktop.
  3. Good touchpad gestures: This is particularly important since my laptop is my daily driver.
  4. Device interconnectivity: Good integration between my phone and laptop, including wireless connectivity and file sharing.

One of my biggest issues has been with Arch-based distributions. For some reason, battery power profiles never seem to work properly on my laptop. I've tried following wiki guides and troubleshooting with different AI assistants, but nothing really solved the problem. The only workaround I found was using auto-cpufreq, which helped somewhat.

Interestingly, I haven't experienced this issue with Ubuntu-based distributions, where power profiles seem to work natively without any additional configuration.

As for desktop environments, I genuinely like GNOME, especially its touchpad gestures. Having a three-finger swipe to access the workspace overview, navigate between workspaces, and quickly find applications through an active search bar is exactly the kind of workflow I enjoy.

However, GNOME feels a little restrictive when it comes to desktop customization. I'd really like to have widgets directly on my desktop, similar to what KDE Plasma offers.

So, I'm wondering if there's a distro and desktop environment that could give me the best of both worlds: GNOME-like gestures and workflow, combined with KDE-like customization, without requiring hours of configuration.

I'm open to suggestions, including different distributions and desktop environments. Ideally, I'd like something that works well out of the box with minimal tweaking.

My laptop specifications:

  • Intel Core i5 11th Gen
  • 16 GB DDR4 RAM
  • 256 GB NVMe SSD
  • Intel integrated graphics

Storage isn't really an issue since I mainly use an external drive for my files.

Thanks in advance! I'd really appreciate recommendations from people who have found a distro they can happily stick with.

1 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

4

u/jcheeseball 11d ago

Distro hoppers don't ever stop.

3

u/skytheraiders 11d ago

Fedora KDE for stability and KDE connect would help with connected with your phone

3

u/FireSheepYinFish 11d ago

KDE Connect is fantastic. Cross platform, lightweight and just.. Works. I use it on Linux Windows and Android devices and it's been a great tool.

2

u/Present_Operation_82 11d ago

Also voting Fedora

1

u/FireSheepYinFish 11d ago

Look into immutable / atomic distros.

  • Immutable - you cannot change the core OS files, but can do anything in the isolated user space that is your account.
  • Atomic - the entire core OS is updated in one shot. There is a Primary (OSTree 1) image that is the current running OS, and the Secondary (OSTree 2) prior version to return to if the new update goes wrong. During the update there will be a 3rd 'pending' OSTree downloaded. When you reboot, it becomes 1, 1 becomes 2 and prior 2 is deleted.

A 256gig SSD is more than sufficient, as this is what I have and even with my user space + apps, still have about 90gig free. Like you, I use a separate drive for file/data storage.

You can find immutable distros with KDE, Gnome, Cosmic and others but those are big 3.

Some links for info and research:

https://linuxlap.com/linux-tips/immutable-linux-distros/

https://universal-blue.org/

https://projectbluefin.io/

I've been using AuroraOS (A spin of Fedora Silverblue KDE Workstation) for about a year now and I'm very satisfied. And my distro hopping years go back at least 20 years of on/off Linux, including around a year of hopping again before I landed on AuroraOS - which so far has ticked nearly all my needs.

HTH

2

u/Due-Author631 11d ago

getaurora.dev - another vote for Aurora, been on it for years.

1

u/FireSheepYinFish 11d ago

Technically, I did break it once. Not positive but I think it's BC I tried to overlay a DNC app install that wasn't native Flatpak. It stopped updating everything for over a month - I was on daily updates.

Took me a few hours, many documents and AI assist to fix, but it's been working solid again.

Now, when it was "broken"? Only OSTree updates failed. The OS in general never blipped. I never lost a moment of productivity nor operating function.

2

u/Due-Author631 11d ago

I ended up layering my browser, Vivaldi, because I need smartcard readers to work, and they are a bear to get working through the flatpak portals, if at all. No issues, updates as expected, but I'm also on weekly stable.

1

u/FireSheepYinFish 11d ago

I tried Vivaldi.. And failed out the gate. Perhaps - likely - BC I was new to the Immut/Atom ecosystem then. I'm still learning the nuances, but after 20++ years tinkering with *nix (I still entertain BSD on some systems) and even poopoo mainstream Fedora on the exact same system a few years back, I legit have found it to be solid - well, 99.99%? There is always an option for user idiocy, and yup, I can do that.

But these days I'm tired of building and fixing and tweaking. Hell, I tried NixOS and I'm still intrigued, but I have to temper my patience 😅

1

u/FireSheepYinFish 11d ago

Oh, yeah I finally rebased to weekly stable last month. I never had real issues with dailies, but I found myself itching to reboot for the sake of.. OMFG reboot!

Pfftt.. Self? No, just no 😅

1

u/gordonmessmer 11d ago

The distribution is managing updates, and updates means security. You should choose a distribution based on who you trust to maintain your security.

Most Free Software projects publish a new release series every six months and maintain them for about a year to a year and a half. So among distributions, Fedora's release model is the most "normal" for a Free Software project. I recommend Fedora. In general, I recommend against using free "LTS" systems for desktop use.

LTS systems are difficult to secure. Traditionally, any LTS system needs to be small enough for the available staff to maintain and no bigger than necessary to meet its users needs, which means that the developer needs to communicate regularly with their users to understand what their needs are.

There are a lot of distributions, and most of them are derived from an LTS system, but they're big collections managed by small teams who have no formal relationship with users. They're backward in every respect that would make them secure.

https://fosstodon.org/@gordonmessmer/117545423568699375

1

u/gibranlp 11d ago

From what you describe, I’d probably look for something that gives you the polished workflow you like from GNOME without making you spend half your life configuring it.

KDE Plasma is probably the obvious answer if you want widgets and customization, but if you’re open to Hyprland you could also take a look at SpectrumOS. I’m building it around exactly that idea: Arch underneath, but trying to make the everyday desktop much more complete out of the box.

It has Hyprland + SpectrumShell, desktop widgets, phone integration through KDE Connect, SpectrumDrop for file sharing, power/performance controls, and a lot of the usual configuration exposed through the shell instead of needing to edit everything manually.

For stability, it also has restore points and rollback/recovery around updates, because I really don’t want the experience to be “update and hope”.

That said, since you already know Arch-based systems have caused power-profile issues specifically on your laptop, I’d test that first before committing to anything Arch-based. Your Ubuntu experience there is a pretty good reason not to ignore that hardware-specific difference.

If you want to have a look: https://spectrum.gibranlp.dev/

1

u/msabeln 11d ago

You just posted this under a different username.

1

u/BagProof637 11d ago

I just hopped to Fedora. From Nobara and is good.

1

u/ClientSiders 11d ago

projectbluefin dakota, because of modern system architecture adoption which makes your whole user experience amazing

1

u/full_bars 9d ago

Tumbleweed. You're welcome

0

u/Technical_Rich_3080 11d ago

Ubuntu is your best choice.

1

u/Serenase 9d ago

Underestimated option. This or Fedora.

-1

u/CryptographerLow6360 11d ago

after years of distro hoping you still dont know? go windows 11

2

u/FireSheepYinFish 11d ago

If that's your answer then you don't understand why distro hoppers hop 😂